Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Osceola County

Court

Osceola County

Florida

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-02-28
Status REOPENED
Docket 152 entries

Parties

Plaintiff State Of Florida
Defendant Shultz, David Scott Jr
Photo of Hon. Wooten Wayne

Judge

Hon. Wooten Wayne

Osceola County (FL)

Florida

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CASE FILED 02/28/2024 CASE NUMBER 2024 CF 000625
  2. DESIGNATION TO COURT REPORTER
  3. SUPPLEMENTAL DIRECTIONS TO CLERK
  4. DESIGNATION OF OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER OF THE TENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT AS COUNSEL FOR APPELLANT
  5. ELECTRONIC APPEAL FILING CONFIRMATION PAGE(S)
  6. INDEX TO RECORD ON APPEAL
  7. CERTIFICATE OF CLERK
  8. EVIDENCE RETURNED RECEIPT
  9. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 7
  10. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 6
  11. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 5 (COPY OF DVD SENT CERTIFIED MAIL)
  12. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 4 (COPY OF DVD SENT CERTIFIED MAIL)
  13. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 2
  14. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 1 FROM TRIAL ON 7/30/25 (COPY OF DVD SENT CERTIFIED MAIL)
  15. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 2 (COPY OF CD SENT CERTIFIED MAIL)
  16. *CONFIDENTIAL* STATE EXHIBIT 1 FROM JURY TRIAL ON 3/4/25
  17. EVIDENCE CHECK-OUT RECEIPT
  18. ACKNOWLEDGMENT OF NEW CASE AND ORDER FROM THE 6DCA
  19. ELECTRONIC APPEAL FILING CONFIRMATION PAGE(S)
  20. TRANSCRIPTS
  21. ORDER FOR TRANSCRIPTION OF PROCEEDINGS
  22. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
  23. STATEMENT OF JUDICIAL ACTS TO BE REVIEWED
  24. DESIGNATION TO COURT REPORTER
  25. DIRECTIONS TO CLERK
  26. MOTION FOR TRANSCRIPTION OF PROCEEDINGS
  27. NOTICE OF APPEAL TO CIRCUIT COURT
  28. CERTIFICATE OF BOND DISCHARGE
  29. EXHIBITS ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
  30. SENTENCING GUIDELINES SCORESHEET
  31. CASE CLOSED
  32. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER JURY TRIAL DAY TWO OF BIFORCATED COUNT 2 ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE STATE: A. RODRIGUEZ, P. LEWIS ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE DEFENSE: T. CARABALLO, J. NADAL DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL JURY RETIRED TO DELIBERATE VERDICT AS TO COUNT 2: GUILTY DEFENDANT REMANDED TO SERVE SENTENCE
  33. CREDIT FOR TIME SERVED WORSHEET
  34. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
  35. VERDICT: GUILTY
  36. APPLICATION FOR INDIGENCY STATUS - FOR APPEAL PURPOSES ONLY
  37. FINGERPRINTS CONCERNING ABOVE-NAMED DEFENDANT
  38. FELONY SENTENCE ORDER
  39. JURY QUESTIONS
  40. EVIDENCE CHECK-OUT RECEIPT
  41. ADD ON SET FOR 07/31/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  42. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER JURY TRIAL DAY ONE OF BIFORCATED COUNT 2 ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE STATE: A. RODRIGUEZ, P. LEWIS ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE DEFENSE: T. CARABALLO, J. NADAL DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL STATES FINAL OFFER PLACED ON THE RECORD AND REJECTED BY THE DEFENDANT DEFENDANT PRO SE MOTIONS TO DISMISS STRICKEN FOR REASONS PLACED ON THE RECORD JURY PANEL SELECTED, SEATED, AND SWORN SWORN AND TESTIFIED FOR THE STATE: COLLIN DUNN SARAH THOMPSON TAYLOR KEEGAN LIZELLE OSORIO SWORN AND TESTIFIED FOR THE DEFENSE: DAVID SCOTT SHULTZ JR. STATES EXHIBIT #1-7 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE STATE RESTS DEFENSE MOVES FORWARD WITH A MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF AQUITTAL -- MOTION DENIED -- DEFENSE RESTS DEFENSE RENEWS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF AQUITTAL -- MOTION DENIED -- TRIAL TO CONTINUE TOMORROW
  43. CRIMINAL COURT NOTES JURY TRIAL DAY _1_ ATTORNEY(S) PRESENT FOR THE STATE: A. RODRIGUEZ, P. LEWIS ATTORNEY(S) PRESENT FOR THE DEFENSE: T. CARABALLO, J. NADAL DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL STATES FINAL OFFER PLACED ON THE RECORD AND REJECTED BY THE DEFENDANT DEFENDANT PRO SE MOTIONS TO DISMISS STRICKEN FOR REASONS PLACED ON THE RECORD JURY PANEL SELECTED, SEATED AND SWORN WITNESSES SWORN AND TESTIFIED: STATE - COLLIN DUNN, SARAH THOMPSON, TAYLOR KEEGAN, LIZELLE OSORIO DEFENSE - DAVID SCOTT SHULTZ JR. EVIDENCE ENTERED: STATE - EXHIBITS #1-7 STATE RESTS DEFENSE MOVES FORWARD WITH A MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF AQUITTAL - MOTION DENIED - DEFENSE RESTS DEFENSE RENEWS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT OF AQUITTAL - MOTION DENIED - TRIAL TO CONTINUE TOMORROW
  44. NOTICE OF PRIOR CONVICTION & CRIMINAL HISTORY
