Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Fulton Co

Court

Fulton Co

Georgia

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2022-01-29
Status E-File Open
Type Tort Medical Malpractice
Docket 252 entries
Disposition dismiss

Parties

Plaintiff Ana Villegas
Defendant Neale Freeman, M.d.,brad Moore, M.d.et Al
Photo of Hon. Martinez, Ana Maria

Judge

Hon. Martinez, Ana Maria

DeKalb County (GA)

Georgia

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Summons
  2. Comment 2022-01-29 Villegas Summons
  3. Complaint
  4. Comment 2022-01-29 Villegas Complaint
  5. Case Summary (civil)
  6. Comment 2022-01-29 Villegas Case Initiation Page 1
  7. Case Summary (civil)
  8. Comment 2022-01-29 Villegas Case Initiation Page 2
  9. Affidavit
  10. Comment 2022-01-11 Gomez-Villegas, Ana Affidavit of Joshua B. Holden, MD, FACOG
  11. Affidavit
  12. Comment Villegas affidavit of Dinner
  13. E Filed Open
  14. Comment /JURY LOPEZ
  15. Interrogatories
  16. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Freeman
  17. Request for Productions of Documents
  18. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Freeman
  19. Interrogatories
  20. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Haven
  21. Request for Productions of Documents
  22. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Haven
  23. Interrogatories
  24. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Lazarus
  25. Request for Productions of Documents
  26. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Lazarus
  27. Interrogatories
  28. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Moore
  29. Request for Productions of Documents
  30. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Moore
  31. Interrogatories
  32. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to North Atlanta
  33. Request for Productions of Documents
  34. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to North Atlanta
  35. Interrogatories
  36. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Northside Anesthesiology
  37. Request for Productions of Documents
  38. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Northside Anesthesiology
  39. Interrogatories
  40. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas ROGS to Northside
  41. Request for Productions of Documents
  42. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas RPDS to Northside
  43. Rule 5.2
  44. Comment 2022-01-31 Villegas COS
  45. Affidavit of Non Service
  46. Comment 2022-02-01 Aff o Non Svc on Haven (Glenridge Connector Address)
  47. Affidavit of Non Service
  48. Comment 2022-02-01 Aff of Non Svc on Z. Lazarus (Sandy Springs Address)
  49. Affidavit of Service
  50. Comment 2022-02-02 Aff of Svc on Brad Moore
  51. Affidavit of Service
  52. Comment 2022-02-02 Aff of Svc on Northside Anesthesiology
  53. Affidavit of Service
  54. Comment 2022-02-03 Aff of Svc on Northside Hospital
  55. Affidavit of Service
  56. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Brad Moore
  57. Affidavit of Service
  58. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Haven OBGYN
  59. Affidavit of Service
  60. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Neale Freeman
  61. Affidavit of Service
  62. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on North Atlanta Maternidad
  63. Affidavit of Service
  64. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Northside Anesthesiologists
  65. Affidavit of Service
  66. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Northside Hospital
  67. Affidavit of Service
  68. Comment 2022-02-03 CJA Aff of Svc on Zachary Lazarus
  69. Affidavit of Service
  70. Comment 2022-02-08 ABC Legal Aff of Svc on North Atlanta Maternidad
  71. Affidavit of Service
  72. Comment 2022-02-08 ABC Legal Aff of Svc on HAVEN
  73. Affidavit of Service
  74. Comment 2022-02-08 ABC Legal Aff of Svc on HAVEN
