Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Portage Co

Court

Portage Co

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2024-05-08
Status CLOSED
Type Dr Never Married
Docket 150 entries
Disposition other terminations

Parties

Plaintiff Goins, Monica M
Defendant Dye, Jr, William E
Photo of Hon. Carnes Thomas J Probate

Judge

Hon. Carnes Thomas J Probate

Portage County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. COMPLAINT FOR CHILD SUPPORT TO ADOPT. ADMIN. ORDERS FILED BY: Attorney: LYLE, ROXANA R (15399) Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  2. COMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  3. COMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  4. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  5. SUMMONS ANSWER AND NOTICE OF HEARING FOR Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  6. Issue Date: 03/21/2007 Service: SUMMONS FOR ANSWER W/NOH 06/05/2007 @ 1:00 PM & COMPLT FOR CS TO ADOPT ADMIN ORDERS (J) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.00 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5 APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: 7160390198492169982 Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  7. Issue Date: 03/21/2007 Service: SUMMONS FOR ANSWER W/NOH 06/05/2007 @ 1:00 PM & COMPLT FOR CS TO ADOPT ADMIN ORDERS (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.39 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000006057 Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  8. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON MOTION TO ADOPT ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS Date: 06/05/2007 Time: 1:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location:
  9. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Issued : 03/21/2007 Service : SUMMONS FOR ANSWER (J) Served : 03/26/2007 Return : 03/27/2007 On : DYE JR, WILLIAM E Signed By : WILLIAM E DYE JR Reason : (JUV) SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 7160390198492169982
  10. LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE SENT TO ROXANA LYLE, CSEA - NO ANSWER HAS BEEN FILED W/THE COURT
  11. NOTICE TO TAKE DEPOSITION - DUCES TECUM - FILED BY: Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004) COPY TO: ROXANA LYLE, CSEA
  12. ANSWER FILED BY Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  13. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - HRG ON COMPLT TO ADOPT ADMIN ORDERS 06/05/2007 - MONICA GOINS APPEARED W/ATTY AXNER. CSEA WAS REPRES BY ATTY LYLE. ATTY D MITCHELL APPEARED ON BEHALF OF WILLIAM E DYE, JR. ADMIN ORDERS FILED HEREIN ARE ADOPTED AND MADE AN ORDER OF THIS COURT. A SEPARATE MAG'S DECISION AND JRNL ENTRY SHALL BE FILED BY CSEA, REFLECTING THIS DECISION. MONICA GOINS OBJECTS TO THE 05/02/2007, ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW/MODIFICATION, WHICH HAS NOT BEEN FILED W/THIS COURT. MS GOINS SHALL BE GRANTED LEAVE TO FILE WRITTEN OBJECTIONS TO SAME. UPON RECEIPT OF THE WRITTEN OBJECTIONS, THE MATTER SHALL BE SCHED BEORE THIS COURT FOR FURTHER HRG. FURTHER, MS GOINS REPRES TO THIS COURT THAT SHE WILL BE FILING A MOT TO MODIFY THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGATION IMPLEMENTED BY THE ADOPTION OF THE ADMINISTRATIVE ORDERS. COPY TO: ATTY AXNER, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  14. NOTICE OF REPRESENTATION FILED BY: Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004)
  15. OBJECTIONS TO ADMIN. MODIFICATION OF SUPPORT FILED BY: Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004)
  16. MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS FILED BY: Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004)
  17. HEARING SET: Event: HRG ON MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS-NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR EDWARD ARTHUR AXNER Date: 07/11/2007 Time: 10:30 am Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  18. MOTION FOR ATTORNEY FEES FOR FRIVOUS, MOTION FOR SANCTIONS Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  19. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER - HRG 06/05/2007 COMPLT TO ADOPT ADMIN ORDERS - ATTY LYLE APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. MAG MAKES FINDINGS UPON THE STATEMENTS OF COUNSEL, AND THE PLEADINGS, AS FOLLOWS: ADMIN ORDERS FILED HEREIN ARE ADOPTED AND MADE AN ORDER OF THIS COURT. PLTF IS RP/LC OF THE CHILD. THIS ORDER DOES NOT CONSTITUTE AN ALLOCATION OF PARENTAL RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES BY THE COURT. THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGATION OF DEF, WILLIAM E DYE, JR., IS ADOPTED EFFECTIVE 07/01/2006, IN THE AMT OF $208.13 PER MONTH, PER CHILD (1), PLUS A PROCESSING CHARGE OF $4.16, PER MONTH, PER CHILD FOR A TOTAL PYMT OF $212.29 PER MONTH. PLTF IS RESPON FOR 79% MED EXP, DEF IS RESPON FOR 21%, AND THE PARTIES SHALL SHARE ALL UNINSURED MED EXP OF THE MINOR CHILD IN ACCORDANCE W/THESE PERCENTAGES. PLTF AND DEF SHALL PROVIDE MED INS FOR THE MINOR CHILD IF THEY CAN DO SO @ A REAS COST THROUGH EMPLOY. THE COURT HEARD STATEMENTS OF COUNSEL AND NOTED FOR THE RECORD THAT MS. GOINS OBJECTS TO AN ADMIN RECOMM FOR ADJUSTMENT IN THE CHILD SUPPT LEVEL. MS. GOINS' OBJECTION MAY BE PROCESSED IN WRITING. MS. GOINS HAS ALSO EXPRESSED THAT SHE PLANS TO FILE A MOT TO MODIFY CHILD SUPPT, WHICH IS ALSO NOTED FOR THE RECORD. THE PARTIES SHALL EACH PAY 1/2 (ONE HALF) OF THE CC OF THIS ACTION. COPY TO: ATTY AXNER, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  20. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE - COPY HANDED TO: ATTY MITCHELL, ATTY AXNER
