Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Case Information
Filed
2022-03-11
Status
Pending
Type
Tort Medical Malpractice
Docket
353 entries
Disposition
Consolidated
Parties
Plaintiff
Nellie Perkins As Administrator Of The Estate Of Larry Mitchell
Defendant
South Atlanta Vascular Institute Llc
South Atlanta Vascular Institute Llc Ra David Allison Md 7402 Davidson Circle W Stockbrige, Ga 30281 | Penn David R
Penn David R 7402 Davidson Circle W Stockbridge, Ga 30281 | Guardian Medical Services | Guardian Medical Services Llc | John Does 15
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- 10:00 AM Room 304 Oral Argument Motion Calendar
- Rule Nisi
- 11:00 AM Room 304 Oral Argument Motion Calendar
- Conflict letter
- Rule Nisi
- Request for Oral Argument
- Pltfs Initial Response in Opposition to Defts
- Motion to Apply the Purported Statutory Cap on
- Noneconomic Damages Pursuant to O.C.G.A.
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 05/18/2026-05/22/2026 06/10/2026-06/16/2026
- 06/22/2026-07/04/2026
- Leave of Absence
- 10:00 AM Room 304 Civil Jury Calendar
- Order Resetting Case
- Defendants Motions in Limine
- Defts David Penn, M.D. and South Atlanta vascular
- Institute, LLCs Motion to Apply the Statutory Cap
- on Noneconomic Damages Pursuant to O.C.G.A and
- Brief in Support
- Conflict Correspondence
- Consolidated Pretrial Order
- Notice of Deposition of Dr. Winston Gandy
- Conflict Letter- Robert P. Monyak
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 10/08/2025-10/14/2025 12/22/2025-12/30/2025
- Attorney Leave of Absence
- Jury Trial Notice to Sam Crochet
- Jury Trial Notice to Robert B. Monyak
- Jury Trial Notice to Michael E. Russ, Jr
- Jury Trial Notice to Megan G. Colter
- Jury Trial Notice to Mahdi Abdur-Rahman
- Jury Trial Notice to John Does 1-5
- Jury Trial Notice to Guardian Medical Services
- Jury Trial Notice to Guardian Medical Services,
- LLC
- Jury Trial Notice to Candice Liverpool-Settle
- Consolidated Pretrial Order
- Return Mail
- JOHN DOES 1-5
- Foster Norlene with prejudice
- 10:00 AM Room 304 Civil Jury Calendar
- Order- Dismissing Party with Prejudice
- Moved to New Calendar - CAL/JRY 08/04/2025
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Mahdi Abdur-Rahman
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Candice
- Liverpool-Settle
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Michael E. Russ Jr.
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Robert P Monyak
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Sam Crochet
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Megan G. Colter
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Shelia K. Kazeman
- Jury Trial Notice to Attorney Terrell Benton
- Jury Trial Notice to Guardian Medical Services,
- LLC
- Jury Trial Notice to Guardian Medical Services
- Certificate of Serving Offer of Settlement -
- David Penn, MD
- Certificate of Serving Offer of Settlement -
- South Atlanta Vascular
- Proposed Consolidated Pre-Trial Order
- 02:30 PM Room 305 Pre-Trial Conference
- Defendants Motion for Set-Off of Settlement
- Amount Paid and Brief in Support
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Notice and Request for a Bifurcated Trial
- Pursuant to O.C.G.A. 51-12-15
- Conflict Letter
- Return Mail
- Order re Motion to Dismiss Defendant Norlene
- Foster (Less Than All Parties)
- Motion to Dismiss Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNA
- (Motion to Dismiss Less Than All Parties)
- LEA Atty Michael E. Russ JR.
- 05/06/2025-05/28/2025 11/24/2025-11/28/2025
- 12/20/2025-01/06/2026
- Leave of Absence
- Certificate of Serving Offer of Settlement
- Stipulated by Plaintiff
- NOTICE TO PLACE CASE ON NEXT TRIAL CALENDAR
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 04/23/2025-04/25/2025 08/20/2025-09/03/2025
- Leave of Absence
- LEA Atty TERRELL BENTON
- 02/11/2025-02/16/2025 03/06/2025-03/10/2025
- 04/02/2025-04/07/2025 06/09/2025-06/11/2025
- 06/19/2025-06/30/2025
- Terrell W. Benton, III Leave of Absence 2025
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 02/24/2025-03/09/2025
- RPM - Leave of Absence
- Atty Liverpool-Settle Candice
- for South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- Atty CROCHET SAM
- for South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- Atty CROCHET SAM
- for Penn David R.
