Judge

Hon. Denise A. Hartman

New York

Hon. Denise A. Hartman has presided over 176 cases in our database. View their complete ruling history and outcome statistics below.

176

Total Cases

Resolved

About

Denise A. Hartman serves as a judge on the New York Court of Claims, having been appointed by Governor Andrew Cuomo in 2015. In the same year, she was also appointed as an acting justice on the Supreme Court’s 3rd Judicial District. Her judicial service reflects a commitment to adjudicating claims against the state and overseeing significant civil matters within New York’s court system.

Cases Presided

176 cases

Case	Date	State
Peachtree Settlement Funding, Llc V. New York Life Insurance Company, New York Life Insurance And Annuity Corporation, Lydia King 2024-07-02 New York	2024-07-02	New York
150 State Street Llc (76.33 1 1), Royal Albany Llc V. Albany City 2024-07-02 New York	2024-07-02	New York
150 State Street Llc (76.33 1 2), Royal Albany Llc V. Albany City 2024-07-02 New York	2024-07-02	New York
Ydrz Albany 248 State St., Llc V. Albany City 2024-07-02 New York	2024-07-02	New York
Wilmington Savings Fund Society, Fsb Not In Its Individual Capacity, But Solely As Owner Trustee Of Csmc 2019 Rpl 11 Trust V. Todd Daggett, Capital Communications Fcu, John Doe #1 Through John Doe #10, The Last Ten Names Being Fictitious And Unknown To The Plaintiff, The Person Or Parties Intended Being The Persons Or Parties, If Any, Having Or Claiming An Interest In Or Lien Upon The Mortgaged Premises Described In The Complaint 2024-05-24 New York	2024-05-24	New York
Santander Consumer Usa, Inc. V. Centereach Car Care Center Ltd, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2024-02-07 New York	2024-02-07	New York
Elizabeth Jacobs V. Zachary Jacobs 2024-02-01 New York	2024-02-01	New York
Chpe Properties, Inc. V. Barbara Wright A/k/a Barbara Dziobecki 2024-01-25 New York	2024-01-25	New York
New York State Office Of Victim Services V. Isaiah Jordan 2024-01-11 New York	2024-01-11	New York
Vw Credit Inc., And Vw Credit Leasing Ltd V. Bx Auto Concept, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-09-22 New York	2023-09-22	New York
Supreme Court Of New York County Of Albany In Re Matter Of Salzer 2023-09-19 New York	2023-09-19	New York
Denise Luczak V. Aaron Luczak 2023-09-18 New York	2023-09-18	New York
Td Bank, N.a. V. Alex Tacoaman Aka A P Tacoamanchanatas, New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles, One 2015 Nissan Vin Jn 1 Ar 5 Efxm 280776 2023-09-18 New York	2023-09-18	New York
Discover Bank V. Broadview Federal Credit Union, Shaun Mullen, Tiffany Mullen 2023-09-08 New York	2023-09-08	New York
In The Matter Of A Parentage Proceeding Concerning Anonymous 2023-08-21 New York	2023-08-21	New York
New York State Office Of Victim Services V. Jonathan Ogando 2023-08-14 New York	2023-08-14	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. Bayfruit Corp D/b/a/ Sheepshead Bay Marketplace 1717 Avenue Z Brooklyn, New York 11235 2023-07-27 New York	2023-07-27	New York
Christina Buck V. Geico Indemnity Company 2023-07-19 New York	2023-07-19	New York
Robert Ferguson V. Fidelity & Guaranty Life Insurance Company Of New York, Associates Of Clifton Park Insurance Agency, John Doe 1 100 2023-07-12 New York	2023-07-12	New York
Flagship Credit Acceptance Llc, V. Myrtle Ave Parking, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-07-12 New York	2023-07-12	New York
Ozgur Gurpinar V. Nilgun Alagoz 2023-06-30 New York	2023-06-30	New York
