Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Missouri Unified County

Court

Missouri Unified County

Missouri

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-11-11
Type Cc Eminent Domain/condemn Oth
Docket 94 entries
Disposition disposed

Parties

Plaintiff Public Water Supply District No. 2 Of St. Charles County, Mo|Piontek, Mark C.
Defendant Mottert, Joshua|Mottert, Julie|Michelle Mcbride, Collector Of Revenue|Such Unknown Person Persons Or Corporation As May Derive Or
Photo of Hon. Alessi Deborah Jean

Judge

Hon. Alessi Deborah Jean

St. Charles County (MO)

Missouri

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  2. etn Serv-Reg/Cert Mail Succs CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT.
  4. iling: NOTICE OF FILING COMMISSIONERS' REPORT SENT ELECTRONICALLY TO ALL ATTORNEYS OF RECORD AND MAILED BY CERTIFIED MAIL TO ALL PARTIES WITHOUT ATTORNEYS. KT
  5. udge/Clerk - Note CLERK RECEIVED PAYMENT IN FULL FOR COMMISSIONERS FEES AND ISSUED CHECKS OUT TO COMMISSIONERS.
  6. udge/Clerk - Note CLERK RECEIVED CHECK FOR $14,638.50 FROM PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DIST . NO 2 AS FOR CONDEMNATION AWARD OF $13,000.00 AND $1638.05 COMMISSIONERS FEES DEPOSITED INTO THE COURTS REGISTRY.
  8. iling: NOTICE OF PAYMENT OF COMMISSIONERS AWARD SENT ELECTRONICALLY TO ALL ATTORNEYS OF RECORD AND MAILED BY REGULAR MAIL TO ALL PARTIES WITHOUT ATTORNEYS. KT
  9. udge/Clerk - Note CERTIFED COPY OF NOTICE OF PAYMENT OF COMMISSIONERS AWARD SENT TO ASSESSOR. COPY OF NOTICE OF PAYMENT ALSO POSTED IN A PUBLIC AREA IN THE COURTS BUILDING. KT
  11. iling: RECORDER OF DEEDS CERTIFICATE OF EXEMPT DOCUMENT FILED. KT
  13. ther Proposed Document Filed Notice of Payment of Award; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  14. rder for Trial Setting CAUSE IS HEREBY SET FOR A 3 DAY JURY TRIAL TO START 10-20-25 AT 9 AM WITH FINAL PRE-TRIAL TO BE HELD 9-29-25 AT 1:30 PM AT WHICH TIME ALL PARTIES MUST APPEAR; PER DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  15. ury Trial Scheduled Scheduled For: 10/20/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  16. re-trial Conference Scheduled Scheduled For: 09/29/2025; 1:30 PM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  17. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 01/13/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 01/13/2025 - Case Mgmt Conf Scheduled Hearing Continued From: 03/17/2025; 9:00 AM Case Management Conference
  19. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS FEE INVOICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFFS ATTORNEY
  21. udge/Clerk - Note ORDER FOR COMMISSIONERS FEES SENT TO ACCOUNTING FOR PAYMENT THIS DATE. ALC
  23. rder ORDER FOR COMMISSIONERS' FEES; PER DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  25. otice Notice of Filing Commissioners Report; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  26. roposed Order Filed PROPOSED ORDER FOR COMMISSIONERS' FEES SENT TO DIVISION 2 FOR JUDGE'S SIGNATURE VIA EMAIL THIS DATE. ALC
  28. roposed Order Filed PROPOSED ORDER FOR COMMISSIONERS' FEES FILED AND SENT TO PRESIDING JUDGE'S SECRETARY. KT
  29. iling: COMMISSIONERS' FEE BILL FILED. KT
  30. eport of Condemn Commissioner COMMISSIONERS ACCESS THE PROPERTY AT $13,000.00. COPY OF REPORT SENT TO RECORDER OF DEEDS. KT
  32. rder ARGUMENTS HEARD ON THE RECORD; QUALIFYING OATH OF COMMISSIONERS IS ENTERED; SO ORDERED DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  33. earing Held Associated Entries: 01/23/2025 - Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 01/23/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 03/03/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  34. rder IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED ABD DECREED THAT THE LAND, PROPERTY AND RIGHT DESCRIBED IN 'EXHIBIT A' BE AND STAND CONDEMNED FOR IT'S PUBLIC USE AND PURPOSES AS SET FORTH IN THE PETITION; PER DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  35. roposed Order Filed PROPOSED ORDER FOR COMMISSIONERS' FEES FILED AND SENT TO PRESIDING JUDGE'S SECRETARY. KT
  36. udge/Clerk - Note PAYMENT RECEIVED IN FULL FOR COMMISSIONERS FEES AND PAYMENTS HAVE BEEN MAILD TO COMMISSIONERS
  37. eport of Condemn Commissioner COMMISSIONERS ACCESS THE PROPERTY AT $13,000.00. COPY OF REPORT SENT TO RECORDER OF DEEDS. KT
  38. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS NOTIFIED OF CONTINUANCE DATE FOR THE ABOVE LISTED CAUSE TO MARCH 3, 2025 AT 9AM IN DIVISION 2 VIA EMAIL THIS DATE. ALC