- Notice Of Substitution of Counsel-Kim Prine
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 08/01/2024-08/13/2024
- Leave of Absence
- Discovery extended by Order through and including
- May 23, 2024
- Granted - Motion to Extend Discovery
- By Foster Norlene
- Order Extending Discovery Deadlines
- Motion to Extend Discovery
- Substitution of Counsel
- Notice of Change of Address
- Atty ABDUR-RAHMAN MAHDI
- for NELLIE PERKINS AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTAT
- Entry of Appearance
- Plaintiffs Designation and Disclosure of Rebuttal
- Expert Witnesses
- LEA Atty TERRELL BENTON
- 02/28/2024-03/04/2024 06/20/2024-06/24/2024
- 08/19/2024-08/26/2024 12/23/2024-12/30/2024
- Notice of Leave of Absence of Terrell W. Benton,
- III
- Notice of Deposition-Mohan
- Second Joint Consent Scheduling Order
- Granted - DEFT SOUTH ATLANTA VASCULAR IN
- By South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- Order on South Atlanta Vascular Institutes Motion
- to Withdraw and Amend Responses
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF EXPERT DR. JEFFREY HOWARD
- Notice of Deposition for Expert Dr. Hurst
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 02/27/2024-03/05/2024 05/09/2024-05/14/2024
- 05/23/2024-06/02/2024
- Leave of Absence - RPM
- Amended NOD-Dr. Mohan
- Notice of Deposition for Darren Hurst
- SECOND PROPOSED SCHEDULING ORDER
- Amended Notice of Deposition of Dr. Mohan
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF BHAT MOHAN, M.D.
- Notice of Deposition of Dr. Teresa Stanton
- Second Joint Scheduling Order
- Granted - Motion for appointment
- Order Appointing Special Process Server
- Proposed order for Appointment
- Appointment Affidavit
- Motion for appointment
- PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
- TO THIRD PARTY (NON-PARTY)
- Notice of Deposition - Tagoe
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- DEFT SOUTH ATLANTA VASCULAR INSTITUTE, LLCs
- MOTION TO WITHDRAW AND AMEND RESPONSES TO
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND REQUESTS FOR ADMISSIONS TO
- SOUTH ATLANTA VASCULAR INSTITUTE, LLC
- COS Defs NPRPD to Butts County Coroners Office
- PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
- TO THIRD PARTY (NON-PARTY)
- PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
- TO THIRD PARTY (NON-PARTY)
- 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Notice of Deposition of Alesia Quante, CRNA
- PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO
- THIRD PARTY (NON-PARTY)
- PLAINTIFFS THIRD REQUEST FOR ADMISSION TO
- DEFENDANT PENN
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND REQ FOR PRODUCTION of DOCUMENTS
- TO DEFENDANT SAVI
- PLAINTIFFS FOURTH REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS TO
- DEFENDANT SAVI
- 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Certificate of Service of Discovery for Defendant
- Norlene Foster, CRNAs Responses to Plaintiffs
- Seventh Requests for Admissions
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- 5.2 Certificate of Service
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND AMENDED DESIGNATION AND
- DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES
- AMENDED NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION ON RALPH WILSON
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- RULE 5.2 - Certificate of Discovery
- Withdrawn - Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNA
- By Foster Norlene
- Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNAs Withdrawal of her
- Motion for Protective Order and Brief in Support
- Scheduling Order
- Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNAs Motion for
- Protective Order and Brief in Support
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF
- DOCUMENTSTO DEFENDANT PENN
- PLAINTIFFS THIRD Request for Production to
- DEFENDANT FOSTER
- PLAINTIFFS SEVENTH RFAs to DEFENDANT FOSTER
- Pltfs Second Req For Adms to Deft Penn
- NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION OF RALPH WILSON
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST RPDs to DEFENDANT SAVI
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND RPD TO DEFENDANT FOSTER
- SECOND PROPOSED JOINT CONSENT SCHEDULING ORDER
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Certificate of Service of Discovery for Defendant
- Norlene Foster, CRNAs Responses to Plaintiffs
- Sixth Request for Admissions
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 04/17/2023-04/19/2023 04/26/2023-04/28/2023
- 06/30/2023-07/05/2023
- Leave of Absence - RPM
- GUARDIAN MEDICAL SERVICES, LLC
- Order Granting Plaintiffs Motion to add a Party
- Consent Scheduling Order
- PLAINTIFFS SIXTH RFAs to DEFENDANT FOSTER
- COS FOR OFFER OF SETTLEMENT
- COS FOR OFFER OF SETTLEMENT
- COS FOR OFFER OF SETTLEMENT
- PLAINTIFFS AMENDED DESIGNATION AND DISCLOSURE OF
- EXPERT WITNESSES
- PLAINTIFFS DESIGNATION AND DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT
- WITNESSES
- NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION OF JO PIKE
- NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION OF CHERON BELSEN
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF RALPH WILSON
- LEA Atty TERRELL BENTON
- 03/03/2023-03/10/2023 04/28/2023-05/01/2023
- 05/12/2023-05/15/2023 08/17/2023-08/25/2023
- 11/20/2023-11/27/2023 12/21/2023-01/02/2024
- Notice of Leave of Absence of Terrell W. Benton,
- III
- Notice of Deposition of Bennie R. White Jr., M.D.
