Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Case Information

Filed 2022-10-12
Status Pending
Type Tort Medical Malpractice
Docket 393 entries
Disposition dismissed

Parties

Plaintiff Charles Danier Jno | Charles Joel Jno
Defendant Mani Md Balu Subra Mani Md Balu Subra 119 Upper Riverdale Road Sw Riverdale, Ga 30274 | South Atlanta Radiology Associates Pc South Atlanta Radiology Associates Pc 119 Upper Riverdale Rd Sw Riverdale, Ga 30274
Photo of Hon. Mspencer

Judge

Hon. Mspencer

Clayton County (GA)

Georgia

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Certificate of Service for Plaintiff Offer of
  2. Settlement
  3. Notice of Change of Address
  4. Premier Women OB/GYN LLC Dismissed with Prejudice
  5. Watkins Jeshenna Jamill Dismissed with Prejudice
  6. Granted - Joint Motion for Dismissal With
  7. Prejudice of Less Than All Defendants
  8. Consent Order Granting Joint Motion for Dismissal
  9. with Prejudice of Less than all Defendants
  10. Proposed Order Granting Motion for Dismissal With
  11. Prejudice of Less than All Defendants
  12. Joint Motion for Dismissal With Prejudice of Less
  13. than All Defendants
  14. Cross Notice of Deposition-Tracey St. Julian, M.D.
  15. Amended Notice to Take Deposition and Notice to
  16. Produce of Tracy St. Julian MD
  17. LEA Atty Arlissa E Williams Jennings
  18. 12/15/2025-12/19/2025 01/30/2026-02/04/2026
  19. Leave of Absence
  20. LEA Atty AUDREY M TOLSON
  21. 12/15/2025-12/19/2025
  22. Leave of Absence
  23. Defendants Motion to Bifurcate Trial
  24. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  25. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  26. Notice of Deposition and Notice to Produce to
  27. Tracey St. Julian MD
  28. LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
  29. 10/08/2025-10/14/2025 12/22/2025-12/30/2025
  30. RPM Leave of Absence
  31. Granted - Joint Motion to Remove Case From Ready
  32. List
  33. Discovery Extended by Order Through and
  34. Including January 27, 2026
  35. Removal from Ready List and Order Extending
  36. Discovery
  37. Moved to New Calendar - CAL/RDY 09/01/2025
  38. Joint Motion to Remove Case From Trial Ready List
  39. and Extend Discovery
  40. Proposed Order Granting Joint Motion to Remove
  41. Case From Trial Ready List and Extend Discovery
  42. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  43. Order Placing Case on Ready-for-Trial List
  44. Notice of Placement on Ready-for-Trial List
  45. Granted - Motion to Withdraw and Amend R
  46. By Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  47. Order Granting Motion to Withdraw and Amend
  48. Responses to Plaintiffs Requests for Admissions
  49. 09:00 AM Room 303 Oral Argument Motion Calendar
  50. Withdrawn - Plaintiffs Motion for Sanction
  51. By Charles Danier Jno
  52. Withdrawal of Plaintiffs Motion for Sanctions for
  53. Spoliation of Critical Evidence
  54. Not Completed - CAL/MOA 08/05/2025
  55. LEA Atty JACOB H RAEHN
  56. 07/30/2025-07/31/2025 08/01/2025-08/01/2025
  57. 09/19/2025-09/19/2025 09/22/2025-09/26/2025
  58. 09/29/2025-09/29/2025
  59. Notice of Leave of Absence of Jacob H. Raehn
  60. Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel
  61. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  62. 09:00 AM Room 303 Oral Argument Motion Calendar
  63. Moved to New Calendar - CAL/MOA 05/30/2025
  64. Notice of Deposition and Notice to Produce to
  65. Janice Moton
  66. Rule 5.2 REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO A
  67. GREENWAY HEALTH (GA), LLC.
  68. 09:00 AM Room 303 Oral Argument Motion Calendar
  69. Defendant Premier Womens OB/GYN, LLCs Response to
  70. Plaintiffs Motion for Sanctions for Spoilation of
  71. Critical Evidence
  72. Moved to New Calendar - CAL/MOA 04/22/2025
  73. 2025.04.01 Conflict Letter (Charles v. Premier
  74. Womens OBGYN)
  75. LEA Atty AUDREY M TOLSON
  76. 05/08/2025-05/09/2025 05/26/2025-06/26/2025
  77. 06/19/2025-06/24/2025 07/21/2025-08/01/2025
  78. 11/24/2025-11/28/2025 12/22/2025-01/02/2026
  79. LEA Atty Arlissa E Williams Jennings
  80. 04/22/2025-05/01/2025 06/06/2025-06/06/2025
  81. 06/23/2025-07/04/2025 07/31/2025-08/04/2025
  82. 11/24/2025-11/28/2025 12/22/2025-01/02/2026
  83. Leave of Absence for Audrey Tolson
  84. Leave of Absence for Arlissa Williams Jennings
  85. Notice of Change of Address
  86. Plaintiffs Motion for Sanctions for Spoliation of
  87. Critical Evidence
  88. Joint Stipulatio to Ext. Def Premiers Time to
  89. Respond to RFAs (Charles v. Premier Womens)
