Judge

Hon. Sheila A. Ditullio

Erie County (NY), New York

Hon. Sheila A. Ditullio has presided over 225 cases in our database. View their complete ruling history and outcome statistics below.

225

Total Cases

Resolved

About

Sheila A. DiTullio is a judge on the Erie County Court in New York, a position she has held since her election in 1995. She was re-elected without opposition in 2005 and again in 2015, serving until the term expires in 2026. Prior to her judicial tenure, DiTullio worked in the New York State Attorney General’s Office, the Erie County District Attorney’s Office, and served as an instructor at the University of Buffalo Law School. She earned her bachelor’s degree from Houghton College and her Juris Doctor from Western New England College School of Law.

Cases Presided

225 cases

Case	Date	State
1537 Union Road West Seneca Llc V. Assessor, Town Of West Seneca, Board Of Assessment Review Of West Seneca, Town Of West Seneca 2023-07-28 New York	2023-07-28	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 335 Gb Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-26 New York	2023-07-26	New York
3580 Southwestern Blvd Llc, Tr Lockport Realty Llc, Sowles Road Joint Venture Inc. V. The Assessor For The Town Of Hamburg, The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Hamburg, The Town Of Hamburg, New York 2023-07-26 New York	2023-07-26	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Amelia J. Habib V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-26 New York	2023-07-26	New York
I 290 Colvin Associates Llc, Elmlawn Cemetery V. The Assessor For The Town Of Tonawanda, The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Of Tonawanda, The Town Of Tonawanda, New York 2023-07-26 New York	2023-07-26	New York
Gregory Papke, Christine Papke V. Town Of Newstead 2023-07-25 New York	2023-07-25	New York
Up State Tower Co., Llc V. Town Of Hamburg, Town Of Hamburg Assessor, Town Of Hamburg Board Of Assessment Review 2023-07-25 New York	2023-07-25	New York
Harper & Rohan Realty, Llc V. Town Of West Seneca, Town Of West Seneca Assessor, Town Of West Seneca Board Of Assessment Review 2023-07-25 New York	2023-07-25	New York
Up State Tower Co., Llc V. Town Of Lancaster, Town Of Lancaster Assessor, Town Of Lancaster Board Of Assessment Review 2023-07-25 New York	2023-07-25	New York
J P H Properties C/o Sci Funeral Services #1721 V. Town Of Amherst 2023-07-21 New York	2023-07-21	New York
Crown Enterprises, Llc V. Town Of West Seneca 2023-07-21 New York	2023-07-21	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 93 Nyrpt, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 570 Dab 38, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Msf Niagara, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The City Of Tonawanda, And The City Of Tonawanda, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 570 Dab 19, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The City Of Tonawanda, And The City Of Tonawanda, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 1401 Nfb, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 7470 Transit, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Del 570 Ix, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Clarence, The Assessor Of The Town Of Clarence, And The Town Of Clarence, New York 2023-07-20 New York	2023-07-20	New York
The Uniland Partnership Of Delaware Lp V. Jill Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Tonawanda, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-18 New York	2023-07-18	New York
6500 Transit Road, Llc V. Town Of Cheektowaga 2023-07-18 New York	2023-07-18	New York
Devere Mortgage Corp. D/b/a Hunt Mortgage V. Emily Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Amherst, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-18 New York	2023-07-18	New York
Wayne N. Keller V. Town Of Aurora 2023-07-18 New York	2023-07-18	New York
Icc South, Inc. V. Jill Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Tonawanda, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-18 New York	2023-07-18	New York
Airport Greenhouses Llc V. Town Of Cheektowaga 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Jrt Singh Properties Llc V. Emily Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Of Amherst, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Kevin T Johnson V. Town Of Orchard Park 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Richard G Chudzik, Joseph M Dommer V. Town Of Orchard Park 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Ratajczyk Properties Llc V. Town Of Cheektowaga 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Nec Transit William Llc; Lancaster Theater Development; Outparcels Acquisitions Inc.; 81 & 3 Of Florida Inc; Danner Realty Corp.; & Transit Properties Inc. V. Town Of Lancaster 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Frank Venditti V. Town Of Lancaster 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Plaza Group 135 Llc V. Jill Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Tonawanda, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-17 New York	2023-07-17	New York
