Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Cuyahoga County

Court

Cuyahoga County

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2025-01-08
Status ACTIVE
Type Tort Medical Malpractice
Docket 71 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Richard Hans|Scott Hans|Summer Sikora|David Hans
Defendant Mercy Health Regional Medical Center, L.l.c. D.b.a. Mercy Health Lorain Hospital C/o Statutory Agent Cororation Service Company|Bon Secours Mercy Health, Inc. D.b.a. Mercy Health Lorain Hospital C/o Statutory Agent Corporation Service Company|Mercy Health Physicians Lorain Specialty Care, L.l.c. C/o Statutory Agent Corporation Service Company|Timothy P. O'donnell Md|Hni Medical Services Of Ohio, Llc (dba Hni Specialists) C/o Corporation Service Company, Statutory Agt|Community Intensivists, Lloc (dba Hni Specialists) C/o Corporation Service Company|Jessica Smith, M.d.
Photo of Hon. Ashley Kilbane

Judge

Hon. Ashley Kilbane

Cuyahoga County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CASE FILED: COMPLAINT, MOTION
  2. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HELD ON 09/24/2025. THE PARTIES APPEARED THROUGH COUNSEL. STATUS OF THE CASE DISCUSSED AND THE FOLLOWING DEADLINES SET: FACT DISCOVERY TO BE COMPLETED BY 04/30/2026. IF A DISCOVERY DISPUTE ARISES, THE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TELEPHONICALLY OR IN-PERSON. IF AFTER A GOOD-FAITH ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE THE ISSUES A DISPUTE REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHOULD CONTACT THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY BY EMAIL WITH A SUGGESTED DATE AND TIME FOR A ZOOM CONFERENCE WITH THE COURT, AND INCLUDE A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE ISSUES TO BE DISCUSSED. THEREAFTER, THE COURT MAY ORDER BRIEFING. PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 06/12/2026. DEFENDANT'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 08/14/2026. DISPOSITIVE MOTION TO BE FILED BY 09/30/2026. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS SHALL INCLUDE BRIEFING AS TO THE THEORY OF LIABILITY, MATERIAL FACTS, AND OTHER MATERIAL INFORMATION, SUCH AS CONTROLLING LAW OR THE EXISTENCE AND APPLICATION OF A CHOICE OF LAW PROVISION. RESPONSES DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6(C). ALL DEPOSITION PAGES THAT ARE CITED SHALL BE ATTACHED TO THE MOTIONS AND BRIEFS. IF A MOTION EXCEEDS 50 PAGES, THE PARTIES SHALL PROVIDE A HARD COPY TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY ON THE 11TH FLOOR. FINAL PRETRIAL SET FOR 12/01/2026 AT 01:00 PM. THE COURT HOLDS FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCES BY ZOOM, UNLESS THE COURT ORDERS OR THE PARTIES REQUEST AN IN-PERSON FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AT LEAST TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE. UNLESS ORDERED OTHERWISE, ONLY COUNSEL WILL BE PERMITTED ON THE ZOOM CALL WITH COURT. CLIENTS AND ADJUSTERS MUST BE READILY AVAILABLE TO COUNSEL BY PHONE. THE PARTIES SHALL EACH FILE A FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE THE FINAL PRETRIAL AND SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: - A BRIEF STATEMENT OF FACTS AND LEGAL ISSUES; - STIPULATIONS; - LIST OF WITNESSES WITH BRIEF SUMMARY OF EXPECTED TESTIMONY; - LIST OF EXHIBITS EXPECTED TO BE USED A TRIAL; - ANY ANTICIPATED UNIQUE LEGAL ISSUES; - AN ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL; - ANY CONTEMPLATED PRETRIAL MOTIONS; AND - SPECIAL EQUIPMENT OR POTENTIAL LOGISTICAL REQUESTS. THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY WILL EMAIL A ZOOM LINK TO COUNSEL PRIOR TO THE FINAL PRETRIAL. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 01/19/2027 AT 09:00 AM. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO SUP.R. 41 AND LOC.R. 17 REGARDING CONTINUANCE OF TRIAL. TRIAL BRIEFS DUE ONE DAY BEFORE TRIAL. DAUBERT MOTIONS CHALLENGING PURPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED AT LEAST FORTY-FIVE (45) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE PARTY CHALLENGING THE PROPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL FILE A COMPLETE COPY OF THE EXPERT'S REPORT(S) AND COMPLETE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS, IF THE EXPERT WAS DEPOSED. MOTIONS IN LIMINE SHALL BE FILED TWENTY-ONE (21) DAYS BEFORE THE START OF TRIAL. RESPONSES DUE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 6(C). NO REPLIES ARE PERMITTED. AFTER THE DEADLINE FOR RESPONSES, COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TO RESOLVE THE MOTIONS IN LIMINE, AND, AT