Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Case Information
Parties
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- Exhibit and Deposition Notice to: All items not picked up by the date stated in the notice will be disposed of pursuant to Administrative Bulletin No. 9. Exhibit and Deposition Notice (12/18) Sent on: 11/12/2025 10:25:05.55
- Complaint for Divorce (No Children) Receipt: 2207193 Date: 07/31/2024
- LODGED: VS-401 Certificate of Absolute Divorce or Dissolution
- Domestic Relations Procedural Order and Assignment
- Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
- Information Sheet - Confidential Document per Civil Rule 90.1(f)(1)
- Notice of Filing Other Requested Relief Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Property and Debt Worksheet Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- [Motion] Other Requested Relief Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #1
- Motion for Designate File as Confidential Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #2
- [Proposed] [REDACTED] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhilips Retirement Plan] Attorney: Self-Represented (0100001) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #3
- Return of Service - Summons Served On: Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Entry of Appearance for Defendant Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Attorney Information Attorney Shepherd, Phyllis A representing Defendant Hartshorn, Thomas Robert as of 08/15/2024
- Defendant's Objection to the Entry of QDRO Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #3: [Proposed] [REDACTED] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhilips Retirement Plan]
- Defendant's Opposition to the Plaintiff's Motion to Designate the File as Confidential Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #2: Motion for Designate File as Confidential
- Entry of Appearance Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Attorney Information Attorney Colbo, Kimberlee representing Plaintiff Avila, Elizabeth Ann as of 08/22/2024
- Civil Deficiency Memo mailed re: The QDRO (Qualified Domestic Relations Order) filed 7/31/24 was redacted. Please file an unredacted copy to the court. Civil Deficiency Memo (11/23) Sent on: 08/28/2024 11:45:59.82
- Answer and Counterclaim Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Notice of Initial Status Hearing
- Motion Deemed Moot ~ [The Court interprets Elizabeth's "Other Requested Relief" as an addendum to the Complaint, not a motion.] Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #1 [Motion] Other Requested Relief
- Order Denying Motion for Designate File as Confidential Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #2 Motion for Designate File as Confidential
- Order Granting Defendant's Objection to the Entry of QDRO (Linked to Case Motion #3): [Proposed] [REDACTED] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhilips Retirement Plan]
- Proposed Order Not Used (Linked to Motion) Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #3 [Proposed] [REDACTED] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhilips Retirement Plan]
- Answer to Counterclaim Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Response to Court's August 28, 2024 Civil Deficiency Memo Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #3: [Proposed] [REDACTED] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhilips Retirement Plan]
- Notice of Filing Corrected Information Sheet (DR-314) Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Information Sheet - Confidential Document per Civil Rule 90.1(f)(1)
- Notice of Hearing
- Notice of Hearing with Exhibit Exchange Deadline
- Defendant's Briefing on Date of Seperation Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147)
- Scheduling Notice with Pretrial Deadlines
- Defendant's Trial Witness List Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Stipulationns to Change Pre Trial Deadlines Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #4
- Order Denying Stipulations to Change Pre Trial Deadlines Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #4 Stipulations to Change Pre Trial Deadlines
- Defendant's Trial Witness List Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Plaintiff's Witness List Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Plaintiff's Trial Brief Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Mr. Thomas Hartshorn's Trial Brief Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Defendant's Evid. R. 803(23) Notice to Plaintiff Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Notice to Court Regarding Updated Joint Property Spreadsheet Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- Defendant's Briefing on Plaintiff's Plan to Exclude Defendant's Expert Reports Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Notice of Filing Qualified Domestic Relations Order Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff);
- [Proposed] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhillips Retirement Plan] Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #5
- [Proposed] [Redacted] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhillips Retirement Plan] Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #5: [Proposed] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhillips Retirement Plan]
- Exhibits to Storage
- Order Granting Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhillips Retirement Plan] Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #5 [Proposed] Qualified Domestic Relations Order [ConocoPhillips Retirement Plan]
- Findings of Fact & Conclusions of Law
- Divorce Decree and Judgment - Granted
- Divorce Granted After Contested Hearing
- First Free Certified Copy of 1.) Divorce Decree & Judgment 2.) Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law 3.) QDRO-Unredacted 4.) QDRO-Redacted Mailed to: Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); ; Phyllis A Shepherd (Attorney) on behalf of Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Kimberlee Colbo (Attorney) on behalf of Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff)
- PROCESSED: VS-401 Certificate of Absolute Divorce or Dissolution
- Defendant's Motion to Reconsider Property Division Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Filing Party: Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #6
- Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #7
- Order Inviting Responses to Reconsideration Motions (Linked to Case Motions) #6: Defendant's Motion to Reconsider Property Division, Case Motion #7: Motion for Reconsideration
