Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Case Information

Filed 2024-04-16
Status CASE CLOSED
Type Other Torts
Docket 100 entries
Disposition dismiss

Parties

Plaintiff Meyer, Sr, Gary D
Defendant Travelers Commercial Casualty Company|Allstate Fire And Casualty Insurance Company|Reese, Adam|Smotherman, Michael|Ace American Insurance Company|Doe Number One Two Three And Four, John

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. COSTS PAID WITH DEPOSIT BILLED TO ADAM REESE REFUND CLARK CRUM WHEN PAID
  2. FEES PAID PURSUANT TO ORC 2303.201C Receipt: 659014 Date:
  3. COST FOR COMPUTER FEE 2303.201B1 Receipt: 659014 Date:
  4. COMPUTERIZED RESEARCH FEE ORC 2303.201A1 Receipt: 659014 Date:
  5. CV GEN'L SPL PROJECTS FUND Receipt: 659014 Date:
  6. COMPLAINT WITH JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREIN FILED 11:04 AM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688740 Date:
  7. PRAECIPE FOR SERVICE- efiling 11:04 AM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  8. NCOURT DEPOSIT Receipt: 659014 Date:
  9. COPIES FOR SERVICE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  10. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Sent On: 12:10:03 Receipt: 688740 Date: 10/22/2025
  11. CERTIFIED MAIL FEE Issue Date: Service: 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Method: CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: 10.0000 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY NOT AVAILABLE C/O CT CORPORATION COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN RD SUITE 4000 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128718 ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY NOT AVAILABLE C/O CT CORPORATION SYSTEMS 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY, SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128719 ADAM REESE HOME ADDRESS 7190 SHAGGY BARK DR WEST CHESTER, OH 45069 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128720 MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN HOME ADDRESS 9742 WOODMILL LN FAYETTE, OH 43521 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128721 Receipt: 688740 Date:
  12. PRAECIPE TO THE CLERK FILED Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  13. COPIES FOR SERVICE Receipt: 688740 Date:
  14. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Sent On: 13:36:16 Receipt: 688740 Date: 10/22/2025
  15. CERTIFIED MAIL FEE Issue Date: Service: 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Method: CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: 10.0000 TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY NOT AVAILABLE C/O CT CORPORATION COMPANY 1160 DUBLIN RD SUITE 4000 COLUMBUS, OH 43215 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128725 ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY NOT AVAILABLE C/O CT CORPORATION SYSTEMS 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY, SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128726 ADAM REESE HOME ADDRESS 7190 SHAGGY BARK DR WEST CHESTER, OH 45069 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128727 MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN HOME ADDRESS 9742 WOODMILL LN FAYETTE, OH 43521 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128728 Receipt: 688740 Date:
  16. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128726
  17. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : REESE, ADAM Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128720
  18. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128719
  19. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128718
  20. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON: REASON: FILED Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL Signed By : Reason : UNSUCCESSFUL Comment : NO SUCH ADDRESS UNABLE TO FORWARD Tracking #: 71042230169001128721
  21. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON: REASON: FILED Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL Signed By : Reason : UNSUCCESSFUL Comment : NO SUCH STREET UNABLE TO FORWARD Tracking #: 71042230169001128728
  22. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE PREPARED FOR DREW R MASSE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  23. EMAILED COPIES TO DREW R MASSE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  24. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Sent On: 14:48:54
  25. CERTIFIED MAIL FEE Issue Date: Service: 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Method: CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: 10.0000 MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN HOME ADDRESS 9742 WOODMILL LN CINCINNATI, OH 45231 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128790
  26. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128790
  27. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON: REASON: FILED Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : 5-SUMMONS ON COMPLAINT Served : Return : on : REESE, ADAM Signed By : Reason : UNSUCCESSFUL Comment : UNCLAIMED UNABLE TO FORWARD Tracking #: 71042230169001128727
  28. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE PREPARED FOR DREEW R MASSE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  29. ANSWER AND CROSSCLAIM OF DEFENDANT ALLSATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY FILED 11:05 AM Applies To: CRUM, CLARK C (Attorney) on behalf of ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (DEFENDANT) Receipt: 688740 Date:
  30. PRAECIPE FOR FOR CERTIFIED MAIL SERVICE OF CROSSCLAIM FILED eFiling submission date: 11:05 AM Applies To: CRUM, CLARK C (Attorney) on behalf of ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (DEFENDANT)
  31. COST FOR COMPUTER FEE 2303.201B1 Receipt: 688735 Date:
  32. COMPUTERIZED RESEARCH FEE ORC 2303.201A1 Receipt: 688735 Date:
  33. CV GEN'L SPL PROJECTS FUND Receipt: 688735 Date:
  34. NCOURT DEPOSIT Applies To: CRUM, CLARK C (Attorney) on behalf of ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (DEFENDANT) Receipt: 660643 Date:
  35. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL FILED eFiling submission date: 03:14 PM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  36. DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S ANSWER TO COMPLAINT WITH JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON FILED eFiling submission date: 03:16 PM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  37. COPIES FOR SERVICE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  38. SUMMONS, COPY OF COMPLAINT CIVIL SUMMONS ON CROSS CLAIM Sent On: 09:06:07 Receipt: 688740 Date: 10/22/2025
