Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of San Diego Court

Court

San Diego Court

California

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-06-26
Status Consolidated
Type (u)pi/pd/wd Auto: Personal Injury (auto)
Docket 54 entries
Disposition transfer

Parties

Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose | Gaitan, Roxanna | Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan | Gonzalez, Ana
Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc | Bozarreyes, Kevin | Budget Rental Trucks | Prosperity Moving Inc
Photo of Hon. Earl H. Maas, III

Judge

Hon. Earl H. Maas, III

San Diego County (CA)

California

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. (Cancelled) Case Management Conference Hearing Date: 12/6/2024 1:30 PM Judicial Officers: Central, C-73; WOHLFEIL, JOEL R Department: C-73 Cancellation Reason: Case Transferred
  2. Rejected Filing Summons (Civil) Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana
  3. Case Ordered Consolidated - Subordinate Case
  4. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  5. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Jose Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose
  6. Notice of Jury Fee Deposit Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  7. Notice of Related Case Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  8. Answer/Response/Denial (Unlimited) Answer Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  9. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  10. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana
  11. Amended Complaint First Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc Defendant Bozarreyes, Kevin Defendant Budget Rental Trucks Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  12. Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana
  13. Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana
  14. Amendment to Complaint/Cross-Complaint Naming Doe Doe 1 Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc
  15. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Case initiation form printed. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  16. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Civil Case Management Conference scheduled for 12/06/2024 at 01:30:00 PM at Central in C-73 Joel R. Wohlfeil. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  17. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Summons issued. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  18. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Case assigned to Judicial Officer Wohlfeil, Joel. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  19. Civil Complaint Complaint filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed by Jose Gaitan, Roxanna Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Budget Rental Trucks Defendant Bozarreyes, Kevin Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc
  20. Civil Case Cover Sheet Civil Case Cover Sheet filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Gonzalez, Ana Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Budget Rental Trucks Defendant Bozarreyes, Kevin
  21. Rejected Filing Summons (Civil) Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  22. Case Ordered Consolidated - Subordinate Case
  23. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  24. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Jose Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose
  25. Notice of Jury Fee Deposit Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  26. Notice of Related Case Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  27. Answer/Response/Denial (Unlimited) Answer Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  28. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  29. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  30. Amended Complaint First Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc Defendant Defendant Defendant
  31. Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  32. Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  33. Amendment to Complaint/Cross-Complaint Naming Doe Doe 1 Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc
  34. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Case initiation form printed. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  35. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Civil Case Management Conference scheduled for 12/06/2024 at 01:30:00 PM at Central in C-73 Joel R. Wohlfeil. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  36. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Summons issued. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  37. Consolidated via: 37-2024-00029982-CU-PA-NC Case assigned to Judicial Officer Wohlfeil, Joel. This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC This event has been consolidated to 37-2024-00024503-CU-PA-NC
  38. Civil Complaint Complaint filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed by Jose Gaitan, Roxanna Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Defendant Defendant
  39. Civil Case Cover Sheet Civil Case Cover Sheet filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Defendant
  40. Summons (Civil) Original Summons filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed By: Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Budget Rental Trucks Defendant Defendant
  41. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  42. Order Appointing Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Family Law Denied Filed by Jose Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose
  43. Notice of Jury Fee Deposit Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  44. Notice of Related Case Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  45. Answer/Response/Denial (Unlimited) Answer Filed by Avis Budget Group Inc Filed By: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc
  46. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna
  47. Application for Appointment of Guardian Ad Litem - Civil and Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  48. Amended Complaint First Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc Defendant Defendant Defendant
  49. Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Proof of Service of Summons - Substitute Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  50. Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Proof of Service of Summons - Personal Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff
  51. Amendment to Complaint/Cross-Complaint Naming Doe Doe 1 Filed by Roxanna Gaitan, Jose Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Prosperity Moving Inc
  52. Civil Complaint Complaint filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed by Jose Gaitan, Roxanna Gaitan, Jeronimo Gaitan Gomez, Ana Gonzalez Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Jose Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Defendant Defendant
  53. Civil Case Cover Sheet Civil Case Cover Sheet filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed By: Plaintiff Gaitan, Roxanna Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Avis Budget Group Inc Defendant Defendant
  54. Summons (Civil) Original Summons filed by Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan; Gonzalez, Ana; Gaitan, Jose; Gaitan, Roxanna.; Transaction Number: 22101838 Filed By: Plaintiff Gomez, Jeronimo Gaitan Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Refers To: Defendant Budget Rental Trucks Defendant Defendant

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more