  90. Discovery extended by Order to and throu 08112025
  91. Attorney Leave of Absence
  92. Granted - Consent Motion to Extend Disco
  93. By Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  94. Order Extending Discovery
  95. Consent Motion to Extend Discovery & Proposed
  96. Order
  97. Exhibit 3
  98. Motion to Withdraw and Amend Responses
  99. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  100. LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
  101. 04/23/2025-04/25/2025 08/20/2025-09/03/2025
  102. RPM - Leave of Absence
  103. LEA Atty STEPHANIE B VARI
  104. 07/24/2025-07/28/2025
  105. SBVs Amended Leave of Absence
  106. Order Removing Case from Ready-for-Trial List and
  107. Reopening Discovery
  108. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  109. LEA Atty STEPHANIE B VARI
  110. 07/14/2025-07/18/2025 11/25/2025-11/28/2025
  111. 12/22/2025-12/26/2025
  112. Atty SBV - Leave of Absence
  113. AMENDED NOTICE TO TAKE VIDEO DEPOSITION AND
  114. NOTICE TO PRODUCE OF BALU SUBRA MANI, MD.
  115. LEA Atty M SCOTT BAILEY
  116. 07/07/2025-07/09/2025 08/15/2025-08/18/2025
  117. 09/16/2025-09/17/2025 10/13/2025-10/14/2025
  118. 10/30/2025-10/31/2025 11/20/2025-11/21/2025
  119. 12/02/2025-12/03/2025 12/15/2025-12/16/2025
  120. Amended Leave of Absence MSB 2025 (Charles)
  121. Rule 5.2 Cert Of Serv Discovery (Charles)
  122. Notice of Deposition and Notice to Produce to
  123. Balu Subra Mani M.D.
  124. Not Completed - CAL/RDY 10/28/2024
  125. Consent Motion for Continuance and to Reopen and
  126. Extend Discovery Period
  127. LEA Atty JACOB H RAEHN
  128. 11/12/2024-11/15/2024 11/18/2024-11/19/2024
  129. 11/27/2024-11/29/2024 12/16/2024-12/20/2024
  130. 12/23/2024-12/27/2024 12/30/2024-12/31/2024
  131. 01/29/2025-01/31/2025 03/27/2025-03/28/2025
  132. 03/31/2025-03/31/2025 04/17/2025-04/18/2025
  133. 04/21/2025-04/21/2025
  134. Notice of Leave of Absence
  135. LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
  136. 02/24/2025-03/09/2025
  137. RPM - Leave Of Absence
  138. Notice General
  139. Ready List Order
  140. Rule 5.2 Certificate for Plaintiff's 2nd Request
  141. for Admissions to Defendant Premier Womens OBGYN
  142. LEA Atty M SCOTT BAILEY
  143. 02/26/2025-02/28/2025 03/05/2025-03/07/2025
  144. Leave of Absence- MSB 2025 (Charles)
  145. LEA Atty AUDREY M TOLSON
  146. 07/29/2024-08/12/2024 11/25/2024-11/29/2024
  147. 12/16/2024-01/06/2025
  148. LEA Atty Arlissa E Williams Jennings
  149. 07/31/2024-08/13/2024 10/14/2024-10/18/2024
  150. 11/25/2024-11/29/2024 12/16/2024-01/06/2025
  151. LEA Atty MEGAN L PATTERSON
  152. 08/01/2024-08/09/2024
  153. Atty PATTERSON MEGAN L
  154. for Mani MD Balu Subra
  155. Atty NGUYEN NGAN T.
  156. for Mani MD Balu Subra
  157. Atty PATTERSON MEGAN L
  158. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  159. Atty NGUYEN NGAN T.
  160. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  161. Notice of Leave of Absence
  162. Notice of Substitution of Counsel
  163. Leave of Absence - Atty Arlissa Williams
  164. Leave of Absence- Atty Audrey Tolson
  165. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Discovery (Charles v.
  166. Premier Womens OBGYN))
  167. Defendant Watkins Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  168. of Discovery
  169. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  170. Returned Mail
  171. Joint Stipulation to Extend Time for Defendant
  172. South Atlanta Radiology Associates, PC to Respond
  173. to Plaintiffs Second Interrogatories, Requests
  174. for Production of Documents, and Notice to Produce
  175. Returned Mail
  176. LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
  177. 08/01/2024-08/13/2024
  178. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  179. Supp Leave of Absence
  180. 5.2 Certificate of Service
  181. Granted - Consent Motion for Continuance
  182. By Charles Danier Jno
  183. Order Removing Case from Ready-for-Trial List
  184. Order Removing Case from Ready-for-Trial List
  185. Not Completed - CAL/RDY 05/20/2024
  186. Consent Motion for Continuance
  187. Defendants Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of
  188. Discovery
  189. Defendants Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of
  190. Discovery
  191. Ready List Order
  192. Defendant Watkins Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  193. Amended Notice of Deposition. Dr. Jeshenna Watkins
  194. Defendant Watkins Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  195. of Discovery
  196. Defendant Watkins Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  197. of Discovery