- Plaintiff's Response to Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #6: Defendant's Motion to Reconsider Property Division
- Defendant's Invited Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Reconsideration Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #7: Motion for Reconsideration
- Order Granting Motion in Part-See Order on Motion #7 RE: Order on Motion for Reconsideration Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #6 Defendant's Motion to Reconsider Property Division
- Order on Motion for Reconsideration-See order for specific details Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #7 Motion for Reconsideration
- Substitution Of Counsel Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #8
- Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #9
- Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #10
- Errata to Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Second Errata to Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Order Approving Substitution Of Counsel Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #8 Substitution Of Counsel
- Defendant's Opposition to the Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibility for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 for Income Tax Purposes (Filed with Defendant's Objections to the Proposed Order Granting Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibility for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes) Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #9: Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes
- Defendant's Objections to the Proposed Order Granting Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibility for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes (Filed with Defendant's Opposition to the Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibility for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 for Income Tax Purposes) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Notice of Filing Attachment that Cannot be Electronically Filed Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #11
- Defendant's Opposition to the Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make an Equalization Payment Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #12
- Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #12 Motion for Extension of Time
- Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #11 Motion for Extension of Time
- Reply to Defendant's Objections to Plaintiff's Proposed Order Regarding Reporting of Income Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #9: Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes
- Revised [Proposed] Order Regarding Reporting of Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #9: Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes
- Reply to Opposition to Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make the Equalization Payment Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Request for a Hearing and with Order and Notice for Same Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Filing Party: Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #13
- Sur-Reply to the Plaintiff's July 31, 2025, Reply Regarding Motion to Compel Defendant to Make an Immediate Equalization Payment Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Sur-Reply to the Plaintiff's July 31, 2025, Reply Regarding Reporting of Income Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #9: Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes
- Motion for an Order to Show Cause Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Filing Party: Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #14
- Order Clarifying Equalization Payment -See order for specific details Linked to Case Motion #10: Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Proposed Order Not Used (Linked to Motion) Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #10 Motion to Compel Defendant to Immediately Make Equalization Payment
- Order Granting Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes - See order for specific details Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #9 Motion for Ruling Regarding Responsibilities for Reporting Income for 2024 and 2025 Income Tax Purposes
- Motion to Strike Sur-Replies Filed by Defendant Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #15
- Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Filing Party: Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #16
- Notice of Withdrawal of Motion (linked to motion) Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #15: Motion to Strike Sur-Replies Filed by Defendant
- Motion Withdrawn Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #15 Motion to Strike Sur-Replies Filed by Defendant
- Notice of Unsigned Affidavit of Counsel Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant);
- Motion for Attorney Fees Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Filing Party: Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #17
- Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time Avila, Elizabeth Ann Case Motion #16 Motion for Extension of Time
- Opposition to Motion Show Cause Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #14: Motion for an Order to Show Cause
- Opposition to Motion for Attorneys' Fees Attorney: Colbo, Kimberlee (9211072) Elizabeth Ann Avila (Plaintiff); Case Motion #17: Motion for Attorney Fees
- Reply to the Plaintiff's Opposition to the Defendant's Motion for Attorney Fees Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #17: Motion for Attorney Fees
- Defendant's Reply to the Plaintiff's Opposition to the Motion for an Order to Show Cause Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147) Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Case Motion #14: Motion for an Order to Show Cause
- Notice of Filing Signed and Notarized Affidavit of Counsel Thomas Robert Hartshorn (Defendant); Attorney: Shepherd, Phyllis A (8310147)
- Order Re: Request for a Hearing and with Order and Notice for Same Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #13 Request for a Hearing and with Order and Notice for Same
- Order Denying Motion for an Order to Show Cause Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #14 Motion for an Order to Show Cause
- Order Granting Motion for Attorney Fees Hartshorn, Thomas Robert Case Motion #17 Motion for Attorney Fees
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In