LEAST (3) DAYS PRIOR TO TRIAL, THE PARTIES SHALL FILE A JOINT NOTICE INFORMING THE COURT WHICH MOTIONS IN LIMINE ARE UNOPPOSED OR RESOLVED, AND WHICH REMAIN OPPOSED. DEPOSITIONS, AUDIOVISUAL OR TRANSCRIPTS, TO BE PROFFERED AT TRIAL. ANY PARTY WISHING TO PROFFER DEPOSITION TESTIMONY AT TRIAL IN LIEU OF THE DEPONENT'S ATTENDANCE SHALL EXCHANGE SUCH DEPOSITION TESTIMONY BY COUNSEL AT LEAST THIRTY (30) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES SHALL MEET TELEPHONICALLY OR IN PERSON TO DISCUSS ANY OBJECTIONS TO THE PROFFERED TESTIMONY. IF ANY DISPUTES RELATING TO THE TESTIMONY REMAIN AFTER THE GOOD FAITH CONFERENCE, THE PARTIES SHALL SEND HARD COPIES OF THEIR RESPECTIVE DESIGNATIONS WITH OBJECTIONS EITHER ANNOTATED IN THE MARGINS OR OUTLINED IN A SEPARATE DOCUMENT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST FOURTEEN (14) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES MAY INCLUDE A BRIEF STATEMENT FOR CONTEXT FOR THE OBJECTIONS IF NECESSARY. JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND JURY INTERROGATORIES ARE DUE SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES IN ORDER TO SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. IF ANY DISAGREEMENT REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHALL HIGHLIGHT DISAGREEMENTS TO THE COURT. THE PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES SHALL BE SUBMITTED IN MICROSOFT WORD FORMAT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY. FURTHER, THE PARTIES ARE ENCOURAGED TO SUBMIT A JOINT STATEMENT OF THE CASE TO BE READ TO THE JURY. THE PARTIES SHALL ALSO SUBMIT A JOINT LIST OF POTENTIAL WITNESSES AND/OR PARTIES INVOLVED IN THE CASE FOR THE COURT TO INQUIRE FROM POTENTIAL JURORS WHETHER THEY ARE FAMILIAR WITH ANY OF THE LISTED INDIVIDUALS. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE EXPECTED TO BE FAMILIAR WITH THE OHIO RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, THE LOCAL RULES, THIS COURT'S STANDING CIVIL ORDER, WHICH CAN BE FOUND ON THE COURT'S WEBSITE, AND ANY OTHER ORDERS OF THIS COURT. NOTICE ISSUED
  3. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INITIAL DISCLOSURES TO DEFENDANTS HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, L.L.C. (D.B.A. HNI SPECIALISTS), COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, L.L.C. (D.B.A. HNI SPECIALISTS) AND JESSICA SMITH, M.D.
  4. DEFENDANT(S) HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, LLC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D5), COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLOC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D6) AND JESSICA SMITH, M.D.(D7) MOTION FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE, FILED 08/15/2025, IS GRANTED. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE SET FOR 09/24/2025 AT 11:00 AM. TO BE HELD BY TELEPHONE. PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL SHALL INITIATE THE CONFERENCE CALL WITH ALL OTHER PARTIES AND CONTACT THE COURT AT THE APPOINTED TIME AT 216-443-8618. PARTIES SHALL BE PREPARED TO DISCUSS DISCOVERY PROGRESS AND SCHEDULING MATTERS, ETC. NOTICE ISSUED
  5. MOTION FILED FOR DEFENDANT(S) HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, LLC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D5), COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLOC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D6) and JESSICA SMITH, M.D.(D7) THOMAS B KILBANE 0066943 DEFENDANTS HNI MEDICAL SERVICE OF OHIO, LLC (D.B.A HNI SPECIALISTS), COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLC (D.B.A. HNI SPECIALISTS), AND JESSICA SMITH, M.D.'S MOTION FOR SCHEDULING CONFERENCE
  6. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, LLC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D5), COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLOC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS)(D6) and JESSICA SMITH, M.D.(D7) ATTORNEY THOMAS B KILBANE 0066943 ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS, HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, L.L.C DBA HNI SPECIALISTS, COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, L.L.C. DBA HNI SPECIALISTS AND JESSICA SMITH, M.D. TO PLAINTIFFS' SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
  7. USPS RECEIPT NO. 57423221 DELIVERED BY USPS 07/15/2025 SMITH, M.D./JESSICA/ PROCESSED BY COC 07/23/2025.
  8. USPS RECEIPT NO. 57423220 DELIVERED BY USPS 07/07/2025 COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLOC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS) PROCESSED BY COC 07/16/2025.
