Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Florida Civitech Unified Court

Court

Florida Civitech Unified Court

Florida

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-06-01
Status CLOSED
Type Other
Docket 276 entries
Disposition dismiss

Parties

Plaintiff Jefferson County
Defendant Winchester, Mark D|Winchester, Sheila P|The Homestead Barn Inc|The Homestead Ministries Inc
Photo of Hon. Caloca Johnson, Dawn

Judge

Hon. Caloca Johnson, Dawn

Jefferson County (FL)

Florida

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Assessment 1 assessed at sum $440.00
  2. ORDER DENYING JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDAS MOTION FOR REHEARING AND DENYING DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR REHEARING
  3. DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR HEARING
  4. JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDAS MOTION FOR REHEARING
  5. ORDER ON COMPLAINT AND COUNTERCLAIM
  6. ORDER DENYING ORDER ON DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO IMPROPER CLOSING ARGUMENT MOTION TO STRIKE MOTION FOR INVOLUNTARY DISMISSA MOTION FOR SANCTIONS REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS FEES AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  7. PROPOSED ORDER DENYING DEFENDANTS COUNTERS PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO IMPROPER CLOSING ARGUMENT
  8. Event HEARING scheduled on 11/13/2024 at 0930 AM, MX - Judge presiding.
  9. NOTICE OF HEARING
  10. JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDAS RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO IMPROPER CLOSING ARGUMENT MOTION TO STRIKE MOTION FOR INVOLUNTARY DISMISSAL MOTION FOR SANCTIONS REQUEST FOR ATTORNEY FEES AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  11. DEFENDANTS/COUNTER PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO IMPROPER CLOSING ARGUMENT MOTION TO STRIKE MOTION FOR INVOLUNTARY DISMISSAL MOTION FOR SANCTIONS REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS FEES AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  12. DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS WRITTEN CLOSING ARGUMENTS
  13. JEFFERSON COUNTY, FLORIDAS CLOSING ARGUMENTS
  14. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 2B 162 322
  15. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 2A I 161
  16. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 1B PAGES 127 255
  17. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 1A PAGES 1 126
  18. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 2
  19. TRANSCRIPT TRIAL VOLUME 1
  20. NOTICE OF FILING TRIAL TRANSCRIPT
  21. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 29 - JEEF. CO ORDINANCE 2022-040722-01
  22. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 30 - PA LTR TO DEF WITH PROPERTY CLASSIFICATION DATED 12/2/20
  23. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 31 - PA TRIM NOTICES 2018 & 2021
  24. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 32 - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING DOC (FL FARM TEAM CARD)
  25. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 33 - FORM 1040 - 2005
  26. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 34-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - CERTIFIED TREE FARM
  27. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 34-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - CERTIFIED TREE FARM
  28. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 35-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - AERIAL VIEW
  29. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 35-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - AERIAL VIEW
  30. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 36-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - BARN
  31. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 36-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - BARN
  32. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 36-c - COMPOSITE PHOTO - BARN
  33. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  34. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  35. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-c - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  36. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-d - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  37. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-e - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  38. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-f - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  39. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-g - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  40. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-h - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  41. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-i - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  42. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-j - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  43. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-k - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  44. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-l - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  45. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-m - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  46. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 37-n - COMPOSITE PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION
  47. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  48. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  49. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-c - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  50. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-d - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  51. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-e - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  52. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-f - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  53. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-g - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  54. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-h - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  55. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-i
