Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Sussex County

Court

Sussex County

Delaware

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-06-01
Status CSO - CASE SCHEDULING ORDER
Type C 1 Medical Malpractice
Docket 263 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Smith Jr., William R.
Defendant Bayhealth Medical Center, Inc.
Photo of Hon. Robinson Jr Robert H

Judge

Hon. Robinson Jr Robert H

Sussex County (DE)

Delaware

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. INIT FILING MALPRACTICE
  2. INITIAL COMPLAINT
  3. INTERROGATORIES
  4. REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION (1ST)
  5. LETTER
  6. WRIT ISSUED
  7. WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
  8. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  9. ANSWER
  10. LETTER
  11. MOTION
  12. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  13. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  14. NOTICE SRV OF RESPONSE
  15. ORDER
  16. LAST RESPONSIVE PLEADING
  17. LETTER
  18. MOTION
  19. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  20. NOTICE OF HEARING
  21. RESPONSE
  22. STIPULATION
  23. SUBPOENA - PROOF OF SERVICE
  24. LETTER
  25. ORDER
  26. EVENT CONTINUED / RESCHEDULED
  27. LETTER
  28. LETTER
  29. LETTER
  30. LETTER
  31. EVENT CONTINUED / RESCHEDULED
  32. MOTION GRANTED
  33. JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
  34. ORDER
  35. INIT FILING 3rd PRTY COMP
  36. PRAECIPE FILED
  37. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  38. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  39. WRIT ISSUED
  40. WRIT ISSUED
  41. LONG ARM SERVICE ISSUED
  42. WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
  43. WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
  44. WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
  45. STIPULATION
  46. ORDER
  47. ANSWER & COUNTERCLAIM
  48. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  49. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  50. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  51. STATUS REPORT
  52. ANSWER & COUNTERCLAIM
  53. NOTICE
  54. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  55. ANSWER & CROSSCLAIM
  56. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  57. ORDER
  58. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE
  59. NOTICE
  60. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  61. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE
  62. ANSWER & CROSSCLAIM
  63. LETTER
  64. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  65. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  66. ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM
  67. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  68. REFERRED TO CASE SCHEDULING
  69. LETTER
  70. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  71. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  72. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  73. ORDER
  74. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  75. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  76. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  77. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  78. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HELD
  79. SCHEDULING ORDER
  80. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  81. VACATION OF DEPOSITION
  82. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE
  83. CERTIFICATION
  84. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE
  85. CERTIFICATION
  86. E-MAIL FILED
  87. LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
  88. ORDER
  89. OFFICE CONFERENCE HELD
  90. JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
  91. LETTER
  92. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  93. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  94. MOTION TO COMPEL
  95. EXHIBITS
  96. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  97. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  98. RSP MOTION TO COMPEL
  99. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  100. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE DATE DOCKETED: APRIL 13, 2024 JOHN E. ELZUFON, ESQUIRE, OF ELZUFON AUSTIN & MONDELL, P.A., HEREBY ENTERS HIS APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL ON BEHALF OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72737824
  101. STATUS REPORT
  102. STATUS REPORT DATE DOCKETED: APRIL 17, 2024 LETTER FROM PHILLIP M. CASALE, ESQUIRE, TO JUDGE ROBINSON. RE: PROVIDING A STATUS ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANT/THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF, BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC., DUE TO PLAINTIFFS' REQUEST FOR THE COURT TO ISSUE A TRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER. NOT OPPOSED BUT IT MAINTAINS THAT IT IS PREMATURE BECAUSE NOT ALL THE THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS HAVE RETAINED COUNSEL NOR FILED RESPONSIVE PLEADINGS. ATTACHMENTS - E-MAILS ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72750193
  103. ANSWER & COUNTERCLAIM