  9. USPS RECEIPT NO. 57423219 DELIVERED BY USPS 07/07/2025 HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, LLC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS) PROCESSED BY COC 07/16/2025.
  10. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 JOINT ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS MERCY HEALTH - REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, LLC (DBA MERCY HEALTH - LORAIN HOSPITAL), BOND SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC. (DBA MERCY HEALTH - LORAIN HOSPITAL), LORAIN MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, LLC AND TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL, M.D. TO PLAINTIFF'S SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT
  11. SUMS COMPLAINT(57423221) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: JESSICA SMITH, M.D. 5340 SANCTUARY LANE SHEFFIELD LAKE, OH 44054-0000
  12. SUMS COMPLAINT(57423220) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: COMMUNITY INTENSIVISTS, LLOC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS) 1160 DUBLIN ROAD, SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215-0000
  13. SUMS COMPLAINT(57423219) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: HNI MEDICAL SERVICES OF OHIO, LLC (DBA HNI SPECIALISTS) 1160 DUBLIN ROAD, SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215-0000
  14. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  15. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  16. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  17. WRIT FEE
  18. WRIT FEE
  19. WRIT FEE
  20. DEPOSIT AMOUNT PAID RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC
  21. AMENDED COMPLAINT $75 SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
  22. PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, INSTANTER, FILED 06/26/2025, IS GRANTED. NOTICE ISSUED
  23. MOTION FILED FOR PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' AMENDED MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, INSTANTER
  24. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, INSTANTER
  25. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF RICHARD HANS, ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTATE OF JOYCE HANS, RESPONSES AND ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C. (D.B.A. MERCY HEALTH LORAIN HOSPITAL)'S FIRST SET OF DISCOVERY
  26. CMC BY PHONE HELD ON 04/30/2025. THE PARTIES APPEARED THROUGH COUNSEL. STATUS OF THE CASE DISCUSSED AND THE FOLLOWING DEADLINES SET: FACT DISCOVERY TO BE COMPLETED BY 01/30/2026. PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 03/15/2026. DEFENDANT'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 05/15/2026. DISPOSITIVE MOTION TO BE FILED BY 06/15/2026. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS SHALL INCLUDE BRIEFING AS TO THE THEORY OF LIABILITY, MATERIAL FACTS, AND OTHER MATERIAL INFORMATION, SUCH AS CONTROLLING LAW OR THE EXISTENCE AND APPLICATION OF A CHOICE OF LAW PROVISION. RESPONSES DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6(C). ALL DEPOSITION PAGES THAT ARE CITED SHALL BE ATTACHED TO THE MOTIONS AND BRIEFS. ALL PAGES SHALL BE SECURELY FASTENED (A BINDER CLIP IS NOT ACCEPTABLE). UPON FILING, HARD COPIES OF ALL DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS, BRIEFS, AND EXHIBITS SHALL BE DELIVERED TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY ON THE 11TH FLOOR. FINAL PRETRIAL SET FOR 09/17/2026 AT 02:00 PM. THE COURT HOLDS FINAL PRETIRAL CONFERENCES BY ZOOM, UNLESS THE COURT ORDERS OR THE PARTIES REQUEST AN IN-PERSON FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AT LEAST TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE. UNLESS ORDERED OTHERWISE, ONLY COUNSEL AND ADJUSTERS WILL BE PERMITTED ON THE ZOOM CALL WITH COURT. CLIENTS, AND ADJUSTERS NOT ON THE ZOOM CALL, MUST BE READILY AVAILABLE TO COUNSEL BY PHONE. THE PARTIES SHALL EACH FILE A FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THE FINAL PRETRIAL AND SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: - A BRIEF STATEMENT OF FACTS AND LEGAL ISSUES; - STIPULATIONS; - LIST OF WITNESSES WITH BRIEF SUMMARY OF EXPECTED TESTIMONY; - LIST OF EXHIBITS EXPECTED TO BE USED A TRIAL; - ANY ANTICIPATED UNIQUE LEGAL ISSUES; - AN ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL; - ANY CONTEMPLATED PRETRIAL MOTIONS; AND - SPECIAL EQUIPMENT OR POTENTIAL LOGISTICAL REQUESTS. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 10/26/2026 AT 09:00 AM. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO SUP.R. 41 AND LOC.R. 17 REGARDING CONTINUANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES SHALL EXCHANGE TRIAL EXHIBITS NO LATER THAN SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. TRIAL BRIEFS DUE ONE (1) DAY BEFORE TRIAL. DAUBERT OR EXPERT-RELATED MOTIONS IN LIMINE: ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPORTED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED BY THE EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE SET BY THE COURT. IF NO EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE WAS SET, THEN ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED AT LEAST FORTY-FIVE (45) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE PARTY CHALLENGING THE PROPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL FILE A COMPLETE COPY OF THE EXPERT'S REPORT(S) AND COMPLETE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS, IF THE EXPERT WAS DEPOSED. MOTIONS IN LIMINE SHALL BE FILED TWENTY-ONE (21) DAYS BEFORE THE START OF TRIAL. RESPONSES DUE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 6(C). NO REPLIES ARE PERMITTED. AFTER THE DEADLINE FOR RESPONSES, COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TO RESOLVE THE MOTIONS IN LIMINE, AND, AT LEAST (3) DAYS PRIOR TO TRIAL, THE PARTIES SHALL FILE A JOINT NOTICE INFORMING THE COURT WHICH MOTIONS IN LIMINE ARE UNOPPOSED OR RESOLVED, AND WHICH REMAIN OPPOSED. DEPOSITIONS, AUDIOVISUAL OR TRANSCRIPTS, TO BE PROFFERED AT TRIAL. ANY PARTY WISHING TO PROFFER DEPOSITION TESTIMONY AT TRIAL IN LIEU OF THE DEPONENT'S ATTENDANCE SHALL EXCHANGE SUCH DEPOSITION TESTIMONY BY COUNSEL AT LEAST THIRTY (30) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES SHALL MEET TELEPHONICALLY OR IN PERSON TO DISCUSS ANY OBJECTIONS TO THE PROFFERED TESTIMONY. IF ANY DISPUTES RELATING TO THE TESTIMONY REMAIN AFTER THE GOOD FAITH CONFERENCE, THE PARTIES SHALL SEND HARD COPIES OF THEIR RESPECTIVE DESIGNATIONS WITH OBJECTIONS EITHER ANNOTATED IN THE MARGINS OR OUTLINED IN A SEPARATE DOCUMENT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST FOURTEEN (14) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES MAY INCLUDE A BRIEF STATEMENT FOR CONTEXT FOR THE OBJECTIONS IF NECESSARY. JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND JURY INTERROGATORIES ARE DUE SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES IN ORDER TO SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. THE PARTIES SHALL SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST ONE (1) DAY BEFORE TRIAL. IF ANY DISAGREEMENT REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHALL HIGHLIGHT DISAGREEMENTS TO THE COURT. THE PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES SHALL BE SUBMITTED IN MICROSOFT WORD FORMAT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY. FURTHER, THE PARTIES ARE ENCOURAGED TO SUBMIT A JOINT STATEMENT OF THE CASE TO BE READ TO THE JURY. ALL PARTIES AND COUNSEL OF RECORD TO BE PRESENT AT BOTH THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND THE FINAL PRETRIAL OR APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS WILL BE IMPOSED, INCLUDING DISMISSAL PURSUANT TO CIV. RULE 41(B)(1) OR DEFAULT JUDGMENT (AS APPLICABLE). THE COURT HOLDS SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES AND FINAL PRETRIALS BY ZOOM, UNLESS THE ORDERED OTHERWISE OR THE PARTIES REQUEST IN-PERSON SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND/OR FINAL PRETRIAL AT LEAST TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE EXPECTED TO BE FAMILIAR WITH THE OHIO RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, THE LOCAL RULES, THIS COURT'S STANDING CIVIL ORDER, WHICH CAN BE FOUND ON THE COURT'S WEBSITE, AND ANY OTHER ORDERS OF THIS COURT. NOTICE ISSUED
  27. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INITIAL DISCLOSURES
  28. NOTICE FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 NOTICE OF SERVICE REGARDING DEFENDANTS' CIVIL RULE 26 INITIAL DISCLOSURES
  29. GENERAL PLEADING FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 JOINT CIVIL RULE 26(F) REPORT
  30. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 JOINT ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
  31. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS DIRECTED TO DEFENDANTS MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C. AND BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.
  32. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) RICHARD HANS(P1), SCOTT HANS(P2), SUMMER SIKORA(P3) and DAVID HANS(P4) ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS DIRECTED TO DEFENDANTS MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C. AND TIMOTHY O'DONNELL, M.D.