Mgv Nyc Regional Center Llc V. Secretary Of State Of The State Of New York 2023-06-26 New York	2023-06-26	New York
Basil Seggos As Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Environmental Conservation, New York State Department Of Environmental Conservation V. Casper Smith 2023-06-08 New York	2023-06-08	New York
Gilberto Fulgencio Mota V. Sheila Maria Oquendo Semprit 2023-05-30 New York	2023-05-30	New York
In The Matter Of The Application Of Harmony Mills South, Llc V. Requiring Mcfay Contracting, Inc., As Lienor, To Either A Mechanic's Lien Or Show Cause Why The Notice Of Lien Should Not Be Vacated And Cancelled Of Record Under The Provisions Of Lien Law 59 2023-05-08 New York	2023-05-08	New York
In The Matter Of The Application Of Deborah Anne Chapin, Petitioner, For Leave To Change Petitioner's Name. 2023-04-11 New York	2023-04-11	New York
Albany Medical Center Hospital V. Barbara Cardone 2023-03-31 New York	2023-03-31	New York
Santander Consumer Usa, Inc. V. Matt's Auto Body, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-03-29 New York	2023-03-29	New York
In The Matter And Application Of Stephanie Michelle Davis, Petitioner For Leave To Change Her Name To Stephanie Michelle Mosso. 2023-03-20 New York	2023-03-20	New York
Charles Stella V. Gabrielle Schaming 2023-03-16 New York	2023-03-16	New York
Sarah Bailey V. Adam Nguyen 2023-03-14 New York	2023-03-14	New York
Hyundai Capital America, Inc. And Hyundai Lease Titling Trust V. Bt Automotive Inc, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-02-28 New York	2023-02-28	New York
Phillip Sperry V. Christian Sperry, Colton Sperry, Calvin Sperry 2023-02-23 New York	2023-02-23	New York
In The Matter Of The Application Of L G 2023-02-21 New York	2023-02-21	New York
Gavcarcorp, Llc V. Albany County Clerk, Keybank National Association 2023-02-17 New York	2023-02-17	New York
Td Bank, N.a. V. Tmt Collision Specialist Llc, Big City Haul, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles, One 2018 Chevrolet Vin 1 Gc 2 Kveg 9 Jz 108054 2023-02-17 New York	2023-02-17	New York
Nir Sapir V. Cristian L. Casco 2023-02-17 New York	2023-02-17	New York
Thabet Abdel Alim Wahba Mansour V. Amal Abdalla Mohamed 2023-02-08 New York	2023-02-08	New York
Ally Bank V. Nyc Wreck A Mended Collision Corp., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-02-07 New York	2023-02-07	New York
Andrew William Moeller V. New York State Department Of Health, Vital Records Section 2023-02-06 New York	2023-02-06	New York
U.s. Bank Trust National Association, Not In Its Individual Capacity But Solely As Owner Trustee For Rcf 2 Acquisition Trust, V. Clarissa Smith A/k/a Clarissa A. Smith, New York State Department Of Taxation And Finance, Lvnv Funding Llc, United States Of America, Internal Revenue Service,, John Doe #1 Through John Doe #12 The Last Twelve Names Being Fictitious And Unknown To Plaintiff, The Persons Or Parties Intended Being The Tenants, Occupants, Persons Or Corporations, If Any Having Or Claiming An Interest In Or Lien Upon The Premises, Described In The Complaint, 2023-02-06 New York	2023-02-06	New York
Albany Silver Maple Properties Llc V. Stewarts Shops Corporation, R.m. Dalrymple Company Inc 2023-01-23 New York	2023-01-23	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. Salmo Corp D/b/a Spice World, 123 21 Liberty Ave., Richmond Hill, New York 11419 2023-01-19 New York	2023-01-19	New York
Vera L Vaccaro V. Benjamin Vaccaro 2023-01-19 New York	2023-01-19	New York