  56. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-j - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  57. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-k - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  58. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-l - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  59. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-m - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  60. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 39-n - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  61. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-o - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  62. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-p - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  63. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-q - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  64. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-r - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  65. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-s - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  66. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-t - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  67. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 38-u - COMPOSITE PHOTO- BARN FOR FARMING ACTIVITIES
  68. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 39- PROPERTY APPRAISER PARCEL SHEET (220)
  69. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  70. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  71. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-c - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  72. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-d - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  73. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-e - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  74. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-f - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  75. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-g - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  76. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-h - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  77. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-i - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  78. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-j - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  79. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-k - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  80. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-l - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  81. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-m - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  82. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-n - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  83. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-o - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  84. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-p - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  85. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-q - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  86. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-r - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  87. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-s - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  88. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-t - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  89. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-u - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  90. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 40-v - COMPOSITE PHOTO - FARMING ACTIVITIES
  91. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-a - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  92. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-b - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  93. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-c - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  94. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-d - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  95. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-e- COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  96. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-f - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  97. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-g - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  98. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-h - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  99. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 41-i - COMPOSITE PHOTO - NATURE SHOOTS FOR WEDDINGS
  100. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 42 - APPLICATIONS; SPECIAL EXCEPTION & BUSINESS PERMIT
  101. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-a -COMPOSITE- CODE ENFORCEMENT: WARNING LETTER 3/2021
  102. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-b - COMPOSITE-CODE ENFORCEMENT: NOTICE OF VIOLATION 4/19/21
  103. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-c - COMPOSITE-CODE ENFORCEMENT: HEARING REQUEST 4/26/21
  104. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-d - COMPOSITE-CODE ENFORCEMENT: HEARING REQUEST EMAIL 6/7/21
  105. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-e - COMPOSITE-CODE ENFORCEMENT: HEARING REQUEST CERTIFED MAIL 7/12/21
  106. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-f - COMPOSITE - CODE ENFORCEMENT: NOTICE OF HEARING FOR 10/19/21
  107. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 43-g - COMPOSITE - CODE ENFORCEMENT: AMENDED NOTICE OF HEARING FOR 11/3/21
  108. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 44 - METTY RESPONSE & INVOICES RE DEFENDANT PRR
  109. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 45 - METTY EMAIL TO PROPERTY OWNERS 1/12/21
  110. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 46 - SHIRLEY/METTY CODE ENFORCEMENT EMAILS DATED 4/19/21
  111. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 47 - METTY/LASHLEY EMAILS 5/11/21
  112. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 48 - UNSIGNED DRAFT LTR OF AN UNLABELED FINAL DEVELOPMENT ORDER BY METTY DATED 6/15/21
  113. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 49 - AUNT LOUISE'S FARM DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
  114. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 50 - A & K BARN DEVELOPMENT PERMIT
  115. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 51 - DEPO. OF BETSY BARFIELD
  116. TRIAL EXHIBIT LIST BY CLERK
  117. TRIAL WITNESS LIST BY CLERK
  118. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 1 - DEPO OF CORP REP OF HOMESTEAD BARN