  75. Affidavit of Service
  76. Comment 2022-02-05 Aff of Svc on HAVEN OBGYN
  77. Affidavit of Service
  78. Comment 2022-02-07 ABC Legal Aff of Svc on Neale Freeman
  79. Answer
  80. Comment Answer of Northside Anesthesiology Consultants, LLC & Zachary Lazarus, M.D.
  81. Answer
  82. Comment Answer of Dr. Freeman and and North Atlanta Maternidad
  83. Answer
  84. Comment Answer of Dr. Moore and Haven
  85. Jury Demand
  86. Comment Jury Demand - Dr. Freeman and Maternidad
  87. Jury Demand
  88. Comment Jury Demand - Dr. Moore and Haven
  89. Answer
  90. Comment Answer of Defendant Northside Hospital, Inc.
  91. Motion to Dismiss
  92. Comment Defendant Northside Hospital, Inc.'s Motion to Dismiss and Supporting Memorandum
  93. Certificate of Service
  94. Comment 5.2 COSD Dr. Moore's 1st Rogs & Rpds to PL
  95. Standing Order
  96. Comment Division VI - 1.19.22
  97. Certificate of Service
  98. Comment Certificate of Service
  99. Notice
  100. Comment LOA - Keith Whitesides
  101. Motion
  102. Comment Villegas MFL to Dismiss NSH
  103. Entry of Appearance
  104. Comment Entry of Appearance
  105. Order
  106. Comment Order Granting Partial Dismissal
  107. Motion
  108. Comment Motion for Summary Judgement
  109. Request
  110. Comment Defendants Zachary Lazarus Request for Oral Argument
  111. Statement of Theory of Recovery
  112. Comment Defendant Zachary Lazarus, MD and Northside Anesthesiology Consultant, LLC's Theories of Recovery and Statement of Undisputed Facts
  113. Brief Filed
  114. Comment Defendant Zachary Lazarus MD and Northside Anesthesiology Consultant LLC's Motion for Summary Judgement and Brief in Support
  115. Exhibit
  116. Comment Exhibit A - Northside Excerpts
  117. Exhibit
  118. Comment Exhibit B - Affidavit of Zachary Lazarus, MD
  119. Notice
  120. Comment Notice of Filing Original Affidavit of Zachary Lazarus, MD
  121. Certificate of Service
  122. Comment 5.2 COSD Freeman, Moore, Haven Ob/Gyn, and North Atlanta Maternidad's Responses to Rogs and Rpds
  123. Certificate of Discovery
  124. Comment Certificate of Service of Discovery
  125. Response
  126. Comment Villegas RIO MSJ
  127. Response
  128. Comment Villegas Responses to Statement of Material Facts
  129. Statement of Material Facts
  130. Comment Villegas Statement of Fact & Theory of Recovery
  131. Certificate of Service
  132. Comment COS- NRPDs
  133. Notice of Hearing
  134. Comment January Motions Hearing**READ HEARING ORDER FOR IMPORTANT DEADLINES**
  135. Brief Filed
  136. Comment Defendants Zachary Lazarus, M.D. and Northside Anesthesiology Consultants, LLC's Reply Brief in Support of Motion for Summary Judgement
  137. Motion
  138. Comment 2023-01-11 A. Villegas Motion to Dismiss Less Than All Parties
  139. Motions
  140. Judicial Officer Martinez, Ana Maria
  141. Hearing Time 9:30 AM
  142. Comment Deft's Zachary Lazarus, M.D. and Northside Anesthesiology Consultants, LLC's MSJ (8/08) w/ reqt for oral arg filed | Case was stayed until an order issued regarding the MTD - Order issued on 7/05 removing Northside as a party | Disc exp: 11.05.22 | JD
  143. Order
  144. Comment Order Granting Motion to Dismiss Zachary Lazarus, M.D.
  145. Notice of Leave of Absence
  146. Comment LOA MSB
  147. Notice
  148. Comment NOD Ms. Villegas
  149. Entry of Appearance
  150. Comment Notice of Entry of Appearance and Substitution of Counsel
  151. Notice of Deposition
  152. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition
  153. Notice of Deposition
  154. Comment Notice of Deposition
  155. Notice of Leave of Absence
  156. Comment LOA MSB 2024- Villegas
  157. Notice of Deposition
  158. Comment 10-27-2023 NOD OF BRAD MOORE, M.D.
  159. Certificate of Discovery
  160. Comment 10-27-23 Plntfs 5.2 COS NOD DR. BRAD MOORE M.D.
  161. Notice of Hearing
  162. Comment January Pretrial Calendar ***READ HEARING ORDER FOR IMPORTANT DEADLINES***
