Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Alaska Unified

Court

Alaska Unified

Alaska

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-02-09
Status Reopened
Type Civil Superior Ct (3 An)|Medical Malpractice
Docket 171 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Odenthal, Karen|Estate Of Rodney L Odenthal
Defendant Mat Su Valley Medical Center Llc|Carr, Md, Kenneth
Photo of Hon. Nesbett David A

Judge

Hon. Nesbett David A

Aleutians East Borough (AK)

Alaska

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Employment File and Training and Orientation Materials of Dr. Kenneth Carr Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #54
  2. Complaint for Medical Malpractice Receipt: 2060974 Date: 02/09/2023
  3. Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
  4. Attorney Information Attorney Simonian, Margaret representing Plaintiff Estate of Rodney L Odenthal as of 02/09/2023
  5. Attorney Information Attorney Simonian, Margaret representing Plaintiff Odenthal, Karen as of 02/09/2023
  6. Return of Service - Summons Served On: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant);
  7. Attorney Information Attorney Gerlach, Scott J representing Defendant Carr MD, Kenneth as of 03/17/2023
  8. Entry of Appearance Scott J Gerlach (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  9. Demand for Jury Trial Scott J Gerlach (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  10. Attorney Information Attorney Tiemessen, John J representing Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC as of 03/20/2023
  11. Entry of Appearance John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant)
  12. Demand for Jury Trial John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant)
  13. Defendant Mt-Su Regional Medical Center's Answer to Plaintiff's Complaint John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant)
  14. Return of Service - Summons Served On: Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant);
  15. Initial Civil Pretrial Order Issued (Anchorage) Initial Pretrial Order (Anchorage) Sent on: 03/22/2023 10:25:47.59
  16. Answer to Complaint Scott J Gerlach (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  17. Notice of Report of Trial Availability John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Scott J Gerlach (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  18. Routine Pretrial Order Issued
  19. AN-23-07079CI Scott J Gerlach (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  20. Attorney Information Attorney Goodnight, Brittany A representing Plaintiff Odenthal, Karen as of 10/23/2023
  21. Attorney Information Attorney Goodnight, Brittany A representing Plaintiff Estate of Rodney L Odenthal as of 10/23/2023
  22. Plaintiff's Entry of Appearance- Brittany A Goodnight Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  23. Administrative Reassignment from Judge William F. Morse to Judge David A. Nesbett
  24. Attorney Information Attorney Babahmetovic, Aida representing Defendant Carr MD, Kenneth as of 01/30/2024
  25. Attorney Information Attorney Ferreira, Catarina representing Defendant Carr MD, Kenneth as of 01/30/2024
  26. Attorney Information Attorney Gerlach, Scott J dismissed/withdrawn for Defendant Carr MD, Kenneth on 01/30/2024
  27. Notice of Withdrawal and Substitution Of Counsel for Defendant Kenneth Carr MD Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant)
  28. Defendant's Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a at-Sue Reginoal Medical Center Amended Answer to Complaint---LODGED John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant)
  29. Motion to Amend Defendants', Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center, Answer to Complaint Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #1
  30. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC's Motion to Amend Answer Until August 5, 2024] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #2
  31. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #2: Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC's Motion to Amend Answer Until August 5, 2024] Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #2 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC's Motion to Amend Answer Until August 5, 2024] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  32. Defendant Kenneth Carr MD's Joinder in Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center's Motion to Reserve Distribution of Estate Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #1: Motion to Amend Defendants', Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center, Answer to Complaint
  33. Non-Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Amend Answer to Complaint Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #1: Motion to Amend Defendants', Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center, Answer to Complaint
  34. Order Granting Motion: Case Motion #1: Motion to Amend Defendants', Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center, Answer to Complaint Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #1 Motion to Amend Defendants', Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center, Answer to Complaint John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  35. Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #3
  36. Errata to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  37. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #4
  38. Order Granting Motion : Case Motion #4: Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #4 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  39. Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  40. Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medial Center's ("MSRMC's") Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #5
  41. Second Errata to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  42. Defendant's, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [until 09/03/2024] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #6
  43. Order Granting Defendant's, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [until 09/03/2024] Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #6 Defendant's, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [until 09/03/2024]
  44. MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order [Filed with Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  45. Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC [Filed with MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #5: Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medial Center's ("MSRMC's") Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  46. Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #5: Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medial Center's ("MSRMC's") Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  47. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Preliminary Witness List and Identification of Consulting Experts Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant);
  48. Defendant, MAT-SU Valley Meidcal LLC d/b/a MAT-SU Regional Medical Center, Preliminary Witness List and Retained Expert Identification Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant);
  49. Plaintiff's Expert Witness Identification Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  50. Plaintiff's Preliminary Witness List Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  51. Notice of Hearing: IN PERSON Motion Hearing on Pending Case Motions #3 & #5: Set for: 11/25/2024, from 9:00 am – 10:00am John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  52. Plaintiff's Supplemental Preliminary Witness List Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff);
  53. Defendant's, MAT-SU Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a MAT-SU Regional Medical Center, Supplemental Retained Expert Identification Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant);