  119. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 1-a - DEPO OF CORP REP OF HOMESTEAD BARN
  120. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 2 - DEPO OF MARK WINCHESTER
  121. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 3 - REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
  122. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 3-a - JEFFERSON LAND DEV CODE AS OF 5/20/21
  123. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 4 - PROPERTY APP PARCEL ID REPORT
  124. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 5 - DEMONSTRATIVE AID OF PA MAP
  125. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 6 - COMPOSITE OH H.B. VENUE RENTAL AGREEMENTS
  126. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 7 - BOCC AGENDA & MINUTES 5/20/21 MEETING
  127. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 8 - USB PARTIAL RECORDING OF 5/20/21 BOCC MEETING
  128. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 9 - MINUTES FROM 5/20/21 BOCC MEETING
  129. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 10 - MINUTES FROM 3/11/21 PLANNING COMM. MEETING
  130. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 11 - LTR FROM MS. BEHARRY (DF ATTY) TO BOCC DATED 5/5/21
  131. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 12 - JEFF CO. ORDINANCE 2022-08042022-01 RELATED TO MORATORIUM ON SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS
  132. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 13 - JEFF CO. ORDINANCE 2023-05 RELATED TO MORATORIUM ON SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS
  133. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 14 - JEFF CO. ORDINANCE 2023-06 RELATED TO PERMIT USES, PROHIBITED USES
  134. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 15 - MARK WINCHESTER RESP TO COUNTY INTERROGATORIES
  135. JOINT EXHIBIT 16 - WINCHESTER PLANNING COMMISSION 3/11/21
  136. JOINT EXHIBIT 17 - COMPOSITE PHOTO OF BARN, STORAGE, EQUIP.
  137. JOINT EXHIBIT 18 - COMPOSITE PHOTO OF BARN, STORAGE, EQUIP.
  138. JOINT EXHIBIT 19 - COMPOSITE PHOTO OF BARN, STORAGE, EQUIP.
  139. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-a - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  140. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-b - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  141. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-c - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  142. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-d - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  143. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-e - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  144. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-f - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  145. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-g - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  146. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-h - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  147. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-i - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  148. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-j - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  149. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-k - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  150. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-l - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  151. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-m - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  152. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-n - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  153. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-o - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  154. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-p - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  155. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-q - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  156. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-r - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  157. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-s - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  158. JOINT EXHIBIT 20-t - COMPOSITE PHOTOS - NATURE SHOOT FOR WEDDINGS
  159. JOINT EXHIBIT 21 - WINCHESTER PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES 2/25/21
  160. JOINT EXHIBIT 22 - SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPLICATION 10/7/19 & METTY VERIFICATION LTR
  161. JOINT EXHIBIT - PHOTO - WATER INTRUSION AT THE BARN
  162. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 24 - LTR FROM COUNTY PLANNING OFFICIAL (METTY) TO DEF RE DENIAL OF APPLICATION 6/15/21
  163. DEFENDANTS EXHIBIT 25 - LTR FROM JEFF CO. FIRE CHEF TO DEFENDANTS RE COMPLIANCE DATED 6/9/21
  164. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 26 - COMPOSITE EXH CONTAINING PHOTOS OF H.B. POST RENOVATIONS
  165. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 27 - COMPOSITE EXH CONTAINING PHOTOS OF H.B. VENUE USE
  166. PLAINTIFFS EXHIBIT 28 - PRINTOUT OF H.B. WEBSITE
  167. SUBPOENA RETURNED NONSERVED - BETSY BARFIELD
  168. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - SHERIFF MCNEILL
  169. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - SHANNON METTY
  170. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - RENEE LONG
  171. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - JAMES KAUFMAN
  172. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - ADAM KALINOWSKI
  173. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - ANGELA GRAY
  174. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - RYAN FLYNT
  175. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - ALAN CAMPER
  176. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - DEPUTY BECK FKA DEPUTY CHEPPEL
  177. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - MARK OGLESBY
  178. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - FELIX JOYNER
  179. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - ROCKY CLEMENT
  180. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED - PAMELA RAY
  181. SUBPOENA RETURNED SERVED -MARK WINCHESTER
  182. DEFENDANT TRIAL MEMORANDUM
  183. JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDA TRIAL MEMORANDUM
  184. JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT
  185. DEFENDANT REQUEST TO TAKE JUDICIAL NOTICE
  186. DEFENDANTS FIRST AMENDED EXHIBIT LIST FOR TRIAL
  187. NOTICE OF INTENTION TO OFFER EVIDENCE BY MEANS OF CERTIFICATION OF RECORDS OF REGULARLY CONDUCTED BUSINESS ACTIVITY