Barry D Taylor V. Ginger Love, Jane Doe 2023-01-19 New York	2023-01-19	New York
Rosch Brothers, Inc. V. Stanley Rosenberg 2023-01-17 New York	2023-01-17	New York
William Kitmir V. Michele Espanet Kitmur 2023-01-17 New York	2023-01-17	New York
Erwin Geraldo Belizario Escueta V. Frances Margarita Cabauatan Escueta 2023-01-13 New York	2023-01-13	New York
U.s. Bank Trust National Association, As Trustee Of Cvi Cgs Mortgage Loan Trust I V. Carmen H Murray, Calin C Murray, Hudson Valley Community College, Sefcu, Credit Acceptance Corporation, John Doe #1 Through John Doe #12 2023-01-12 New York	2023-01-12	New York
Khamzai Makhmadvali V. Nataliya Protas 2023-01-11 New York	2023-01-11	New York
Melisa Levi V. Xavier P Foxe 2023-01-11 New York	2023-01-11	New York
The New York State Commissioner Of Taxation And Finance V. Bank Of America, Maharani Pokhai 2023-01-10 New York	2023-01-10	New York
K. R. Infant By Mother And Natural Guardian Molly Empire And Molly Empire, Individually V. Mary Christina Whyte M.d., Albany Medical Center 2023-01-10 New York	2023-01-10	New York
Joseph Dominic Bolognese V. Mary T. Bassett M.d., M.p.h. The Commissioner, New York State Department Of Health 2023-01-09 New York	2023-01-09	New York
Mercedes Benz Financial Services Usa, Llc V. Lux V 2021 Corp, Dmv, One 2022 Mercedes Benz Vin W 1 K 6 G 6 Db 2 Na 110320 2023-01-06 New York	2023-01-06	New York
United Professional & Service Employees Union, Local 1222 V. Troy Ambulance Service, Inc. D/b/a Empire Ambulance Service 2023-01-05 New York	2023-01-05	New York
Hyundai Motor Finance, V. Advance A 1 Body Shop Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-01-04 New York	2023-01-04	New York
Roger John Stewart V. Olena Stewart 2023-01-04 New York	2023-01-04	New York
Manufacturers And Traders Trust Co. V. Reef Parking Dba Impark, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-01-03 New York	2023-01-03	New York
Toyota Motor Credit Corporation V. Astoria Height Auto Collision, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-01-03 New York	2023-01-03	New York
Td Bank, Na, V. Action Autobody Inc.,, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2023-01-03 New York	2023-01-03	New York
Mashkhura Rahimova V. Rustam Umarov 2022-12-28 New York	2022-12-28	New York
Broadview Federal Credit Union, Successor By Merger And Name Change To Capital Communications Federal Credit Union V. Randolph S. Phillips A/k/a Randolph Phillips, Regina L. Tebordo Phillips, Td Bank Usa Na, American Express National Bank, Capital One Bank, Usa Na, John/jane Doe 1 Through John/jane Doe 10 2022-12-23 New York	2022-12-23	New York
Kyle A Murray V. Tammy M Murray 2022-12-20 New York	2022-12-20	New York
Mary Elizabeth Cade V. Cares, Inc., Cares Of Ny, Inc., Corporation For Aids Research, Education And Services, Inc. (cares, Inc.) 2022-12-13 New York	2022-12-13	New York
Us Bank Trust National Association As Trustee For Igloo Series Iv Trust, Referee V. Barbara N. Hall, Lvnv Funding Llc, New York State Department Of Taxation And Finance 2022-12-05 New York	2022-12-05	New York
City Of Albany V. Lakeview Loan Servicing, Llc, Flagstar Bank, Fsb 2022-12-05 New York	2022-12-05	New York
Erich Hartmann V. New York State Department Of Health 2022-12-05 New York	2022-12-05	New York