  33. DEPOSIT AMOUNT PAID RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC
  34. AMENDED COMPLAINT $75 STIPULATED FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
  35. DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS, FILED 03/11/2025, IS WITHDRAWN. NOTICE ISSUED
  36. NOTICE FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF THEIR MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
  37. DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4)'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS. ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
  38. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR SICILIANO/NICHOLAS/J. 03/09/2025 17:02:03
  39. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR HESS/ERIN/SIEBENHAR 03/09/2025 17:02:03
  40. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR BAKER DEBEVEC/RHONDA/ 03/09/2025 17:02:03
  41. CMC BY PHONE SET FOR 04/30/2025 AT 02:15 PM. PURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 21, PART I, THE COURT WILL CONDUCT A CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. DISCOVERY SCHEDULE, AMOUNT IN CONTROVERSY, EXCHANGE OF EXPERT REPORTS, DATE FOR FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE, REFERRAL TO ARBITRATION, ETC., SHALL BE RESOLVED AND INCLUDED IN A BINDING DECREE AND ORDER FORMALIZED. ALL COUNSEL ATTENDING SHALL HAVE FULL AUTHORITY TO ENTER INTO A BINDING CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER . PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL SHALL INITIATE THE CONFERENCE CALL WITH ALL OTHER PARTIES AND CONTACT THE COURT AT THE APPOINTED TIME AT 216-443-8618. PARTIES SHALL BE PREPARED TO DISCUSS DISCOVERY PROGRESS AND SCHEDULING MATTERS, ETC. COUNSEL AND UNREPRESENTED PARTIES SHALL FOLLOW THE DISCOVERY PROCEDURES OUTLINED IN CIVIL RULE 26(F) IN PREPARATION FOR THE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.
  42. DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STAY DISCOVERY, FILED 02/03/2025, IS GRANTED. DISCOVERY IS STAYED IN THIS MATTER UNTIL PLAINTIFFS FILE AN AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT IN COMPLIANCE WITH OHIO CIV. R. 10(D)(2). NOTICE ISSUED
  43. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ATTORNEY ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 JOINT ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS MERCY HEALTH - REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, LLC (DBA MERCY HEALTH - LORAIN HOSPITAL), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC. (DBA MERCY HEALTH - LORAIN HOSPITAL), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, LLC AND TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL, M.D. TO PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT
  44. NOTICE FILED BY P1 RICHARD HANS ATTORNEY RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC 0068260 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF FILING THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT OF ALAN SCHURICHT, M.D.
  45. MOTION FILED FOR DEFENDANT(S) MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C.(D1), BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC.(D2), MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C.(D3) and TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL(D4) ERIN SIEBENHAR HESS 0074007 DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STAY DISCOVERY
  46. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, FILED 01/08/2025, IS GRANTED. PLAINTIFFS ARE GIVEN AN ADDITIONAL 90 DAY PERIOD WITHIN WHICH TO FILE THEIR AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT. NOTICE ISSUED
  47. USPS RECEIPT NO. 55774649 DELIVERED BY USPS 01/13/2025 MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C. PROCESSED BY COC 01/22/2025.
  48. USPS RECEIPT NO. 55774647 DELIVERED BY USPS 01/13/2025 MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C. PROCESSED BY COC 01/22/2025.
  49. USPS RECEIPT NO. 55774648 DELIVERED BY USPS 01/17/2025 BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC. PROCESSED BY COC 01/22/2025.
  50. USPS RECEIPT NO. 55774650 DELIVERED BY USPS 01/11/2025 O'DONNELL MD/TIMOTHY/P. PROCESSED BY COC 01/15/2025.
  51. SUMS COMPLAINT(55774650) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: TIMOTHY P. O'DONNELL MD 28914 WEYBRIDGE DRIVE WESTLAKE, OH 44145
  52. SUMS COMPLAINT(55774649) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: MERCY HEALTH PHYSICIANS LORAIN SPECIALTY CARE, L.L.C. 1160 DUBLIN ROAD, SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215
  53. SUMS COMPLAINT(55774648) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: BON SECOURS MERCY HEALTH, INC. 1160 DUBLIN ROAD, SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215
  54. SUMS COMPLAINT(55774647) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: MERCY HEALTH REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER, L.L.C. 1160 DUBLIN ROAD, SUITE 400 COLUMBUS, OH 43215
  55. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  56. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  57. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  58. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  59. WRIT FEE
  60. WRIT FEE
  61. WRIT FEE
  62. WRIT FEE
  63. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
  64. JUDGE ASHLEY KILBANE ASSIGNED (RANDOM)
  65. LEGAL RESEARCH
  66. LEGAL NEWS
  67. LEGAL AID
  68. COURT SPECIAL PROJECTS FUND
  69. COMPUTER FEE
  70. CLERK'S FEE
  71. DEPOSIT AMOUNT PAID RHONDA BAKER DEBEVEC

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more