Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Fulton Co

Court

Fulton Co

Georgia

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2022-04-20
Status Closed
Type Transfer Civil
Docket 488 entries
Disposition Judgment

Parties

Plaintiff The West Firm, P.c.vs.central United Methodist Church Atlanta, Inc.,vance Ross,aurelius Freeman,john Doe,jane Doe,monique Mabry,james Gordon,jacqueline Sykes,monica Prothro,mildred Gunn
Photo of Hon. Carnesale Rachelle L

Judge

Hon. Carnesale Rachelle L

Fulton County (GA)

Georgia

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL PETITION
  2. View Document PETITION
  3. Comment Index, Certificate and Complaint
  4. CASE INITIATION FORM
  5. View Document CASE INITIATION FORM
  6. Comment GENERAL TORT
  7. SUMMONS
  8. View Document SUMMONS
  9. Comment Summons
  10. MOTION
  11. View Document MOTION
  12. Comment Motion For Process Server
  13. ORDER
  14. View Document ORDER
  15. Comment Order for Process Server
  16. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  17. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  18. Comment Affidavit of Service
  19. CERTIFICATE
  20. View Document CERTIFICATE
  21. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  22. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  23. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  24. Comment Affidavit of Service
  25. CERTIFICATE
  26. View Document CERTIFICATE
  27. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  28. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  29. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  30. Comment Affidavit of Service
  31. AFFIDAVIT
  32. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  33. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  34. AFFIDAVIT
  35. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  36. Comment Affidavit of Service
  37. AFFIDAVIT
  38. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  39. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  40. AFFIDAVIT
  41. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  42. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  43. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  44. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  45. Comment Affidavit of Service
  46. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  47. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  48. Comment Affidavit of Service
  49. AFFIDAVIT
  50. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  51. Comment Affidavit of Service
  52. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  53. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  54. Comment Affidavit of Service
  55. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  56. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  57. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  58. CERTIFICATE
  59. View Document CERTIFICATE
  60. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  61. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  62. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  63. Comment Affidavit of Service
  64. ENTRY/NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  65. View Document ENTRY/NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  66. Comment Entry of Appearance
  67. ANSWER
  68. View Document ANSWER/RESPONSE
  69. Comment Answer
  70. MOTION TO TRANSFER VENUE
  71. View Document MOTION TO TRANSFER VENUE
  72. Comment Motion To Transfer
  73. OTHER
  74. View Document OTHER
  75. Comment Amended Complaint
  76. MOTION
  77. View Document MOTION
  78. Comment Motion To Disqualify
  79. ANSWER
  80. View Document ANSWER/RESPONSE
  81. Comment Amended Answer
  82. ANSWER
  83. View Document ANSWER/RESPONSE
  84. Comment Answer
  85. OTHER
  86. View Document OTHER
  87. Comment Sheriff's Entry of Service
  88. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  89. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  90. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  91. NOTICE
  92. View Document NOTICE
  93. Comment Notice of Hearing
  94. MOTION
  95. View Document MOTION
  96. Comment Motion for Leave to File Response
  97. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  98. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  99. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  100. NOTICE
  101. View Document NOTICE
  102. Comment Notice of Witness Under Subpoena
  103. NOTICE OF FILING
  104. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  105. Comment AMENDED EXHIBIT TO DEFENDANT'S SUPPLEMENTA BRIEF TO ITS MOTION TO TRANSFER TO FULTON COUNTY
  106. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  107. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  108. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate
  109. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  110. View Document AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
  111. Comment Affidavit of Service
  112. AMENDED ANSWER COUNTERCLAIM
  113. View Document AMENDED ANSWER COUNTERCLAIM
  114. Comment Second Restate And Amended Answers and Counterclaim
  115. NOTICE OF FILING
  116. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  117. Comment Notice of Filing Amended Exhibit To Defendant's Supplemental Brief To Its Motion To Transfer To Fulton County.
  118. ORDER
  119. View Document ORDER
  120. Comment Order Granting Transfer
  121. ORDER
  122. View Document ORDER
  123. Comment Order Denying Motion
  124. RESPONSE
  125. View Document RESPONSE
  126. Comment Plaintiff's Objections To Proposed Orders on Defendant's Motion and Brief
  127. MOTION
  128. View Document MOTION
  129. Comment Motion to Lift Stay of Discovery
  130. CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
  131. View Document CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
  132. Comment Case Management Order
  133. ENTRY/NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  134. View Document ENTRY/NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  135. Comment ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  136. MOTION
  137. View Document MOTION
  138. Comment CUMC'S MOTION TO DISMISS WITHOUT PREJUDICE