  198. Defendant Watkins Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  199. of Discovery
  200. Defendant Watkins Objections and Responses to
  201. Plaintiffs NOD
  202. Notice of Deposition. Jasheena Watkins MD
  203. Atty DILLARD JORDAN D
  204. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  205. Atty WILSON NIA S
  206. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  207. Substitution of Counsel - JDD
  208. Atty RAEHN JACOB H
  209. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  210. Atty RAEHN JACOB H
  211. for Mani MD Balu Subra
  212. Notice of Entry of Appearance (Jacob H. Raehn)
  213. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  214. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  215. Atty NGUYEN NGAN T.
  216. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  217. Atty NGUYEN NGAN T.
  218. for Mani MD Balu Subra
  219. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  220. for Mani MD Balu Subra
  221. Notice of Substitution of Counsel (Ngan T. Nguyen)
  222. LEA Atty STEPHANIE B VARI
  223. 04/15/2024-04/19/2024 06/17/2024-06/17/2024
  224. 06/28/2024-07/05/2024 08/19/2024-08/23/2024
  225. 12/30/2024-01/03/2025
  226. Leave of Absence of Stephanie Vari
  227. LEA Atty M SCOTT BAILEY
  228. 05/16/2024-05/17/2024 05/23/2024-05/24/2024
  229. 05/30/2024-05/31/2024 06/06/2024-06/07/2024
  230. 06/20/2024-06/21/2024 07/08/2024-07/09/2024
  231. 09/27/2024-09/30/2024 01/09/2025-01/10/2025
  232. 01/13/2025-01/14/2025
  233. Leave of Absence For Atty M. Scott Bailey
  234. Notice of Leave of Absence for Atty Sandra
  235. LEA Atty M SCOTT BAILEY
  236. 01/24/2024-01/27/2024
  237. For M. Scott Bailey
  238. LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
  239. 02/27/2024-03/05/2024 05/09/2024-09/14/2024
  240. 05/23/2024-06/02/2024
  241. Leave of Absence
  242. Atty CIANEFLONE SANDRA M
  243. for Mani Balu Subra
  244. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  245. for Mani Balu Subra
  246. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  247. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  248. Atty CIANEFLONE SANDRA M
  249. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  250. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  251. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  252. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  253. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  254. Notice of Substitution of Counsel
  255. Atty VARI STEPHANIE B
  256. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  257. Atty MONYAK ROBERT P
  258. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  259. Atty WILSON NIA S
  260. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  261. Atty BAILEY M SCOTT
  262. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  263. Notice of Substitution of Counsel
  264. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  265. LEA Atty AUDREY M TOLSON
  266. 10/09/2023-10/16/2023 12/18/2023-12/29/2023
  267. LEA Atty Arlissa E Williams Jennings
  268. 10/09/2023-10/16/2023 11/20/2023-11/27/2023
  269. 12/18/2023-12/29/2023
  270. Atty Williams Jennings Arlissa E
  271. for Charles Joel Jno
  272. Atty Williams Jennings Arlissa E
  273. for Charles Danier Jno
  274. Leave of Absence
  275. Leave of Absence
  276. Second Amended Notice of Deposition of Joel Jno
  277. Charles
  278. Second Amended Notice of Deposition of Danier Jno
  279. Charles
  280. Amended Notice of Deposition of Joel Jno Charles
  281. Amended Notice of Deposition of Danier Jno Charle
  282. Discovery extended by Order Through And Including
  283. November 13,2023
  284. Consent Order Extending Discovery
  285. Consent Motion to Extend Discovery
  286. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  287. Certificate of Service
  288. 5.2 Certificate of Service of Defendants Requests
  289. for Production of Documents to Non-Parties
  290. LEA Atty AUDREY M TOLSON
  291. 05/08/2023-05/12/2023 05/22/2023-06/02/2023
  292. 08/07/2023-08/11/2023 11/20/2023-11/24/2023
  293. 12/25/2023-01/05/2024
  294. NOTICE OF LEAVE OF ABSENCE
  295. 2023.02.27- COSD 1st ROGS RPDS to Plfs (WATKINS)
  296. Notice of Deposition of Joel Jno Charles
  297. Notice of Deposition Danier Jno Charles
  298. LEA Atty BRIAN D TRULOCK
  299. 02/13/2023-02/17/2023 03/13/2023-03/24/2023
  300. 04/03/2023-04/07/2023 06/26/2023-07/07/2023
  301. 09/18/2023-09/22/2023
  302. Notice of Leave of Absence of Brian Trulock
  303. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Discovery