Pioneer Bank, As Successor By Conversion And Name Change To Pioneer Savings Bank V. Francis X. Foley Iii, Emily F. Foley, Francis X. Foley Jr., And, John/jane Doe 1 Through John/jane Doe 10 (said Last Ten Names Being Fictitious, It Being The Intention Of Plaintiff To Designate Any And All Other Tenants, Occupants Or Other Persons Or Entities Having Or Claiming An Interest In The Real Property Which Is The Subject Of This Action, Whose Identity Is Not Presently Known To Plaintiff) 2022-11-07 New York	2022-11-07	New York
Philip James Cirulli V. New York State Department Of Health, Vital Records Section 2022-11-04 New York	2022-11-04	New York
Victoria F. Potter As Natural Parent And Guardian Of Dfv, An Infant Under The Age Of 14 Years V. Jelly Beans Daycare 2022-10-24 New York	2022-10-24	New York
Toyota Motor Credit Company V. Africa United Auto Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-10-20 New York	2022-10-20	New York
Celeste T. Barrett Tolliver, Denton Tolliver V. Eileen D. Curwen, Gregg D. Curwen 2022-10-10 New York	2022-10-10	New York
Lakeview Loan Servicing, Llc V. Andy Waldron, Barbara E. Savery, Capital Communications Fcu, Midland Funding, Llc, John Doe 2022-09-22 New York	2022-09-22	New York
Nadira Yakubova V. Eugene Cherry 2022-09-21 New York	2022-09-21	New York
Pioneer Bank, As Successor By Conversion And Name Change To Pioneer Savings Bank V. Dorothy E. Keith Estate Defendants (said Name Being Fictitious, It Being The Intention Of The Plaintiff To Designate Thereby Any And All Persons Or Entiies Not Specifically Name And Joined As A Party Defendant Herein Who Are The Heirs At Law, Next Of Kin, Distributees, Executors, Administrators, Trustees, Legatees, Assignors, Lienors, Creditors And Successors In Interest Of Dorothy E. Keith, Deceased, And Generally All Persons Having Or Claiming Under, By Or Through The Said Dorothy E. Keith, Deceased, Or, Through And Distributee Or Heir At Law Of The Said Dorothy E. Kith, Deceased, By Purchade, Inheritance, Lien Or Otherwise, Any Right, Title Or Interest In And To The Respective Husbands Or Widowers, Wives And Widows Of Said Person(s), If Any, All Of Whoes Names Are Unknown To Plaintiff), Suzanne Mcdonald A/k/a Suzanne Kelley, James F. Mcdonald, Karen E. Vandemark, Steven G. Mcdonald, Thomas M. Mcdonal 2022-09-02 New York	2022-09-02	New York
Exeter Finance Llc V. John Devereaux, Dmv, One 2017 Honda Vin 1 Hgcr 2 F 17 Ha 069788 2022-09-01 New York	2022-09-01	New York
In The Matter Of The Application Of Jose M. Baquerizo, As Parent For Leave To Change The Name Of His Child. 2022-08-31 New York	2022-08-31	New York
John Corrigan V. Bank Of America, N.a., Carrington Mortgage Services, County Of Albany 2022-08-25 New York	2022-08-25	New York
Ally Bank V. Brook Parking Garage, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-08-24 New York	2022-08-24	New York
Antoine Smith V. Abdur Rehman Khan, Rejha Group, Llc 2022-08-24 New York	2022-08-24	New York
Nybdc Local Development Corporation D/b/a Pursuit Community Finance, F/k/a The Excelsior Growth Fund V. Hammer Club Corp., Jiahao Liao, Qiang Feng 2022-08-23 New York	2022-08-23	New York
John Mcdonald V. Tamara Mcdonald 2022-08-21 New York	2022-08-21	New York
Toorak Capital Partners, Llc V. 135 Fourth Avenue Llc S/h/a 135 Fourth Avenue Llc, Pauleen Hendricks, New York State Department Of Taxation And Finance, John Doe Refused Name Sued Herein As John Doe #1, Gelsen Berberenasoto Sued Herein As John Doe #2, Jane Doe Rfused Name Sued Herein As Jane Doe #1, Alexis Berberenasoto Sued Herein As Jane Doe #2 2022-08-19 New York	2022-08-19	New York
