Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Clermont County

Court

Clermont County

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-11-09
Status Closed
Type Cvc Other Tort
Docket 121 entries
Disposition voluntary dismissal

Parties

Plaintiff Muse, Shanta
Defendant P 3 K 2 P Llc|Hilton Franchise Holding Llc|Hilton Domestic Operating Company Inc|Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc|Abc Corporation 1 5|Xyz Corporation 1 5|Aetna|Anthem Insurance Companies Inc|Cigna
Photo of Hon. Ferenc Richard P

Judge

Hon. Ferenc Richard P

Clermont County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Docket Entries

  1. Court Room 203
  2. Court Room 203
  3. Court Room 203
  4. Court Room 203
  5. Court Room 203
  6. Complaint, filed Receipt: 297695 Date: 11/09/2023
  7. Classification form, filed
  8. Deposit Received (CV) Receipt: 297695 Date: 11/09/2023
  9. Clerk's fee for indexing
  10. Praecipe for Service: Certified Mail Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  11. Notification form filed Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  12. Per Page Fee Civil case only Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  13. Summons and copy of complaint issued Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  14. Issue Date: 11/14/2023 Service: Summons and Copy of Complaint Method: Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Cost Per: $9.00 P3K2P LLC Payal P. Patel 4402 Hartman Lane Batavia, OH 45103 Tracking No: 7112436946802835278/ 92148901121360000000315068 Hilton Franchise Holding LLC Any Agent 7930 Jones Branch Drive, Suite 1100 McLean, VA 22102 Tracking No: 7112436946802835279/ 92148901121360000000315075 Hilton Domestic Operating Company Inc Any Agent 7930 Jones Branch Drive, Suite 1100 McLean, VA 22102 Tracking No: 7112436946802835280/ 92148901121360000000315082 Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc Any Agent 7930 Jones Branch Drive, Suite 1100 McLean, VA 22102 Tracking No: 7112436946802835281/ 92148901121360000000315099 Aetna CT Corpration System 4400 Easton Commons Way, Suite 125 Columbus, OH 43219 Tracking No: 7112436946802835282/ 92148901121360000000315105 Anthem Insurance Companies Inc Any Agent 120 Monument Circle INDIANAPOLIS, IN 46204 Tracking No: 7112436946802835283/ 92148901121360000000315112 Cigna CT Corporation System 4400 Easton Commons Way, Suite 125 Columbus, OH 43219 Tracking No: 7112436946802835284/ 92148901121360000000315129
  15. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 11/14/2023 Service : Summons and Copy of Complaint Served : 11/21/2023 Return : 12/01/2023 On : P3K2P LLC Signed By : not legible Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking # : 7112436946802835278 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  16. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 11/14/2023 Service : Summons and Copy of Complaint Served : 11/21/2023 Return : 12/01/2023 On : Hilton Domestic Operating Company Inc Signed By : C. Owens Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking # : 7112436946802835280 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  17. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 11/14/2023 Service : Summons and Copy of Complaint Served : 11/20/2023 Return : 12/01/2023 On : Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc Signed By : C. Owens Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking # : 7112436946802835281 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  18. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 11/14/2023 Service : Summons and Copy of Complaint Served : 11/20/2023 Return : 12/01/2023 On : Anthem Insurance Companies Inc Signed By : not legible Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking # : 7112436946802835283 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  19. Answer to Complaint and Affirmative Defenses on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Company DBA Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  20. Notice of Appearance filed Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  21. Initial Disclosures Pursuant to Rule 26(B)(3) on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Company DBA Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  22. DEFENDANTS P3K2P LLC, HILTON FRANCHISE HOLDING LLC, HILTON DOMESTIC OPERATING COMPANY, INC AND HILTON WORLDWIDE HOLDINGS INC'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT; WITH JURY DEMAND AND NOTICE OF SUBMISSION OF DISCOVERY REQUESTS ENDORSED HEREON Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  23. Notification form filed Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  24. Deposit Received (CV) - Jury Demand Receipt: 298596 Date: 12/19/2023