  139. RESPONSE
  140. View Document RESPONSE
  141. Comment Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to Defendant's [sic] Motion and Brief to Dismiss Without Prejudice
  142. MOTION
  143. View Document MOTION
  144. Comment DEFENDANTS MOTION TO SUBSTITUTE EXHIBIT E ATTACHED IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS WITHOUT PREJUDICE
  145. RESPONSE
  146. View Document RESPONSE
  147. Comment DEFENDANTS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS WITHOUT PREJUDICE
  148. RESPONSE
  149. View Document RESPONSE
  150. Comment Plaintiff's Sur-Response in Opposition to "Defendant's [sic] Motion and Brief to Dismiss Without Prejudice"
  151. ORDER
  152. View Document ORDER
  153. Comment ORDER DENYING MOTION TO DISMISS
  154. REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS-
  155. View Document REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS-
  156. Comment Corrected Plaintiff's Request for Production of Documents to Third-Party The North Georgia Conference
  157. REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS-
  158. View Document REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS-
  159. Comment Corrected Plaintiff's Request for Production of Documents to Third-Party Central North District of the North Georgia Conference
  160. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  161. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  162. Comment Certificate of Service of Discovery
  163. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  164. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  165. Comment Certificate of Service of Discovery of Defendants' First Request for Discovery
  166. MOTION
  167. View Document MOTION
  168. Comment Plaintiff's Motion for Entry of Default Judgment Against Defendants Monique Mabry, Monica Prothro and Aurelius Freeman
  169. MOTION
  170. View Document MOTION
  171. Comment Individually Named Defendants' Motion For Protective Order
  172. AFFIDAVIT
  173. View Document AFFIDAVIT
  174. Comment C.M. Freeman Dease Affidavit ISO Motion for Protective Order
  175. OPPOSITION-OTHER
  176. View Document OPPOSITION-OTHER
  177. Comment Defendants Monique Mabry, Monica Prothro, and Aureilus Freeman's Motion in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Entry of Default Judgement
  178. REPLY
  179. View Document REPLY
  180. Comment Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Its Motion for Entry of Default Judgment Against Defendants Mabry, Prothro and Freeman
  181. MOTION
  182. View Document MOTION
  183. Comment Motion to Compel
  184. CERTIFICATE
  185. View Document CERTIFICATE
  186. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Serving Discovery Responses
  187. ORDER
  188. View Document ORDER
  189. Comment ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT JUDGMENT
  190. MOTION
  191. View Document MOTION
  192. Comment Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Discovery
  193. CERTIFICATE
  194. View Document CERTIFICATE
  195. Comment RULE 5.2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE OF DISCOVERY
  196. CERTIFICATE
  197. View Document CERTIFICATE
  198. Comment Amended Certificate of Service
  199. RESPONSE
  200. View Document RESPONSE
  201. Comment Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to "Individually Named Defendants' Motion for Protective Order"
  202. ORDER
  203. View Document ORDER
  204. Comment Protective Order
  205. OPPOSITION-OTHER
  206. View Document OPPOSITION-OTHER
  207. Comment DEFENDANTS OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
  208. REQUEST
  209. View Document REQUEST
  210. Comment Request for Certificate of Immediate Review of Protective Order
  211. CERTIFICATE
  212. View Document CERTIFICATE
  213. Comment CERTIFICATE OF IMMEDIATE REVIEW
  214. MOTION
  215. View Document MOTION
  216. Comment Motion for Order of Supersedeas
  217. ORDER
  218. View Document ORDER
  219. Comment ORDER STAYING DISCOVERY
  220. NOTICE
  221. View Document NOTICE
  222. Comment Notice of Conflict
  223. CERTIFICATE
  224. View Document CERTIFICATE
  225. Comment Certificate Pursuant to Uniform Rule 5.2
  226. CERTIFICATE
  227. View Document CERTIFICATE
  228. Comment Certificate Pursuant to Uniform Rule 5.2
  229. LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  230. View Document LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  231. Comment Leave of Absence - CMFD
  232. COURT OF APPEALS ORDER
  233. View Document COURT OF APPEALS ORDER
  234. Comment DOCKETING NO. A23I0023 (APPLICATION FOR INTERLOCUTORY APPEAL DENIED)
  235. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  236. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  237. Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery: Individually Named Defendants' 30(b)(6) Amended Notice
  238. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  239. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  240. Comment Individually Named Defendants' 30(v)(6) Amended Notice of Videotaped Deposition of The West Firm at 11am
  241. CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
  242. View Document CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
  243. Comment SUPPLEMENTAL CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
  244. ORDER
  245. View Document ORDER
  246. Comment ORDER COMPELLING DISCOVERY
  247. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  248. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  249. Comment Notice of Deposition
  250. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  251. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  252. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Serving Discovery
  253. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  254. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  255. Comment Certificate of Service of Discovery-Individual Defendants
  256. NOTICE
  257. View Document NOTICE
  258. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition - Vance P. Ross
  259. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  260. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  261. Comment Notice of Deposition - Defendant Christopher Beal