  104. ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: APRIL 23, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT KENT DIAGNOSTIC RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A.'S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT WITH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES; COUNTERCLAIM AGAINST THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF FOR CONTRIBUTION AND/OR INDEMNITY; CROSSCLAIMS AGAINST THIRD-PARTY CO-DEFENDANTS FOR CONTRIBUTION AND/OR INDEMNITY; AND DENIAL TO ALL CROSS-CLAIMS (LORENZA A. WOLHAR) CIVIL CASE INFORMATION STATEMENT ANSWERS TO FORM 30 INTERROGATORIES ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72798296
  105. NOTICE
  106. NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF COUNSEL DATE DOCKETED: APRIL 24, 2024 MARIA R. GRANAUDO, ESQUIRE HEREBY WITHDRAWS HER APPEARANCE AS COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT, REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72805747
  107. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  108. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: APRIL 24, 2024 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT KENT DIAGNOSTIC RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A.'S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT WITH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES, COUNTERCLAIM, CROSSCLAIMS, AND ANSWERS TO FORM 30 INTERROGATORIES, UPON THIRD-PARTY CO-DEFENDANT, APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC., VIA REGULAR AND CERTIFIED MAIL. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72805795
  109. ANSWER & CROSSCLAIM
  110. ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 1, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.S, ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT WITH AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES; CROSSCLAIMS FOR CONTRIBUTION/INDEMNIFICATION AGAINST THIRD-PARTY CO-DEFENDANTS; ANSWER TO ALL CROSSCLAIMS AND COUNTERCLAIMS; AND COUNTERCLAIMS FOR CONTRIBUTION AND/OR INDEMNIFICATION (DAWN C. DOHERTLY) ANSWERS TO FORM 30 INTERROGATORIES CIVIL CASE INFORMATION STATEMENT CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: GGM TRANSACTION ID: 72864033
  111. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  112. MOTION FOR REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT DATE DOCKETED: MAY 1, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DE, INC.'S MOTION FOR IN CAMERA REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT (DAWN C. DOHERTY) NOTICE OF MOTION TO BE HEARD AT THE COURT'S CONVENIENCE PROPOSED ORDER CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MMT TRANSACTION ID: 72864258
  113. ORDER
  114. ORDER DATE DOCKETED: MAY 7, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. ON MAY 6, 2024. THE COURT HAVING CONSIDERED THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S MOTION FOR IN CAMERA REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVITS OF MERIT; IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THIS COURT SHALL DETERMINE IN CAMERA WHETHER THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT COMPLIES WITH THE REQUISITES OF 18 DEL. C. §6853(A)(1) AND (C). ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 72901909
  115. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE
  116. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE DATE DOCKETED: MAY 10, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF CHRISTIAN M. SCHEUERMAN, ESQUIRE (DAWN C. DOHERTY) CERTIFICATION OF CHRISTIAN M. SCHEUERMAN, ESQUIRE PROPOSED ORDER CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73011648
  117. NOTICE
  118. NOTICE DATE DOCKETED: MAY 11, 2024 NOTICE OF MOTION OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF CHRISTIAN M. SCHEUERMAN, ESQUIRE TO BE HEARD AT THE COURT'S CONVENIENCE ACCEPTED BY: MMT TRANSACTION ID: 73013070
  119. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  120. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: MAY 16, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, DIRECTED TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73056324
  121. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE
  122. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE DATE DOCKETED: MAY 16, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. ON MAY 13, 2024. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF CHRISTIAN M. SCHEUERMAN, ESQUIRE, IS GRANTED. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73063304
  123. ANSWER & CROSSCLAIM
  124. ANSWER & CROSSCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 21, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC'S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT WITH ADDITIONAL DEFENSES, RESERVATION OF RIGHTS, CROSS-CLAIMS FOR CONTRIBUTION AND INDEMNIFICATION AGAINST THIRD-PARTY CO-DEFENDANTS AND DEFENDANT BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC., AND ANSWERS TO ALL PRESENT AND FUTURE CROSS-CLAIMS (JOHN A. ELZUFON) ANSWERS TO FORM 30 INTERROGATORIES (JOHN A. ELZUFON) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: AT TRANSACTION ID: 73093820
  125. LETTER
  126. LETTER DATE DOCKETED: MAY 21, 2024 LETTER FROM JOSHUA MEYEROFF, ESQUIRE, TO JUDGE ROBINSON. RE: REQUESTING ON BEHALF OF THE PLAINTIFFS FOR A TRIAL SCHEDULING CONFERENCE. ACCEPTED BY: AT TRANSACTION ID: 73103698
