Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Orange Co

Court

Orange Co

California

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-05-13
Type Medical Malpractice
Docket 154 entries
Disposition notice of entry of judgment

Parties

Plaintiff Laila Nemetallah|Mazen Nemetallah|Shatha Ahmad Abdallah
Defendant Epifanio P. Anzaldo|Peter Anzaldo|Providence Health & Services|Providence St. Joseph Hospital Orange|Reema Basu|St. Joseph Hospital Of Orange|Vanessa Ferragamo Gutierrez|Venessa Ferragamo Gutierrez, M.d.|Yuqi Wang
Photo of Hon. Claster William

Judge

Hon. Claster William

Orange County (CA)

California

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11308088 RECEIVED ON 05/13/2024 04:40:57 PM.
  2. NOTICE - OTHER FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 03/03/2026
  3. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41985214 RECEIVED ON 03/03/2026 12:33:57 PM.
  4. NOTICE OF ENTRY OF JUDGMENT FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 03/03/2026
  5. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11634709 RECEIVED ON 03/03/2026 12:33:55 PM.
  6. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  7. ORDER - OTHER (ON MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT) FILED BY THE SUPERIOR COURT OF ORANGE ON 02/13/2026
  8. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11610148 RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026 09:29:50 AM.
  9. JUDGMENT GENERATED
  10. THE COURT ENTERS JUDGMENT AS TO COMPLAINT.
  11. JURY TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 08/31/2026 AT 09:30:00 AM IN C28 AT CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER.
  12. PROPOSED STIPULATION AND ORDER RECEIVED ON 01/27/2026
  13. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  14. THE COURT ENTERS JUDGMENT AS TO COMPLAINT.
  15. JUDGMENT FILED BY ANZALDO, PETER ON 01/23/2026
  16. PROPOSED JUDGMENT RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026.
  17. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21782170 RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026 10:03:47 AM.
  18. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 01/20/2026
  19. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21782171 RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026 10:03:48 AM.
  20. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 01/20/2026
  21. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31782563 RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026 09:29:52 AM.
  22. PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED ON 01/20/2026
  23. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND/OR ADJUDICATION 01/12/2026 02:00:00 PM.
  24. NOTICE OF RULING FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 01/13/2026
  25. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31778805 RECEIVED ON 01/13/2026 11:44:11 AM.
  26. NOTICE OF NON-OPPOSITION FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 12/23/2025
  27. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31769615 RECEIVED ON 12/23/2025 03:06:30 PM.
  28. PROPOSED JUDGMENT RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025.
  29. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41898843 RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025 10:32:34 AM.
  30. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND/OR ADJUDICATION SCHEDULED FOR 01/12/2026 AT 02:00:00 PM IN C28 AT CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER.
  31. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY LEGALCONNECT FOR 38 - MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OR ADJUDICATION IN THE AMOUNT OF 500.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13688280 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13516540.
  32. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT/ADJUDICATION FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/19/2025
  33. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31718831 RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025 10:29:09 AM.
  34. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/19/2025
  35. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31718866 RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025 10:55:13 AM.
  36. DECLARATION IN SUPPORT FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/19/2025
  37. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31718832 RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025 10:29:12 AM.
  38. SEPARATE STATEMENT FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/19/2025
  39. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11549156 RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025 10:29:11 AM.
  40. PROPOSED ORDER RECEIVED ON 09/19/2025
  41. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY LEGALCONNECT FOR 37 - STIPULATION AND ORDER IN THE AMOUNT OF 20.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13655885 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13484146.
  42. STIPULATION AND ORDER FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 07/17/2025
  43. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31681668 RECEIVED ON 07/10/2025 01:46:19 PM.
  44. JURY TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR 07/13/2026 AT 09:30:00 AM IN C28 AT CENTRAL JUSTICE CENTER.
  45. PROPOSED STIPULATION AND ORDER RECEIVED ON 07/10/2025
  46. SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 06/11/2025
  47. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41845721 RECEIVED ON 06/11/2025 04:27:27 PM.
  48. SUBSTITUTION OF ATTORNEY FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 05/08/2025
  49. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21647686 RECEIVED ON 05/08/2025 04:52:36 PM.
  50. DECLARATION - OTHER (OF TRIAL COUNSEL) FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 05/13/2025
