Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Case Information
Parties
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- Jury Trial Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Hearing Time 9:00 AM
- Citation Requested By Esquibel, Sameera, Ochoa, Diondre Served 9:42 AM Anticipated Server Private Process Server Anticipated Method In Person Actual Server Private Process Server Returned 9:57 AM Comment EMAILED TO ATTORNEY
- Citation Requested By Esquibel, Sameera, Ochoa, Diondre Served 6:58 PM Anticipated Server Private Process Server Anticipated Method In Person Actual Server Private Process Server Returned 3:25 PM Comment EMAILED TO ATTORNEY
- Service Returned Served - by Private Process Server Comment ON 2/6/23 AT 9:42 AM
- Service Returned Served - by Private Process Server Comment ON AT 6:58 PM
- DEFENDANT'S ORIGINAL ANSWER Comment AND SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS
- DEFENDANT'S ORIGINAL ANSWER Comment AND SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS
- Motion Comment TO TRANSFER TO DISTRICT COURT
- Judge's Docket Note Comment Signed order granting motion to transfer to DC- BH
- Order to Transfer (between courts within Ector County) Judicial Officer Hendricks, Brooke Comment Case Now Assigned to A-23-03-0341-CV
- NOTICE OF FILING OF BUSINESS RECORDS AFFIDAVIT Comment FIRST
- NOTICE OF FILING OF BUSINESS RECORDS AFFIDAVIT
- NOTICE Comment PLAINTIFF'S SECOND NOTICE OF FILING OF AFFIDAVITS
- Certificate of Service
- Certificate of Service
- NOTICE Comment of Service of Controverting Affidavits
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment -EDDY COUNTY SHERIFF AND NEW MEXICO DPS (INVESTIGATE)
- CERTIFICATE OF COURT COSTS Comment $228.65- EDDY COUNTY SHERIFF- INVESTIGATIVE RECORDS
- CERTIFICATE OF COURT COSTS Comment $234.05 CHARGED FOR THE COURT COSTS RE: T-MOBILE (CELLULAR PHONE)
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTION- T-MOBILE- CELLULAR PHONE RECORDS
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS- ANGELA S GORDON (HARLINE BARGER, LLP)
- Proof of Service of Subpoena (Not Issued by Clerk)
- NOTICE Comment OF SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM-FOR 2019 MERCEDES-BENZ
- VACATION LETTER
- DOCKET CONTROL ORDER / SCHEDULING ORDER Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Comment AGREED DOCKET CONTROL PLAN
- NOTICE Comment OF SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM - NHS AUTO SALES LP
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS OF Artesia General Hospital, Patient Accounts Dept. (Billing), Matthew Emerson Kaiser, PA-C (Billing)
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - EXCEL ER - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - EXCEL ER - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - EXCEL ER - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $284.20 - BACK PAIN INSTITUTE OF WEST TEXAS - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $230.40- ARTESIA FIRE DEPARTMENT EMS- BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $194.20 ARTESIA FIRE DEPARTMENT EMS (MEDICAL - TRANSPORT)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $311.90 - AIRROSTI REHABILITATION CENTER - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $262.80 - BACK PAIN INSTITUTE OF WEST TEXAS - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $273.30 - MULTUS MEDICAL - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $330.40 - MULTUS MEDICAL - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $237.80 - SOFT TOUCH CHIROPRACTIC & WELLNESS CENTER - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $225.60 - SOFT TOUCH CHIROPRACTIC & WELLNESS CENTER - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $327.00 - MULTUS MEDICAL - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $215.60- RELIANCE ANESTHESIA GROUP- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $268.40- VISTA SURGERY CENTER- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $200.00- VISTA SURGERY CENTER- RADIOLOGY RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $207.50 - AVALON IMAGING - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $207.50 - AVALON IMAGING - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $343.15 - DORADO PHARMACY - PRESCRIPTION RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $225.60 - DORADO PHARMACY - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $207.50 - AVALON IMAGING - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $182.50 - HEAD INJURY CENTER - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $301.40 - HEAD INJURY CENTER - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $295.30 - HEAD INJURY CENTER - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $431.60 - WEST TEXAS SPINE INSTITUTE, PLLC - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $331.10 - WEST TEXAS SPINE INSTITUTE, PLLC - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $237.40 - CLARK CHIROPRACTIC CLINIC - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $230.40 - CLARK CHIROPRACTIC CLINIC - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $182.50 - WEST TEXAS SPINE INSTITUTE, PLLC - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - CLARK CHIROPRACTIC CLINIC - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $301.60 - MIDESSA NEUROSURGERY AND COMPLEX SPINE - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $390.75 - MID-TEXAS MRI - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $307.40 - SHANNON MEDICAL CENTER - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $285.55 ODESSA MEDICAL GROUP (MEDICAL - DOCTOR/CLINIC)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 BACK PAIN INSTITUTE OF WEST TEXAS (RADIOLOGICAL)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 COX NATURAL HEALTHCARE (RADIOLOGICAL)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $252.00 SHANNON MEDICAL CENTER, RADIOLOGY DEPT. (RADIOLOGICAL)
- MOTION TO COMPEL Comment INDEPENDENT NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF AND TO COMPEL EXCHANGE OF NEUROPSYCHOLOGY RAW TEST DATA
- RESPONSE Comment TO DEFENDANTS' REQUEST FOR A MEDICAL EXAMINATION
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $387.95 SALCIDO FAMILY CLINIC (MEDICAL - DOCTOR/CLINIC)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $255.60 SALCIDO FAMILY CLINIC (BILLING)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $257.80 VISTA SURGERY CENTER, ANCILLARY RESOURCE GROUP (BILLING))
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $297.60 - MID-TEXAS MRI - MEDICAL RECORDS OF SAMEERA ESQUIBEL
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $317.90 - MID-TEXAS MRI - BILLING RECORDS OF SAMEERA ESQUIBEL
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $455.70 - COX NATURAL HEALTHCARE - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $294.00 - COX NATURAL HEALTHCARE - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - DR. JUDITH BIRUNGI - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- Request Comment FOR HEARING ON DEFENDANTS' REQUEST FOR MEDICAL EXAMINATION AND PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $362.45 - MIDESSANEUROSURGERY AND COMPLEX SPINE - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $257.80 - RELIANCE ANESTHESIA GROUP, PLLC - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $300.25 - JUDITH BIRUNGI, M.D. - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $413.65 - EMERGICON, LLC - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $628.65 - ARTESIA GENERAL HOSPITAL - MEDICAL RECORDS
- ORDER SETTING HEARING Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Comment SET FOR: AT 9:30 PM
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $350.10- AIRROSTI REHAB CENTER- BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF INDIRECT COURT COSTS (DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $272.30 MIDLAND PRIMARY CARE (MEDICAL - DOCTOR/CLINIC)
- NOTICE OF INDIRECT COURT COSTS (DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $ 272.20 ARTESIA GENERAL HOSPITAL, PATIENT ACCOUNTS DEPT. (BILLING)
- NOTICE OF INDIRECT COURT COSTS (DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $252.00 ARTESIA GENERAL HOSPITAL, RADIOLOGICAL DEPT. (RADIOLOGICAL)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $280.05- ARTSIA GENERAL HOSPITAL- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $672.28- SHANNON MEDICAL CENTER- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $250.80- ARTESIA GENERAL HOSPITAL- RADIOLOGY RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $311.46-MIDESSA NEUROSURGERY AND COMPLEX SPINE
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $402.33-MATTHEW EMERSON KAISER, PA-C