New York State Workers' Compensation Board V. Imelda Saito Individually And D/b/a The Maple Hill Rest Home 2022-08-17 New York	2022-08-17	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. Troy Mini Market Llc D/b/a Troy Mini Market, 71 Congress Street, Troy, New York 12180 2022-08-17 New York	2022-08-17	New York
Rachel Novick V. Steve Novick 2022-08-16 New York	2022-08-16	New York
Audi Financial Services V. Perfection Auto Services, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-07-26 New York	2022-07-26	New York
Ally Bank Lease Trust V. Bobby's Auto Repair & Collision, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-07-26 New York	2022-07-26	New York
Santander Consumer Usa, Inc. V. Brother Auto Body Shop, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-07-15 New York	2022-07-15	New York
Santander Consumer Usa, Inc. V. Online Automotive Inc, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-07-07 New York	2022-07-07	New York
Nadezhda Odes V. Alam Shodiev 2022-06-27 New York	2022-06-27	New York
Lisa Lorraine O'neil V. Mary T Bassett M.d., M.p.h. 2022-06-27 New York	2022-06-27	New York
Hyundai Capital America V. Carl P Mohan Dba Mohan's Auto Repair, Jij Auction Services Ltd, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-06-15 New York	2022-06-15	New York
Nissan Motor Acceptance Company Llc V. Jose Dilone, Dmv, One 2021 Nissan Vin 5 N 1 Az 2 Ds 1 Mc 138101 2022-06-14 New York	2022-06-14	New York
Tracy Anne Gresis Nash V. Derek James Nash 2022-06-14 New York	2022-06-14	New York
Sally Ann Edwards V. Michael Henderson Edwards 2022-05-20 New York	2022-05-20	New York
Sean Froehlich V. Amy Froehlich 2022-05-16 New York	2022-05-16	New York
Hvt, Inc. V. Pkck Autobody & Mechanics, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-05-04 New York	2022-05-04	New York
Stephanie Dawn Turan V. Serhat Turan 2022-04-28 New York	2022-04-28	New York
Ryan A De Franco V. Sanja Blau 2022-04-25 New York	2022-04-25	New York
Daniel Safer V. Katherine Phillips 2022-04-20 New York	2022-04-20	New York
Nationstar Mortgage Llc D/b/a Mr. Cooper V. Ian J. Wessman, New York State Department Of Taxation And Finance, United States Of America, John Doe #1 Through John Doe #12, The Last Twelve Names Being Fictitious And Unknown To Plaintiff, The Persons Or Parties Intended Being The Tenants, Occupants, Persons Or Corporations, If Any, Having Or Claiming An Interest In Or Lien Upon The Subject Property Described In The Complaint, 2022-04-20 New York	2022-04-20	New York
Nybdc Local Development Corporation D/b/a Pursuit Community Finance F/k/a The Excelsior Growth Fund V. Thanya Thai Cuisine, Patrick Katkaew 2022-04-19 New York	2022-04-19	New York
Steven Sanchez, Andrea Sanchez V. Bcms Bowling Inc. D/b/a Del Lanes 2022-04-18 New York	2022-04-18	New York
Stratosphere Development Co. Llc D/b/a Republic Jet Center V. Marie Therese Dominguez As Commissioner Of The New York State Department Of Transportation, New York State Department Of Transportation 2022-04-12 New York	2022-04-12	New York
Midland Credit Management Inc. V. Anargyros K Dikas Aka Anargyros Dikas 2022-04-04 New York	2022-04-04	New York
Exeter Finance Llc V. Jonathan Mendoza, Dmv, One 2019 Nissan Vin 3 N 1 Ab 7 Ap 0 Ky 266407 2022-03-28 New York	2022-03-28	New York
Maria D. Torres V. Village One Llc D/b/a Lake Shore Apartments, Lake Shore Park Llc 2022-03-28 New York	2022-03-28	New York
Rickner Pllc V. The New York State Department Of Corrections And Community Supervision, Michael J. Ranieri 2022-03-28 New York	2022-03-28	New York
Emily G. Saunders V. Peter J. Saunders 2022-03-23 New York	2022-03-23	New York