  304. 5.2 Certificate of Service of Defendants Requests
  305. for Production of Documents to Non-Parties
  306. LEA Atty M SCOTT BAILEY
  307. 07/05/2023-07/07/2023 07/17/2023-07/21/2023
  308. 09/11/2023-09/13/2023
  309. Leave Of Absence M. Scott Bailey
  310. Certificate of Service
  311. Rule 5.2 Certificate
  312. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  313. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  314. Rule 5.2 Cert of Service
  315. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  316. 12 Person Jury
  317. By Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  318. By Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  319. Atty WILSON NIA S
  320. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  321. Atty BAILEY M SCOTT
  322. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  323. Atty WILSON NIA S
  324. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  325. Atty BAILEY M SCOTT
  326. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  327. Answer And Jury Trial Demand Of Defendants
  328. Jeshenna Jamill Watkins, M.D. And Premier Womens
  329. Ob/Gyn
  330. Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  331. 12 Person Jury
  332. By Mani Balu Subra
  333. By South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  334. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  335. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  336. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  337. for Mani Balu Subra
  338. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  339. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  340. Atty WILCOX MARIE L.
  341. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  342. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  343. for Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  344. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  345. for South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.
  346. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  347. for Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  348. Atty TRULOCK BRIAN D
  349. for Mani Balu Subra
  350. Defendants Balu Subra Mani, M.D. and South
  351. Atlanta Radiology Associates, P.C.s Answer to
  352. Plaintiffs Complaint
  353. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE JESHENNA JAMILL WATKINS MD
  354. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE SOUTH ATLANTA RADIOLOGY
  355. ASSOCIATES P.C.
  356. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE PREMIER WOMENS OB.GYN LLC
  357. AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE BALU MANI MD
  358. PERSONAL, Watkins Jeshenna Jamill
  359. CORPORATION, Premier Women OB/GYN LLC
  360. PERSONAL, Mani Balu Subra
  361. CORPORATION, South Atlanta Radiology Associates, P
  362. 6 Person Jury
  363. By Charles Danier Jno
  364. By Charles Joel Jno
  365. Receipt# 202203591 issued
  366. PLAINTIFFS REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT
  367. SOUTH ATLANTA RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.C.
  368. PLAINTIFFS REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT
  369. PRMIER WOMENS OB/GYN, LLC
  370. PLAINTIFFS REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT
  371. JESHENNA JAMILL WATKINS, MD
  372. PLAINTIFFS REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO DEFENDANT
  373. BALU SUBRA MANI, MD
  374. PLAINTIFFS FIRST CONTINUING INTERROGATORIES,
  375. REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, AND NOTICE
  376. TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANT SOUTH ATLANTA RADIOLOGY
  377. ASSOCIATES, P.C.
  378. PLAINTIFFS FIRST CONTINUING INTERROGATORIES,
  379. REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, AND NOTICE
  380. TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANT PREMIER WOMENS OB/GYN, LLC
  381. PLAINTIFFS FIRST CONTINUING INTERROGATORIES,
  382. REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, AND NOTICE
  383. TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANT JESHENNA JAMILL WATKINS,
  384. MD
  385. PLAINTIFFS FIRST CONTINUING INTERROGATORIES,
  386. REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, AND NOTICE
  387. TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANT BALU SUBRA MANI, MD
  388. Summons
  389. Affidavit of Martha H. Garrison, M.D.
  390. Affidavit of Dawn Robinson, MD, FACOG
  391. COMPLAINT FOR MEDICAL MALPRACTICE AND DEMAND FOR
  392. A TRIAL BY JURY
  393. Case Initiation Form

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase