Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Missouri Unified County

Court

Missouri Unified County

Missouri

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-10-17
Type Cc Pers Injury Other
Docket 129 entries
Disposition jury verdict - civil

Parties

Plaintiff Caruso, Jeanne|Schmittgens, Robert Eugene
Defendant Robinson, Krystal M|Robinson, Tony R.|Carner, Kristie Lynn|Ultimate Realty, Llc
Photo of Hon. Connolly Madeline O

Judge

Hon. Connolly Madeline O

St. Louis city (MO)

Missouri

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  2. udgment Entered
  3. rder THEREFORE, it is hereby Ordered and Adjudged that Plaintiff Jeanne Caruso have and recover from Defendant Ultimate Realty, LLC, the sum of Two Hundred, Twenty-Five Thousand Dollars and 00/100. So Ordered: Judge Madeline O. Connolly
  5. inancial Documents Filed Plaintiffs Bill of Costs; Exhibit A; Exhibit B; Exhibit C; Exhibit D; Exhibit E; Exhibit F; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  6. roposed Judmt/Dec Dis Filed Full and Final Judgment; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  8. ury Verdict - Civil
  9. rial Minutes Filed
  10. eport Filed
  11. ury Reached Final Verdict
  12. ury Instructions Filed
  14. rial Minutes Filed
  15. iling: JURY PANEL LIST
  16. ury Trial Conducted Associated Entries: 05/07/2025 - Jury Trial Scheduled + Scheduled For: 06/30/2025; 8:59 AM; MADELINE O CONNOLLY; City of St. Louis
  18. xhibit Filed Plaintiffs First Amended Exhibit List; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  19. otice of Dismissal Plaintiffs Dismissal Without Prejudice of Plaintiffs Claims for Medical Past and Future Medical Bills; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  21. otion to Dismiss Dismissal of Crossclaims; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER, ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  22. rder PLAINTIFFS' PROPOSED INSURANCE QUESTIONS
  23. rder DEFENDANTS' RULE 69.025 MOTIONS
  24. rder PLAINTIFF'S MOTION IN LIMINE
  25. rder DEFENDANTS' KRISTIE LYNN CARNER AND ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC'S MOTIONS IN LIMINE
  26. rder of Dismissal COMES NOW, Plaintiff Jeanne Caruso, by and through, her undersigned counsel, and dismisses Defendants Krystal Michelle Robinson, Tony Ray Robinson, and Kristie Lynn Carner, without prejudice.
  28. otice Notice of Filing Medical Records by Affidavit; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  29. otice of Dismissal NOTICE OF DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF CERTAIN DEFENDANTS COMES NOW, Plaintiff Jeanne Caruso, by and through, her undersigned counsel, anddismisses Defendants Krystal Michelle Robinson, Tony Ray Robinson, and Kristie LynnCarner, without prejudice; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  30. xhibit Filed Plaintiffs Exhibit List; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  31. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 06/24/2025 - Pre-trial Conference Scheduled Scheduled For: 06/26/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  33. ther Proposed Document Filed Plaintiffs Proposed Insurance Question; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  34. ertificate of Delivery Certificate of Deposition.
  36. re-trial Conference Scheduled Associated Entries: 06/26/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 06/26/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  38. otion Filed Plaintiffs Rule 69.025 Motion; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  39. otion In Limine Plaintiffs Motions in Limine; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  41. otion Filed Defendants Rule 69.025 Motion; Exhibit A; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER, ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  42. otion In Limine Defendants Kristie Lynn Carner and Ultimate Realtys Motions in Limine; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER, ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  44. rder This matter is set for status conference on June 26, 2025 at 9:00am in Division 13. All parties and Attorneys for all parties are required to appear at that time. Each party must file any requested Motions in Limine at least 7 days prior to the pre-trial conference. All timely filed motions will be heard at the pre-trial conference. Each party must bring 3 copies of the following to the pre-trial conference: (1) Joint proposed early case summary with alternate paragraphs for those areas where the parties cannot agree. (2) Draft proposed jury instructions. (3) Exhibit list (4) Witness list. So Ordered: Judge Theresa Counts Burke
  45. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 06/02/2025 - Counsel Status Hrng Scheduled Scheduled For: 06/09/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  47. rder Case set for trial status conference on 6/9/25 at 9am in Division 13. So Ordered: Judge Theresa Counts Burke
  48. ounsel Status Hrng Scheduled Associated Entries: 06/09/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 06/09/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  50. otice to Take Deposition Notice of Deposition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  52. ert Serv Answers Interrog Fil Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  54. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 05/07/2025 - Counsel Status Hrng Scheduled Scheduled For: 05/19/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  55. udge Assigned Filed By: THERESA COUNTS BURKE
