Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Missouri Unified County

Court

Missouri Unified County

Missouri

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-04-04
Type Ap Petition For Review
Docket 104 entries

Parties

Plaintiff The Osage Nation|Dobyns, Randal S|Dobyns, Leslie R|Dobyns Family Trust
Defendant Missouri Department Of Natural Resources|Missouri Mining Commission|Midstates Materials, Llc

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. et for Review Filed - Appl Ct Filed in WD87090 On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION
  2. lerk Remark 703 SW3D 238
  4. ase Disp- Opin & Mandate Sent
  6. pinion Reversed & Remanded Associated Entries: 12/17/2024 - Signed Majority Opinion
  7. igned Majority Opinion Associated Entries: 12/17/2024 - Opinion Reversed & Remanded
  9. ase Submitted Scheduled For: 12/05/2024; DIVISION 2; 3; WESTERN DISTRICT CT OF APPEALS
  11. ase Docketed for oral argument on 05-DEC-2024 before Division 2: Ahuja, P.J., Ardini, Jr., and Thomson, JJ. Docket call is at 10:00 a.m.
  13. aper Copy of Document Receivd Appellant's Reply Brief Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION
  15. aper Copy of Document Due One copy of un-redacted bound Appellant's Reply Brief due on or before: 15-OCT-2024
  16. ppellant's Reply Brief Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION
  18. ustained Associated Entries: 09/20/2024 - Motion to Seal +
  20. aper Copy of Document Receivd Respondents Brief and Appendix Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC
  21. aper Copy of Document Receivd Respondents Brief Filed By: TIMOTHY P DUGGAN On Behalf Of: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
  23. aper Copy of Document Due One copy of un-redacted bound Respondent Brief of Missouri Department of Natural Resources due on or before: 27-SEPT-2024
  24. espondent's Brief Filed By: TIMOTHY P DUGGAN On Behalf Of: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
  25. aper Copy of Document Due One copy of un-redacted bound Respondent Brief of Mid-States Materials, LLC due on or before: 27-SEPT-2024
  26. eq for Oral Argument Filed Requested on Respondent Brief Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC
  27. ppendix Filed Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Associated Entries: 09/20/2024 - Respondent's Brief
  28. otion to Seal Respondent Appendix - Mid-States Materials, LLC Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Associated Entries: 09/30/2024 - Sustained
  29. espondent's Brief Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Associated Entries: 09/20/2024 - Appendix Filed
  31. ustained Until 20-SEP-2024 Associated Entries: 08/27/2024 - Mot Ext Time to File Brief +
  33. eq for Oral Argument Filed Joint Filing: Filed By: TIMOTHY P. DUGGAN Associated To: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES, MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY Associated To: THE OSAGE NATION Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER Associated To: RANDAL S. DOBYS, LESLIE R. DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST, Filed By: Justin Jay Johl, Associated To: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC
  34. Sustained Associated Entries: 06/05/2024 - Motion to Seal +
  35. ot Ext Time to File Brief Joint Motion: Filed By: DAVID L. MCCAIN Associated To: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES, Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL Associated To: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Associated Entries: 09/05/2024 - Sustained Until +
  36. ntry of Appearance Filed Filed By: DAVID LEE MCCAIN JR On Behalf Of: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
  37. <td></td><td></td><td></td>
  38. aper Copy of Document Receivd Appellant's Brief and Appendix Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST
  39. <td></td><td></td><td></td>
  40. aper Copy of Document Due 4 Copies of un-redacted Appellant's Brief and Appendix (individually bound) due on or before: 06-AUG-2024
  41. ppendix Filed Appellant's Appendix Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST Associated Entries: 07/30/2024 - Appellant's Brief
  42. ppellant's Brief Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST Associated Entries: 07/30/2024 - Appendix Filed +
  43. Record on Appeal Volume XXXVIII; Volume XXXIX; Volume XL Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  44. n Courts Own Motion Extension of time to file the Appellants Randal S. Dobyns', Leslie R. Dobyns', and Dobyns' Family Trust's Brief DUE: 1-AUG-2024.
  45. ismissal Notice Sent Appellants Randal S. Dobyns', Leslie R. Dobyns', and Dobyns' Family Trust's Brief.
  46. Record on Appeal Volume XXIX; Volume XXX; Volume XXXI Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  47. ustained Associated Entries: 07/08/2024 - Motion to Seal +
  48. Record on Appeal Volume XXII; Volume XXIII; Volume XXIV Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  49. ustained Until 16-JUL-2024 Associated Entries: 07/03/2024 - Mot Ext Time to File Brief
  50. Record on Appeal Volume XVI; Volume XVII; Volume XVIII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  51. aper Copy of Document Receivd Appellant's Brief and Appendix Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION
  52. Record on Appeal Volume X; Volume XI; Volume XII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  53. aper Copy of Document Due 4 Copies of un-redacted Appellants Brief and Appendix (individually bound) due on or before: 15-JULY-2024
  54. ote to Clerk eFiling Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY
  55. otion to Seal Motion to Seal Appellants Appendix Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION Associated Entries: 07/16/2024 - Sustained
