Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Case Information

Filed 2021-10-21
Status OPEN
Type Malpractice Medical
Docket 201 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Thomas, Richard Michael
Defendant Pitarys, Christos J Ii | S Goldman Md C Pitarys Md Pl | Karumanchi, Prudhvi R | Baycare Medical Group Inc | Morton Plant Hospital Associat
Photo of Hon. Byrd Kimberly Sharpe

Judge

Hon. Byrd Kimberly Sharpe

Pasco County (FL)

Florida

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. DescriptionNotice Of Taking Deposition
  2. DescriptionList Of Exhibits DF
  3. DescriptionWitness List DF
  4. DescriptionWitness List FILED BY BRITTANY MICHELLE MOLINARI
  5. DescriptionRequest To Produce DF
  6. DescriptionRequest To Produce DF
  7. DescriptionRequest To Produce DF
  8. DescriptionNotice Of Serving Interrogatories DF
  9. DescriptionNotice Of Serving Interrogatories DF
  10. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories DF
  11. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  12. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  13. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  14. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  15. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  16. List Of Exhibits FILED BY HENRY E VALENZUELA
  17. Witness List FILED BY HENRY E VALENZUELA
  18. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  19. Request To Produce
  20. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  21. AGREED Order Granting ExtenDING DISCOVERY DEADLINE
  22. AGREED Order Granting ExtenDING DISCOVERY DEADLINE
  23. Notice of Production from Non Party
  24. Witness List FILED BY CHRISTOS PITARYS, II, MD
  25. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition
  26. Notice Of Conflict FILED BY CHRISTOS J PITARYS, II, MD AND WEST FLORIDA CARDIOLOGY CONSULTANTS
  27. Notice Of Telephonic Hearing 071423 AT 1145AM
  28. Motion FOR CASE MGT CONFERENCE, FILED BY PLF
  29. Notice Of Serving Proposal For Settlement FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  30. Notice Of Serving Proposal For Settlement FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  31. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  32. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  33. Notice PL
  34. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  35. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  36. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  37. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  38. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  39. Witness List FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  40. AGREED Order Of Dismissal With Prejudice AS TO AS TO DEFENDANTS PRUDHVI R KARUMANCHI MD AND BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP
  41. BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC dismissed 4/25/2023
  42. PRUDHVI R KARUMANCHI dismissed 4/25/2023
  43. Notice of Filing JOINT STIPULATION FOR ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE FILED BY DEFS
  44. Notice PL
  45. Notice PL
  46. Notice of Cancellation of Deposition 040423@230PM
  47. Response To Request Produce FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  48. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  49. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  50. Response DF
  51. Notice DF
  52. Amended Notice PL
  53. Notice OF AVAILABILITY
  54. Notice OF AVAILABILITY
  55. Notice Of Serving Proposal For Settlement FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  56. Notice OF FINAL DISPOSITION OF MEDIATION REFERRAL
  57. Request For Admissions FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  58. Request For Admissions FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  59. Mediation Results Report (IMPASSE)
  60. Certification DF
  61. Certificate of Settlement Authority FILED BY DEFS
  62. Order Setting Jury Trial (10 DAYS) 2 WEEK TRIAL DOCKET COMMENCING ON AUGUST 21 2023@9AM AND PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE AUGUST 3 @9AM
  63. Order ON RULE 4-1.5(F)(4)(B)(II) PETITION
  64. Order TO SEAL RECORD-RULE 4-1.5(F)(4)(B)(II)PETITION
  65. Notice of Non Availability FILED BY CHRISTOS PITARYS, II, MD AND WEST FLORIDA CARDIOLOGY CONSULTANTS
  66. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  67. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  68. Petition FOR ORDER PL
  69. Notice of Taking Video Deposition
  70. Attachment or Exhibit to Pleading 1
  71. Notice of Taking Video Deposition
  72. Certificate of Settlement Authority FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  73. Notice of Mediation Conference FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  74. Response To Request Production FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  75. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  76. Notice Of Taking Deposition (RE-NOTICE)
  77. Notice of Cancellation of Deposition FILED BY CHRISTOS J. PITARYS, II, M.D. AND WEST FLORIDA CARDIOLOGY CONSULTANTS
  78. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  79. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  80. Notice of Cancellation of Deposition
  81. Response To Request Production FILED BY DEFS
  82. Notice of Non Availability FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  83. Notice of Non Availability FILED BY DEFS
  84. Request For Copies
  85. Request For Copies
  86. Return of Service on Subpoena Served FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  87. Return of Service on Subpoena Served FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  88. Return of Service on Subpoena Served FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  89. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  90. Response To Request Production FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  91. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  92. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  93. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  94. Request To Produce FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  95. Order Of Referral To Mediation
  96. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  97. Notice of Taking Video Deposition
  98. Notice of Taking Video Deposition
  99. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY PLTF