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $252.00-MATTHEW EMERSON KAISER, PA-C(BILLING)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $175.00 - Matthew Emerson Kaiser, PA-C (Radiological)
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS - MULTIPLE PARTIES
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $256.60 - Artesia General Hospital, Patient Accounts Dept. (Billing)
- MOTION TO QUASH Comment DEPOSITION BY WRITTEN QUESTION
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment 573.08-Midland Memorial Hospital, Medical Records Dept. (Medical - Hospital)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $314.20-Midland Memorial Hospital, Patient Accounts Dept. (Billing)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $217.00-Medical Center Hospital, Radiology Dept. (Radiological)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $304.60 WALGREENS, PRIVACY OFFICE (PRESCRIPTIONS)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $160.00 - SALCIDO FAMILY CLINIC - RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS FOR SAMEERA ESQUIBEL
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $436.11- MEDICAL CENTER HOSPITAL- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $358.40- MEDICAL CENTER HOSPITAL- BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $334.00 - MIDESSA NEUROSURGERY AND COMPLEX SPINE - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $439.31- ODESSA REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER- MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $459.00 - ABDUL KADIR, M.D. - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $230.40 - ABDUL KADIR, M.D. - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE Comment DEFENDANTS' REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO COMPEL INDEPENDENT NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF SAMEERA ESQUIBEL AND TO COMPEL EXCHANGE OF RAW TEST DATA
- Motion Hearing Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Hearing Time 09:30 AM Comment Plaintiff's Motion Request for Hearing on Defendant's Request for Medical Examination and Plaintiff's Response
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $342.00 - WALGREENS, PRIVACY OFFICE - BILLING RECORDS OF SAMEERA ESQUIBEL
- ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Comment TO COMPEL INDEPENDENT NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF SAMEERA ESQUIBEL AND TO COMEPL EXCHANGE OF RAW TEST DATA
- NOTICE OF INTENT TO TAKE DEPOSITION Comment BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $341.05 - LEGACY SPINE & NERVE CARE - MEDICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $228.00- LEGACY SPINE & NERVE CARE - BILLING RECORDS
- MOTION TO QUASH Comment DEPOSITIONS BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $235.40 - LEGACY SPINE & NERVE CARE RADIOLOGICAL RECORDS
- NOTICE/DESIGNATION OF EXPERT WITNESS(ES)
- NOTICE/DESIGNATION OF FACT WITNESS(ES)
- NOTICE/DESIGNATION OF FACT WITNESS(ES)
- AMENDED PETITION Comment FIRST
- NOTICE/DESIGNATION OF EXPERT WITNESS(ES)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $297.70 - MIDLAND PRIMARY CARE - BILLING RECORDS
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $336.56 ODESSA REGINAL MEDICAL CENTER, PATIENT ACCOUNTS DEPT. (BILLING)
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $384.28 MIDLAND MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, RADIOLOGY DEPT. (RADIOLOGICAL)
- MOTION TO RESET HEARING Comment NOVEMBER 17, 2025 TRIAL SETTING TO CONDUCT MEDIATION, CONDUCT PARTY DEPOSITIONS, AND COMPLETE EXPERT DISCOVERY
- NOTICE OF DELIVERY (COMPLETED DEPO BY WRITTEN QUESTIONS) Comment $251.80- PERMIAN GASTROENTEROLOGY- MEDICAL RECORDS
- ORDER RESETTING HEARING Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Comment NOVEMBER 17, 2025, JURY TRIAL SETTING SET FOR:
- NOTICE OF FILING AFFIDAVIT Comment THIRD
- Pre-Trial Hearing Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Hearing Time 09:30 AM Cancel Reason Other
- Jury Trial Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Continued
- MOTION TO DISMISS Comment WITH PREJUDICE
- DISMISSAL - Other (OCA) Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn Comment WITH PREJUDICE-JOINT
- Docket Sheet Judicial Officer Whalen, Denn
- Certificate of Deposition Comment OF ROQUE CHAVIRRIA - $1480.45
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In