  56. rd Transfer P/Judge for Assn Cause is transferred from Division 4 to Division 13 for Trial. So Ordered Presiding Judge Christopher E McGraugh 36301
  57. otion Denied Motion for Continuance was DENIED. Parties still have discovery to complete and need to complete 3 to 4 depositions. Plaintiff?s Counsel is also scheduled to be in trial in case # 2322-CC01298. So Ordered Presiding Judge Christopher E McGraugh 36301
  58. otion for Continuance Joint Motion to Continue Trial Setting; Notice of Hearing - Motion to Continue Trial Setting; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  59. ounsel Status Hrng Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/12/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 05/19/2025; 9:00 AM; THERESA COUNTS BURKE; City of St. Louis
  60. ury Trial Scheduled THREE DAY TRIAL REVISED Event Information: New EventRoom: Division 13; Associated Entries: 06/30/2025 - Jury Trial Conducted Scheduled For: 06/30/2025; 8:59 AM; MADELINE O CONNOLLY; City of St. Louis
  61. rd Transfer P/Judge for Assn Cause assigned to Division # 04 for trial on 06/30/25. see court order So Ordered: Christopher E. McGraugh, Judge
  62. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 10/23/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Scheduled For: 06/30/2025; 8:00 AM; CHRISTOPHER EDWARD MCGRAUGH; City of St. Louis
  63. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 02/05/2024 - Motion Hearing Scheduled Scheduled For: 03/14/2024; 9:00 AM; JOSEPH PATRICK WHYTE; City of St. Louis
  64. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 02/13/2024 - Motion Hearing Scheduled Scheduled For: 04/04/2024; 9:00 AM; JOSEPH PATRICK WHYTE; City of St. Louis
  65. otice to Take Deposition Notice of Deposition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  66. ertificate of Service Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  67. ross Claim Filed Defendant Ultimate Realty, LLCs Crossclaim for Contribution; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  68. nswer Filed Defendant Ultimate Realty, LLCs Answer to Plaintiffs First Amended Petition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  69. ntry of Appearance Filed Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC
  70. ummons Issued-Circuit Document ID: 24-SMCC-16477, for ULTIMATE REALTY, LLC.
  71. lias Summons Requested Plaintiffs Request for a Summons for Ultimate Realty, LLC; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  72. ross Claim Filed Defendant Kristie Lynn Carners Crossclaim for Contribution; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  73. otion Granted/Sustained Plaintiff's Motion to File First Amended Petition is granted by consent. The First Amended Petition is deemed filed this date. So Ordered: Elizabeth B. Hogan, Judge.
  74. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/07/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 06/30/2025; 8:00 AM; CHRISTOPHER EDWARD MCGRAUGH; City of St. Louis
  75. rder for Continuance Motion for Continuance was called, heard and granted. So Ordered: Elizabeth B. Hogan, Judge.
  76. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 09/12/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Scheduled For: 12/02/2024; 9:00 AM; DAVID C MASON; Carnahan Courthouse
  77. udge Assigned
  78. nswer Filed DEFENDANT KRISTIE LYNN CARNER'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED PETITION; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  79. otion for Leave Motion for Leave to File an Amended Petition; Exhibit 1 - First Amended Petition; Proposed Order; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS
  80. otion Filed Motion for Peremptory Trial Setting; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  81. otice to Take Deposition Amended Notice To Take Deposition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRYSTAL M ROBINSON, TONY R. ROBINSON, KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  82. rd Transfer P/Judge for Assn Cause assigned to Division # 17 for trial on 12/02/24. see court order So Ordered: Elizabeth B. Hogan, Judge
  83. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 10/23/2024 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 12/02/2024; 9:00 AM; DAVID C MASON; Carnahan Courthouse
  84. earing/Trial Cancelled Associated Entries: 09/04/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 09/04/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Scheduled For: 12/02/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  85. udge Assigned
  86. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 09/12/2024 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 12/02/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  87. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 07/17/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 07/17/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 09/12/2024 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Hearing Continued From: 10/07/2024; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
  88. otion for Sub of Counsel Withdrawal and Substitution of Counsel; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  89. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 09/04/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 10/07/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  90. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 05/09/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 05/09/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 09/04/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Hearing Continued From: 08/12/2024; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
