Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of New Mexico Unified

Court

New Mexico Unified

New Mexico

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2021-08-27
Status CLS: JUDGMENT/ DISPOSITION
Type Water Adjudication
Docket 280 entries
Disposition judgment

Parties

Plaintiff City Of Farmington
Defendant D'antonio John
Photo of Hon. Marsh Daylene

Judge

Hon. Marsh Daylene

San Juan County (NM)

New Mexico

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CLS: SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  2. Order Closing Appeal on Granting of Appellees' Motions for Summary Judgment
  3. ORD: SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  4. abandon
  5. ORD: SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  6. regarding standing
  7. AUDIO LOG NOTES
  8. :17:21-03:36:27
  9. ORD: VACATING HEARING
  10. MTN: MOTION
  11. Joint Motion to Vacate Trial Setting and all Pre-trial Deadlines and Reset Trial Setting after February 1, 2024 for any Remaining Issues
  12. NTC: HEARING (MOTION)
  13. ORD: VACATING HEARING
  14. NTC: NOTICE
  15. City of Farmington's Notice of Supplemental Authority
  16. NTC: NOTICE
  17. The City of Farmington's Notice of Errata and Completion of Briefing on COF's MSJ
  18. ORD: SCHEDULING/PRETRIAL ORDER
  19. MTN: MOTION
  20. Joint Proposed Schedule for December 12, 2023 Oral Argument on Motions for Summary Jugment
  21. ORD: SCHEDULING/PRETRIAL ORDER
  22. MTN: MOTION
  23. Joint Motion to Enter Pretrial Deadlines
  24. NTC: HEARING (MOTION)
  25. Motion for Summary Judgment filed June 20, 2023 by Intervenor United States of America, Defendant Appellee State Engineer, and Plaintiff Appellant City of Farmington
  26. REQUEST FOR HEARING/ SETTING
  27. Request for Hearing re City of Farmington's Motion for Partial Summary Judgement
  28. NTC: COMPLETION OF BRIEFING
  29. NOCB re City of Farmington's Motion for Partial Summary Judgement
  30. REQUEST FOR HEARING/ SETTING
  31. Request For Hearing re City of Farmington's Motion for Summary Judgement
  32. NTC: COMPLETION OF BRIEFING
  33. NOCB Appellant, City of Farmington s Motion for Summary Judgement
  34. NTC: NOTICE
  35. Notice of Errata
  36. NTC: COMPLETION OF BRIEFING
  37. Notice of Completion of Briefing
  38. REPLY
  39. THE NAVAJO NATION S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THE UNITED STATES MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  40. REPLY
  41. Appellant's Reply ISO Motion for Summary Judgment
  42. REPLY
  43. Appellant's Reply ISO Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
  44. REPLY
  45. State Engineer's Reply to Applicant/Appellant's Response to State Engineer's Motion for Summary Judgment
  46. REPLY
  47. Reply in Support of United States' Motion for Summary Judgment
  48. ORD: ORDER GRANTING
  49. STIPULATED ORDER GRANTING JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINES FOR RESPONSES TO DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS
  50. MTN: Motion to Extend Dates in Scheduling Order
  51. Motion to Extend Deadline For Replies to Responses of MSJ's
  52. RESPONSE
  53. RESPONSE
  54. Farmington's Response in Opposition to the State Engineer s Motion for Summary Judgment and Brief in Support
  55. RESPONSE
  56. United States Response in Opposition to the City's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
  57. RESPONSE
  58. United States Response in Opposition to the City's Motion for Summary Judgment (Abandonment)
  59. RESPONSE
  60. NAVAJO NATION S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO THE CITY OF FARMINGTON S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  61. RESPONSE
  62. State Engineer's Response to City of Farmington's Motion for Summary Judgment
  63. ORD: ORDER GRANTING
  64. Stipulated Order Granting Joint Motion to Extend Deadlines for Responses to Dispositive Motions
  65. MTN: MOTION/ PETITION TO EXTEND TIME
  66. Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Dispositive Motion Responses
  67. ORD: ORDER GRANTING
  68. ORDER GRANTING UNOPPOED JOINT MOITON TO VACATE ALL REAMINING PRE-TRIAL DEADLINES
  69. MTN: TO VACATE
  70. Amended Unopposed Joint Motion to Vacate all Remaining Pre-Trial Deadlines
  71. MTN: TO VACATE
  72. Joint Motion to Vacate all remaining pre-trial deadlines
  73. ORD: ORDER GRANTING
  74. STIPULATED ORDER GRANTING JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINES FOR RESPONSES AND REPLIES TO DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS
  75. MTN: MOTION/ PETITION TO EXTEND TIME
  76. Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Responses and Replies to Dispositive Motions
  77. NTC: NOTICE
  78. Defendant Navajo Nation's Joinder in the United States' Motion for Summary Judgment
  79. MTN: FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  80. APPELLANT, THE CITY OF FARMINGTON S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, DEPARTMENT OF INTERIOR
