Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Portage Co

Court

Portage Co

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2025-03-20
Status REOPEN (RO)
Type Dr Never Married
Docket 63 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Nutter, Karesha
Defendant Shaffer, Tiffany|Shaffer, Brian
Photo of Hon. Berger Robert W Probate

Judge

Hon. Berger Robert W Probate

Portage County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Docket Entries

  1. EPOSIT PAID BY KARESHA NUTTER Receipt: 85361 Date: 05/18/2017
  2. REDIT CARD CONVENIENCE FEE Receipt: 85361 Date: 05/18/2017
  3. OMPLAINT FOR CHILD CUSTODY FILED BY KARESHA NUTTER Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  4. USTODY AFFIDAVIT
  5. OMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  6. OMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  7. UV SPECIAL PROJ FUND Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  8. NSWER AND WAIVER OF SERVICE SIGNED BY TIFFANY SHAFFER
  9. NSWER AND WAIVER OF SERVICE SIGNED BY BRIAN SHAFFER
  10. IVIL COMPLAINT ASSIGNMENT
  11. EARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON PETITION NOTICE TO: KARESHA M NUTTER TIFFANY L SHAFFER BRIAN M SHAFFER Date: 06/21/2017 Time: 3:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  12. ETTER/CORRESPONDENCE - FAX DATED 06-07-17 RCVD FROM KARESHA NUTTER RQSTING HER HUSBAND BE ADDED TO THE PETITION - *REVIEWED BY MAG 06-08-17**
  13. ETURN OF COURT NOTICE FOR 6/21/17 SENT TO TIFFANY L. SHAFFER @ C/O 183 CANTERBURY DRIVE, AURORA, OH MARKED "NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED".
  14. AGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER - HRG ON PETITION FOR CUSTODY 6/21/17. THE MAG FINDS THAT THE PARTIES AGREE THIS CHANGE IS IN THE BEST INTEREST OF THE CHILDREN; IT IS FOR THE CONVENIENCE OF THE PARTIES; AND THAT IS IS SUBJECT TO THE ONGOING JURIS OF THE COURT. NO FINDING IS MADE REGARDING THE SUITABILITY OF THE PARENTS. THE MAG DECIDES THAT KARESHA M. AND KENNETH G. NUTTER SHOULD BE GRANTED CUSTODY OF THE CHILDREN, SUBJECT TO THE CONTINUING JURIS AND FURTHER ORDER OF THIS COURT. FURTHER, UPON THE FILING OF A WITHDRAWAL OF CONSENT BY THE CUSTODIAL PARENT, THE MATTER SHALL BE SCHED FOR HRG AT WHICH TIME CUSTODY OF THE CHILDREN SHALL BE IMMEDIATELY RETURNED TO THE PARENT WHO HAD CUSTODY PRIOR TO THE FILING OF THIS DECISION. FURTHER, THE CHILDREN LAST RESIDED W/ PARENTS AT 11939 GARFIELD RD, HIRAM, OH. ACCORDINGLY, CRESTWOOD SCHOOL DIST SHALL BEAR THE COST OF THE CHILDREN'S EDUCATION, SUBJECT TO THE RE-DETERM BY THE DEPT OF ED. COPY TO T. SHAFFER, B. NUTTER, K & K NUTTER, CSEA, CRESTWOOD CSD Receipt: 85548 Date: 06/22/2017
  15. ETURN OF MAG DEC/ORDER SENT TO TIFFANY L. SHAFFER @ C/O 183 CANTERBURY DRIVE, AURORA, OH 44202 MARKED "NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED"
  16. ETURN OF MAG DEC/ORDER SENT TO BRIAN M. SHAFFER @ C/O 183 CANTERBURY DRIVE, AURORA, OH 44202 MARKED "NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED"
  17. EPOSIT REFUNDED TO: KARESHA NUTTER Check Issued: 07/11/17 Check #6588 $23.24 Payable to: KARESHA M NUTTER.
  18. OTION TO INTERVENE FILED BY CSEA Attorney: FRANK, REGINA (84550)
  19. AGISTRATE'S ORDER. UPON MOTION AND FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN, THE DEPT OF JOB AND FAM SERV IS HEREBY PERMITTED TO INTERVENE IN THE ABOVE CAPTIONED MATTER.
  20. OTION FOR ADOPTION OF ADMIN ORDER FILED BY CSEA
  21. OTICE OF HEARING 2/25/2020 @ 1:15 PM
  22. ssue Date: 01/16/2020 Service: MOTION SENT MOTION AND ORDER TO INTERVENE, MOT TO ADPOT ADMIN ORDER W/NOH 2/25/20 @ 1:15 PM (J) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.00 SHAFFER, TIFFANY L 593 LAFOLLETTE ST AKRON, OH 44311 Tracking No: 7266990421500869280