  39. rder ARGUMENTS HEARD ON THE RECORD; QUALIFYING OATH OF COMMISSIONERS IS ENTERED; SO ORDERED DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  40. earing Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/03/2025 - Hearing Held Scheduled For: 03/03/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  41. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 01/21/2025 - Motion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/03/2025 - Hearing Held Hearing Continued From: 02/03/2025; 9:00 AM Motion Hearing
  42. otion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 01/23/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 02/03/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  43. otice of Hearing Filed Notice of Hearing; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  44. equest Filed Request for Commissioners; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  45. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS FEE INVOICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFFS ATTORNEY
  46. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 01/21/2025 - Motion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/03/2025 - Hearing Held Hearing Continued From: 02/03/2025; 9:00 AM Motion Hearing
  47. udge/Clerk - Note ORDER SENT TO FINANCE QUEUE THIS DATE FOR PAYMENT OF COMMISSIONERS. ALC
  48. otion Hearing Scheduled Associated Entries: 01/23/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 02/03/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  49. rder COUNSEL WAS UNABLE TO APPEAR, HOWEVER COMMISSIONERS WERE NOT NOTIFIED AND APPEARED 1-13-25; THEREFORE IT IS ORDERED THAT THE COMMISSIONERS BE ALLOWED FEES AND MILEAGE AS PER ORDER; PER DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  50. rder for Continuance PRO SE DEFENDANTS APPEAR IN PERSON; COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF APPEARS NOT - DUE TO HEALTH ISSUES; CAUSE IS HEREBY CONTINUED TO 3-17-25 AT 9 AM FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE; PLAINTIFF MAY RE-NOTICE HIS MOTION WITH PROPER NOTIFICATION GOING TO DEFENDANTS; PER DJA /dsh Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  51. ase Mgmt Conf Scheduled Associated Entries: 03/17/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 03/17/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  52. earing Continued/Rescheduled Associated Entries: 01/07/2025 - Hearing Scheduled + Associated Entries: 03/17/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Hearing Continued From: 01/13/2025; 9:00 AM Hearing
  53. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS STREGE, EBERHARD AND BULLOCK AGREE TO APPEAR ON JANUARY 13, 2025 AT 9AM IN DIVISION 2. ALC
  54. udge/Clerk - Note THE CIVIL DOCKET OF 1-6-25 WAS CANCELED DUE TO INCLEMENT WEATHER AND HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED FOR 1-13-25; PARTIES UNABLE TO MAKE THIS DATE MAY FILE A CONSENSUAL MOTION FOR A DIFFERENT DATE; dsh
  55. earing Scheduled RESET FROM 1-6-25 Associated Entries: 01/13/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 01/13/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  56. earing Held Associated Entries: 11/19/2024 - Hearing Scheduled + Scheduled For: 01/06/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  57. udge/Clerk - Note THE CIVIL DOCKET OF 1-6-25 WAS CANCELED DUE TO INCLEMENT WEATHER AND HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED FOR 1-13-25; PARTIES UNABLE TO MAKE THIS DATE MAY FILE A CONSENSUAL MOTION FOR A DIFFERENT DATE; dsh
  58. equest Filed Request for Continuance and for Resetting; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  59. ffidavit Filed Affidavit of Publication; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  60. earing Scheduled RESET FROM 1-6-25 Associated Entries: 01/13/2025 - Hearing Continued/Rescheduled Scheduled For: 01/13/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  61. ntry of Appearance Filed Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EDWARD HOEYNCK JR On Behalf Of: MICHELLE MCBRIDE, COLLECTOR OF REVENUE
  62. udge/Clerk - Note THE CIVIL DOCKET OF 1-6-25 WAS CANCELED DUE TO INCLEMENT WEATHER AND HAS BEEN RESCHEDULED FOR 1-13-25; PARTIES UNABLE TO MAKE THIS DATE MAY FILE A CONSENSUAL MOTION FOR A DIFFERENT DATE; dsh
  63. amily Member/Roommate Served Document ID - 24-SMCD-61; Served To - JULIE MOTTERT; Served Date - 12/13/2024; Served Time - 09:30:00; Service Type - SD; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -SUMMONS SERVED TO JOSHUA MOTTERT, CO-RESIDENT
  64. ummons Personally Served Document ID - 24-SMCD-60; Served To - JOSHUA MOTTERT; Served Date - 12/13/2024; Served Time - 09:30:00; Service Type - SD; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -
  65. ote to Clerk eFiling
  66. otice of Service 24-SMCD-61; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
  67. otice of Service 24-SMCD-60; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