  81. MTN: FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  82. APPELLANT, THE CITY OF FARMINGTON S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  83. BRIEF
  84. Brief in Support of State Engineer's Motion for Summary Judgment
  85. MTN: FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  86. State Engineer's Motion for Summary Judgment
  87. MTN: FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
  88. United States Motion for Summary Judgment with attachments
  89. ORD: ORDER GRANTING
  90. Stipulated Order Granting Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Filing Dispositive Motions
  91. MTN: MOTION/ PETITION TO EXTEND TIME
  92. JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINE FOR DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS
  93. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  94. Entry of Appearance
  95. ORD: STIPULATED
  96. Stipulated Order Granting Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Filing Dispositive Motions
  97. MTN: Motion to Extend Dates in Scheduling Order
  98. Joint Motion to Extend Deadline for Dispositive Motions
  99. WITNESS LIST
  100. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S THIRD AMENDED FACT WITNESS LIST
  101. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  102. Applicant/Appellate City of Farmington's Amended Notice of Deposition Duces Tecum of Bill Enenbach
  103. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  104. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF BILL ENENBACH
  105. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  106. Certificate of Service (Second Supplemental Response to City of Farmington's Interrogatories and Requests for Production)
  107. AMENDED NOTICE
  108. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF BILL DUEMLING
  109. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  110. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF BILL DUEMLING
  111. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  112. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF JOHN LEEPER
  113. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  114. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF IAN WILSON
  115. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  116. Certificate of Service
  117. WITHDRAWAL/ ENTRY/ SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
  118. Notice of Substitution of Counsel
  119. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  120. Notice of Deposition of Mustafa Chudnoff
  121. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  122. Notice of Deposition of Andrew D. Sova
  123. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  124. Notice of Deposition of Paul Gurule
  125. WITNESS LIST
  126. APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S SECOND AMENDED FACT WITNESS LIST
  127. NTC: HEARING (NON JURY TRIAL)
  128. AUDIO LOG NOTES
  129. :32:21-10:36:20
  130. ORD: ORDER
  131. Stipulated Order
  132. MTN: Motion to Extend Dates in Scheduling Order
  133. JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINES AND TO ALLOW THE PARTIES TO ATTEND THE SCHEDULING CONFERENCE REMOTELY
  134. NTC: HEARING (SCHEDULING CONFERENCE)
  135. REQUEST FOR HEARING/ SETTING
  136. REQUEST FOR RULE 1-016 NMRA SCHEDULING CONFERENCE
  137. ORD: ORDER
  138. order extending discovery deadlines
  139. MTN: Motion to Extend Dates in Scheduling Order
  140. OINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINES AND TO VACATE PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
  141. NTC: HEARING (PRETRIAL CONFERENCE)
  142. AMENDED NOTICE OF Pretrial Conference
  143. NTC: NOTICE
  144. Navajo Nation's Notice of Withdrawal of Attorney of Record
  145. ORD: EXTENDING TIME
  146. MTN: Motion to Extend Dates in Scheduling Order
  147. JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND DEADLINES AND TO RESCHEDULE TRIAL
  148. WITNESS LIST
  149. State Engineers Expert Witness Disclosure
  150. NTC: NOTICE
  151. Appellee Navajo Nation's Notice of Service
  152. DISCLOSURE
  153. Protestant/Appellee Navajo Nation's Expert Witness Disclosure
  154. NTC: NOTICE
  155. United States Notice of Expert Disclosure and Service of United States' Discovery Requests
  156. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  157. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE RE APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION TO APPELLEES THE NAVAJO NATION AND THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
  158. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  159. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE RE APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION TO APPELLEE JOHN D ANTONIO, NEW MEXICO STATE ENGINEER
  160. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  161. State Engineer Entry of Appearance
  162. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  163. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE RE OBJECTIONS AND SUPPLEMENTAL ANSWERS TO APPELLEE NAVAJO NATION S AND UNITED STATES (FIRST) JOINT DISCOVERY REQUESTS TO APPLICANT/APPELLANT CITY OF FARMINGTON