  23. ssue Date: 01/16/2020 Service: MOTION SENT MOTION AND ORDER TO INTERVENE, MOT TO ADPOT ADMIN ORDER W/NOH 2/25/20 @ 1:15 PM (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.50 NUTTER, KARESHA M 930 KINSMAN RD. NW NORTH BLOOMFIELD, OH 44450 Tracking No: R000041554
  24. NSUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Issued : 01/16/2020 Service : MOTION SENT (J) Served : 02/18/2020 Return : 02/19/2020 On : SHAFFER, TIFFANY L Signed By : Reason : (JUV) UNSUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : RET OF CERT MAIL MARKED "NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED/UNABLE TO FORWARD" FOR HGR SCHED 2/25/20 @ 1:15 PM. HRG TO BE CANCELLED. AWAIT NEW INSTR. Tracking #: 7266990421500869280
  25. NNER OFFICE MAIL FAILURE OF SERVICE NOTIFICATION Requester Notified Tracking number: 7266990421500869280
  26. EARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON MOTION TO ADOPT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS Date: 02/25/2020 Time: 1:15 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court Result: NO SERVICE (J)
  27. EW NOTICE OF HEARING ON 6/2/2020 @ 2:30 PM
  28. NSTRUCTIONS FOR RE-SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  29. ssue Date: 02/26/2020 Service: MOTION SENT MOTION AND ORDER TO INTERVENE, MOT TO ADPOT ADMIN ORDER W/NEW NOH 6/2/2020 @ 2:30 PM (J) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.00 NUTTER, KARESHA M 930 KINSMAN RD. NW NORTH BLOOMFIELD, OH 44450 Tracking No: 7266990421500869365
  30. ssue Date: 02/26/2020 Service: NEW NOH 6/2/2020 @ 2:30 PM (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.50 SHAFFER, TIFFANY L 25 FREDERICK AVE #19 AKRON, OH 44310 Tracking No: R000041901
  31. EARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON MOTION TO ADOPT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS Date: 06/02/2020 Time: 2:30 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court
  32. UCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Issued : 02/26/2020 Service : MOTION SENT (J) Served : 03/04/2020 Return : 03/04/2020 On : NUTTER, KARESHA M Signed By : KENNETH NUTTER Reason : (JUV) SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 7266990421500869365
  33. AGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER. HRG 6/2/20 ON THE MOTION TO ADOPT ADMIN ORDERS. ATTY REGINA FRANK APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. THE MAG FINDS THAT THE ADMIN ORDER FILED HEREIN AND ATTACHED AS EXHIBIT BE ADOPTED AND MADE AN ORDER OF THIS COURT. KARESHA M NUTTER IS THE LC OF THE CHILDREN. TIFFANY SHAFFER SHALL BE THE CHILD SUPPT OBLOGOR. OBLIGOR SHALL PAY$83.96/MO PLUS 2% PROC CHG, FOR A TOTAL OF $342.55/MO EFFECT 3/11/2019. WHEN PRIVATE HEALTH INS IS NO LONGER BEING PROVIDED OR HAS NOT YET BEEN IDENTIFIED, OBLIGOR SHALL PAY $83.96/MO AND $0.00/MO CASH MED SUPPT FOR A TOTAL OF $ 342.55/MO. IT IS FURTHER RECOMMENDED THAT PCCSEA BE ASSESED COSTS IN THIS MATTER. COPY TO T SHAFFER, K NUTTER, CSEA
  34. ETURN OF MAG DEC SENT TO TIFFANY SHAFFER 25 FREDERICK AVE #19, AKRON, OH 44310 MARKED "RETURN TO SENDER - ATTEMPTED NOT KNOWN- UNABLE TO FORWARD."
  35. ERMINATION OF SUPPORT - CURRENT SUPPORT BY TIFFANY SHAFFER TO KARESHA NUTTER FOR SAYBRI SHAFFER DOB: 8/20/01 SHALL TERM EFFECTIVE 5/21/20 AS THE CHILD IS 18 AND GRADUATED FROM HIGH SCHOOL ON 5/22/20. HOWEVER, PER THE RECORD OF THE CSEA, AS OF JULY 12, 2020 AN ARREARAGE OF $2,533.35 STILL EXISTS ON THE ORDER. THERE IS/ARE MINOR CHILD(REN) REMAINING ON THE ORDER FOR WHOM SUPPORT SHOULD CONTINUE: KOLT SHAFFER DOB: 3/18/13; SOPHIA SHAFFER DOB: 4/2/07; KYLA SHAFFER DOB: 5/8/04. PAYMENT ON ARREARS: EFFECITVE 5/22/20 THE FULL ORDERED AMOUNT OF $83.96 SHALL CONTINUE TO BE PAID AND WILL BE APPLIED TO THE EXISTING CHHILD SUPPORT ARREARS, ALONG WITH THE EXISTING ORDER FOR $67.17 PER MONTH PAYMENT ON THE ARREARS BALANCE UNTIL ALL ARREARS ARE PAID IN FULL. CHILD SUPPORT: EFFIECTIVE 5/22/20 THE CURRENT CHILD SUPPORT AND ASSOCIATED CASH MEDICAL AMOUNT UNDER THE REVISED CHILD SUPPORT ORDER FOR THE REMAINING CHILDREN WILL BE: WHEN MEDICAL INSURANCE IS BEING PROVIDED: $83.96 PER MONTH PER CHILD AS CHILD SUPPORT PLUS 2% ADMINISTRATIVE FEES. WHEN MEDICAL INSURANCE IS NOT BEING PROVIDED: $83.96 PER MONTH PER CHILD AS CHILD SUPPORT AND $0.00 PER MONTH PER CHILD AS CASH MEDICAL SUPPORT PLUS 2% ADMINISTRATIAVE FEES.