  54. Request to Appear by Telephone Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Filing Party: Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #7
  55. Order Granting Motion: Case Motion #7:Request to Appear by Telephone Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #7 Request to Appear by Telephone John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  56. Third Errata to Defendant MAT-SU Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  57. Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #8
  58. Order Denying Motion on Record:Case Motion #3: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #3 Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  59. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until December 6, 2024] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #9
  60. Defendant Kenneth Carr MD's Joinder in Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  61. Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #10
  62. Order for Response John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #10: Motion for Reconsideration
  63. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #9: Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until December 6, 2024] Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #9 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until December 6, 2024] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  64. Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Case Motion #10: Motion for Reconsideration
  65. Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until 12-9-24 Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #11
  66. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Leave to File Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #12
  67. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #11: Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until 12-9-24 Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #11 Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time to Oppose Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order Until 12-9-24 Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); ; John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  68. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #12: Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Leave to File Reply to Plaintiff's: Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #12 Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Leave to File Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  69. Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order [and Cross-Motion to Compel] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  70. Cross-Motion to Compel Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #13
  71. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Counsel's Notice of Unavailability Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Attorney: Ferreira, Catarina (2307090) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant);
  72. Defendant, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [until 12/20/2024] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #14
  73. Defendant, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Reconsideration (linked to motion #10) Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #10: Motion for Reconsideration
  74. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #14: Defendant, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time[until 12/20/2024] Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #14 Defendant, Mat-Su Valley Medical Center d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's ("MSRMC") Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [until 12/20/2024] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  75. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Response to Plaintiff's Opposition to the Second Motion for Protective Order [and [Opposition to] Cross-Motion to Compel] Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  76. [Opposition to] Cross-Motion to Compel [Filed with Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Response to Plaintiff's Opposition to the Second Motion for Protective Order] Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #13: Cross-Motion to Compel
  77. Defendant MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective Order [Filed with Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Production of Peer Review Privileged Materials] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  78. Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Production of Peer Review Privileged Materials [Filed with Defendant MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective Order] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #13: Cross-Motion to Compel
  79. Attorney's Request for Oral Argument on Defendant MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective Order John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order
  80. Defendant MSRMC's Motion to File Overlength Combined Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective Order and Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #15
  81. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #16
  82. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Joinder to Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Reply in Support of Its Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order and Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order, Case Motion #16: Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential
  83. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #15: Defendant MSRMC's Motion to File Overlength Combined Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective:Order and Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #15 Defendant MSRMC's Motion to File Overlength Combined Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Second Motion for a Protective Order and Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  84. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Until 1-2-25] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #17
  85. Plaintiff's Partial Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #16: Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential
  86. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #17: Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Until 1-2-25] Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #17 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Until 1-2-25] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  87. Reply to Opposition to Motion to Compel Credentialing Committee Materials Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #13: Cross-Motion to Compel
  88. Plaintiffs' Motion to Accept Overlength Reply to MSRMC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross-Motion to Compel Credentialing Committee Materials Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #18
  89. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion to Accept Filing One Day Late RE Reply in Support of its Cross Motion to Compel Credentialing Committee Materials Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #19
  90. Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #20
  91. Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #21
  92. Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Reply to Plaintiff's Partial Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #16: Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center Motion to Keep Exhibits Confidential
  93. MSRMC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #21: Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline
  94. Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #21: Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline
  95. Affidavit of Brittany A. Goodnight Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff);