- RULE 5.2 CERT OF SERV
- NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION
- Proposed Consent Scheduling Order
- Proposed Order Granting Extension of Discovery
- Joint Motion to Extend Discovery
- Notice of Deposition of Nellie Perkins
- Notice of Deposition of Carlton Perkins
- LEA Atty ROBERT P MONYAK
- 01/12/2023-01/17/2023 04/05/2023-04/11/2023
- 05/25/2023-05/31/2023 06/01/2023-06/13/2023
- Atty Leave of Absence- Robert P. Monyak
- Certificate of Service of Discovery for Defendant
- Norlene Foster, CRNAs Responses to Plaintiffs
- Fifth Request for Admissions
- Deft Foster Response to Pltf 4th Req for Adm
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT PENN
- RULE 5.2 Cert of Serv
- 5.2 Certificate of Service
- PLTFS SECOND REQ FOR ADM TO DEFT
- PLTFS FIIFTH REQ FOR ADM TO DEFT
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Notice of Deposition of Dorothy Sims
- PLAINTIFFS FOURTH REQ FOR ADM TO DEFENDANT FOSTER
- CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
- Certificate of Service 5.2
- Rule 5.2 Cert of Service
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND REQ FOR ADM TO DEFT
- Certificate of Service of Discovery
- Certificate of Service of Discovery for Defendant
- Norlene Foster, CRNAs First Req for Prod of
- Docmts to Plaintiff
- Certificate of Service of Discovery for Defendant
- Norlene Foster, CRNAs First Interrogatories to
- Plaintiff
- PLAINTIFFS FOURTH RFAs TO DEFENDANT
- Rule 5.2 Cert Of Serv Disc
- Def Discovery Responses to Plf
- Atty CROCHET SAM
- for Penn David R.
- Atty COLTER MEGAN G.
- for Penn David R.
- Notice of Substitution of Counsel
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- PLAINTIFFS SECOND RFAs TO DEFENDANT
- PLAINTIFFS AMENDED FIRST RFAs TO DEFENDANT
- RULE 5.2
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST REQUEST FOR ADMISSIONS
- PLAINTIFFS FIRST INTERROGATORIES
- Withdrawn - Defendant Norlene F. Mot to Di
- Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNAs Notice of
- Withdrawal of Her Motion to Dismiss and Brief in
- Support
- Plaintiffs Response to Defendant Fosters Motion
- to Dismiss
- LEA Atty TERRELL BENTON
- 07/01/2022-07/08/2022 09/16/2022-09/19/2022
- 11/21/2022-11/28/2022 12/22/2022-01/02/2023
- Notice of Leave of Absence of Terrell W. Benton,
- III
- Certificate of Service
- 12 Person Jury
- By Foster Norlene
- GUARDIAN MEDICAL SERVICES
- Scheduling Order: Plaintiffs Motion to Add Party
- Answer and Affirmative Defenses of Norlene
- Foster, CRNA to Plaintiffs First Amended
- Complaint for Wrongful Death, Medical
- Malpractice, Negligence Per Se, Ordinary
- Negligence, and Respondeat Superior
- Defendant Norlene Foster, CRNAs Request for Oral
- Argument
- STIP EXTENDING TIME FOR DEFT DAVID R. PENN, M.D.
- AND SOUTH ATLANTA VASCULAR INSTITUTE, LLC TO RESP
- TO DISC
- Proposed Order
- Motion to Add Defendant
- 12 Person Jury
- By Foster Norlene
- Scheduling Order: Deft Fosters Motion to Dismiss
- Defendant Norlene F. Mot to Dismiss and Brief in
- Support to Dismiss Pltfs Complaint
- Answer and Affirmative Defenses of Norlene F. to
- Plfs Original Complaint
- 12 Person Jury
- Pltfs First Amended Complaint
- CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
- Atty COLTER MEGAN G.
- for Penn David R.
- Atty COLTER MEGAN G.
- for South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- Atty MONYAK ROBERT P
- for South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- Atty MONYAK ROBERT P
- for Penn David R.
- 12 Person Jury
- By South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- By Penn David R.
- Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
- Answer of Defts Penn MD and South Atlanta
- Vascular Institute
- Atty KAZEMAN SHEILA K
- for Foster Norlene
- Atty BENTON TERRELL
- for Foster Norlene
- Consent Stipulation to Extend Time to File Answer
- Affidavit of Service for Defendant David Penn
- Affidavit of Service for Defendant Norlene Foster
- Affidavit of Service for Defendant South Atlanta
- Vascular Institute
- MOST NOTORIOUS PLACE OF ABODE, Foster Norlene
- CORPORATION, South Atlanta Vascular Institute, LLC
- PERSONAL, Penn David R.
- Atty Russ Michael E. JR.
- for NELLIE PERKINS AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTAT
- Atty CROWTHER DERRIC
- for NELLIE PERKINS AS ADMINISTRATOR OF THE ESTAT
- Granted - Motion for Appointment of Spec
- SUMMONS
- Order Appointing Process Server
- 12 Person Jury
- Motion for Appointment of Special Process Server
- and Proposed Order
- First Cont Interrs to Deft South Atlanta Vascular
- First Req for Adms to Deft South Atlanta Vascular
- Plaintiffs First Request for Admissions to
- Defendant David R. Penn, M.D.
- Receipt# 202200872 issued
- Complaint
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In