Riverwalk Parkway I Llc V. Town Of Tonawanda 2023-07-16 New York	2023-07-16	New York
12 Main Street Llc V. Town Of Hamburg 2023-07-16 New York	2023-07-16	New York
Camp 200, Llc V. Dan Stanford Assessor Of The Town Of Hamburg, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Hamburg, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-14 New York	2023-07-14	New York
Seventeen Hundred Properties, Inc V. Town Of Lancaster 2023-07-14 New York	2023-07-14	New York
Adco Management Llc V. Jill Murphy Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Tonawanda, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-14 New York	2023-07-14	New York
3712 Southwestern Boulevard, Llc V. Dan Stanford Assessor Of The Town Of Orchard Park, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The Town Of Orchard Park, Country Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-07-14 New York	2023-07-14	New York
Edwin Stevenson V. Town Of Holland 2023-07-14 New York	2023-07-14	New York
Erie Road Of Wny, Llc V. Town Of Evans 2023-07-13 New York	2023-07-13	New York
Cambria Property Group Llc V. Town Of Orchard Park 2023-07-13 New York	2023-07-13	New York
Am Elm Realty, Inc. & Franimal Llc V. Town Of Tonawanda 2023-07-13 New York	2023-07-13	New York
Tolip Tonawanda Apartments Llc A/k/a Englewood Apartments V. Town Of Tonawanda 2023-07-13 New York	2023-07-13	New York
Ruth K Dorr V. Town Of Clarence 2023-07-12 New York	2023-07-12	New York
Damar Homes, Inc. V. City Of Tonawanda 2023-07-12 New York	2023-07-12	New York
Aaron B. Siegel V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The City Of Buffalo, New York 2023-03-28 New York	2023-03-28	New York
Tristan D. Hujer And, Kathryn M. Hujer V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The City Of Buffalo, New York 2023-03-28 New York	2023-03-28	New York
Jenesis Development Llc; Great Point Studio Management (b) Qozb, Llc; Great Point Studio West Ferry Parcels, Llc V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York 2023-03-28 New York	2023-03-28	New York
Lanzer Holdings, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-21 New York	2023-03-21	New York
132 Dingens St, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-21 New York	2023-03-21	New York
Solar Solutions Of Upstate Ny, Llc & Elmwood Forest Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-21 New York	2023-03-21	New York
Newberry Construction Co., Inc. V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-21 New York	2023-03-21	New York
850 West, Llc; 552 7 Th, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
1582 Main Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Russell Mariner, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Samuel Shatkin Jr., Joanne M. Shatkin V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Fbbt/us Properties, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The City Of Buffalo, New York 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Del Linden Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The City Of Buffalo, New York 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Am Elm Realty, Inc. V. City Of Buffalo 2023-03-17 New York	2023-03-17	New York
Cathedral Park Tower Board Of Managers, Ltd. Individually And On Behalf Of The Condominium Owners At The Cathedral Park Tower Office Condominiums V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York 2023-03-14 New York	2023-03-14	New York
33 High Street Partners, Llc V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York 2023-03-10 New York	2023-03-10	New York
900 Delaware Avenue Condominium Board Of Managers, On Behalf Of All Condominium Homeowners At 900 Delaware Avenue, V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York, 2023-03-09 New York	2023-03-09	New York
Egp 130 Buffalo Llc V. The Assessor, The Board Of Assessors And The Board Of Assessment Review Of The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo 2023-03-09 New York	2023-03-09	New York
Carriage House Square Llc V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York 2023-03-09 New York	2023-03-09	New York
Rue Franklin West, Inc. V. Jason C Shell Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The City Of Buffalo, County Of Erie And State Of New York 2023-03-08 New York	2023-03-08	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 335 Gb Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Amherst, The Assessor Of The Town Of Amherst, And The Town Of Amherst, New York 2022-07-29 New York	2022-07-29	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By 2631 Sheridan Drive Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, And The Town Of Tonawanda, New York 2022-07-20 New York	2022-07-20	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Tim Donut Us Limited Inc. C/o Ryan Property Tax Services V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The City Of Tonawanda, And The City Of Tonawanda, New York 2022-07-20 New York	2022-07-20	New York