  96. Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #22
  97. Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #23
  98. Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #24
  99. Stipulated Protective Order Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal; Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC; Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #25
  100. Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #26
  101. Plaintiff's Entry of Appearance - Julia D. Moudy Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff);
  102. Attorney Information Attorney Moudy, Julia D representing Plaintiff Odenthal, Karen as of 01/10/2025
  103. Attorney Information Attorney Moudy, Julia D representing Plaintiff Estate of Rodney L Odenthal as of 01/10/2025
  104. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Motion for Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions Until 1-14-25] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #27
  105. MSRMC's Motion to File Overlength Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Plaintiff's Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #28
  106. [Lodged Pending Acceptance] Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #29
  107. Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #30
  108. Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that MSRMC May Be Held Vicariously Liable for Dr. Carr's Negligence Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #31
  109. MSRMC'S Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #20: Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline
  110. [Lodged] MSRMC's Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Opposition to Cross-Motion to Compel Credentials Committee Materials John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #8: Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Second Motion for Entry of a Protective Order, Case Motion #13: Cross-Motion to Compel
  111. MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Opposition to Cross-Motion to Compel Credentials Committee Materials Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #32
  112. Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File a Sur-Reply [and Motion to Strike Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Cross-Motion to Compel] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Case Motion #32: MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Opposition to Cross-Motion to Compel Credentials Committee Materials
  113. Motion to Strike Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Cross-Motion to Compel [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File a Sur-reply] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #33
  114. Plaintiff's Opposition to Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #26: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal
  115. MAT-SU Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a MAT-SU Regional Medical Center's Partial Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Case Motion #24: Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses
  116. [Lodged] Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #20: Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline
  117. Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Reply in Support of Motion Requesting Immediate Hearing to Compel Scheduling 30(b)(6) Depositions and Extend the January 13 Fact Deposition Deadline Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #34
  118. Order on Defendants' Motion for Reconsideration & Plaintiff's Motion to Compel John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #5: Cross-Motion to Compel Discovery from MSRMC [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant Mat-Su Regional Medial Center's ("MSRMC's") Motion for Entry of a Protective Order, Case Motion #10: Motion for Reconsideration, Case Motion #26: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal
  119. Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #24: Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses
  120. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #25: Stipulated Protective Order Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #25 Stipulated Protective Order John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  121. MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply [Filed with Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Sur-Reply] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #32: MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Opposition to Cross-Motion to Compel Credentials Committee Materials
  122. Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Sur-Reply [Filed with MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File Sur-Reply] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #33: Motion to Strike Sur-Reply to Plaintiff's Reply to Cross-Motion to Compel [Filed with Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Leave to File a Sur-reply]
  123. Defendants' Joint Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Until 1-30-25] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC; Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #35
  124. Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #36
  125. Attorney's Request for Oral Argument on Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Protective Order of Witness Mary Alden John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #36: Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  126. [Lodged] Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #23: Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses
  127. Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Overlength Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #37
  128. Civil Deficiency Memo mailed re: RE: Defendant’s Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Record The filed document did not contain a signature or an original signature, so you must sign the document and refile. Civil Rule 11. Deficiencies due within 20 calendar days. Civil Deficiency Memo (11/23) Sent on: 01/23/2025 10:05:50.03
  129. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Until 1-28-25] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #38
  130. Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records [Deficiency Cure] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #36: Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  131. Attorney's Request for Oral Argument on Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Protective Order of Witness Mary Alden [Duplicate] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #36: Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  132. Order Granting Motion: Case Motion #38: Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [Reply to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Until 1-28-25] Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #38 Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Until 1-28-25] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  133. Order Granting Motion: Case Motion #35: Defendants' Joint Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Until 1-30-25] Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #35 Defendants' Joint Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Until 1-30-25] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  134. Order on Request for Oral Argument on Defendant MSRC's Motion for Protective Order of Witness Case Motion #36: Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  135. Request to Appear by Telephone Attorney: Ferreira, Catarina (2307090) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Filing Party: Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #39