  21. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - 07/11/2007 HRG ON MOT TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS - PLTF APPEARED W/ATTY AXNER. DEF APPEARED W/ATTY MITCHELL. THE PARTIES ARE GIVEN TEN (10) DAYS FROM TEH DATE OF THE HRG TO SUBMIT BRIEFS REGARDING THE APPLICABILITY OF THE OHIO CIVIL RULES OF PROCEDURE, SPECIFICALLY REGARDING DEPOSITIONS, IN THE JUVENILE COURT, FOR MATTERS PERTAINING TO CHILD SUPPT ISSUES. COPY TO: ATTY AXNER, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  22. BRIEF FILED Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  23. BRIEF FILED Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004)
  24. MAGISTRATE'S DECISION. 07-11-07 HRG ON MOT. TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS. W. DYE APPEARED W/ ATTY MITCHELL, M. GOINS APPEARED W/ATTY AXNER. MAG. MADE VARIOUS FINDINGS BASED UPON THE PLEADINGS, PREVIOUS ENTRIES, ARGUMENT OF COUNSEL & BRIEFS SUBMITTED. THE MAG. DECIDES: PLTFS MOT. TO COMPEL DISCOVERY AND FOR SANCTIONS IS NOT WELL-TAKEN AND IS DENIED; THIS COURT WILL ENTERTAIN ANY MOT SEEKING COURT AUTHORITY TO TAKE THE DEPOSITION OF ANY PARTY IN THIS ACTION; DEF MOT FOR ATTY. FEES SHALL BE SCHED. FOR HRG. W/PLTF OBJ TO ADMIN. REVIEW & MODIF RECOMMENDATION; COSTS TO PLTF. COPIES TO ATTY. AXNER, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  25. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER - NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR ROXANA R LYLE DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR EDWARD ARTHUR AXNER Date: 09/06/2007 Time: 1:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  26. MOTION TO TAKE DEPOSITION Attorney: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR (21004)
  27. OBJECTIONS TO MOTION TO TAKE DEPOSITION Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  28. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON MOTION TO TAKE DEPOSITION & HEARING ON OBJECTION TO MOTION TO TAKE DEPOSITION-NOTICE TO: MONICA GOINS ARTHUR AXNER WILLIAM DYE DONALD MITCHELL Date: 09/04/2007 Time: 1:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  29. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER. 09-04-07 PLTF'S MOT TO TAKE DEPOSITION & DEF'S OBJ. TO SAME HRG. PLTF APPEARED W ATTY AXNER. DEF APPEARED W ATTY MITCHELL. PRIOR TO THE START OF THE HRG, THE PARTIES ADVISED THE COURT THEY HAVE REACHED AN AGREEMENT REGARDING THE OUTSTANDING ISSUES. THE PARTIES AGREE THE PLTF'S OBJ TO THE ADMIN. REV & MODIF. RECOMD. OF CSEA IS WITHDRAWN. DEF MOT FOR SANCTIONS, INCLUDING ATTY FEES IS WITHDRAWN. THE MOT TO TAKE DEPOSITION & OBJ TO SAME IS WITHDRAWN. ACCORDINGLY, PURSUANT TO THE PCCSEA ADMIN. ORDER, EFFECT 05-01-07, DEF SHALL BE RESPON FOR MONTHLY CHILD SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $337.37 + PROC FEE. PCCSEA SHALL FILE A COPY OF THE ADMIN. ORDER REFLECTING THE MODIF. & ANY NECESSARY PAPERWORK TO EFFECTUATE THE MODIF. AS A RESULT OF THIS AGREEMENT, THE HRG SCHED FOR 09-06-07 IS CANCELLED. COSTS TO PLTF. COPY TO ATTY AXNER, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 63525 Date: 01/15/2008
  30. COST BILL SENT TO MONICA GOINS, 10141 HAZELTON RD, STREETSBORO OH 44241 IN THE AMT OF $73.15 DUE IN FULL BY 10-11-07 COST BILL PLTF VS DEF Sent on: 09/11/2007 07:36:09
  31. SUBMISSION OF ADMINISTRATIVE MODIFICATION ORDER Attorney: LYLE, ROXANA R (15399)
  32. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  33. Issue Date: 09/20/2007 Service: SUBMISSION OF ADMINISTRATIVE MODIFICATION ORDER (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.41 ATTY: AXNER, EDWARD ARTHUR 80 S SUMMIT ST #400 AKRON, OH 44308 Tracking No: R000007436 ATTY: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL 3766 FISHCREEK RD #267 STOW, OH 44224 Tracking No: R000007437
  34. MOTION TO DETERMINE ARREARAGE AND PAYMENT OF ARREARAGE Attorney: LYLE, ROXANA R (15399) Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008 Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  35. REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS FILED BY: Attorney: LYLE, ROXANA R (15399)
  36. COMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  37. COMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  38. MOTION FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT FILED BY: Attorney: LYLE, ROXANA R (15399)
  39. ENTRY CITING PARTY OF CONTEMPT OF COURT Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  40. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  41. SUMMONS FOR CONTEMPT FAILURE TO PAY SUPPORT W / NOH FOR 8-12-08 @ 2:00 PM