  262. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  263. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  264. Comment Notice of Deposition - Defendant Mildred Gunn
  265. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  266. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  267. Comment Notice of Deposition - Defendant James Gordon
  268. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  269. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  270. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  271. OTHER
  272. View Document OTHER
  273. Comment Entry of Appearance
  274. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  275. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  276. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  277. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  278. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  279. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition
  280. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  281. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  282. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition
  283. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  284. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  285. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition
  286. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  287. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  288. Comment Notice of Deposition of Non-Party, Melinda Carlisle
  289. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  290. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  291. Comment Second Amended Notice of Deposition (Gordon)
  292. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  293. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  294. Comment Second Amended Notice of Deposition (Gunn)
  295. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  296. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  297. Comment Second Amended Notice of Deposition (Beal)
  298. NOTICE
  299. View Document NOTICE
  300. Comment Corrected Second Amended Notice of Deposition (Beal)
  301. NOTICE
  302. View Document NOTICE
  303. Comment NOTICE OF CANCELLATION OF FIRST NOTICED DEPOSITION OF NON-PARTY MELINDA CARLISLE
  304. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  305. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  306. Comment Defendant's Amended Notice of Deposition of Non-Party Melinda Carlisle
  307. CERTIFICATE
  308. View Document CERTIFICATE
  309. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Serving Supplemental Discovery Responses
  310. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  311. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  312. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Serving Discovery Requests
  313. MOTION
  314. View Document MOTION
  315. Comment Motion to Compel Defendant Mildred Gunn to Respond to Deposition Questions and for an Order Prohibiting Obstruction of Depositions by Defendants' Counsel
  316. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  317. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  318. Comment Notice of Deposition (Mabry)
  319. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  320. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  321. Comment Notice of Deposition (Sykes)
  322. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  323. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  324. Comment Amended Notice of Deposition (Gordon)
  325. RESPONSE
  326. View Document RESPONSE
  327. Comment Defendants' Response in Opposition to Plaintiff's Second Motion to Compel Discovery
  328. NOTICE OF FILING
  329. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  330. Comment -Deposition of Defendant Christopher Beal
  331. NOTICE OF FILING
  332. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  333. Comment -TRANSCRIPT Deposition of Defendant Mildred Gunn
  334. MOTION
  335. View Document MOTION
  336. Comment Individually Named Defendants' Motion to Compel Discovery
  337. OTHER
  338. View Document OTHER
  339. Comment Declaration of Chelsea M. Freeman Dease + Exhibits
  340. NOTICE OF FILING
  341. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  342. Comment - TRANSCRIPT OF 30(b)(6) Deposition of Plaintiff The West Firm, PC
  343. AMENDED MOTION
  344. View Document AMENDED MOTION
  345. Comment Plaintiff's Amended Motion to Compel Defendant Mildred Gunn to Respond to Deposition Questions and for an Order Prohibiting Obstruction of Depositions by Defendants' Counsel
  346. CERTIFICATE
  347. View Document CERTIFICATE
  348. Comment Rule 5.2 COS of Discovery-Obj. and Resp. to Pl 2nd RPDs
  349. LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  350. View Document LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  351. Comment Notice of Medical Leave of Absence
  352. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  353. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  354. Comment Third Amended Notice of Deposition (James Gordon)
  355. ORDER
  356. View Document ORDER
  357. Comment Order of Stipulation
  358. DEMAND-OTHER
  359. View Document DEMAND-OTHER
  360. Comment Demand for Trial by Jury
  361. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  362. View Document CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  363. Comment 5.2 COS of Discovery-Def Vance P Ross Supplemental Objections & Responses to Pl's 2nd RPDs
  364. NOTICE
  365. View Document NOTICE
  366. Comment Defendants' Notice of Continued Deposition of Non-Party Melinda Carlisle
  367. CERTIFICATE OF DISCOVERY
  368. View Document CERTIFICATE OF DISCOVERY
  369. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  370. MOTION
  371. View Document MOTION
  372. Comment JOINT MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF DISPOSITIVE MOTION DEADLINE
  373. ORDER EXTENDING TIME
  374. View Document ORDER EXTENDING TIME
  375. Comment ORDER EXTENDING DISPOSITIVE MOTION DEADLINE
  376. RESPONSE
  377. View Document RESPONSE