  45. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 07/30/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  46. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER TRIAL CALL HELD CASE PLACED ON TRIAL STANDBY
  47. MOTION TO DISMISS FOR VIOLATION OF DUE PROCESS RIGHTS
  48. MOTION TO DISMISS FOR VIOLATION OF SPEEDY TRIAL RIGHTS
  49. NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
  50. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER PRETRIAL HELD CASE REMAINS ON TRIAL DOCKET, TRIAL LIST FORTHCOMING
  51. PRO SE MOTION TO DISMISS- COPY SENT TO CHAMBERS
  52. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 07/15/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  53. PRETRIAL SET FOR 07/02/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  54. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER COURT UNABLE TO TRY THE CASE WITHIN THE CURRENT TRIAL PERIOD CASE SET FOR PRETRIAL AND TRIAL
  55. ADD ON SET FOR 06/26/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  56. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 06/25/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  57. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 06/18/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  58. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER TRIAL CALL HELD DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL CASE REMAINS ON THE TRIAL DOCKET CASE PLACED ON TRIAL STANDBY
  59. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER PRETRIAL HELD DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL CASE REMAINS ON THE TRIAL DOCKET, TRIAL LIST FORTHCOMING
  60. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 06/10/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  61. PRETRIAL SET FOR 05/28/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  62. ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO CONTINUE THE COURT, HAVING REVIEWED THE STATE'S MOTION TO CONTINUE, HEREBY GRANTS THE MOTION TO CONTINUE FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS: UNAVAILABILITY OF A WITNESS THE NON-MOVING PARTY OBJECTS CASE RESET FOR PRETRIAL AND TRIAL STATE TO PROVIDE A WRITTEN MOTION
  63. ORDER GRANTING STATES MOTION TO CONTINUE
  64. STATES MOTION TO CONTINUE
  65. NOTICE FOR COURT TO TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE
  66. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 05/13/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  67. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER PRETRIAL HELD DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL CASE REMAINS ON TRIAL DOCKET, TRIAL LIST FORTHCOMING PLEA CUT OFF OF 4/30
  68. NOTICE TO APPEAR
  69. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 05/05/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  70. PRETRIAL SET FOR 04/23/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  71. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER RICHARDSON HEARING HELD DEFENDANTS APPEARANCE WAIVED AS TO THIS HEARING ARGUMENTS MADE BY BOTH PARTIES COURT FINDS AN EXCLUSION OF EVIDENCE BASED ON A DISCOVERY VIOLATION IS NOT APPROPRIATE
  72. NOTICE OF HEARING
  73. ADD ON SET FOR 04/11/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  74. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER JURY TRIAL RESET PARTIES TO COORDINATE RICHARDSON HEARING WITH THE JUDICIAL ASSISTANT
  75. EXHIBITS ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE
  76. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 04/09/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  77. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER TRIAL CALL RESET DUE TO DEFENSE COUNSEL UNAVAILABILITY DEFENDANT PRESENT CASE REMAINS READY FOR TRIAL
  78. NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
  79. NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
  80. NOTICE OF INTENT TO RELY UPON BUSINESS RECORD CERTIFICATION
  81. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER PRETRIAL HELD DEFENDANT PRESENT WITH COUNSEL STATE'S PLEA OFFER PLACED ON THE RECORD CASE REMAINS ON THE TRIAL DOCKET, TRIAL LIST FORTHCOMING
  82. DISCOVERY NOTICE OF DIGITAL EVIDENCE SENT TO DEFENSE
  83. MAIL RETURNED
  84. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  85. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  86. NOTICE TO APPEAR
  87. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 04/01/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  88. PRETRIAL SET FOR 03/19/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  89. VERDICT: COUNT 1
  90. ADD ON SET FOR 03/06/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  91. JURY INSTRUCTIONS
  92. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER JURY TRIAL DAY ONE ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE STATE: L. BALLANCE, S. BARR ATTORNEYS PRESENT FOR THE DEFENSE: E. LOPEZ, J. NADAL COUNT TWO BIFORCATED JURY PANEL SELECTED, SEATED, AND SWORN STATES EXHIBITS #1-3 ENTERED INTO EVIDENCE SWORN AND TESTIFIED FOR THE STATE: COLLIN DUNN JESSICA BARRINGTON DEFENSE MOTION FOR JUDGEMENT OF ACQUITTAL DENIED VERDICT AS TO COUNT ONE: NOT GUILTY TRIAL CALL AS TO COUNT TWO SET