  56. ote to Clerk eFiling Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY
  57. ppendix Filed Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION Associated Entries: 07/05/2024 - Appellant's Brief
  58. Sustained Filed in WD87144 Associated Entries: 04/25/2024 - Mot for Consolidation of Cases +
  59. ppellant's Brief Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION Associated Entries: 07/08/2024 - Appendix Filed
  60. Correspondence Received Respondent, Missouri Mining Commission, Will Not File a Respondent Brief Filed in WD87144 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  61. ot Ext Time to File Brief Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST Associated Entries: 07/15/2024 - Sustained Until +
  62. Correspondence Received Respondent, Missouri Mining Commission, Will Not File a Respondent Brief Filed in WD87090 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  63. ustained Associated Entries: 06/05/2024 - Motion to Seal +
  64. <td></td><td></td><td></td>
  65. otion to Seal Portions of the Record on Appeal Filed By: TIMOTHY P DUGGAN On Behalf Of: MISSOURI DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES, MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION Associated Entries: 06/13/2024 - Sustained
  66. Pet for Review Filed - Appl Ct Filed in WD87144 Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST
  67. aper Copy of Document Receivd Record on Appeal Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  68. Note to Clerk eFiling Filed in WD87144
  69. ecord on Appeal Complete Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  70. aper Copy of Document Due Copy of Record on Appeal Index due on or before: 14-MAY-2024
  71. ecord on Appeal Volume XLI; Certificate of Service Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  72. ecord on Appeal Volume XXXVIII; Volume XXXIX; Volume XL Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  73. ecord on Appeal Volume XXXV; Volume XXXVI; Volume XXXVII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  74. ecord on Appeal Volume XXXII; Volume XXXIII; Volume XXXIV Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  75. ecord on Appeal Volume XXIX; Volume XXX; Volume XXXI Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  76. ecord on Appeal Volume XXV; Volume XXVI; Volume XXVII; Volume XXVIII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  77. ecord on Appeal Volume XXII; Volume XXIII; Volume XXIV Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  78. ecord on Appeal Volume XIX; Volume XX; Volume XXI Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  79. ecord on Appeal Volume XVI; Volume XVII; Volume XVIII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  80. ecord on Appeal Volume XIII; Volume XIV; Volume XV Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  81. ecord on Appeal Volume X; Volume XI; Volume XII Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  82. ecord on Appeal Volume VII; Volume VIII; Volume IX; Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  83. ecord on Appeal Volume IV; Volume V; Volume VI; Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  84. ecord on Appeal Cover and Index; Volume I; Volume II; Volume III Filed By: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  85. ases Consol Under this Case WD87144
  86. ustained Filed in WD87144 Associated Entries: 04/25/2024 - Mot for Consolidation of Cases +
  87. orrespondence Received Respondent, Missouri Mining Commission, Will Not File a Respondent Brief Filed in WD87144 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  88. ntry of Appearance Filed Filed in WD87144 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  89. orrespondence Received Respondent, Missouri Mining Commission, Will Not File a Respondent Brief Filed in WD87090 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  90. ntry of Appearance Filed Filed in WD87090 Filed By: CHRIS ALAN WENDELBO On Behalf Of: MISSOURI MINING COMMISSION
  91. iling Info Sheet eFiling Filed in WD87144
  92. et for Review Filed - Appl Ct Filed in WD87144 Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST
  93. ot for Consolidation of Cases Filed in WD87144 Filed By: MARK JEFFREY BREDEMEIER On Behalf Of: RANDAL S DOBYNS, LESLIE R DOBYNS, DOBYNS FAMILY TRUST Associated Entries: 05/03/2024 - Sustained +
  94. ote to Clerk eFiling Filed in WD87144
  95. ustained Filed in WD87090 Associated Entries: 04/04/2024 - Motion for Stay +
  96. uggestions in Opposition Filed in WD87090 Filed By: JUSTIN JAY JOHL On Behalf Of: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Associated Entries: 04/04/2024 - Motion for Stay +
  97. ustained Filed in WD87090 Associated Entries: 04/11/2024 - Motion for Intervention +
  98. otion for Intervention Filing Party: JUSTIN J. JOHL Associated To: MID-STATES MATERIALS, LLC Filed in WD87090 Associated Entries: 04/19/2024 - Sustained +
  99. ourt Order Issued Respondents' response due on or before April 11, 2024. Filed in WD87090
  100. iling For Immediate Temporary Stay, Pending Ruling on Appellants Motion to Stay Permit Filed in WD87090 Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION Associated Entries: 04/04/2024 - Motion for Stay +
  101. otion for Stay Filed in WD87090 Filed By: PATRICK OGLESBY DAUGHERTY On Behalf Of: THE OSAGE NATION Associated Entries: 04/04/2024 - Filing + Associated Entries: 04/19/2024 - Suggestions in Opposition + Associated Entries: 04/19/2024 - Sustained +
  102. iling Fee Paid Filed in WD87090
  103. iling Info Sheet eFiling Filed in WD87090
  104. ote to Clerk eFiling Filed in WD87090

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more