  378. Comment Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to "Individually[-]Named Defendants' Motion to Compel Discovery" and Plaintiff's Request for Award of Attorney's Fees and Costs Incurred in Responding to Same
  379. ORDER
  380. View Document ORDER
  381. Comment ORDER ON DISCOVERY MOTIONS
  382. CERTIFICATE OF DISCOVERY
  383. View Document CERTIFICATE OF DISCOVERY
  384. Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Serving Discovery Responses
  385. ANSWER
  386. View Document ANSWER/RESPONSE
  387. Comment Plaintiff's Sworn Response to Requests 4-8 of the Notice to Produce in "Individually[-]Named Defendants' 30(b)(6) Amended Notice of Deposition of The West Firm, PC
  388. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  389. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  390. Comment Third Amended Notice of Deposition (Gunn)
  391. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  392. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  393. Comment DEFENDANTS FIRST AMENDED NOTICE OF CONTINUED DEPOSITION OF NON-PARTY MELINDA CARLISLE
  394. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  395. View Document NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  396. Comment Fourth Amended Notice of Deposition (Gunn)
  397. NOTICE
  398. View Document NOTICE
  399. Comment Notice of Continued Deposition of Non-Party MELINDA CARLISLE
  400. NOTICE
  401. View Document NOTICE
  402. Comment NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF DEFENDANTS FIRST AMENDED NOTICE OF CONTINUED DEPOSITION OF NON-PARTY MELINDA CARLISLE
  403. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  404. View Document MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  405. Comment Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment
  406. STATEMENT-OTHER
  407. View Document STATEMENT-OTHER
  408. Comment Plaintiff's Statement of Material Facts
  409. REQUEST
  410. View Document REQUEST
  411. Comment Plaintiff's Request for Oral Argument of its Motion for Summary Judgment
  412. OTHER
  413. View Document OTHER
  414. Comment Plaintiff's Exhibits in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment
  415. BRIEF
  416. View Document BRIEF
  417. Comment Plaintiff's Brief in Support of Its Motion for Summary Judgment
  418. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  419. View Document MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  420. Comment DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL COUNTERCLAIMS
  421. BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
  422. View Document BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION
  423. Comment DEFENDANTS BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL COUNTERCLAIMS
  424. THEORY OF RECOVERY
  425. View Document THEORY OF RECOVERY
  426. Comment DEFENDANTS THEORIES OF RECOVERY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL COUNTERCLAIMS
  427. STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS
  428. View Document STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS
  429. Comment DEFENDANTS STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR DAMAGES AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON ALL COUNTERCLAIMS
  430. REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
  431. View Document REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
  432. Comment DEFENDANTS REQUEST FOR ORAL ARGUMENT
  433. NOTICE OF FILING
  434. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  435. Comment AMENDED NOTICE OF FILING OF TRANSCRIPT OF THE DEPOSITION OF DEFENDANT CHRISTOPHER BEAL
  436. OTHER
  437. View Document OTHER
  438. Comment INDEX OF EXHIBITS1 FILED IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  439. NOTICE OF HEARING
  440. View Document NOTICE OF HEARING
  441. Comment Notice of Hearing
  442. MOTION
  443. View Document MOTION
  444. Comment DEFENDANTS MOTION TO SEAL
  445. NOTICE OF FILING
  446. View Document NOTICE OF FILING
  447. Comment DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF FILING REDACTED DEPOSITIONS AND EXHIBITS AS ATTACHMENTS TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO SEAL
  448. LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  449. View Document LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  450. Comment Notice of Leave of Absence
  451. RESPONSE
  452. View Document RESPONSE
  453. Comment Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Seal
  454. RESPONSE
  455. View Document RESPONSE
  456. Comment DEFENDANTS SHELL RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  457. RESPONSE
  458. View Document RESPONSE
  459. Comment Plaintiff's Response Brief in Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment
  460. STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
  461. View Document STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
  462. Comment Plaintiff's Statement of Material Facts in Support of Its Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  463. OTHER
  464. View Document OTHER
  465. Comment Plaintiff's Additional Exhibit in Support of Its Opposition to Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment
  466. OBJECTIONS
  467. View Document OBJECTIONS
  468. Comment Plaintiff's Objection to a Portion of the Affidavit of Mildred Gunn
  469. ORDER
  470. View Document ORDER
  471. Comment ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE DELAYED RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
  472. RESPONSE
  473. View Document RESPONSE
  474. Comment DEFENDANTS SHELL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS COMES
  475. MOTION
  476. View Document MOTION
  477. Comment DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE DELAYED RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF MATERIAL FACTS
  478. ORAL ARGUMENT
  479. Judicial Officer CARNESALE, RACHELLE L.
  480. Hearing Time 10:30 AM
  481. ORAL ARGUMENT
  482. Judicial Officer CARNESALE, RACHELLE L.
  483. Hearing Time 10:30 AM
  484. ORDER ALLOWING FILING UNDER SEAL
  485. View Document ORDER ALLOWING FILING UNDER SEAL
  486. Comment ORDER ON MOTION TO SEAL
  487. FINAL ORDER
  488. View Document FINAL ORDER

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more