  127. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  128. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 24, 2024 THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF, BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC.S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, KENT DIAGNOSTICS RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A.S COUNTERCLAIMS AND CROSSCLAIMS (PHILLIP M. CASALE) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73201562
  129. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  130. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 24, 2024 THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF, BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC.S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.S COUNTERCLAIM AND CROSSCLAIMS (PHILLIP M. CASALE) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73201562
  131. ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM
  132. ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 24, 2024 THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF, BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC.S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, REAL RADIOLOGY, LLCS CROSSCLAIMS (PHILLIP M. CASALE) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73201562
  133. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
  134. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: MAY 24, 2024 THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF, BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER, INC.S ANSWER TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O.S COUNTERCLAIMS AND CROSSCLAIMS (PHILLIP M. CASALE) CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73201562
  135. REFERRED TO CASE SCHEDULING
  136. REFERRED TO CASE SCHEDULING - MS (ANSWERS TO COMPLAINT, ANSWERS TO THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT, AND ANSWERS TO ALL CROSSCLAIMS & COUNTERCLAIMS HAVE BEEN FILED BY ALL PARTIES) DATE DOCKETED: MAY 23, 2024
  137. LETTER
  138. LETTER DATE DOCKETED: JUNE 4, 2024 LETTER FROM MARGARET THATCHER TO COUNSEL. RE: A SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HAS BEEN SCHEDULED FOR MONDAY, JULY 29, 2024, AT 9:30 A.M. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73295019 (6/5 - BRIGITTE FROM MORRIS JAMES WAS GIVEN THE 800 TELECONF. NUMBER AND PARTICIPANT PASSCODE AND STATED SHE WOULD FORWARD TO ALL COUNSEL)
  139. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  140. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE DATE DOCKETED: JUNE 11, 2024 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FOR NATHAN V. GIN, ESQ. AS CO-COUNSEL FOR REAL RADIOLOGI, LLC CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: GGM TRANSACTION ID: 73340881
  141. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
  142. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DATE DOCKETED: JUNE 21, 2024 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O., SCHEDULED FOR WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 14, 2024, AT 10:00 A.M. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73426685
  143. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  144. MOTION FOR REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT DATE DOCKETED: JUNE 25, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O'S MOTION FOR REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT PURSUANT TO 18 DEL. C. 6853 (A)(1) AND (C) (EMILY K. SILVERSTEIN) PROPOSED ORDER NOTICE OF MOTION TO BE HEARD AT THE CONVENIENCE OF THE COURT CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73463053
  145. ORDER
  146. ORDER DATE DOCKETED: JUNE 26, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. ON JUNE 25, 2024. HAVING CONSIDERED THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O.'S MOTION FOR REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT PURSUANT TO 18 DEL. C. §6853(A)(1) AND (C); IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THIS COURT WILL REVIEW THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT IN CAMERA AND DETERMINE WHETHER IT COMPLIES WITH THE STATUE IN EACH OF THE SPECIFIC PARTS AS LISTED IN THE MOTION. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73479568
  147. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
  148. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE DATE DOCKETED: JULY 3, 2024 DEBORAH A. CUOCO, ESQUIRE, OF BALAGUER MILEWSKI & IMBROGNO, HEREBY ENTERS HER APPEARANCE AS CO-COUNSEL ON BEHALF OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73529341
  149. MOTION REVIEW AFFIDAVIT MERIT
  150. MOTION FOR REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT DATE DOCKETED: JULY 13, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC'S MOTION FOR REVIEW OF THE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT PURSUANT TO 18 DEL. C. 6853 (A)(1) AND (C) (NATHAN V. GIN) NOTICE OF MOTION TO BE HEARD AT THE CONVENIENCE OF THE COURT CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73633126
  151. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  152. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: JULY 20, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O.'S: REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION, SOCIAL MEDIA INTERROGATORIES AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION, AND MEDICARE/MEDICAID INTERROGATORIES AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, DIRECTED TO THE PLAINTIFFS; INTERROGATORIES DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFF JENNIFER J. SMITH; AND FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFFS BROOKLYNN SMITH, WILLIAM R. SMITH, JR., DYLAN R. SMITH, ALEXA A. SMITH, JOSEPH L. SMITH, AND TYLER W. SMITH. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73728317