  25. Plaintiff Shanta Muse's Partial Dismissal of Defendants Hilton Franchise Holding, LLC, Hilton Domestic Operating Company, Inc. and Hilton Worldwide Holdings, cc: parties/counsel Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  26. Issue Date: 01/11/2024 Service: Partial Dismissal Method: Ordinary Mail (1-4 sheets) Cost Per: $1.00 Muse, Shanta c/o ATTY: Persinger, Jason Norris Persinger Law, LLC 10700 Montgomery Road Suite 110 Cincinnati, OH 45242 Tracking No: R000142192 P3K2P LLC c/o ATTY: Carlson, John P 9277 Center Pointe Drive Suite 370 West Chester, OH 45069 Tracking No: R000142193 Hilton Franchise Holding LLC c/o ATTY: Carlson, John P 9277 Center Pointe Drive Suite 370 West Chester, OH 45069 Tracking No: R000142194 Hilton Domestic Operating Company Inc c/o ATTY: Carlson, John P 9277 Center Pointe Drive Suite 370 West Chester, OH 45069 Tracking No: R000142195 Hilton Worldwide Holdings Inc c/o ATTY: Carlson, John P 9277 Center Pointe Drive Suite 370 West Chester, OH 45069 Tracking No: R000142196 Anthem Insurance Companies Inc c/o ATTY: Oliver, Lance K 5178 Wheelis Drive Memphis, TN 38117 Tracking No: R000142197 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  27. Praecipe for Service by Certified Mail filed in Civil case Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  28. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil) service copies Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  29. Alias Summons, copy of complaint issued Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  30. Issue Date: 02/16/2024 Service: Alias Summons on Complaint Method: Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Cost Per: $9.00 Aetna 151 Farmington Ave Hartford, CT 06156 Tracking No: 7112436946802836323 Cigna Po Box 182223 Chattanooga, TN 37422 Tracking No: 7112436946802836324
  31. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 02/16/2024 Service : Alias Summons on Complaint Served : 02/24/2024 Return : 03/01/2024 On : Aetna Signed By : Kirk Neville Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking #: 7112436946802836323 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  32. Successful Service (Civil Case) Method : Certified mail; cv case; return receipt requested Issued : 02/16/2024 Service : Alias Summons on Complaint Served : 02/21/2024 Return : 03/01/2024 On : Cigna Signed By : Brandon Jones Reason : Successful Comment : Tracking #: 7112436946802836324 Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  33. Notice of Hearing filed. Event: Scheduling Conference Date: 05/13/2024 Time: 8:30 am Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203 Result: Scheduling conference held
  34. Fee for preparation notice and page fee Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  35. Motion to be Excused on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Company D/B/A Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield Filed CC: Judge w/Order to sign Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  36. Order Granting Motion to Be Excused on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Company D/B/A Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield filed Receipt: 302110 Date: 05/01/2024
  37. Answer, Affirmative Defenses, Cross-Claim and Counterclaim of Defendant Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company
  38. Defendant P3K2P, LLC's Answer to Defendant Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company's Cross-Claim filed
  39. Notice of Deposition of Plaintiff Shanta Muse filed
  40. Hearing held as scheduled The following event: Scheduling Conference scheduled for 05/13/2024 at 8:30 am has been resulted as follows: Result: Scheduling conference held Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203
  41. Notice of Hearing filed. Event: Scheduling Conference Date: 08/19/2024 Time: 8:30 am Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203 Result: Vacated
  42. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  43. Amended Notice of Deposition of Plaintiff Shanta Muse filed
  44. Answer of Plaintiff, Shanta Muse, to Counterclaim of Defendant, Cigna Health and Life Insurance Company filed
  45. Motion to Withdraw as Counsel Filed cc judge
  46. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil)
  47. Notice of Hearing filed. Event: Hearing on Motion Date: 07/22/2024 Time: 10:00 am Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203 Result: Motion granted
  48. Signed Order Setting Motion to Withdraw for Hearing filed
