Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Washtenaw Co

Court

Washtenaw Co

Michigan

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-11-03
Type Medical Malpractice (nh)
Docket 226 entries
Disposition without prejudice

Parties

Plaintiff Sands Lewis, Miricle As Personal Representative Of The Estate Of Elizabeth Sands, Deceased
Defendant Aina Lpn, Victoria E|Ciena Health Care Management, Inc.|Halimi Md, Hamidullah|Mc Intosh, Lpn, Alonna P.|Nichol, Lpn, Erin|Riverview Acquisition Company
Photo of Hon. Motion for Summary Disposition (2:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) ZOOM- Deft Esurance/ MSD Result: Adjourned

Judge

Hon. Motion for Summary Disposition (2:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) ZOOM- Deft Esurance/ MSD Result: Adjourned

Washtenaw County (MI)

Michigan

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. ury Trial (8:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) Adj. 3/24,7/7,11/3 03/24/2025 Reset by Court to 07/07/2025 07/07/2025 Reset by Court to 11/03/2025 11/03/2025 Reset by Court to 04/27/2026
  2. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  3. ummons Royston, Brent, RN Served 12/11/2023
  4. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  5. ummons Whitehead, Lashonda, RN Served 12/11/2023
  6. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  7. ummons Ashara,, Suliat, RN Served 12/11/2023
  8. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  9. ummons Aina LPN, Victoria E Served 12/11/2023
  10. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  11. ummons Ciena Health Care Management, Inc. Served 12/11/2023
  12. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  13. ummons Long, LPN, Caroline Served 12/11/2023
  14. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  15. ummons Lancina,, Jennifer, RN Served 12/11/2023
  16. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  17. ummons IHA Health Services Corporation Served 12/11/2023
  18. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  19. ummons Nichol, LPN, Erin Served 12/11/2023
  20. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  21. ummons Frye, LPN, Alicia Served 12/11/2023
  22. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  23. ummons Halimi MD, Hamidullah Served 11/29/2023
  24. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  25. ummons Johnson, LPN, Desylvia Served 12/11/2023
  26. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  27. ummons Lau, LPN, Candace Served 12/11/2023
  28. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  29. ummons RIVERVIEW ACQUISITION COMPANY, LLC Served 12/11/2023
  30. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  31. ummons Estes,, Brittany M., RN Served 12/11/2023
  32. omplaint
  33. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  34. ummons McIntosh, LPN, Alonna P. Served 12/11/2023
  35. ury Demand Trial
  36. roof of Service
  37. ppearance /proof of service
  38. roof of Service
  39. ppearance /proof of service
  40. nswer to Complaint Affirmative defenses/ reliance on demand for trial by jury/ proof of service
  41. roof of Service
  42. roof of Service
  43. ppearance
  44. roof of Service
  45. otion For a more definite statement with brief in support and proof of service
  46. roof of Service
  47. oom Notice of Motion Hearing Scheduled
  48. nswer To defendant halimi's affirmative defenses & proof of service
  49. roof of Service
  50. roof of Service
  51. ocument Initial disclosures pursuant to mcr 2.302(a) & proof of service
  52. roof of Service
  53. esponse To defendant halimi's motion for a more definite statement/ brief in support/ proof of service
  54. roof of Service
  55. roof of Service
  56. ppearance
  57. roof of Service
  58. eliance on Jury Demand
  59. nswer to Complaint Affirmative defenses & further answers
  60. otion Hearing (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) ZOOM - Deft Halimi/ Motion for More Definite Statement Result: Held
  61. roof of Service
  62. otice of Submission - Copy of Order - Proof of Service
  63. roof of Service
  64. otice of Submission - Copy of Order - Proof of Service
  65. roof of Service
  66. tipulated Order Granting defendant, hamidullah halimi, m.d.'s motion for more definitive statement (sgd 12/19/23)
  67. nswer To defendant hamidullah halimi md's affirmative defenses & proof of service
  68. roof of Service
  69. roof of Service
  70. itness - Exhibit List & proof of service
  71. ocument Initial disclosures pursuant to mcr 2.302(a) & proof of service