  136. Order Granting Motion:Case Motion #39: Request to Appear by Telephone Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #39 Request to Appear by Telephone John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Aida Babahmetovic (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff)
  137. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Motion #29, Reply to Motion #33, and Reply to Motion #23 Until 1-30-25] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #40
  138. MSRMC's Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that MSRMC May Be Held Vicariously Liable for Dr. Carr's Negligence John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #31: Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that MSRMC May Be Held Vicariously Liable for Dr. Carr's Negligence
  139. [Lodged Pending Acceptance] Mat-Su Valley Medical center LLc d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #26: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal
  140. Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Overlength Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #41
  141. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLc d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File its Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #42
  142. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Motions #33 and #23 Until 2-3-25] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #43
  143. Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Case Motion #29: [Lodged Pending Acceptance] Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct
  144. Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #44
  145. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Until 2/3/25] Attorney: Ferreira, Catarina (2307090) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant); Filing Party: Carr MD, Kenneth Case Motion #45
  146. Request to Appear by Telephone Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #46
  147. Plaintiff's Notice of Partial Non-Opposition to Defendant MSMRC Request to Appear by Telephone Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #46: Request to Appear by Telephone
  148. Order Granting Request to Appear by Telephone Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #46 Request to Appear by Telephone
  149. Order Granting Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Motion #29, Reply to Motion #33, and Reply to Motion #23 Until 1-30-25] Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #40 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Oppose Motion #29, Reply to Motion #33, and Reply to Motion #23 Until 1-30-25]
  150. Order Granting Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Overlength Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #41 Defendant MSRMC's Motion for Overlength Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion to Stay Order of Trial Court Pending Appeal
  151. Order Granting Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLc d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File its Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #42 Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLc d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File its Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence
  152. Order Granting Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Motions #33 and #23 Until 2-3-25] Odenthal, Karen Case Motion #43 Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Motions #33 and #23 Until 2-3-25]
  153. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Motion #33 Until 2-7-25 and Reply to Motion #31 Until 2-14-25] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #47
  154. Defendant Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Third Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time to File its Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence [Until 2-7-25] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #48
  155. Plaintiff's Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Record Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #36: Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  156. Defendant Kenneth Carr, M.D.'s Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Catarina Ferreira (Attorney) on behalf of Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant) Case Motion #30: Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence
  157. Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses Margaret Simonian (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Julia D Moudy (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Brittany A Goodnight (Attorney) on behalf of Karen Odenthal, Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff) Case Motion #23: Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Production of Documentary Evidence from Fact Witness Mary Alden and Discovery Responses
  158. [LODGED Pending Acceptance] Defendant MSRMC's Second Amended Answer to Complaint John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant)
  159. MSRMC's Motion to File Second Amended Answer Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #49
  160. Order Denying Motion Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #36 Defendant's Motion for Protective Order of Witness and for In Camera Review of Witness Medical Records
  161. Order on Discovery Status Re Letter of Engagement
  162. Defendant Carr's Entry of Appearance - Rando B. Wick Attorney: Wick, Rando B (0810063) Attorney: Babahmetovic, Aida (1812131) Attorney: Ferreira, Catarina (2307090) Kenneth Carr MD (Defendant);
  163. Attorney Information Attorney Wick, Rando B representing Defendant Carr MD, Kenneth as of 02/05/2025
  164. [Lodged Pending Acceptance] MSRMC's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #29: [Lodged Pending Acceptance] Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct
  165. MSRMC's Conditional Non-Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims [Filed with Cross-Motion to File Overlength Reply to Plaintiff's Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims] John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #44: Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims Based on Dr. Carr's Underlying Conduct
  166. Cross-Motion to File Overlength Reply to Plaintiff's Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims [Filed with MSRMC's Conditional Non-Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Accept Overlength Opposition to MSRMC's Motion for Summary Judgment to Dismiss Vicarious Liability Claims] Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #50
  167. MSRMC'S Oppositioin and Joinder to Dr Carr'sOpposition to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence John J Tiemessen (Attorney) on behalf of Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant) Case Motion #30: Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence
  168. Plaintiff's Non-Opposed Motion for Extension of Time [to Reply to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule of Law that Affirmative Defenses Must Be Supported by Facts in Evidence Until 2-14-25] Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Odenthal, Karen; Estate of Rodney L Odenthal Case Motion #51
  169. MSRMC's Motion to Compel Plaintiff's Production in Response to Discovery Request RE: Actual Financial Dependency Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #52
  170. Defendants Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC d/b/a Mat-Su Regional Medical Center's Motion in Limine Regarding Plaintiff's Undisclosed Expert Witness Opinion Evidence Attorney: Tiemessen, John J (9111105) Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC (Defendant); Filing Party: Mat-Su Valley Medical Center LLC Case Motion #53
  171. Plaintiff's Notice of Filing Unsigned Affidavit Attorney: Moudy, Julia D (9411112) Attorney: Simonian, Margaret (9901001) Attorney: Goodnight, Brittany A (1211096) Karen Odenthal (Plaintiff); Estate of Rodney L Odenthal (Plaintiff);

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more