  42. Issue Date: 06/19/2008 Service: SUMMONS FOR CONTEMPT W / NOH FOR 8-12-08 @ 2:00 PM, MOT TO DETERM ARREAGES, REQ FOR DOCS, MOT FOR CONTEMPT & ENTRY CITING (J) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 5.32 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: 7160390198455455555 Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  43. Issue Date: 06/19/2008 Service: SUMMONS W / NOH FOR 8-12-08 @ 2:00 PM, MOT TO DETERM ARREAGES, REQ FOR DOCS, MOT FOR CONTEMPT & ENTRY CITING Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.42 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000009221 Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  44. HEARING SET: Event: A HRG. ON MOT. TO DETERMINE ARREARAGES & CONTEMPT Date: 08/12/2008 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Result: CONTINUED (J)
  45. SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Issued : 06/19/2008 Service : SUMMONS FOR CONTEMPT (J) Served : 06/26/2008 Return : 06/27/2008 On : DYE JR, WILLIAM E Signed By : WILLIAM E. DYE, JR Reason : (JUV) SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 7160390198455455555
  46. HEARING SET: Event: A HRG. ON MOT. TO DETERMINE ARREARAGES & CONTEMPT - NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR ROXANA R LYLE Date: 09/18/2008 Time: 3:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Result: RESET Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  47. NOTICE OF REPRESENTATION Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  48. ANSWER FILED BY Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  49. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER. MTDA & CONTEMPT HRG 8-12-08. PLTD APPEARED AND WAS UNREP BY COUNSEL. DEF APPEARED AND WAS REP BY ATTY D. MITCHELL, JR. THE MAG FINDS THE PARTIES HAVE REQ A CONTINUANCE AND ORDERS THIS MATTER BE RE-SET FOR HRG. Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  50. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  51. Issue Date: 08/29/2008 Service: MAGISTRATE'S ORDER(J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.42 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000009651 DYE JR, WILLIAM E c/o ATTY: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL 3766 FISHCREEK RD #267 STOW, OH 44224 Tracking No: R000009652 Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  52. DEPOSIT PAID BY MONICA GOINS Receipt: 65318 Date: 09/19/2008
  53. MOTION FILED BY MONICA GOINS REGARDING PAST MED EXP OWED BY DEF. COPY TO CSEA, ATTY MITCHELL.
  54. HEARING SET: The following event: A HRG. ON MOT. TO DETERMINE ARREARAGES & CONTEMPT scheduled for 09/18/2008 at 3:00 pm has been rescheduled as follows: Event: A HRG. ON MOT. TO DETERMINE ARREARAGES & CONTEMPT - NOTICE TO : MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR ROXANA R LYLE DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 10/30/2008 Time: 3:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  55. RESPONSE TO LETTER OF MONICA COLLINS FILED ON 09-19-08 & RQST FOR PROD OF DOCUMENTS Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  56. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER. 09-25-08 REV OF DEF'S MOT FOR PROD OF DOCUMENTS. FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN, PLTF SHALL PROVIDE COUNSEL FOR DEF COPIES OF ANY & ALL BILLS & RECPTS FOR ANY MEDICAL EXP INCURRED ON BEHALF OF THE CHILD, OF WHICH PLTF SEEKS REIMBURSEMENT FOR. THE DOCUMENTS SHALL BE FURNISHED W/IN 14 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER. COPY ATTY MITCHELL(SASE), M. GOINS, CSEA Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  57. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER. HRG 9-18-08. PLTF APPEARED AND WAS UNREP BY COUNSEL. DEF DID NOT APPEAR AND WAS UNREP BY COUNSEL. ATTY LYLE APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. MAG FINDS THAT DEF ATTY DID NOT RECEIVE NOH AND ORDERS THIS MATTER BE RESCHED FOR HRG ON 10-30-08 @ 3:00 PM. Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  58. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  59. Issue Date: 10/29/2008 Service: MAGISTRATE'S ORDER(J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.42 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000010095 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000010096 Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  60. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON MOTION FOR MEDICAL EXP-NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR ROXANA R LYLE DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 12/16/2008 Time: 3:30 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  61. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER. MTDA & CONTEMPT HRG 10-30-08. PLTF APPEARED AND WAS UNREP BY COUNSEL. DEF APPEARED AND WAS REP BY ATTY DONALD P. MITCHELL, JR. ATTY LYLE APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. UPON AGREEMENT OF THE PARTIES, MAG FINDS THAT CSEA & PLTF SHALL DISMISS THE MOT FOR CONTEMPT AND MOT TO DETERM ARREARS UPON PMNT BY DEF OF $884.11 BY 11-14-08 AND AN ADD $337.37 BEFORE 11-30-08. DEF, WILLIAM E. DYE, JR., SHALL MAKE ALL FUTURE REG SUPPT PMNTS IN THE AMT OF $337.37 + PROC FEE / MO / CHILD(1) THRU ATTACHMENT OF HIS REALITY CHECKING ACCT. HRG ON PLT'S MOT FOR REIMBURSEMENT FOR MED EXP IS SET FOR HRG ON 12-16-08 @ 3:30 PM. DEF TO PAY CC. Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  62. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  63. Issue Date: 12/04/2008 Service: MAGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.59 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000010324 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000010325 Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  64. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER. HRG ON MEDICAL EXP ON 12/16/08. PLTF APPEARED W/O COUNSEL. DEF APPEARED W/ATTY MITCHELL. DEF OWES PLTF $1,448.30 FOR PAST MED EXP FOR THE CHILD. UPON AGREEMT OF THE PARTIES, THIS AMT SHALL BE REDUCED TO JUDGMT. PLTF IS GRANTED JUDGMT AGAINST DEF IN THE AMT OF $1,448.30. COPIES TO ATTY MITCHELL AND M. GOINS CSEA Receipt: 65952 Date: 12/19/2008
  65. COST BILL SENT WILLIAM DYE JR. 6605 S T 5, APT 36, RAVENNA, OH 44266 IN THE AMT OF $10.55 DUE IN FULL BY 1/21/09 COST BILL PLTF VS DEF Sent on: 12/19/2008 08:25:38
  66. NOTICE OF REVISED AMOUNT OF CHILD SUPPORT FILED BY CSEA
  67. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER - PLTF, MONICA M. GOINS, IS THE RP OF THE CHILD. DEF, WILLIAM E. DYE, JR., SHALL BE THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGOR. IF HEALTH INS IS BEING PROVIDED: DEF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $514.15 / MO / CHILD (1) + 2% PROC FEE FOR A TOTAL PMNT OF $524.43 / MO. IF HEALTH INS IS NOT BEING PROVIDED: DEF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $376.97 / MO / CHILD (1) + $112.00 CASH MED SUPPT / MO + 2% PROC FEE FOR A TOTAL PMNT OF $498.75 / MO. 1ST PMNT DUE 8/01/15. HEALTH INS COVERAGE IS CURRENTLY ACCESSIBLE @ REASON COST TO PLTF THRU EMPLOYMENT. NO LATER THAN 30 DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS ORDER, PLTF SHALL OBTAIN HEALTH INS COVERAGE FOR THE CHILD AND PROVIDE WRITTEN PROOF OF SAID COVERAGE TO PCCSEA. PLTF SHALL BE RESPON FOR 66% OF ALL UNINSURED MED EXP & DEF SHALL BE RESPON FOR 34%.
  68. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  69. Issue Date: 08/19/2015 Service: NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT & MAG DEC/ORDER (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $ 0.49 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000028996 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000028997
  70. DEPOSIT PAID BY ATTY MITCHELL ON BEHALF OF WILLIAM DYE Receipt: 84718 Date: 02/08/2017
  71. REVIEW/OBJECTION TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER FILED BY ATTY DON MITCHELL ON BEHALF OF WILLIAM DYE, JR. Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  72. COMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  73. COMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  74. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  75. CIVIL COMPLAINT ASSIGNMENT
  76. LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE TO ATTY MITCHELL REQUESTING LEGIBLE & PROPER IFS IN ORDER TO SET THE MATTER FOR HEARING
  77. **INFORMATIONAL ONLY**NOTICE OF REVISED AMOUNT OF CHILD SUPPORT FILED BY CSEA
  78. **INFORMATIONAL ONLY**REVISED CHILD SUPPORT & CASH MEDICAL SUPPORT ORDER FILED BY CSEA
  79. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  80. Issue Date: 02/21/2017 Service: INFORMATION ONLY**NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT & INFORMATIONAL REVISED CHILD SUPPT & CASH MEDICAL SUPPT ORDER(J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.46 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000033651 Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  81. Issue Date: 02/21/2017 Service: INFORMATION ONLY**NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT & INFORMATIONAL REVISED CHILD SUPPT & CASH MEDICAL SUPPT ORDER(J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.46 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000033652 Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  82. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  83. SUMMONS ISSUED W/ NOH FOR 5/24/17 @ 2:45 PM Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  84. Issue Date: 02/28/2017 Service: SUMMONS-CERTIFIED W/ NOH FOR 5/24/17 @ 2:45 PM, OBJECT TO ADMIN ORDER (J) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $6.77 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: 7266990420600913388 Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  85. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NOTICE TO: WILLIAM E DYE JR NANCY MORRISON DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 05/24/2017 Time: 2:45 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court Result: RESET DUE TO SCHEDULING CONFLICT Result: RESET DUE TO SCHEDULING CONFLICT Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  86. UNSUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL (JUV) Issued : 02/28/2017 Service : SUMMONS-CERTIFIED (J) Served : 03/23/2017 Return : 03/23/2017 On : GOINS, MONICA M Signed By : Reason : (JUV) UNSUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : RETURNED UNCLAIMED. HRG REMAINS SET FOR MAY 24, 2017 AT 2:45 PM. AW NEW INSTRUCT FOR SERVICE FROM ATTY MITCHELL Tracking #: 7266990420600913388