  72. tipulated Order Granting defendant, hamidullah halimi, m.d.'s motion for more definitive statement (sgd 12/26/23)
  73. roof of Service
  74. nswer To defendant ciena healthcare et al's affirmative defenses and proof of service
  75. roof of Service
  76. tipulated Order Qualified protective order allowing ez parte meetings between defense counsel and miricle sands-lewis's healthcare providers (sgd 1/5/24)
  77. roof of Service
  78. ocument First set of interrgatories and request to produce to plaintiff and certificate of service
  79. otice of Taking Deposition Arbitrary/ proof of service
  80. equest To admit non-economic damages and certificate of service
  81. mended Complaint First
  82. roof of Service
  83. ury Demand
  84. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  85. ummons IHA Health Services Corporation Unserved
  86. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  87. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  88. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  89. ummons Aina LPN, Victoria E Unserved
  90. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  91. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  92. ummons Lancina,, Jennifer, RN Served 12/11/2023
  93. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  94. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  95. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  96. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  97. ummons Nichol, LPN, Erin Unserved
  98. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  99. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  100. ummons McIntosh, LPN, Alonna P. Unserved
  101. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  102. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  103. roof of Service
  104. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  105. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  106. nswer to Complaint Further answers, affirmative defenses, relaince on jury demand, proof of service
  107. roof of Service
  108. roof of Service
  109. ffidavit Of meritorious defense of suzzane brown, r.n. on behalf of defendants ciena healthcare management, regency at bluffs park, jennifer lancina, suliat ashara, lashonda whitehead, brent roystin, brittany estes, candace lau, alicia frye, desylvia johnson and caroline long
  110. x Parte Motion To extend life of summons/ brief in support
  111. roof of Service
  112. oom Notice of Motion Hearing Scheduled
  113. roof of Service
  114. roof of Service
  115. rder for Second Summons - Granted (expires 4/2/24) (sgd 2/2/24)
  116. rder for Second Summons - Granted (expires 4/2/24) (sgd 2/2/24)
  117. rder for Second Summons - Granted (expires 4/2/24) (sgd 2/2/24)
  118. rder for Second Summons - Granted (expires 4/2/24) (sgd 2/2/24)
  119. rder for Second Summons - Granted (expires 4/2/24) (sgd 2/2/24)
  120. roof of Service
  121. esponse To defendants first set of interrogatories and requests to produce & proof of service
  122. roof of Service
  123. equest To defendants s for non-economic damages & proof of service
  124. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  125. ummons Ashara,, Suliat, RN Unserved
  126. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  127. ummons Aina LPN, Victoria E Unserved
  128. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  129. ummons Nichol, LPN, Erin Unserved
  130. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  131. ummons Johnson, LPN, Desylvia Unserved
  132. ummons Issued (Summons and Complaint)
  133. ummons McIntosh, LPN, Alonna P. Unserved
  134. roof of Service
  135. eliance on Jury Demand upon plaintiff's jury trial / cert of service
  136. roof of Service
  137. nswer to Complaint (first amended) / affirmative defences / cert of service
  138. nswer To defendants affirmative defenses for first amended complaint & proof of service
  139. roof of Service
  140. ANCELED Motion Hearing (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) Cancel ZOOM- Pltf/ Ex Parte Motion to Extend Life of Summons
  141. ffidavit Of meritorious defense of jonathan lovy, do
  142. roof of Service
  143. ffidavit Of non-involvement of iha health services corporation d/b/a trinity health iha medical group/ proof of service
  144. roof of Service
  145. ocument Initial disclosures pursuant to mcr 2.302(a)/ proof of service
  146. roof of Service
  147. roof of Service
  148. roof of Service