  153. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  154. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: JULY 30, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS DIRECTED TO THE PLAINTIFFS, AND MEDICAL AUTHORIZATIONS. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73815549
  155. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HELD
  156. SCHEDULING CONFERENCE HELD ON 7-29-24 - MMT COMMISSIONER ALICIA B. HOWARD PRESIDING - DATES FOR THE SCHEDULING ORDER WERE ESTABLISHED DATE DOCKETED: JULY 29, 2024
  157. SCHEDULING ORDER
  158. SCHEDULING ORDER DATE DOCKETED: JULY 30, 2024 PRETRIAL SCHEDULING ORDER SIGNED BY COMMISSIONER ALICIA B. HOWARD ON JULY 29, 2024. IT IS SO ORDERED THAT: - MEDIATION SHALL TAKE PLACE ON OR BEFORE 6-30-2026 - MOTIONS TO AMEND THE PLEADINGS SHALL BE FILED BY 12-31-2024 - FACT DISCOVERY SHALL BE COMPLETED BY 6-30-2025 - PLAINTIFFS SHALL IDENTIFY EXPERT WITNESSES BY 9-30-2025 - DEFENDANTS SHALL IDENTIFY EXPERT WITNESSES BY 1-30-2026 - PLAINTIFFS SHALL IDENTIFY REBUTTAL EXPERT WITNESSES BY 4-30-2026 - DEPOSITIONS OF PLAINTIFFS' EXPERTS SHALL BE COMPLETED BY 12-05-2025 - DEPOSITIONS OF DEFENDANT'S EXPERTS SHALL BE COMPLETED BY 3-31-2026 - EXPERT DISCOVERY SHALL BE COMPLETED BY 6-30-2026 - DAUBERT, IN LIMINE & DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS WITH OPENING BRIEFS SHALL BE FILED BY 7-31-2026 - ANSWERING BRIEFS SHALL BE FILED BY 8-31-2026 - REPLY BRIEFS SHALL BE FILED BY 9-30-2026 - PRETRIAL STIPULATION IS DUE BY NOON ON 3-10-2027 (TO INCLUDE ANY NON-ROUTINE VOIR DIRE, JURY INSTRUCTIONS, AND SPECIAL VERDICT FORMS) - PLAINTIFFS' ($150.00) TRIAL FEE IS DUE BY 3-17-2027 - PRETRIAL CONFERENCE IS SCHEDULED FOR 3-17-2027 AT 9:00 A.M., VIA ZOOM - ALL MARKED EXHIBITS SHALL BE FILED TEN (10) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL - MEDIA EQUIPMENT MUST BE TESTED NO LATER THAN SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL - JURY INSTRUCTIONS SHALL BE SUBMITTED AT LEAST TEN (10) DAYS PRIOR TO TRIAL - FIFTEEN-DAY JURY TRIAL IS SCHEDULED TO COMMENCE ON 4-19-2027 AT 9:30 A.M. THROUGH 4-22-2027; RESUMMING 4-26-2027 THROUGH 4-29-2027; RESUMMING 5-03-2027 THROUGH 5-06-2027; RESUMMING 5-10-2027 THROUGH 5-12-2027 ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73831482
  159. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  160. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 1, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O.'S OBJECTIONS AND ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS, WITH RESPONSIVE DOCUMENT ATTEBERY 00001 - ATTEBERY 00004. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73866965
  161. VACATION OF DEPOSITION
  162. VACATION OF DEPOSITION DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 3, 2024 PLAINTIFFS NOTICE TO VACATE THE DEPOSITION OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O., PREVIOUSLY SCHEDULED FOR WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 14, 2024. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73898231
  163. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE
  164. MOTION FOR PRO HAC VICE DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 10, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF ASHLEY S. COHEN, ESQUIRE (DAWN C. DOHERTY) NOTICE OF MOTION TO BE HEARD AT THE CONVENIENCE OF THE COURT PROPOSED ORDER CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73995523
  165. CERTIFICATION
  166. CERTIFICATION DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 10, 2024 CERTIFICATION OF ASHLEY S. COHEN, ESQUIRE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 73999761
  167. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE
  168. ORDER - PRO HAC VICE DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 13, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. ON AUGUST 9, 2024. IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT THE MOTION FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF ASHLEY S. COHEN, ESQUIRE, ON BEHALF OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC., IS GRANTED. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74016456
  169. CERTIFICATION
  170. CERTIFICATION DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 13, 2024 CERTIFICATION OF ASHLEY S. COHEN, ESQUIRE, SIGNED JULY 30, 2024 (DAWN C. DOHERTY) ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74018457
  171. E-MAIL FILED
  172. E-MAIL FILED DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 13, 2024 E-MAIL FROM MARCO SUAREZ, JUDICIAL CASE MANAGER, TO ALL COUNSEL. RE: CONFIRMING THAT A CONFERENCE ON THE PENDING MOTIONS FOR REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, IS SCHEDULED TO BE HELD ON THURSDAY, AUGUST 29, 2024, AT 9:30 A.M., VIA ZOOM CONFERENCING. (ZOOM MEETING LOGIN INFORMATION & LINK PROVIDED) ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74022393
  173. LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
  174. LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 29, 2024 LETTER FROM EMILY K. SILVERSTEIN, ESQUIRE, TO JUDGE ROBINSON. RE: REQUESTING PERMISSION FOR LAW CLERK TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR AUGUST 29, 2024, ON BEHALF OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, M. LISA ATTEBERY D.O., AS PART OF HIS CLERKSHIP REQUIREMENTS. ALL PARTIES WERE NOTIFIED AND DO NOT OPPOSE THIS REQUEST. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74173874