  87. INNER OFFICE MAIL FAILURE OF SERVICE NOTIFICATION - RETURNED UNCLAIMED. HERG REMAINS SET FOR 5/24/17 @ 2:45 PM. AW FOR NEW INSTRUCT FOR SERVICE FROM ATTY MITCHELL Requester Notified Tracking number: 7266990420600913388
  88. INSTRUCTIONS FOR RE-SERVICE
  89. Issue Date: 04/21/2017 Service: SUMMONS W/ NOH FOR 5/24/17 @ 2:45 PM, OBJECT TO ADMIN ORDER (J) Method: REG MAIL W/ CERTIFICATE OF MAILING (JUV) Cost Per: $0.67 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: C000001543 Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  90. HEARING SET: The following event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER scheduled for 05/24/2017 at 2:45 pm has been rescheduled to 5/23/2017 @ 2:45pm: Event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR NANCY MORRISON DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 05/23/2017 Time: 2:45 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court Result: RESET Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  91. MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF THE HRG ORIGINALLY SET FOR 5/24/17 BUT CHANGED TO 5/23/17 DUE TO CLERK ERROR AS COUNSEL FOR DEF HAS A SCHED CONFLICT. Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  92. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - UPON MOT AND FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN, THE HRG SET FOR 5/23/17 @ 2:45 IS HEREBY RESET TO 5/24/17 @ 3:00 PM. COPY TO M. GOINS, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  93. HEARING SET: The following event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER scheduled for 05/23/2017 at 2:45 pm has been rescheduled as follows: Event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO ADMINISTRATIVE ORDER Date: 05/24/2017 Time: 3:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court
  94. LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE E-MAIL RCVD FROM MONICA GOINS OBJECTING TO CONTINUANCE REQUEST BY ATTY MITCHELL
  95. MAGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER - OBJ TO ADMIN ADJ RECOMMENDATION HRG 5/24/17. DEF, WILLIAM DYE, JR. APPEARED AND WAS REP BY ATTY DON MITCHELL. PLTF, MONICA GOINS, APPEARED AND WAS UNREP BY COUNSEL. ATTY MORRISON APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. BASED UPON THE PLEADINGS AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED, INCLUDING THE TESTIMONY OF DEF AND PLTF, AND EXHIBITS INTRODUCED, THE MAG FINDS: DEF HAS A MONTHLY CHILD SUPPORT OBLIGATION FOR MINOR CHILD IN THE AMT OF $514.15 PLUS PROC FEE WHEN HEALTH INS IS PROVIDED AND $376.97, PLUS CASH MEDICAL OF $112.00 PLUS PROC FEE WHEN HEALTH INS IS NOT PROVIDED. THE AAR AMT FOR DEF'S INCOME IS BASED UPON AN INTERNET SEARCH CONDUCTED BY A MOD SPECIALIST EMPLOYED BY CSEA. THERE WAS NO LEGAL BASIS PRESENTED FOR THIS COURT TO ACCEPT THE FIGURES USED IN ADDRESSING MODIFICATION; 4. BASED UPON DEF FEDERAL INCOME TAX RETUIRNS, DEF'S TOTAL INCOME FOR 2015 (EXHIBIT B) AND 2016 (EXHIBIT C); 5. PLTF AND CSEA BOTH SUSPECT DEF INCOME RETURNS ARE NOT INDICATIVE OF WHAT HE TRULY EARNS; 6. UNFORTUNATELY FOR PLTF, SUSPICIONS WITHOUT EVIDENCE CANNOT BE USED BY THIS COURT. WITHOUT SPECIFIC EVIDENCE, SUCH AS FINDINGS FROM A FORENSIC ACCOUNTANT THIS COURT CANNOT SPECULATE AS TO DEF'S ACTUAL EARNINGS; 7. PLTF IS IN PROCESS OF FILING BAKRUPTCY. DEF IS CURRENT W/CHILD SUPPORT OBLIGATION. PLTF'S POTENTIAL BANKRUPTCY IS NOT A FACTOR THIS COURT CAN CONSIDER; 8. DEF DOES NOT HAVE ANY DISABILITIES WHICH WOULD PREVENT HIM FROM WORKING A FULL TIME JOB. ACCORDINGLY, FOR PURPOSES OF THIS HRG, DEF'S ANNUAL INCOME SHALL BE IMPUTED AT MINIMUM WAGE ($16,952.00). 9. THE ATTACHED CHILD SUPPORT COMPUTATION WORKSHEET IS BASED UPON THE INFO PROVIDED TO CSEA, AT THE AAR, WITH A CHANGE BEING MADE TO DEF'S INCOME TO REFLECT THE IMPUTED MINIMUM WAGE AMOUNT. ACCORDINGLY, THE MAGISTRATE DECIDES: DEF'S OBJECTION IS SUSTAINED; 11. EFFECTIVE 01/01/2017, DEF'S MONTHLY CHILD SUPPORT OBLIGATION IS $314.57, PLUS PROC FEE WHEN HEALTH INS IS PROVIDED AND $230.01 AND $0.00 CASH MEDICAL PLUS FEES WHEN HEALTH INS IS NOT PROVIDED; 12. CSEA SHALL PREPARE THE NECESSARY DOCUMENTS TO EFFECTUATE THIS DECISION. COSTS TO FATHER. COPIES TO MONICA GOINES, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA Receipt: 85405 Date: 05/26/2017
  96. DEPOSIT REFUNDED TO: WILLIAM DYE JR Check Issued: 05/30/17 Check #6559 $10.03 Payable to: WILLIAM E DYE JR.
  97. MOTION TO INTERVENE FILED BY CSEA
  98. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER. UPON REQUEST OF PCCSEA, THEIR MOTION FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE IS GRANTED.
  99. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  100. PRAECIPE TO COURT REPORTER FILED BY CSEA
  101. OBJECTIONS TO MAG DEC/JRLE FILED 05-26-17 FILED BY MONICA GOINS
  102. AFFIDAVIT OF INCOME & EXPENSES OF MONICA GOINS - NOT FILLED OUT OR SIGNED
  103. AFFIDAVIT OF INCOME & EXPENSES OF WILLIAM DYE - NOT FILLED OUT OR SIGNED
  104. OBJECTIONS TO MAGISTRATE'S DECISION DATED 05-26-17 & REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT SAID OBJECTIONS FILED BY ATTY MORRISON, CSEA
  105. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  106. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO OBJECT TO MAGISTRATES'S DECISION PENDING RECEIPT OF TRANSCRIPT, FILED BY ATTY MORRISON
  107. Issue Date: 06/08/2017 Service: MOTION & ORDER TO INTERVENE, OBJECTIONS TO THE MAG DEC, MOTION FOR LEAVE TO OBJ TO MAG DEC PENDING RCPT OF TRANSCRIPT Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.46 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000034488 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000034489 DYE JR, WILLIAM E c/o ATTY: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL 3732 FISHCREEK RD #267 STOW, OH 44224 Tracking No: R000034490
  108. JOURNAL ENTRY. PCCSEA REQUEST FOR LEAVE TO FILE AN OBJECTION (SUPPLEMENTAL) IN THIS MATTER IS HEREBY GRANTED. SAID SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTIONS SHALL BE FILED W/IN 10 DAYS OF THE FILING OF THE TRANSCRIPT. COPY TO CSEA, ATTY MITCHELL, M. GOINS
  109. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE RESPONSE TO OBJECTION AFTER TRANSCRIPT IS FILED W/ THE COURT Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  110. MAGISTRATES’S ORDER - UPON MOT AND FOR GOOD CAUSE SHOWN, THE DEF AND HIS COUNSEL ARE GIVEN LEAVE TO FILE A RESPONSE TO PCCSEA. COPY TO M. GOINS, CSEA
  111. TRANSCRIPT OF COURT REPORTER, ELIZABEBETH KEHRES FOR HRG 05-24-17
  112. HEARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON OBJECTIONS TO MAGISTRATE'S DECISION NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR NANCY MORRISON DONALD PAUL MITHCELL JR Date: 07/24/2017 Time: 1:00 pm Judge: BERGER, ROBERT W Location: Portage County Juvenile Court
  113. SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTION TO MAGISTRATE'S DECISION DATED 5/26/2017 FILED BY: Attorney: MORRISON, NANCY (66028)
  114. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  115. Issue Date: 07/10/2017 Service: SUPPLEMENTAL OBJECTION TO MAGISTRATE'S DECISION DATED 5/26/2017(J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.46 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000034739 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; APT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000034740 DYE JR, WILLIAM E c/o ATTY: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL 3732 FISHCREEK RD #267 STOW, OH 44224 Tracking No: R000034741
  116. RESPONSE TO OBJECTION BY INTERVIEWERS Attorney: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL (16178)
  117. JOURNAL ENTRY - HRG ON OBJ 7/24/17. DEF, WILLIAM E. DYE JR., APPEARED AND WAS REP BY ATTY MITCHELL. PLTF, MONICA M. GOINS, APPEARED PRO SE. ATTY MORRISON APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. THE COURT FINDS ON 5/26/17 THE MAG FILED A DEC AFTER HRG ON DEF'S OBJ TO THE ADMIN ORDER. THE ADMIN ORDER AMT OF DEF'S INCOME WAS BASED UPON AN INTERNET SEARCH. DEF SUBMITTED HIS INCOME TAX RETURNS. THE PLTF ALSO TESTIFIED. PLTF AND PCCSEA SUSPECTED DEF WAS NOT REPORTING HIS TRUE INCOME, BUT SUSPICIONS ARE NOT EVIDENCE. THE MAG REJECTED THE INTERNET SEARCH AND IMPUTED DEF'S INCOME @ MIN WAGE. ON 6/07/17 PLTF SENT A LETTER TO THE COURT WHICH WAS DEEMED AS AN OBJ TO THE MAG'S DEC. ON 6/08/17 THE PCCSEA FILED OBJ BASED UPON ITS BELIEF THAT THE MAG FAILED TO PROPERLY GIVE WEIGHT TO THE INTERNET SEARCH, FAILED TO CONSIDER THE HISTORY OF THE CASE AND IGNORED DEF'S INCOME TAX RETURNS. THE PCCSEA'S OBJ WAS SUPPLEMENTED ON 6/08/17. DEF RESPONDED TO THE OBJ ON 7/19/17. AFTER ARGUMENTS OF COUNSEL AND A THOROUGH INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF THE TRANS FROM THE 5/24/17 HRG, THE COURT AGREES W/ THE MAG THAT THE DEF'S OBJ TO THE ADMIN ORDER SHOULD BE SUSTAINED. THE RECORD HAS SPARSE EVIDENCE THAT GAVE WEIGHT TO EITHER PARTY'S ARGUMENTS. THERE WAS HIGH SUSPICION THAT THE DEF WAS NOT REPORTING ALL OF HIS INCOME. THERE WAS NO PROOF THAT SHOULD BE GIVEN ANY WEIGHT AS THE TO HISTORY OF THE CASE OR THE INTERNET SEARCH TO CORROBORATE THE SUSPICION. THE DEF'S INCOME TAXES IN AND OF THEMSELVES DID NOT PROVE HIS INCOME FOR CHILD SUPPT PURPOSES. THE MAG WAS CORRECT IN IMPUTING TO THE DEF'S INCOME AT MIN WAGE. CSEA SHOULD HAVE ASKED THE COURT TO ORDER DEF TO COMPLY W/ ANY REQ THEY MADE TO DISCOVER INCOME SOURCES. THE PLTF AND PCCSEA MAY FILE FOR A MOD OF SUPPT UPON DISCOVERY OF ASSETS THAT CAUSE A CHANGE IN THE SUPPT ORDER IN ACCORDANCE W/ STATUES. THE COURT IS ENTITLED TO REVIEW EVIDENCE, NOT SPECULATE. THE OBJ OF THE PLTF AND PCCSEA ARE HEREBY OVERRULED. EFFECT 1/01/17, DEF'S MONTHLY CHILD SUPPT OBLIG IS $314.57 + PROC FEE WHEN INS IS BEING PROVIDED AND $230.01 / MO + $0.00 CASH MED SUPPT / MO + PROC FEE WHEN INS IS NOT BEING PROVIDED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED THAT PCCSEA SHALL PREPARE ALL NECESSARY DOCS TO EFFECT THIS ORDER. COPY TO M. GOINS, W. DYE, ATTY MITCHELL, CSEA
  118. NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT FILED BY CSEA
  119. MAGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER- PLTF, MONICA GOINS, IS THE RP OF THE MINOR CHILD. DEF, WILLIAM E. DYE, JR, SHALL BE THE CHILD SUPPORT OBLIGOR. EFFECTIVE 01/01/17, IF HEALTH INS IS BEING PROVIDED, DEF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPORT IN THE AMT OF $314.57/MO/CHILD (1) PLUS 2% PROC FEE FOR A TOTAL PYMT OF $320.86/MO. EFFECTIVE 01/01/17, IF HEALTH INS IS NOT BEING PROVIDED, DEF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPORT IN THE AMT OF $230.01/MO/CHILD (1) PLUS 2% PROC FEE AND CASH MEDICAL IN THE AMT OF $0.00/MO FOR A TOTAL PYMT OF $234/61/MO. PRIVATE HEALTH INS IS NOT ACCESSIBLE AT REASONABLE COSTS TO EITHER PARENT. DEF SHALL BE RESP FOR 22% OF ALL UNINSURED MEDICAL EXP AND PLTF SHALL BE RESP FOR 78%.
  120. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  121. Issue Date: 10/26/2017 Service: NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.46 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000035562 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; LOT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000035563
  122. OBJECTIONS AND APPEAL TO ADMIN DECISION OF SUPPORT FILED BY ATTY DONALD P. MITCHELL, JR COPY TO CSEA AND M GOINS
  123. HEARING SET: Event: A CIVIL PRETRIAL ON OBJECTIONS- NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM DYE JR REGINA FRANK DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 05/05/2020 Time: 1:15 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court Result: CONTINUED (J) Result: CONTINUED (J)
  124. INFORMATIONAL ONLY NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORT AND CASH MEDICAL SUPPORT FILED BY CSEA
  125. MAGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER. PLTF IS THE RP OF THE CHILDREN. WILLIAM E DYE JR SHALL BE THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGOR. EFFECT 11/1/2019 OBLIGOR SHALL PAY $448.80/MO, PLUS 2% PROC CHG AND $17.32/MO, PLUS 2% PROC CHG FOR A TOTAL OF $475.44/MO. OBLIGOR SHALL PAY $0.00/MO, PLUS 2% PROC CHG AS PMNT ON ARREARS. OBLIGOR SHALL PAY 53% AND OBLIGEE SHALL PAY 46% OF THE COSTS OF THE UNINSURED MED EXP.
  126. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  127. Issue Date: 02/19/2020 Service: INFORMATIONAL ONLY NOTICE OF REVISED CHILD SUPPORTAND CASH MED SUPPT ORDER & INFORMATIONAL NOTICE OF REVISED AMOUNT OF CHILD SUPPT AND CASH MED SUPPT (J) Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: $0.50 GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000041834 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; LOT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000041835
  128. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER - DUE TO THE CORONAVIRUS (COVID-19) PANDEMIC THIS MATTER IS HEREBY CONTINUED TO A LATER DATE AND TIME. ALL PARTIES SHALL RECEIVE A NEW COURT NOTICE WITH A RESCHEDULED HEARING DATE AND TIME. COPY TO M GOINS, W. DYE JR, ATTY DON MITCHELL, CSEA
  129. HEARING SET: The following event: A CIVIL PRETRIAL scheduled for 05/05/2020 at 1:15 pm has been rescheduled to 7/28/2020 @ 1:30pm: Event: A CIVIL PRETRIAL ON OBJECTIONS NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIAM E DYE JR REGINA FRANK DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 07/28/2020 Time: 1:30 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court
  130. MAGISTRATE'S ORDER. TELEPHONIC HRG ON 7/28/20 ON OBJECTION AND APPEAL OF THE ADMIN HRG DEC. WILLIAM DYE JR APPEARED AND WAS REPRESENTED BY ATTY P MITCHELL, JR. MONICA GOINS, APPEARED AND WAS NOT REPRESENTED BY COUNSEL. MOTHER WAIVED HER RIGHT TO COUNSEL. ATTY REGINA FRANK APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. THE PARTIES DO NOT AGREE TO A RESOLUTION OF THE ISSUES RAISED BY THE PLEADINGS FILED HEREIN. THIS MATTER SHALL THEREFORE BE SCHEDULED FOR TRIAL IN APPROXIMATELY 45 DAYS PURSUANT TO ORC SECTION 3119.61(C) (6). COPY TO CSEA, M GOINS, W. DYE
  131. HEARING SET: Event: A TRIAL ON OBJECTION TO DECISION ON CHILD SUPPORT NOTICE TO: MONICA M GOINS WILLIALM E DYE JR REGINA FRANK DONALD PAUL MITCHELL JR Date: 09/23/2020 Time: 1:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Portage County Juvenile Court
  132. SUBPOENA ISSUED AND FILED BY ATTY DON MITCHELL FOR: APRIL KELLER
  133. SUBPOENA SERVED ON CSEA BY LEAVING AT PLACE OF EMPLOYMENT: APRIL KELLER
  134. LETTER/CORRESPONDENCE FROM MONICA GOINS STATING SHE IS UNABLE TO ATTEND HRG ON 9/23/2020 AS SHE IS OUT OF TOWN
  135. OBJECTIONS TO SUBPOENA FILED BY: Attorney: FRANK, REGINA (84550)
  136. MAGISTRATE'S DECISION. HRG ON 9/23/20. DEF DISPUTES THE INCOMES USED FOR BOTH PLTF AND DEF. DEF APPEARED AND WAS REPRESENTED BY ATTY DONALD MITCHELL JR. PLTF FILED DOCUMENTATION THAT SHE WAS NOT AVAILABLE FOR THE HRG AND WAS NOT PRESENT. ATTY REGINA FRANK APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. BASED UPON THE PLEADINGS AND EVIDENCE PRESENTED, INCLUDED THE TESTIMONY OF FATHER AND EXHIBIT A , THE MAG FINDS: FATHER'S OBJECTION TO THE ADMIN HRG DETERMINATION IS SUSTAINED. PURSUANT TO THE ATACHED CHILD SUPPT COMP WORKHEET, FATHER'S MO CHILD SUPPT OBLIGATION IS $322.58 AND CASH MED OF $10.58, PLUS PROC FEES, FOR A TOTAL OF $339.83/MO EFFECT 1/1/2020. COPY TO CSEA, M GOINS, ATTY MITCHELL, W DYE JR
  137. MAGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER. HRG ON 9/23/20. PLTF WAS UNAVAILABLE FOR APPEARANCE AND WAS NOT REPRESENTED BY COUNSEL. DEF APPEARED AND WAS REPRESENTED BY ATTY DON MITCHELL, JR. ATTY REGINA FRANK APPEARED ON BEHALF OF PCCSEA. THE MAG HEARD STATEMENTS OF THE PARTIES AND OF COUNSEL. PLTF IS THE RP OF THE CHILD. WILLIAM DYE SHALL BE THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGOR. OBLIGOR SHALL PAY $322.58/MO, PLUS PROC FEES AND $10.58/MO, PLUS PROC FEES, FOR CASH MED SUPPT FOR A TOTAL MO OBLIGATION IN THE AMOUNT OF $339.82 EFFECT 1/1/2020. OBLIGOR SHALL PAY 32.67% AND OBLIGEE SHALL PAY 67.33% OF THE COST OF THE UNINSURED MED EXP INCURRED FOR THE CHILD DURING A CALENDAR YEAR THAT EXCEEDS THE TOTAL CASH MEDICAL SUPPT AMOUNT OWED BY THE PARTIES DURING THAT YEAR.
  138. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED BY CSEA
  139. Issue Date: 10/30/2020 Service: MAGISTRATE'S DECISION/ORDER Method: REGULAR MAIL (JUV) Cost Per: GOINS, MONICA M 10141 HAZELTON RD STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: R000043183 DYE JR, WILLIAM E 6605 STATE ROUTE 5; LOT 36 RAVENNA, OH 44266 Tracking No: R000043184 DYE JR, WILLIAM E c/o ATTY: MITCHELL JR, DONALD PAUL 3732 FISHCREEK RD #267 STOW, OH 44224 Tracking No: R000043185
  140. BATCH SCAN: COMPLETE FILE - FILE 2 OF 2
  141. BATCH SCAN: COMPLETE FILE - FILE 1 OF 2
  142. JOURNAL ENTRY: AN ORDER OF TRANSFER PURSUANT TO R.C. 2301.03(P)
  143. CSEA DISPOSITION.
  144. JUDGMENT ENTRY - ACCEPTANCE OF TRANSFER FILED.
  145. JUDGMENT ENTRY FILED.
  146. COPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  147. COPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  148. TERMINATION OF SUPPORT PAYMENTS TO PO CTY WELFARE DEPT FILED (R58).
  149. CSEA NOTICE OF RULE 58 ISSUED TO ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE MONICA M GOINS (PLAINTIFF); CSEA RULE 58 (NOTICE) Sent on: 05/16/2024 10:10:47.84 MONICA M GOINS (PLAINTIFF); MONICA M GOINS (PLAINTIFF);
  150. CSEA NOTICE OF RULE 58 ISSUED TO ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE WILLIAM E DYE JR (DEFENDANT);

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more