  51. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11481763 RECEIVED ON 05/13/2025 03:38:15 PM.
  52. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 01/27/2025 09:00:00 AM.
  53. THE JURY TRIAL IS SCHEDULED FOR 03/30/2026 AT 09:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT C28.
  54. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 01/10/2025
  55. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21586559 RECEIVED ON 01/10/2025 03:16:19 PM.
  56. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY WANG, YUQI ON 01/10/2025
  57. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21586447 RECEIVED ON 01/10/2025 02:23:30 PM.
  58. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY ANZALDO, EPIFANIO P. ON 01/10/2025
  59. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41764992 RECEIVED ON 01/10/2025 01:28:03 PM.
  60. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY PROVIDENCE HEALTH & SERVICES; PROVIDENCE ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL ORANGE; ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL OF ORANGE ON 01/10/2025
  61. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21586287 RECEIVED ON 01/10/2025 12:26:10 PM.
  62. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY BASU, REEMA; GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 01/07/2025
  63. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41762940 RECEIVED ON 01/07/2025 08:42:26 AM.
  64. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL FILED BY WANG, YUQI ON 12/04/2024
  65. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21570990 RECEIVED ON 12/04/2024 05:31:22 PM.
  66. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER, 209 - ADVANCED JURY FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE) IN THE AMOUNT OF 585.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13524718 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13352878.
  67. NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY WANG, YUQI ON 12/04/2024
  68. ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED BY WANG, YUQI ON 12/04/2024
  69. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11402898 RECEIVED ON 12/04/2024 05:31:22 PM.
  70. PROOF OF SUBSTITUTE SERVICE FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 11/07/2024
  71. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31559828 RECEIVED ON 11/07/2024 09:28:40 AM.
  72. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/23/2024
  73. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41714784 RECEIVED ON 09/23/2024 11:19:21 AM.
  74. NOTICE OF INTENT TO INTRODUCE DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE (PURSUANT TO 3333.1(A), (B) AND (C)) FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/23/2024
  75. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21536862 RECEIVED ON 09/23/2024 11:19:20 AM.
  76. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER, 209 - ADVANCED JURY FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE) IN THE AMOUNT OF 585.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13486443 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13314563.
  77. NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/23/2024
  78. DECLARATION - OTHER (OF TRIAL COUNSEL) FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/23/2024
  79. ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED BY BASU, REEMA ON 09/23/2024
  80. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21536863 RECEIVED ON 09/23/2024 11:19:22 AM.
  81. NOTICE OF RULING FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 09/20/2024
  82. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21536328 RECEIVED ON 09/20/2024 02:29:41 PM.
  83. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 09/16/2024 09:00:00 AM.
  84. CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE CONTINUED TO 01/27/2025 AT 09:00 AM IN THIS DEPARTMENT PURSUANT TO STIPULATION.
  85. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 209 - ADVANCED JURY FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE) IN THE AMOUNT OF 150.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13474830 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13302910.
  86. NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY PROVIDENCE HEALTH & SERVICES; ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL OF ORANGE ON 08/30/2024
  87. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21526518 RECEIVED ON 08/30/2024 12:57:39 PM.
  88. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY PROVIDENCE HEALTH & SERVICES; ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL OF ORANGE ON 08/30/2024
  89. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31526769 RECEIVED ON 08/30/2024 12:57:40 PM.
  90. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY ANZALDO, EPIFANIO P. ON 08/30/2024
  91. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21526391 RECEIVED ON 08/30/2024 11:24:31 AM.
  92. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL FILED BY ANZALDO, EPIFANIO P. ON 08/30/2024
  93. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21526390 RECEIVED ON 08/30/2024 11:24:30 AM.
  94. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY LEGALCONNECT FOR 209 - ADVANCED JURY FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE) IN THE AMOUNT OF 150.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13472138 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13300218.
  95. NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  96. NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM NAME FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  97. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21524602 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:20 PM.
  98. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  99. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41702762 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:22 PM.
  100. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  101. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21524605 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:22 PM.
  102. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  103. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21524604 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:22 PM.
  104. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  105. E-FILING TRANSACTION 21524603 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:21 PM.
  106. PROOF OF SERVICE FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 08/27/2024
  107. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11357144 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 04:40:21 PM.
  108. CASE MANAGEMENT STATEMENT FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/27/2024
  109. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31524610 RECEIVED ON 08/27/2024 11:10:56 AM.
  110. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER, 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER IN THE AMOUNT OF 870.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13468665 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13296745.
  111. ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED BY PROVIDENCE HEALTH & SERVICES; ST. JOSEPH HOSPITAL OF ORANGE ON 08/21/2024
  112. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41699882 RECEIVED ON 08/21/2024 02:35:28 PM.
  113. NOTICE OF INTENT TO INTRODUCE DOCUMENTARY EVIDENCE (CCP 3333.1) FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/13/2024
  114. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11350442 RECEIVED ON 08/13/2024 03:18:44 PM.
  115. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/13/2024
  116. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41695876 RECEIVED ON 08/13/2024 03:18:43 PM.
  117. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER, 209 - ADVANCED JURY FEE (NON-REFUNDABLE) IN THE AMOUNT OF 585.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13465121 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13293201.
  118. NOTICE OF POSTING JURY FEES FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/13/2024
  119. DECLARATION - OTHER (OF TRIAL COUNSEL) FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/13/2024
  120. ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED BY GUTIERREZ, M.D., VENESSA FERRAGAMO ON 08/13/2024
  121. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41695877 RECEIVED ON 08/13/2024 03:18:44 PM.
  122. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY ONELEGAL FOR 195 - ANSWER OR OTHER 1ST PAPER IN THE AMOUNT OF 435.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13451697 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13279778.
  123. ANSWER TO COMPLAINT FILED BY ANZALDO, EPIFANIO P. ON 07/22/2024
  124. E-FILING TRANSACTION 31507374 RECEIVED ON 07/22/2024 01:47:45 PM.
  125. PROOF OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 07/22/2024
  126. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41685395 RECEIVED ON 07/22/2024 01:04:43 PM.
  127. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  128. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CHAMBERS WORK 06/26/2024 02:05:00 PM.
  129. CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE CONTINUED TO 09/16/2024 AT 09:00 AM IN THIS DEPARTMENT PURSUANT TO COURT'S MOTION.
  130. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  131. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CHAMBERS WORK 06/26/2024 01:35:00 PM.
  132. THIS CASE IS REASSIGNED TO THE HONORABLE THOMAS S MCCONVILLE FOR ALL PURPOSES.
  133. PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE UNDER C.C.P. 170.6 AS TO THE HONORABLE NATHAN R. SCOTT FILED.
  134. PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE PURSUANT TO 170.6 CCP (HON. NATHAN SCOTT) FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 06/20/2024
  135. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11325498 RECEIVED ON 06/20/2024 03:04:33 PM.
  136. SUMMONS ISSUED AND FILED FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD ON 06/07/2024
  137. E-FILING TRANSACTION 11319485 RECEIVED ON 06/07/2024 12:19:48 PM.
  138. ORDER APPOINTING GUARDIAN AD LITEM FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA ON 06/07/2024
  139. APPLICATION FOR APPOINTMENT OF GUARDIAN AD LITEM FILED BY NEMETALLAH, LAILA ON 06/05/2024
  140. E-FILING TRANSACTION 41664000 RECEIVED ON 06/05/2024 12:30:26 PM.
  141. CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR 08/22/2024 AT 02:00:00 PM IN W02 AT WEST JUSTICE CENTER.
  142. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  143. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CHAMBERS WORK 06/05/2024 09:09:00 AM.
  144. THIS CASE IS REASSIGNED TO THE HONORABLE NATHAN SCOTT FOR ALL PURPOSES.
  145. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  146. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CHAMBERS WORK 06/05/2024 08:31:00 AM.
  147. CLERK'S CERTIFICATE OF MAILING/ELECTRONIC SERVICE
  148. MINUTES FINALIZED FOR CHAMBERS WORK 06/04/2024 02:25:00 PM.
  149. THE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE IS SCHEDULED FOR 09/11/2024 AT 08:30 AM IN DEPARTMENT CX101.
  150. THE COURT DEEMS THIS CASE EXCEPTIONAL.
  151. CASE ASSIGNED TO JUDICIAL OFFICER CLASTER, WILLIAM ON 05/13/2024.
  152. PAYMENT RECEIVED BY LEGALCONNECT FOR 194 - COMPLAINT OR OTHER 1ST PAPER IN THE AMOUNT OF 435.00, TRANSACTION NUMBER 13416978 AND RECEIPT NUMBER 13245130.
  153. CIVIL CASE COVER SHEET FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; NEMETALLAH, LAILA ON 05/13/2024
  154. COMPLAINT FILED BY ABDALLAH, SHATHA AHMAD; NEMETALLAH, MAZEN; NEMETALLAH, LAILA ON 05/13/2024

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more