  93. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 03/04/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  94. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER NELSON HEARING HELD DEFENDANT PRESENT DEFENDANT WROTE A LETTER TO THE COURT MOTION DENIED COURT DOES NOT FIND THE DEFENDANT IS RECEIVING INEFFECTIVE COUNSEL
  95. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  96. NOTICE OF HEARING
  97. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 03/04/2025 AT 8:15 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  98. LETTER FROM DEFENDANT
  99. FELONY COURT MINUTES/ORDER PRETRIAL HELD DEFENSE WAS PROVIDED CHARGING DOCUMENTS IN OPEN COURT CASE REMAINS ON THE TRIAL DOCKET TRIAL LIST FORTHCOMING
  100. NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
  101. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF STATE'S SUPPLEMENTAL WITNESS LIST
  102. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  103. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF STATE'S AMENDED WITNESS LIST
  104. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF STATE'S SUPPLEMENTAL WITNESS LIST
  105. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITIONS
  106. WAIVER OF PRESENCE AT PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
  107. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  108. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 02/24/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  109. PRETRIAL SET FOR 02/12/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  110. ORDER GRANTING ORE TENUS MOTION TO CONTINUE THE COURT, HAVING REVIEWED THE DEFENSE'S MOTION TO CONTINUE, HEREBY GRANTS THE MOTION TO CONTINUE FOR THE FOLLOWING REASONS: A. DEFENSE NOT SUFFICIENTLY PREPARED FOR TRIAL THE NON-MOVING PARTY DOES NOT OBJECT TO THE MOTION TO CONTINUE DEFENDANT WAIVES SPEEDY TRIAL CASE RESET FOR PRETRIAL AND TRIAL DEFENSE TO PROVIDE A WRITTEN MOTION
  111. NOTICE OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  112. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF STATE'S SUPPLEMENTAL WITNESS LIST
  113. ORDER ON STATES UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR FINGERPRINT EXEMPLARS
  114. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF SUPPLEMENTAL DISCOVERY
  115. NOTICE OF PROVISION OF WITNESS LIST
  116. STATES UNOPPOSED MOTION FOR FINGERPRINT EXEMPLARS
  117. RESPONSE TO NOTICE OF DISCOVERY
  118. DEFENDANT'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO PARTICIPATE IN DISCOVERY AND DEMAND FOR FAVORABLE AND IMPEACHMENT INFORMATION IN ACCORDANCE WITH BRADY
  119. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 12/03/2024 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  120. PRETRIAL SET FOR 11/20/2024 AT 9:00 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  121. NOTICE SETTING PRETRIAL HEARING AND TRIAL DATE AND UNIFIED PRETRIAL ORDER ARRAIGNMENT HELD PUBLIC DEFENDER REMAINS CASE SET FOR PRETRIAL AND TRIAL PLEA OFFER PLACED ON RECORD
  122. ARRAIGNMENT SCHEDULED. NOTICE SENT
  123. ARRAIGNMENT SET FOR 09/12/2024 AT 8:30 AM IN 4F BEFORE JUDGE: CARSTEN, KEITH
  124. CERTIFICATE OF BOND DISCHARGE
  125. LINE DOCKETED IN ERROR
  126. ENCOMPASSED FROM 2024 CF 002414
  127. INFORMATION
  128. WARRANT RETURNED EXECUTED
  129. SURETY BOND U5-39622504 POSTED $4,000.00
  130. BOND (COPY SURETY)
  131. ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR INDIGENT STATUS PUBLIC DEFENDER APPOINTED
  132. FIRST APPEARANCE HELD. ORDER OF COMMITMENT.
  133. WARRANT ARREST-BOOKING REPORT FILED WANTED PERSONS TABLE ADVICE TO DEFENDANT
  134. WEEKEND INITIAL APPEARANCE SET FOR 08/04/2024 AT 8:00 AM IN WE BEFORE JUDGE: KRAYNICK, MICHAEL S
  135. BOND (COPY SURETY)
  136. DATE OF RELEASE
  137. DATE OF ARREST
  138. CRIMINAL CASE OPENED - ARREST WARRANT FILED MEMORANDUM FILED AFFIDAVIT OF ARREST WARRANT
  139. CASE FILED 07/30/2024 CASE NUMBER 2024 CF 002414
  140. SURETY BOND U5-21756797 POSTED $1,000.00
  141. SURETY BOND U5-21756796 POSTED $2,500.00
  142. BOND (COPY SURETY)
  143. DATE OF RELEASE
  144. WARRANT RETURNED EXECUTED
  145. FIRST APPEARANCE HELD. ORDER OF COMMITMENT.
  146. ORIGINAL APPLICATION FOR INDIGENT STATUS PUBLIC DEFENDER APPOINTED
  147. INITIAL APPEARANCE INFORMATION SHEET
  148. WARRANT ARREST-BOOKING REPORT FILED WANTED PERSONS TABLE ADVICE TO DEFENDANT
  149. INITIAL APPEARANCE SET FOR 03/05/2024 AT 1:00 PM IN 4A BEFORE JUDGE: ARENDAS, CHRISTINE E
  150. DATE OF ARREST
  151. SUPPLEMENTAL REPORT FROM SHERIFF'S OFFICE
  152. CRIMINAL CASE OPENED - ARREST WARRANT FILED AFFIDAVIT OF ARREST WARRANT

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more