Frank Venditti V. Town Of Lancaster 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Har Wal Associates, Inc. V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Orchard Park, The Assessor Of The Town Of Orchard Park, And The Town Of Orchard Park, New York 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
Paul Marinaccio V. Town Of Clarence 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Tim Donut Us Limited, Inc. For Itself And As Agent In Fact For Colvin Holdings Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, And The Town Of Tonawanda, New York 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
In The Matter Of The Application For Review Under Article 7 Of The Real Property Tax Law Of A Tax Assessment By Tim Donut Us Limited Inc. V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The Town Of Tonawanda, The Assessor Of The Town Of Tonawanda, And The Town Of Tonawanda, New York 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
Wayne N. Keller V. Town Of Aurora 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
8570 Roll Road Holdings, Llc And Blum Development, Llc V. Town Of Clarence 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
Nec Transit William Llc; Lancaster Theater Development; Outparcels Acquisitions Inc.; 81 & 3 Of Florida Inc; Danner Realty Corp.; & Transit Properties Inc. V. Town Of Lancaster 2022-07-19 New York	2022-07-19	New York
2215 Delaware Avenue, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-28 New York	2022-03-28	New York
Herbert M. Siegel V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-25 New York	2022-03-25	New York
Gpk Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-25 New York	2022-03-25	New York
900 Delaware Avenue Condominium Board Of Managers On Behalf Of All Condominium Homeowners At 900 Delaware Avenue V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York, 2022-03-23 New York	2022-03-23	New York
457 Niagara Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Har Wal Associates, Inc. V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Victoria 1927, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Niagara Maryland Development V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Robert Bavisotto, And Susan Bavisotto V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
430 Niagara Street Associates V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Harbor District Associates, Llc V. The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo, The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, And The City Of Buffalo, New York 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
Scf Rc Funding Iv Llc V. City Of Lackawanna 2022-03-22 New York	2022-03-22	New York
64 West Chippewa Associates Llc & Celoron Development Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-21 New York	2022-03-21	New York
Murak Properties Llc V. City Of Lackawanna 2022-03-21 New York	2022-03-21	New York
Rano Development Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-21 New York	2022-03-21	New York
Gramax, Llc A/k/a Franks Independent Service Inc V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-21 New York	2022-03-21	New York
Newberry Construction Co., Inc. V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-18 New York	2022-03-18	New York
746 748 Elmwood Avenue Inc. V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-17 New York	2022-03-17	New York
Manzoor Musa V. City Of Lackawanna 2022-03-17 New York	2022-03-17	New York
Mla Development, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-17 New York	2022-03-17	New York
Crown Atlantic Co. V. The Assessor Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review Of The City Of Buffalo, The City Of Buffalo 2022-03-17 New York	2022-03-17	New York
Bright Elm, Llc V. City Of Buffalo 2022-03-16 New York	2022-03-16	New York
Cathedral Park Tower Board Of Managers, Ltd. Individually And On Behalf Of Certain Condominium Owners At The Cathedral Park Tower Office Condominiums, V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York, 2022-03-16 New York	2022-03-16	New York
33 High Street Partners, Llc, V. Commissioner Of Assessment Of The City Of Buffalo, The Board Of Assessment Review For The City Of Buffalo And The City Of Buffalo In The County Of Erie, New York, 2022-03-10 New York	2022-03-10	New York

Full Analytics Report

Ruling patterns
Case duration stats
Appeal reversal rates
Comparable benchmarks

$20

One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more

Case Details

809568/2023809355/2023809375/2023809384/2023809385/2023809273/2023809311/2023809300/2023809295/2023809165/2023809150/2023809107/2023809103/2023809068/2023809070/2023809111/2023809127/2023809131/2023808910/2023808972/2023

New York

Case Types for All Time