  149. rder Of dismissal as to defendants jennifer lancina, rn, suliat ashara, rn, lashonda whitehead, rn, brent royston, rn, brittany m. estes, rn, candace lau, lpn and caroline long,lpn only (sgd 2/28/24)
  150. cheduling Order (sgd 2/29/24)
  151. ocument Reliance on affidavit of meritorious defense of jonathan lovy, do & proof of service
  152. roof of Service
  153. otice of Taking Deposition / proof of service
  154. roof of Service
  155. roof of Service
  156. otion and Verification for Alternate Service
  157. otion and Verification for Alternate Service
  158. otion and Verification for Alternate Service
  159. otion and Verification for Alternate Service
  160. roof of Service
  161. roof of Service
  162. rder Regarding Alternate Service (sgd 4/2/24)
  163. rder Regarding Alternate Service (sgd 4/2/24)
  164. rder Regarding Alternate Service (sgd 4/2/24)
  165. rder Regarding Alternate Service (sgd 4/2/24)
  166. roof of Service
  167. rder for Second Summons - Denied (sgd 4/2/24)
  168. otion for Second Summons
  169. rder for Second Summons - Denied (sgd. 4/2/24)
  170. rder for Second Summons - Denied (sgd 4/2/24)
  171. roof of Service
  172. rder Of dismissal as to defendants alicia frye, lpn and desylvia johnson, lpn only (sgd 4/11/24)
  173. ffidavit Of meritorious defense by annette t carron do, cmd, facoi, faahpm & proof of service
  174. roof of Service
  175. xhibit List
  176. itness List / proof of service
  177. roof of Service
  178. roof of Service
  179. itness List / proof of service
  180. xhibit List / proof of service
  181. itness List
  182. roof of Service
  183. roof of Service
  184. roof of Service
  185. rder Substitution of counsel (sgd 9/12/24)
  186. tipulated Order To amend caption (sgd 9/12/24)
  187. ocument (first) set of interrogatories to defendant, riverview acquisition company, llc dba regency at bluffs park / proof of service
  188. equest (first) for production of documents to defendant ciena health care management, inc. / proof of service
  189. equest (first) for production of documents to defendant riverview acquisition company, llc dba regency at bluffs park / proof of service
  190. equest (first) to for production of documents to defendant, iha health service corporation dba trinity health iha medical group / proof of service
  191. roof of Service
  192. roof of Service
  193. tipulated Order Adjourning scheduling order 120 days (sgd. 9/18/2024)
  194. roof of Service
  195. otice of Taking Deposition (arbitrary) duces tecum of hamidullah halimi, md with notice to produce documents & proof of service
  196. roof of Service
  197. roof of Service
  198. otice of Taking Deposition Duces tecum of tamara davies (sparkman) via video & proof of service
  199. roof of Service
  200. otice of Taking Deposition Duces tecum of hamidullah halimi, md & proof of service
  201. roof of Service
  202. ppearance & proof of service
  203. roof of Service
  204. tipulated Order (2nd) adjourning scheduling order dates for a period of one hundred and twenty (120) days (sgd 1/17/25)
  205. roof of Service
  206. otice of Taking Deposition (duces tecum) of ram choudhary, np/ proof of service
  207. roof of Service
  208. ubstitution of Attorney (sgd. 2/5/2025)
  209. roof of Service
  210. otice of Taking Deposition (renotice) video duces tecum of ram choudhary, np, via zoom and notice to produce documents with proof of service
  211. roof of Service
  212. otice of Taking Deposition (renotice) video duces tecum of defendant hamidullah halimi, md, via zoom & proof of service
  213. roof of Service
  214. roof of Service
  215. otice of Taking Deposition 2nd renotice duces tecum, via video, of ram choudhary, np with proof of service
  216. tipulated Order Protective order regarding defendant ciena healthcare management, inc., riverview acquisition company, llc d/b/a regency at bluffs park's policies and procedures (sgd 5/7/25)
  217. ppearance Notice & proof of service
  218. roof of Service
  219. roof of Service
  220. ettlement Conference (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol) Adj. 2/6,5/29 02/06/2025 Reset by Court to 05/29/2025 05/29/2025 Reset by Court to 10/02/2025 Result: Held
  221. roof of Service
  222. tipulated Order Dismissing iha health services corporation d/b/a trinity health iha medical group without prejudice (sgd 10/6/25)
  223. roof of Service
  224. tipulated Order Adjourn discovery and trial (sgd 10/9/25)
  225. roof of Service
  226. ettlement Conference (10:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Kuhnke, Carol)

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more