Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Mahoning County

Court

Mahoning County

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2025-04-29
Status CLOSED
Type Civil Common Pleas
Docket 116 entries
Disposition default

Parties

Plaintiff Pennymac Loan Services Llc
Defendant Perkins, Charles|Perkins,unk Spouse Of, Charles|Usa Secretary Of Housing And Urban Development|Discover Bank|Midland Credit Management Inc|Portfolio Recovery Assoc Llc|Bdm Resurgent Receivables
Photo of Hon. d'Apolito Anthony M

Judge

Hon. d'Apolito Anthony M

Mahoning County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. $75.00
  2. COMPLAINT FILED Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  3. LEGAL AID (TOSCV) FILED Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  4. LEGAL NEWS Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  5. COURT COMPUTER RESEARCH (CIVIL) Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  6. CLERK COMPUTERIZATION FEE (CIVIL) Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  7. CV-COURT MEDIATION PROGRAM Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  8. CV-SPECIAL PROJECTS FUND Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  9. CV-TECHNOLOGY FUND Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  10. FORECLOSURE SPECIAL PROJECT FUND Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  11. SHERIFF'S FORECLOSURE FUND Receipt: 521336 Date: 04/29/2025
  12. COMPLAINT FILED ELECTRONICALLY COMPLAINT IN FORECLOSURE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  13. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE WRITTEN REQUEST FOR SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  14. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE WRITTEN REQUEST FOR SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  15. COPIES ISSUED: ADDITIONAL COSTS ADDED FOR SERVICE COPIES
  16. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT MAILED BY CERTIFIED MAIL TO DEFTS
  17. Issue Date: 05/02/2025 Service: CIVIL SUMMONS Method: (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: $0.00 PERKINS, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS RD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: 941472669904224127056 PERKINS,UNK SPOUSE OF, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS ROAD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: 941472669904224127057 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT SERVE U.S. ATTORNEYS OFFICE 801 WEST SUPERIOR AVENUE SUITE CLEVELAND, OH 44113 Tracking No: 941472669904224127058 DISCOVER BANK 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking No: 941472669904224127059 MIDLAND CREDIT MANAGEMENT INC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD. STE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: 941472669904224127060 PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 10 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 941472669904224127061 BDM RESURGENT RECEIVABLES CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN ROAD SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: 941472669904224127062 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT U.S. 7TH STREET SW WASHINGTON, DC 20410 Tracking No: 941472669904224127063
  18. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT ISSUED TO PROCESS SERVER PROVEST, LLC FOR SERVICE UPON DEFTS
  19. Issue Date: 05/02/2025 Service: CIVIL SUMMONS Method: (CP) PERSONAL SERVICE Provider: PROCESS SERVER Cost Per: $ PERKINS, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS RD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: P000086476 PERKINS,UNK SPOUSE OF, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS ROAD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: P000086477 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT SERVE U.S. ATTORNEYS OFFICE 801 WEST SUPERIOR AVENUE SUITE CLEVELAND, OH 44113 Tracking No: P000086478 DISCOVER BANK 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking No: P000086479 MIDLAND CREDIT MANAGEMENT INC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD. STE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: P000086480 PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 10 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: P000086481 BDM RESURGENT RECEIVABLES CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN ROAD SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: P000086482
  20. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : 05/05/2025 Return : 05/06/2025 On : PERKINS,UNK SPOUSE OF, CHARLES Signed By : UNKNOWN Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127057
  21. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : 05/05/2025 Return : 05/06/2025 On : PERKINS, CHARLES Signed By : UNKNOWN Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127056
  22. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : 05/05/2025 Return : 05/07/2025 On : MIDLAND CREDIT MANAGEMENT INC Signed By : NO SIGNATURE Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127060
  23. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : 05/05/2025 Return : 05/07/2025 On : BDM RESURGENT RECEIVABLES Signed By : CORPORATION SERVICE CO Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127062
  24. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : 05/05/2025 Return : 05/09/2025 On : USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT Signed By : HINSEN Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127058
  25. UNSUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : Return : 05/12/2025 On : PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC Signed By : Reason : (CP) UNSUCCESSFUL Comment : UNABLE TO FORWARD Tracking #: 941472669904224127061
  26. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 05/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : Return : 05/15/2025 On : DISCOVER BANK Signed By : DANIEL D KELLEY Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127059
  27. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE ON PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC C/O CORP SERVICE CO REGISTERED AGT TO ATTY YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  28. REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES
  29. REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES
  30. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE WRITTEN REQUEST FOR SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  31. Certificate of Service
  32. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT ISSUED TO DEFT BY CERT MAIL TO ADDRESS IN WRIT INSTR