  163. Certificate of Discovery
  164. Comment 2023.12.11-COSD
  165. Motion for Continuance
  166. Comment 2023.12.18-Consent Mtn for Continuance from Trial Calendar
  167. Order
  168. Comment ORDER EXTENDING DISCOVERY PERIOD
  169. Certificate of Discovery
  170. Comment 2024.01.11-Rule 5.2 COSD
  171. Notice of Deposition
  172. Comment 2024-02-14 NOD Def Neale Freeman
  173. Certificate of Discovery
  174. Comment 2024-02-14 5.2 COS NOD of Dr. Neale Freeman MD
  175. Notice of Leave of Absence
  176. Comment 2024-03-11 ARS LOA
  177. Certificate of Discovery
  178. Comment 2024-05-21 5.2 COS Supplemental Responses to Interrogatories and RPD's - Anna Villegas
  179. Motion
  180. Comment 2024-07-16 CMED
  181. Motion
  182. Comment 2024-07-16 CMED
  183. Order
  184. Comment Order Granting Scheduling Order
  185. Notice of Deposition
  186. Comment 2024-09-10 NOD of Dr. Jenna Mclendon
  187. Certificate of Discovery
  188. Comment 2024-09-10 COS of NOD of Dr. Jenna Mclendon
  189. Notice of Leave of Absence
  190. Comment 2024.10.03 LOA MSB 2025 (Villegas)
  191. Notice
  192. Comment Notice of a Non Party Fault
  193. Notice of Leave of Absence
  194. Comment 2024.11.25 Amended LOA MSB 2025 (Villegas)
  195. Certificate of Discovery
  196. Comment 2025-01-06 Pltfs 5.2 COS Resp to Dr. Lazarus ROGS - RPDS
  197. Notice of Leave of Absence
  198. Comment 2025-01-21 ARS LOA
  199. Motion
  200. Comment 2025.01.31 Consent Motion to Extend Discovery (Villegas)
  201. Order
  202. Comment Scheduling Order
  203. Notice of Deposition
  204. Comment NOD - Joshua Holden, MD
  205. Notice of Deposition
  206. Comment NOTICE OF DEPOSITION AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
  207. Pre-Trial
  208. Judicial Officer Martinez, Ana Maria
  209. Hearing Time 1:00 PM
  210. Cancel Reason Cancelled by Court
  211. Comment Service. Answers & JD. Deft Zachary Lazarus M.D. dismissed. SO 08/07 - Disc exp:01.31.25. Mediation 02.28.25 - CMTED/ASO 01/31 - PR
  212. Motion
  213. Comment DEFENDANTS??? MOTION TO ENTER AMENDED SCHEDULING ORDER
  214. Notice of Deposition
  215. Comment 2025-07-10 NOD of A. Seagal, M.D.
  216. Certificate of Discovery
  217. Comment 2025-07-10 5.2 COS NOD of A. Seagal, M.D.
  218. Notice of Deposition
  219. Comment 2025-07-10 NOD of E. Fennell Williams, M.D.
  220. Certificate of Discovery
  221. Comment 2025-07-10 5.2 COS NOD of E Fennell Williams M.D.
  222. Notice of Deposition
  223. Comment 2025-07-10 NOD of Jay Annis CRNA
  224. Certificate of Discovery
  225. Comment 2025-07-10 5.2 COS NOD of Jay Annis, CRNA
  226. Notice of Deposition
  227. Comment 2025-07-10 NOD of Michael Hochman, M.D.
  228. Certificate of Discovery
  229. Comment 2025-07-10 5.2 COS NOD of Michael Hochman, M.D.
  230. Notice of Deposition
  231. Comment 2025-07-16 ANOD of Jay Annis CRNA
  232. Rule 5.2
  233. Comment 2025-07-16 5.2 COS ANOD of Jay Annis, CRNA
  234. Notice of Deposition
  235. Comment 2025-07-16 ANOD of E. Fennell Williams, M.D.
  236. Rule 5.2
  237. Comment 2025-07-16 5.2 COS ANOD of E Fennell Williams M.D.
  238. Notice of Deposition
  239. Comment 2025-07-16 ANOD of Michael Hochman, M.D.
  240. Rule 5.2
  241. Comment 2025-07-16 5.2 COS ANOD of Michael Hochman, M.D.
  242. Notice of Deposition
  243. Comment 2025-07-17 2ND ANOD of Jay Annis CRNA
  244. Rule 5.2
  245. Comment 2025-07-17 5.2 COS 2ND ANOD of Jay Annis, CRNA
  246. Motion
  247. Comment Plaintiff's Motion in Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Amend the Scheduling Order
  248. Motion
  249. Comment Emergency Motion for Protective Order and Motion to Quash Plaintiff's Notice to Take Depositions and Subpoenas Duces Tucem and Brief in Support
  250. Pre-Trial
  251. Judicial Officer Martinez, Ana Maria
  252. Hearing Time 1:00 PM

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more