  188. PLAINTIFF REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE
  189. PLAINTIFF AMENDED TRIAL EXHIBITS LIST
  190. DEFENDANTS FIRST AMENDED WITNESS LIST FOR TRIAL
  191. DEFENDANT THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO FIRST REQUEST TO PRODUCE
  192. DEFENDANT THIRD SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF FIRST REQUEST TO PRODUCE
  193. NOTICE AND VERIFICATION OF DEFENDANT SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
  194. NOTICE AND VERIFICATION OF DEFENDANT SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
  195. PLAINTIFF FIRST AMENDED TRIAL WITNESS LIST
  196. MEDIATION REPORT
  197. MOTION IN LIMINE
  198. PLAINTIFF RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT MARK WINCHESTER SECOND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
  199. DEFENDANT MARK WINCHESTER RESPONSE TO SECOND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
  200. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - BETSY BARFIELD; ANGELA GRAY; RENEE LONG; RAY JOYNER
  201. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - ROCKY CLEMENT; MARK OGLESBY; PAMELA RAY
  202. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - MAC MCNEILL
  203. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION - DERRICK BURRUS
  204. NOTICE OF FILING MEDIATION ATTENDANCE AND CERTIFICATION OF AUTHORITY
  205. DEFENDANT INITIAL WITNESS LIST FOR TRIAL
  206. DEFENDANT INITIAL EXHIBITS LIST FOR TRIAL
  207. PLAINTIFFS WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LISTS
  208. PLAINTIFFS WITNESS AND EXHIBIT LISTS
  209. Event NJ scheduled on 5/17/2024 at 0900 AM, MX - Judge presiding.
  210. Event NJ scheduled on 5/15/2024 at 0900 AM, MX - Judge presiding.
  211. ORDER SETTING NON JURY TRIAL
  212. MARK WINCHESTER SECOND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF/COUNTER DEFENDANT
  213. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF JEFFERSON COUNTY RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT MARK WINCHESTER INTERROGATORIES
  214. COUNTER DEFENDANT SECOND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO DEFENDANT MARK WINCHESTER
  215. COUNTER DEFENDANT RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
  216. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION
  217. NOTICE OF MEDIATION
  218. NOTICE OF CANCELING DEPOSITIONS
  219. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION OF THE HOMESTEAD MINISTRIES
  220. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION OF THE HOMESTEAD BARN
  221. NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION OF MARK WINCHESTER
  222. MARK WINCHESTER NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF COUNTER DEFENDANT JEFFERSON COUNTY
  223. MARK WINCHESTER FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF COUNTER DEFENDANT JEFFERSON COUNTY
  224. RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION AND MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  225. NOTICE OF HEARING
  226. Event CM scheduled on 2/14/2024 at 1030 AM, MX - Judge DAWN CALOCA-JOHNSON presiding.
  227. NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
  228. DEFNDANT THE HOMESTEAD BARN SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF/COUNTER DEFENDANTS FIRST REQUEST TO PRODUCE
  229. DEFNDANT MARK WINCHESTER SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF/COUNTER DEFENDANTS FIRST REQUEST TO PRODUCE
  230. Event HEARING scheduled on 1/9/2024 at 0930 AM, MX - Judge DAWN CALOCA-JOHNSON presiding.
  231. NOTICE OF HEARING
  232. Defendant Attorney: Beth A Miller Assigned to Sheila P Winchester
  233. Defendant Attorney: KRISTAL BEHARRY Assigned to Mark D Winchester
  234. DEFENDANT COUNTER PLAINTIFF RESPONSE TO FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
  235. DEFENDANT COUNTER PLAINTIFF RESPONSE TO FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS
  236. DEFENDANT COUNTER PLAINTIFF NOTICE OF SERVICE OF ANSWERS TO FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES
  237. JEFFERSONCOUNTY FLORIDA AMENDED MOTION FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  238. JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIADS REPLY TO DEFENDANTS COUNTER PLAINTIFFS AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
  239. JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDAS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES TO COUNTERCLAIM FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AND MOTION TO STRIKE
  240. PLAINTIFF COUNTER DEFENDANT JEFFERSON COUNTY FLORIDAS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS TO DEENDANT COUNTER PLAINTIFF THE HOMESTEAD BARN INC
  241. PLAINTIFF COUNTER DEFENDANT JEFFERSONCOUNTY FLORIDAS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT TO DEFENDANT MARK D WINCHESTER
  242. NOTICE OF SERVICE OF FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT
  243. Payment received: $395.00 Receipt Number MX 20233127
  244. DEFENDANTS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
  245. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL AND DESIGNATION OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EMAIL ADDRESSES
  246. COMPLAINT COUNTERCLIAM FOR DECLARATORY JUDGMENT
  247. Assessment 3 assessed at sum $395.00
  248. SUMMONS RETURNED SERVED THE HOMESTEAD MINISTRIES INC
  249. SUMMONS RETURNED SERVED THE HOMESTEAD BARN INC
  250. SUMMONS RETURNED SERVED SHEILA P WINCHESTER
  251. SUMMONS RETURNED SERVED MARK D WINCHESTER
  252. AMENDED SUMMONS ISSUED - THE HOMESTEAD MINISTRIES, INC
  253. AMENDED SUMMONS ISSUED - THE HOMESTEAD BARN, INC
  254. AMENDED SUMMONS ISSUED - SHEILA P WINCHESTER
  255. AMENDED SUMMONS ISSUED - MARK D WINCHESTER
  256. AMENDED ORDER FOR ACTIVE, DIFFERENTIAL CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT
  257. Payment received: $40.00 Receipt Number MX 20232662
  258. SUMMONS
  259. SUMMONS
  260. SUMMONS
  261. SUMMONS
  262. Assessment 2 assessed at sum $40.00
  263. SUMMONS ISSUED - THE HOMESTEAD MINISTRIES INC
  264. SUMMONS ISSUED - THE HOMESTEAD BARN INC
  265. SUMMONS ISSUED - SHEILA P WINCHESTER
  266. SUMMONS ISSUED - MARK WINCHESTER
  267. UNIFORM ORDER FOR ACTIVE DIFFERENTIAL CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT
  268. Payment received: $440.00 Receipt Number MX 20232459
  269. Attorney: Assigned to Jefferson County
  270. SUMMONS
  271. SUMMONS
  272. SUMMONS
  273. SUMMONS
  274. PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTION AND INCORPORATED MEMORANDUM OF LAW
  275. VERIFIED COMPLAINT FOR TEMPORARY INJUNCTIVE RELIEF AND PERMANENT INJUNCTIVE RELIEF
  276. CIVIL COVER SHEET

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more