  91. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 07/17/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 08/12/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  92. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 03/27/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 03/27/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 07/17/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Hearing Continued From: 07/01/2024; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
  93. ert Serv Resp Req Prod Doc Th CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  94. ert Serv Answers Interrog Fil CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  95. otice of Hearing Filed Notice of Hearing Cancellation; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  96. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/09/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 07/01/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  97. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 02/22/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 02/22/2024 - Jury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/09/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Hearing Continued From: 05/13/2024; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
  98. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/27/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 05/13/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  99. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 10/30/2023 - Jury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/27/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Hearing Continued From: 04/01/2024; 9:00 AM Jury Trial
  100. ert Serv Resp Req Prod Doc Th Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  101. otion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/07/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 04/04/2024; 9:00 AM; JOSEPH PATRICK WHYTE; City of St. Louis
  102. mended Notice of Hrng Filed Amended Notice of Hearing; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  103. ert Serv of Rspns to Interrog COS - Pltff R-INT1st RFP1st; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  104. otion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 05/07/2025 - Hearing/Trial Cancelled Scheduled For: 03/14/2024; 9:00 AM; JOSEPH PATRICK WHYTE; City of St. Louis
  105. otice of Hearing Filed Notice of Hearing; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  106. ertificate of Service Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  107. ntry of Appearance Filed Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: JAMES ALBERT WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  108. ert Serv Req Prod Docs Things COS - INT1st RFP1st to Def Carner. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  109. otion Filed Defendant Kristie Lynn Carners Motion for More Definite Statement; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  110. ert Serv Req Prod Docs Things Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  111. ert Serv of Interrog Filed Certificate of Service; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  112. nswer Filed Defendant Kristie Lynn Carners Answer to Plaintiffs Petition; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  113. ntry of Appearance Filed Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: DANIEL E WILKE On Behalf Of: KRISTIE LYNN CARNER
  114. ffidavit Special Process Serv Return of Service - Tony Robinson. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  115. ffidavit Special Process Serv Return of Service - Krystal Robinson. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  116. amily Member/Roommate Served Document ID - 23-SMCC-14677; Served To - KRYSTAL M ROBINSON; Served Date - 12/28/2023; Served Time - 13:18:00; Service Type - SP; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -
  117. amily Member/Roommate Served Document ID - 23-SMCC-14669; Served To - TONY R. ROBINSON; Served Date - 12/28/2023; Served Time - 13:18:00; Service Type - SP; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -
  118. otice of Service Return of Service - Carner. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  119. amily Member/Roommate Served Document ID - 23-SMCC-14678; Served To - KRISTIE LYNN CARNER; Served Date - 12/12/2023; Served Time - 17:25:00; Service Type - SP; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -
  120. lias Summons Issued Document ID: 23-SMCC-14678, for CARNER, KRISTIE LYNN.
  121. lias Summons Issued Document ID: 23-SMCC-14677, for ROBINSON, KRYSTAL M.
  122. lias Summons Issued Document ID: 23-SMCC-14669, for ROBINSON, TONY R..
  123. lias Summons Requested Request for Alias Summonses; Return of Service - NON EST - Kristie Carner; Return of Service - NON EST - Krystal Robinson; Return of Service - NON EST - Tony Robinson. Filed By: ROBERT EUGENE SCHMITTGENS On Behalf Of: JEANNE CARUSO
  124. ury Trial Scheduled Associated Entries: 02/22/2024 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 04/01/2024; 9:00 AM; ELIZABETH BYRNE HOGAN; City of St. Louis
  125. ummons Issued-Circuit Document ID: 23-SMCC-13663, for CARNER, KRISTIE LYNN
  126. ummons Issued-Circuit Document ID: 23-SMCC-13660, for ROBINSON, TONY R.
  127. ummons Issued-Circuit Document ID: 23-SMCC-13659, for ROBINSON, KRYSTAL M
  128. equest Filed REQUEST FOR APPOINTMENT OF PROCESS SERVER
  129. onfid Filing Info Sheet Filed

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more