  175. ORDER
  176. ORDER - COURT'S RESPONSE DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 29, 2024 EMILY K. SILVERSTEIN, ESQUIRE'S REQUEST THAT HER LAW CLERK BE PERMITTED TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR AUGUST 29, 2024, ON BEHALF OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, M. LISA ATTEBERY D.O., AS PART OF CLERKSHIP REQUIREMENTS; APPROVED BY JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. ON AUGUST 28, 2024. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74179944
  177. OFFICE CONFERENCE HELD
  178. OFFICE CONFERENCE HELD AUGUST 29, 2024 - MS JUDGE ROBERT H. ROBINSON, JR. PRESIDING. JOSHUA H. MEYEROFF, ESQ. PRESENT FOR THE PLAINTIFFS (VIA ZOOM); PHILLIP M. CASALE, ESQ. PRESENT FOR DEFENDANT BAYHEALTH MEDICAL CENTER (VIA ZOOM); BRADLEY J. GOEWERT, ESQ. PRESENT FOR TPD KENT DIAGNOSTIC READIOLOGY (VIA ZOOM); DAWN C. DOHERTY, ESQ. PRESENT FOR TPD APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP (VIA ZOOM); NATHAN V. GIN, ESQ. PRESENT FOR TPD REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC (VIA ZOOM); EMILY K. SILVERSTEIN, ESQ. PRESENT FOR TPD M. LISSA ATTEBERY, D.O. (VIA ZOOM). - THE PARTIES STATED THEIR POSITIONS AS TO WHETHER THE FILED AFFIDAVITS OF MERIT ARE SUFFICIENT OR NOT TO APPLY TO ALL THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS. - PENDING MOTIONS FOR REVIEW OF AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT TAKEN UNDER ADVISEMENT; - DECISION RESERVED BY THE COURT. DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 29, 2024
  179. JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
  180. JUDICIAL ACTION FORM DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 30, 2024 JUDICIAL ACTION FORM FROM REMOTE OFFICE CONFERENCE HELD AUGUST 29, 2024. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74189125
  181. LETTER
  182. LETTER DATE DOCKETED: AUGUST 30, 2024 LETTER FROM EMILY K. SILVERSTEIN, ESQUIRE, TO JUDGE ROBINSON. RE: PROVIDING INFORMATION FOLLOWING TODAY'S HEARING ON THE AFFIDAVITS OF MERIT. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74192321
  183. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  184. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 17, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' ANSWERS AND RESPONSE TO APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFFS ACCEPTED BY: MMT TRANSACTION ID: 74331280
  185. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  186. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 17, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS' ANSWERS AND RESPONSE TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT M. LISA ATTEBERY, D.O.'S INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS ACCEPTED BY: MMT TRANSACTION ID: 74331280
  187. MOTION TO COMPEL
  188. MOTION TO COMPEL DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 21, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY DIRECTED TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANTS KENT DIAGNOSTIC RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A., APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC. AND REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC (JOSHUA H. MEYEROFF) NOTICE OF MOTION SCHEDULED TO BE HEARD ON FRIDAY, OCTOBER 18, 2024, AT 1:00 P.M. PROPOSED ORDER CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74384728
  189. EXHIBITS
  190. EXHIBITS DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 24, 2024 EXHIBITS A - E (AS TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION TO COMPEL FILED SEPTEMBER 20, 2024) ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74387706
  191. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  192. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 24, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT REAL RADIOLOGY, LLC'S RESPONSE AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST REQUEST FOR INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74563262
  193. NOTICE OF SERVICE
  194. NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 11, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT, KENT DIAGNOSTIC RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A.'S ANSWERS AND RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS. ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74729720
  195. RSP MOTION TO COMPEL
  196. RESPONSE TO MOTION TO COMPEL DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 11, 2024 THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT KENT DIAGNOSTIC RADIOLOGY ASSOCIATES, P.A., RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY (LORENZA A. WOLHAR) PROPOSED ORDER CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74732455
  197. RSP MOTION TO COMPEL
  198. RESPONSE TO MOTION TO COMPEL DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 12, 2024 THIRD-PARTY APOGEE MEDICAL GROUP, DELAWARE, INC.S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY (DAWN C. DOHERTY) PROPOSED ORDER EXHIBITS A - C CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: MS TRANSACTION ID: 74742328

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more