  36. NSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  37. ssue Date: 02/18/2021 Service: TERMINATION OF SUPPORT Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: NUTTER, KARESHA M 930 KINSMAN RD. NW NORTH BLOOMFIELD, OH 44450 Tracking No: R000043976 SHAFFER, TIFFANY L 1200 BRYCE AVE AURORA, OH 44202 Tracking No: R000043977
  38. ATCH SCAN
  39. ATCH SCAN
  40. ERMINATION OF SUPPORT
  41. NSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  42. ssue Date: 09/08/2022 Service: TERMINATION OF SUPPORT Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: NUTTER, KARESHA M 930 KINSMAN RD. NW NORTH BLOOMFIELD, OH 44450 Tracking No: R000047659 SHAFFER, TIFFANY L 1200 BRYCE AVE AURORA, OH 44202 Tracking No: R000047660
  43. ATCH SCAN: COMPLETE FILE
  44. OURNAL ENTRY: AN ORDER OF TRANSFER PURSUANT TO R.C. 2301.03(P).
  45. UDGMENT ENTRY FILED.
  46. SEA DISPOSITION.
  47. UDGMENT ENTRY FILED. ACCEPTANCE OF TRANSFER. (SEE IMAGE)
  48. OPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  49. OPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  50. OMPLAINT TO ADOPT CHILD SUPPORT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER FILED.
  51. CSEA) NOTICE OF HEARING FILED.
  52. ERSONAL IDENTIFIER FORM - PATERNITY/CHILD SUPPORT/CHILD CUSTODY FILED.
  53. NSTRUCTIONS FROM CSEA FILED.
  54. ssue Date: 03/21/2025 Service: TITLE 4 D SERVICE Method: (CSEA) PERSONAL SERVICE Provider: MOON, TIM Cost Per: $ NUTTER, KARESHA Tracking No: R000000974
  55. OTICE TO SERVE WITH PERTINENT PAPERS ISSUED TO TIM MOON AND/OR JIM ACKLIN PROCESS SERVERS TO SERVE PLTF. NOTICE TO SERVE Sent on: 03/21/2025 09:05:01.64
  56. NSTRUCTIONS FILED FROM CSEA.
  57. CSEA) SUPPORT SUMMONS, COMPLAINT TO ADOPY CHILD SUPPORT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS, AND NOTICE OF HEARING ISSUED TO DEFT BRIAN M SHAFFER BY PROCESS SERVER TIM MOON AND/OR JIM ACKLIN. SUPPORT SUMMONS Sent on: 03/24/2025 09:10:10.16
  58. ssue Date: 03/24/2025 Service: (CSEA) SUPPORT SUMMONS Method: (CSEA) PERSONAL SERVICE Provider: MOON, TIM Cost Per: $ SHAFFER, BRIAN 1911 HARTVILLE RD MOGADORE, OH 44260 Tracking No: R000000977
  59. NSTRUCTIONS FILED FROM CSEA.
  60. CSEA) SUPPORT SUMMONS, COMPLAINT TO ADOPT CHILD SUPPORT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS, AND NOTICE OF HEARING ISSUED TO DEFT TIFFANY SHAFFER BY PROCESS SERVER TIM MOON AND/OR JIM ACKLIN. SUPPORT SUMMONS Sent on: 03/24/2025 09:14:19.28
  61. ssue Date: 03/24/2025 Service: (CSEA) SUPPORT SUMMONS Method: (CSEA) PERSONAL SERVICE Provider: MOON, TIM Cost Per: $ SHAFFER, TIFFANY 930 KINSMAN RD NW NORTH BLOOMFIELD, OH 44450 Tracking No: R000000978
  62. UCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CSEA) PERSONAL SERVICE Issued : 03/21/2025 Service : TITLE 4 D SERVICE Served : 03/21/2025 Return : 03/24/2025 On : NUTTER, KARESHA Signed By : Reason : IV-D SUCCESSFUL Comment : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE ON PLTF BY PROCESS SERVER JIM ACKLIN. Tracking #: R000000974
  63. UCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : (CSEA) PERSONAL SERVICE Issued : 03/24/2025 Service : (CSEA) SUPPORT SUMMONS Served : 03/24/2025 Return : 03/26/2025 On : SHAFFER, TIFFANY Signed By : Reason : IV-D SUCCESSFUL Comment : GOOD SERVICE MADE ON DEFENDANT TIFFANY SHAFFER BY PROCESS SERVER JIM ACKLIN. Tracking #: R000000978

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more