  33. Issue Date: 06/02/2025 Service: CIVIL SUMMONS Method: (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: $0.00 PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD STE 400 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 941472669904224127934
  34. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CP) CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : 06/02/2025 Service : CIVIL SUMMONS Served : Return : 06/09/2025 On : PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC Signed By : CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY Reason : (CP) SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 941472669904224127934
  35. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  36. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  37. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  38. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  39. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  40. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  41. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  42. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF RETURN OF SERVICE :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  43. Certificate of Service
  44. MILITARY AFFIDAVIT AND AFFIDAVIT OF STATUS OF ACCOUNT CERTIFICATION AS TO MILITARY STATUS :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  45. PRELIMINARY JUDICIAL REPORT FILED FINAL JUDICIAL REPORT :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  46. MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGEMENT (FORECLOSURE) FILED BY MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  47. MOTION MOTION TO APPOINT PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: YANFANG LI RAMIREZ
  48. Certificate of Service
  49. Certificate of Service
  50. ORDER OF MAGISTRATE (FOWLER)
  51. Certificate of Service
  52. COST FOR JUDGMENT ENTRY FOR CLERK COMPUTERIZATION
  53. COPIES ISSUED OF 09/14/2025 MAGISTRATE'S ORDER
  54. Issue Date: 09/16/2025 Service: COPIES OF 09/14/2025 MAGISTRATE'S ORDER Method: (CP) REGULAR MAIL Cost Per: $0.69 PERKINS, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS RD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: R001383794 PERKINS,UNK SPOUSE OF, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS ROAD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: R001383795 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT SERVE U.S. ATTORNEYS OFFICE 801 WEST SUPERIOR AVENUE SUITE CLEVELAND, OH 44113 Tracking No: R001383796 DISCOVER BANK 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking No: R001383797 MIDLAND CREDIT MANAGEMENT INC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD. STE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: R001383798 PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD STE 400 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: R001383799 BDM RESURGENT RECEIVABLES CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN ROAD SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: R001383800 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT 451 7TH STREET SW WASHINGTON, DC 20410 Tracking No: R001383801
  55. JE> ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO APPOINT PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER (D'APOLITO) SEE ATTACHED IMAGE
  56. Certificate of Service
  57. JE> JUDGMENT ENTRY AND DECREE OF FORECLOSURE (D'APOLITO) SEE ATTACHED IMAGE
  58. Certificate of Service
  59. COST FOR JUDGMENT ENTRY FOR CLERK COMPUTERIZATION
  60. COST FOR JUDGMENT ENTRY FOR CLERK COMPUTERIZATION
  61. COPIES ISSUED OF 10/14/2025 (2) JE
  62. Issue Date: 10/15/2025 Service: COPIES OF 10/14/2025 (2) JE Method: (CP) REGULAR MAIL Cost Per: $0.64 PERKINS, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS RD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: R001386067 PERKINS,UNK SPOUSE OF, CHARLES 3972 HOPKINS ROAD YOUNGSTOWN, OH 44511 Tracking No: R001386068 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT SERVE U.S. ATTORNEYS OFFICE 801 WEST SUPERIOR AVENUE SUITE CLEVELAND, OH 44113 Tracking No: R001386069 DISCOVER BANK 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking No: R001386070 MIDLAND CREDIT MANAGEMENT INC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD. STE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: R001386071 PORTFOLIO RECOVERY ASSOC LLC CO CORPORATION SERVICE COMPAN 1160 DUBLIN ROAD STE 400 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: R001386072 BDM RESURGENT RECEIVABLES CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN ROAD SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking No: R001386073 USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT 451 7TH STREET SW WASHINGTON, DC 20410 Tracking No: R001386074
  63. ANSWER OF ANSWER OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA :: :: On behalf of Defendant: USA SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT :: Filed By: KIMBERLY L LUBRANI
  64. Certificate of Service
  65. PRAECIPE FOR ORDER OF SALE PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER PRAECIPE FOR PSO :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: CARRIE L DAVIS Receipt: 530836 Date: 11/26/2025
  66. PRAECIPE FOR PRAECIPE FOR POA :: :: On behalf of Plaintiff: PENNYMAC LOAN SERVICES LLC :: Filed By: CARRIE L DAVIS
  67. Certificate of Service
  68. PRAECIPE FOR ORDER OF APPRAISAL FILED 11-26-25 SENT TO MAHONING COUNTY SHERIFF'S OFFICE {PRIVATE SELLER}
  69. PRAECIPE FOR ORDER OF APPRAISAL FILED 11-26-25 SENT TO (ROSS BARTON III) {PRIVATE SELLER} BY REGULAR MAIL
  70. REGULAR MAIL POSTAGE FEES
  71. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON ROSS BARTON III, PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER (RTS; NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDR; UNABLE TO FWD)
  72. REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO-- SHELLY DEMSKY Voided on 03/05/2026. Re-issued Check.
  73. REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO-- GAIL BATTISTI
  74. REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO-- DEAN GONATAS Voided on 03/05/2026.
  75. REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO-- DENNIS GONATAS. 2025CV01092
  76. $10.00
  77. $25.00
  78. $26.00
  79. $13.00
  80. $6.00
  81. $20.00
  82. $40.00
  83. $50.00
  84. $10.00
  85. $225.00
  86. $75.00
  87. $0.00
  88. $37.30
  89. $16.00
  90. $99.36
  91. $14.00
  92. $2.00
  93. $0.64
  94. $0.64
  95. $2.00
  96. $12.42
  97. $0.00
  98. $0.00
  99. $4.00
  100. $2.00
  101. $1.60
  102. $5.52
  103. $12.00
  104. $8.00
  105. $4.00
  106. $6.00
  107. $8.00
  108. $5.52
  109. $225.00
  110. $0.00
  111. $0.00
  112. $0.64
  113. $0.00
  114. $75.00
  115. $75.00
  116. $0.00

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more