Absolute Resolutions Investments Llc V. Sheila Liptak 2022-03-23 New York	2022-03-23	New York
David Katzman V. Tyrone M. Hedgepeth 2022-03-15 New York	2022-03-15	New York
Susan Lee Cox V. Damon L. Berryman 2022-03-11 New York	2022-03-11	New York
Nys Office Of Victim Services V. Nazeem Francis 2022-03-08 New York	2022-03-08	New York
Enil Andermanis V. Atticus Moorman, Robert Baggett 2022-03-08 New York	2022-03-08	New York
Willie Dabbs V. Montana Colton Love, Jason Fowler, Elite Sports & Entertainment Marketing Group, Eddie Hearns, Matchroom Boxing, Llc 2022-03-08 New York	2022-03-08	New York
Elizabeth K Poole, John F Poole V. Hbol Llc D/b/a Parker Inn, 434 State Street Llc, Condiminiums At The Parker Inn Inc, Arts Center And Theatre Of Schenectady D/b/a Proctors Theatre 2022-03-03 New York	2022-03-03	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. K&b Gourmet Deli Inc. D/b/a K&b Gourmet Deli, 1980 2 Nd Avenue, New York, New York 10029 2022-03-01 New York	2022-03-01	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. A & N Deli & Grocery Inc. D/b/a A & N Deli & Grocery, 34 26 Steinway Street, Long Island City, New York 11101 2022-03-01 New York	2022-03-01	New York
Stacy Kieper V. Zachary Kieper 2022-02-22 New York	2022-02-22	New York
Town Of Guilderland V. Kent Hanson, Joshua White, The Backdoor Albany, Abc Corporation, John Doe, Jane Doe 2022-02-22 New York	2022-02-22	New York
Crisafullibros. V. Hogans Paving, Llc 2022-02-10 New York	2022-02-10	New York
Chrysler Capital V. Magic Touch Auto & Collision, The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-02-10 New York	2022-02-10	New York
Warren Ashenmil V. Pmi International Stone Importers, Precision Marble, Inc., Jeffrey Ward 2022-02-07 New York	2022-02-07	New York
Deborah A. Carey Kilcullen V. Dennis F. Kilcullen 2022-01-31 New York	2022-01-31	New York
Richard A. Ball, Commissioner Of Agriculture And Markets Of The State Of New York V. Bread Depo Inc. D/b/a Leskes, 7612 5 Th Avenue, Brooklyn, New York 11209 2022-01-28 New York	2022-01-28	New York
Peter Saunders V. Emily Saunders 2022-01-24 New York	2022-01-24	New York
Nys Office Of Victim Services V. Anthony Daniels 2022-01-19 New York	2022-01-19	New York
Hvt, Inc. V. Universe Towing, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-01-14 New York	2022-01-14	New York
State Farm Mutual Automobile Ins. Co. A/s/o Silfredo Vazquez V. Christopher Mozone 2022-01-13 New York	2022-01-13	New York
Santander Consumer Usa, Inc. V. Lees Auto Repair, Inc., The New York State Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-01-12 New York	2022-01-12	New York
Adina German V. Guram Gelashvili 2022-01-12 New York	2022-01-12	New York
Luis Serrano V. Marilyn Tollinchi, The New York Department Of Motor Vehicles 2022-01-12 New York	2022-01-12	New York
R. Grace Dillon V. Charles A. Bootier 2022-01-12 New York	2022-01-12	New York
Nivea D Lounds V. Hta Washington Medical Arts Ii, Fee, Llc 2022-01-09 New York	2022-01-09	New York
Complete Packaging And Shipping Supplies, Inc V. Raymond Associates Llc 2021-12-01 New York	2021-12-01	New York
Cem Tiryaki V. Zeynep Aglamis 2021-11-11 New York	2021-11-11	New York

Full Analytics Report

Ruling patterns
Case duration stats
Appeal reversal rates
Comparable benchmarks

$20

One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more

Case Details

906166-24906173-24906175-24906177-24904940-24901403-24901259-24900982-24900637-24909049-23908828-23908759-23908785-23908470-23908007-23907746-23907012-23906742-23906415-23906425-23