  164. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  165. Amended Notice of Deposition of David McWilliams, Peggy McWilliams, and Stephanie Roady
  166. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  167. NTC: OF DEPOSITION
  168. Notice of Deposition of David McWilliams, Peggy McWilliams, Paul Gurule and Stephanie Roady
  169. WITNESS/ EXHIBIT DISCLOSURE
  170. APPLICANT/APPELLANT S EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE
  171. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  172. Certificate of Service re Objections and Answers to Appellee Navajo Nation's and United States' [First] Joint Discovery Requests to Appellant City of Farmington
  173. ORD: TO INTERVENE
  174. NTC: NOTICE
  175. Notice of Service of first Joint Discovery Request to City of Farmington
  176. WITNESS LIST
  177. Joint Lay Witnesses Disclosure
  178. NTC: COMPLETION OF BRIEFING
  179. Joint Notice that Briefing is Complete
  180. WITNESS LIST
  181. Applicant/Appellant's Amended Fact Witness List
  182. WITNESS LIST
  183. Applicant/Appellant's Fact Witness List
  184. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  185. Protestant/Appellee Navajo Nation's Entry of Appearance
  186. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  187. Protestant/Appellee Navajo Nation's Entry of Appearance
  188. REPLY
  189. NN Reply in Support of U.S. Motion to Intervene
  190. NTC: NOTICE
  191. Notice of Stipulation to a Mediator
  192. REPLY
  193. Reply in Support of United States Motion to Intervene
  194. RESPONSE
  195. Response in Opposition to the U.S. Dept. of Interior's Mtn. to Intervene
  196. NTC: CHANGE OF INFORMATION
  197. Notice of Change of Firm Name
  198. ORD: SCHEDULING/PRETRIAL ORDER
  199. WITHDRAWAL/ ENTRY/ SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
  200. Withdrawal of Counsel
  201. MTN: TO INTERVENE
  202. United States Motion to Intervene
  203. AUDIO LOG NOTES
  204. :03:32-11:13:10 TRIAL AND FPTC SET
  205. NTC: HEARING (NON JURY TRIAL)
  206. NTC: HEARING (PRETRIAL CONFERENCE)
  207. NTC: NOTICE
  208. Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel for the Navajo Nation
  209. NTC: HEARING (SCHEDULING CONFERENCE)
  210. REQUEST FOR HEARING/ SETTING
  211. Request for Rule 1-016 NMRA Scheduling Conference
  212. ADDENDUM
  213. Attachment 6; Addendum 12; Bates No. 000798-000847
  214. ADDENDUM
  215. Attachment 6; Addendum 11: Bates No. 000783-000797
  216. ADDENDUM
  217. Attachment 6; Addendum 9; Bates No. 000753-000767
  218. ADDENDUM
  219. Attachment 6; Addendum 4; Bates No. 000648-000667
  220. ADDENDUM
  221. Attachment 6; Addendum 10; Bates No. 000768-000782
  222. ADDENDUM
  223. Attachment 6; Addendum 8; Bates No. 000738-000752
  224. ADDENDUM
  225. Attachment 6; Addendum 7; Bates No. 000723-000737
  226. ADDENDUM
  227. Attachment 6; Addendum 6; Bates No. 000698-000722
  228. ADDENDUM
  229. Attachment 6; Addendum 5; Bates No. 000668-000697
  230. ADDENDUM
  231. Attachment 6; Addendum 3; Bates No. 000628-000647
  232. ADDENDUM
  233. Attachment 6; Addendum 2; Bates No. 000613-000627
  234. ADDENDUM
  235. Attachment 3; Addendum 3; Bates No. 000300-000399
  236. ADDENDUM
  237. Attachment 3; Addendum 2; Bates No. 000200-000299
  238. ADDENDUM
  239. Attachment 3; Addendum 5; Bates No. 000500-000538
  240. ADDENDUM
  241. Attachment 3; Addendum 4; Bates No. 000400-000499
  242. ADDENDUM
  243. Attachment 6; Exhibits; Bates No. 000522-000586
  244. ADDENDUM
  245. Attachment 5; Link to Video Recording
  246. ADDENDUM
  247. Attachment 4; Notice of Appeal; Bates No. 000539-000551
  248. ADDENDUM
  249. Attachment 6; Addendum 1; Bates No. 000587-000612
  250. ADDENDUM
  251. Attachment 3; Addendum 1; Bates Number 000100-000199
  252. ADDENDUM
  253. Attachment 3; Record of Administrative Proceeding; Bates Number 000001-000099
  254. ADDENDUM
  255. Attachment 1
  256. ADDENDUM
  257. Attachment 2
  258. NTC: NOTICE
  259. Notice of Filing of Administrative Record
  260. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  261. Protestant/Appellee Navajo Nation's Entry of Appearance
  262. SUMMONS RETURN
  263. Summons Return - D'Antonio
  264. ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
  265. NTC: OF INTENT
  266. Protestant/Appellee Navajo Nation's Entry of Appearance and Notice of Intent to Participate in Appeal
  267. RETURN OF SERVICE
  268. Return of Service Summons Water Rights
  269. RETURN OF SERVICE
  270. Return of Service Summons Navajo Nation
  271. RETURN OF SERVICE
  272. Return of Service Summons H. Balderas
  273. SUMMONS ISSUED
  274. Water Rights Division Office of the State Engineer
  275. SUMMONS ISSUED
  276. The Navajo Nation C/O Stanley Pollack
  277. SUMMONS ISSUED
  278. Hector Balderas
  280. OPN: ADMINISTRATIVE APPEAL

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more