  100. Response To Request Production FILED BY PLTF
  101. Certificate OF NON-OBJECTION FILED BY DEFS
  102. Notice of Taking Video Deposition
  103. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  104. Request For Copies FILED BY DEFS
  105. Request For Copies FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  106. Notice of Production from Non Party
  107. Notice Of Compliance For Request Of Copies FILED BY DEFS
  108. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  109. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories
  110. Response To Request Production FILED BY PLTF
  111. Certificate DEFENDANTS, CHRISTOS J. PITARYS, II, M.D. AND S. GOLDMAN, M.D./C. PITARYS, M.D., P.L. D/B/A WEST FLORIDA CARDIOLOGY CONSULTANTSS, CERTIFICATE OF NON-OBJECTION
  112. Notice of Non Availability FILED BY COUNSEL FOR DEFS
  113. Notice Of Telephonic Hearing (2ND AMENDED) ON 053122 @3PM
  114. Request For Production FILED BY CHRISTOS J PITARYS II MD AND S GOLDMAN MD/C PITARYS MD PL
  115. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  116. Notice of Production from Non Party
  117. Request For Copies FILED BY MORTON PLANT NORTH BAY HOPSITAL
  118. Notice of Production from Non Party
  119. Amended Notice Of Hearing 062322 at 2:45
  120. Notice of Hearing 062322 AT 2:45
  121. Notice of Completion or Compliance FILED BY DEFS
  122. Request For Copies FILED BY PLF
  123. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY S GOLDMAN MD C PITARYS MD PL
  124. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY CHRISTOS PITARYS
  125. Notice Designating Email Address
  126. Notice Of Appearance FILED BY COUNSEL FOR MORTON PLANT NORTH BAY HOSPITAL
  127. Request To Produce FILED BY DEFS
  128. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories
  129. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FOR RICHARD THOMAS
  130. Agreed Mandatory Civil Case Management Order - General Civil Case
  131. Amended Notice of Taking Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  132. Notice Of Taking Deposition
  133. Response To Request Production PL
  134. Response To Request Production PL
  135. Response To Request Production PL
  136. Response To Request Production FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  137. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  138. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  139. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  140. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  141. Mandatory COVID-19 Emergency Case Management Order
  142. Notice of Non Availability
  143. Response To Request Production FILED BY BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  144. Response To Request Production FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  145. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  146. Notice Of Serving Answers To Interrogatories FILED BY BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  147. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  148. Notice of Non Availability FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  149. Notice of Hearing 030922 AT 11:45
  150. Notice of Taking Video Deposition FILED BY RICHARD THOMAS
  151. Response To Request Production FILED BY S GOLDMAN MD C PITARYS MD PL
  152. Response To Request Production FILED BY CHRISTOS PITARYS II, M.D.
  153. Response To Request Production FILED BY MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  154. Request For Copies FILED BY DEFS
  155. Request For Copies FILED BY DEFS
  156. Certificate and/or Affidavit of Non Objections FILED BY DEFS
  157. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  158. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  159. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  160. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO PLTF
  161. Request To Produce FILED BY DEF
  162. Request To Produce FILED BY DEF
  163. Request To Produce FILED BY DEF
  164. Motion FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE, FILED BY PLF
  165. Notice of Production from Non Party
  166. Request To Produce FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  167. Request To Produce FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  168. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  169. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  170. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  171. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories FILED BY PRUDHVI KARUMANCHI
  172. Notice Designating Email Address DF
  173. Answer, Affirmative Defenses and Demand for Jury Trial DF
  174. Notice Designating Email Address DF
  175. Answer And Affirmative Defense DF
  176. Answer And Affirmative Defense AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL FILED BY PRUDHVI R KARUMANCHI MD AND BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  177. Summons Issued And Returned To MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION INC
  178. Summons Issued And Returned To ATTY BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP INC
  179. Summons Issued And Returned To ATTY PRUDHVI R KARUMANCHI
  180. Summons Issued And Returned To ATTY S GOLDMAN MD C PITARYS MD PL
  181. Summons Issued And Returned To ATTY CHRISTOS J PITARYS II MD
  182. Request To Produce FILED BY PLF
  183. Request To Produce FILED BY PLF
  184. Request To Produce FILED BY PLF
  185. Request To Produce FILED BY PLF
  186. Request To Produce FILED BY PLF
  187. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO MORTON PLANT HOSPITAL ASSN., INC.
  188. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO BAYCARE MEDICAL GROUP, INC.
  189. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories PRUDHVI R. KARUMANCHI, MD
  190. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO S. GOLDMAN, MD/C PITARYS, MD, PL
  191. Notice Of Serving Interrogatories TO CHRISTOS J PITARYS, II, MD
  192. Exhibit EXHIBIT 2
  193. Exhibit EXHIBIT 1
  194. Complaint
  195. Summons to be Issued by Clerk
  196. Summons to be Issued by Clerk
  197. Summons to be Issued by Clerk
  198. Summons to be Issued by Clerk
  199. Summons to be Issued by Clerk
  200. Notice Designating Email Address FILED BY ATTY OBO PLF
  201. Civil Cover Sheet

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.