  49. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  50. Motion granted The following event: Hearing on Motion scheduled for 07/22/2024 at 10:00 am has been resulted as follows: Result: Motion granted Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203
  51. Hearing date vacated The following event: Scheduling Conference scheduled for 08/19/2024 at 8:30 am has been resulted as follows: Result: Vacated Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203
  52. Notice of Hearing filed. Event: Scheduling Conference Date: 09/16/2024 Time: 8:30 am Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203 Result: Scheduling conference held
  53. Signed Entry Granting Motion to Withdraw and Setting a Scheduling Conference filed;
  54. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  55. Motion to be Excused on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Company D/B/A Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield cc judge Filed
  56. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil)
  57. Order Granting Motion to be Excused on Behalf of Defendant, Community Insurance Compant D/B/A Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield
  58. Hearing held as scheduled The following event: Scheduling Conference scheduled for 09/16/2024 at 8:30 am has been resulted as follows: Result: Scheduling conference held Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203
  59. Notice of Hearing filed. Event: Scheduling Conference Date: 09/23/2024 Time: 8:30 am Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203 Result: Scheduling conference held
  60. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  61. Hearing held as scheduled The following event: Scheduling Conference scheduled for 09/23/2024 at 8:30 am has been resulted as follows: Result: Scheduling conference held Judge: Ferenc, Richard P Location: Court Room 203
  62. Notice of Voluntary Dismissal of Cross-Claim and Counterclaim without Prejudice filed cc: all parties or counsel of record
  63. Issue Date: 10/01/2024 Service: Dismissal Method: Ordinary Mail (1-4 sheets) Cost Per: $1.00 Muse, Shanta 2260 Siesta Drive Batavia, OH 45103 Tracking No: R000147853 Cigna c/o ATTY: Beck, Jonathon L 130 W. Second Street, Ste. 2000 Dayton, OH 45402 Tracking No: R000147854 P3K2P LLC c/o ATTY: Carlson, John P 9277 Center Pointe Drive Suite 370 West Chester, OH 45069 Tracking No: R000147855 Aetna CT Corpration System 4400 Easton Commons Way, Suite 125 Columbus, OH 43219 Tracking No: R000147856 Anthem Insurance Companies Inc c/o ATTY: Oliver, Lance K 5178 Wheelis Drive Memphis, TN 38117 Tracking No: R000147857
  64. $447.90
  65. Complaint, filed
  66. Classification form, filed
  67. Deposit Received (CV)
  68. Clerk's fee for indexing
  69. Praecipe filed in Civil case
  70. Notification form filed
  71. Per Page Fee Civil case only
  72. Summons and copy of complaint issued
  73. Costs: Certified mail
  74. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  75. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  76. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  77. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  78. Answer filed
  79. Notification form filed
  80. Misc
  81. Answer filed
  82. Notification form filed
  83. Deposit Received (CV)
  84. Entry filed;
  85. Postage, CV-Ordinary Mail, 1-4 sheets
  86. Praecipe filed in Civil case
  87. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil)
  88. Alias Summons, copy of complaint issued
  89. Costs: Certified mail
  90. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  91. Successful Service (Civil Case)
  92. Notice of Hearing filed.
  93. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  94. Motion Filed
  95. Order filed
  96. Cross Claim filed
  97. Answer filed
  98. Notice filed
  99. Hearing held as scheduled
  100. Notice of Hearing filed.
  101. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  102. Notice filed
  103. Answer filed
  104. Motion Filed
  105. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil)
  106. Notice of Hearing filed.
  107. Order filed
  108. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  109. Motion granted
  110. Hearing date vacated
  111. Notice of Hearing filed.
  112. Entry filed;
  113. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  114. Motion Filed
  115. Copies taxed as cost. (Civil)
  116. Order filed
  117. Hearing held as scheduled
  118. Notice of Hearing filed.
  119. Fee for preparation notice and page fee
  120. Hearing held as scheduled
  121. Notice of Dismissal filed cc: all parties or counsel of record

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more