  68. ntry of Appearance Filed Entry of Appearance; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service. Filed By: ROBERT EDWARD HOEYNCK JR On Behalf Of: MICHELLE MCBRIDE, COLLECTOR OF REVENUE
  69. orporation Served Document ID - 24-SMCD-62; Served To - MICHELLE MCBRIDE, COLLECTOR OF REVENUE; Served Date - 12/10/2024; Served Time - 12:04:00; Service Type - SD; Reason Description - SERV; Service Text -
  70. ote to Clerk eFiling
  71. otice of Service 24-SMCD-62; Electronic Filing Certificate of Service.
  72. ote to Clerk eFiling
  73. ummons Issued- Condemnation Document ID: 24-SMCD-62, for MICHELLE MCBRIDE, COLLECTOR OF REVENUE SUMMONS SAVED AND ATTACHED IN PDF FORM FOR ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE FROM SECURE CASE.NET. MLS
  74. ummons Issued- Condemnation Document ID: 24-SMCD-61, for MOTTERT, JULIE SUMMONS SAVED AND ATTACHED IN PDF FORM FOR ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE FROM SECURE CASE.NET. MLS
  75. ummons Issued- Condemnation Document ID: 24-SMCD-60, for MOTTERT, JOSHUA SUMMONS SAVED AND ATTACHED IN PDF FORM FOR ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE FROM SECURE CASE.NET. MLS
  76. otice of Order of Publication Document ID: 24-NOSP-75, for SUCH UNKNOWN PERSON PERSONS OR CORPORATION AS MAY DERIVE OR . SUMMONS SAVED AND ATTACHED IN PDF FORM FOR ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE FROM SECURE CASE.NET. MLS FIRST DATE OF PUBLICATION NOVEMBER 27, 2024
  77. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS STREGE, BULLOCK AND EBERHARD AGREE TO APPEAR ON JANUARY 6, 2025 AT 9AM IN DIVISION 2. ALC
  78. earing Scheduled Revised Event Information: New EventRoom: DIVISION 2 COURTROOM; Associated Entries: 01/07/2025 - Hearing Held Scheduled For: 01/06/2025; 9:00 AM; DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI; St Charles Circuit Div
  79. rder of Publication ORDER FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION BY NOTICE, FILED. MLS Associated Entries: 11/11/2024 - Application Filed +
  80. equest Filed Request for Commissioners. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  81. ummons Issued- Condemnation Document ID: 24-SMCD-61, for MOTTERT, JULIE SUMMONS SAVED AND ATTACHED IN PDF FORM FOR ATTORNEY TO RETRIEVE FROM SECURE CASE.NET. MLS
  82. rder for Hearing CAUSE IS HEREBY SET FOR HEARING ON THE CONDEMNATION PETITION 1-6-25 AT 9 AM IN DIVISION 2; CIRCUIT CLERK SHALL ISSUE A PROPER SUMMONS AND CAUSE IT TO BE SERVED WITH A COPY OF THE PETITION UPON EACH NAMED DEFENDANT AT LEAST 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE SET FOR HEARING; PER DJA /dsh CC PJSEC Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  83. udge/Clerk - Note ORDER FOR FILING PETITION AND SETTING DATE AND PLACE FOR HEARING SENT TO THE DIVISION 2 CLERK VIA THE ACTION QUEUE FOR JUDGES REVIEW AND TO BE SENT BACK TO THE NEW FILINGS QUEUE. MLS
  84. udge/Clerk - Note COMMISSIONERS STREGE, BULLOCK AND EBERHARD AGREE TO APPEAR ON JANUARY 6, 2025 AT 9AM IN DIVISION 2. ALC
  85. iling Info Sheet eFiling Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK
  86. pplication Filed APPLICATION AND ORDER FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO Associated Entries: 11/19/2024 - Order of Publication +
  87. roposed Order Filed ORDER FOR FILING PETITION AND SETTING DATE AND PLACE FOR HEARING. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  88. ffd for Serv by Publication AFFIDAVIT FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  89. rder for Hearing CAUSE IS HEREBY SET FOR HEARING ON THE CONDEMNATION PETITION 1-6-25 AT 9 AM IN DIVISION 2; CIRCUIT CLERK SHALL ISSUE A PROPER SUMMONS AND CAUSE IT TO BE SERVED WITH A COPY OF THE PETITION UPON EACH NAMED DEFENDANT AT LEAST 10 DAYS PRIOR TO THE DATE SET FOR HEARING; PER DJA /dsh CC PJSEC Filed By: DEBORAH JEAN ALESSI
  90. udge/Clerk - Note ORDER FOR FILING PETITION AND SETTING DATE AND PLACE FOR HEARING SENT TO THE DIVISION 2 CLERK VIA THE ACTION QUEUE FOR JUDGES REVIEW AND TO BE SENT BACK TO THE NEW FILINGS QUEUE. MLS
  91. iling Info Sheet eFiling Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK
  92. pplication Filed APPLICATION AND ORDER FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO Associated Entries: 11/19/2024 - Order of Publication +
  93. roposed Order Filed ORDER FOR FILING PETITION AND SETTING DATE AND PLACE FOR HEARING. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO
  94. ffd for Serv by Publication AFFIDAVIT FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION. Filed By: MARK C. PIONTEK On Behalf Of: PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY DISTRICT NO. 2 OF ST. CHARLES COUNTY, MO

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more