  39. CERTIFIED MAIL FEE Issue Date: Service: SUMMONS ON ANSWER AND CROSS CLAIM Method: CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: 10.0000 MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN HOME ADDRESS 9742 WOODMILL LN CINCINNATI, OH 45231 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128926 ADAM REESE HOME ADDRESS 7190 SHAGGY BARK DR WEST CHESTER, OH 45069 Tracking Number: 71042230169001128927 Receipt: 688740 Date:
  40. ANSWER OF DEFENDANT TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY FILED 09:35 AM Applies To: CARBONE, ANTONIA E (Attorney) on behalf of TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY (DEFENDANT)
  41. ELECTRONIC RETURN FILED SIGNED: DATE: Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : SUMMONS ON ANSWER AND CROSS CLAIM Served : Return : on : REESE, ADAM Signed By : Reason : ELECTRONIC RETURN SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001128927
  42. ANSWER OF DEFENDANT SMOTHERMAN TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT W/ JURY DEMAND FILED 08:24 AM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  43. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFF GARY MEYER SR AND DEFENDANT ADAM REESE FILED 08:24 AM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  44. DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S ANSWER TO CROSS-CLAIM OF CO-DEFENDANT ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY WITH JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON FILED eFiling submission date: 01:27 PM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  45. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON: REASON: FILED Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : SUMMONS ON ANSWER AND CROSS CLAIM Served : Return : on : SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL Signed By : Reason : UNSUCCESSFUL Comment : UNCLAIMED UNABLE TO FORWARD Tracking #: 71042230169001128926
  46. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE PREPARED FOR CLARK C CRUM Receipt: 688735 Date:
  47. EMAILED COPIES TO CLARK C CRUM Receipt: 688735 Date:
  48. DEFENDANT SMOTHERMAN'S ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM OF DEFENDAT ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY FILED 08:38 AM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  49. NOTICE OF SERVICE FILED Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  50. DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S NOTICE TO TAKE REMOTE VIDEO DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFF GARY D. MEYER, SR. FILED eFiling submission date: 10:52 AM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  51. NOTICE OF PARTIAL VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL FILED Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688735 Date:
  52. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE A FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  53. SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL FILED 11:39 AM Applies To: CAMPBELL, REBECCA L (Attorney) on behalf of TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY (DEFENDANT)
  54. CASE CONFERENCE ORDER FILED Receipt: 688735 Date:
  55. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  56. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT Receipt: 688740 Date:
  57. ORDER FILED Receipt: 688735 Date:
  58. EMAILED COPIES TO COUNSEL Receipt: 688740 Date:
  59. COPIES FOR SERVICE Receipt: 688740 Date:
  60. PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON FILED Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688740 Date:
  61. SUMMONS, COPY OF AMENDED COMPLAINT ISSUED BY CERTIFIED MAIL TO DEFENDANTS CIVIL SUMMONS ON AMENDED COMPLAINT 5 DEFENDANTS Sent On: 11:04:59 Receipt: 688735 Date: 10/22/2025
  62. CERTIFIED MAIL FEE Issue Date: Service: SUMMONS ON AMENDED COMPLAINT 5 DEFENDANTS (CV) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL Cost Per: 10.0000 CLARK C CRUM BUSINESS ADDRESS ALLSTATE STAFF COUNSEL PO BOX 2166 HUDSON, OH 44236 Tracking Number: 71042230169001129527 JONATHON L BECK HOME ADDRESS 130 W SECOND ST; SUITE 2000 DAYTON, OH 45402 Tracking Number: 71042230169001129528 SUNDEEP A MUTGI HOME ADDRESS 603 ALPHA DR BOX ON11 HIGHLAND HEIGHTS, OH 44143 Tracking Number: 71042230169001129529 ACE AMERICAN INSURANCE COMPANY HOME ADDRESS C/O CT CORPORATION SYSTEM 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY COLUMBUS, OH 43219 Tracking Number: 71042230169001129530 Receipt: 688740 Date:
  63. SUMMONS RETURNED SERVED: DATE: FILED Method : CERTIFIED MAIL Issued : Service : SUMMONS ON AMENDED COMPLAINT 5 DEFENDANTS (CV) Served : Return : on : BECK, JONATHON L Signed By : Reason : PERSONAL SERVICE RETURNED SUCCESSFUL Comment : Tracking #: 71042230169001129528
  64. AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFF GARY MEYER, SR. AND DEFENDANT ADAM REESE FILED eFiling submission date: 03:10 PM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  65. ANSWER OF DEFENDANT SMOTHERMAN TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FILED 11:31 AM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  66. NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 41(A) OF DEFENDANT, TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY, ONLY FILED eFiling submission date: 11:07 AM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688735 Date:
  67. DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S ANSWER TO FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITH JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON FILED eFiling submission date: 04:17 PM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  68. NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 41(A) OF DEFENDANT ACE AMERICAN, ONLY FILED 02:52 PM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688740 Date:
  69. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  70. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT Receipt: 688740 Date:
  71. SCHEDULING ORDER FILED Receipt: 688740 Date:
  72. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT Receipt: 688740 Date:
  73. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  74. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  75. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  76. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  77. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT Receipt: 688740 Date:
  78. DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S NOTICE TO TAKE REMOTE VIDEO DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFF GARY D. MEYER, SR FILED eFiling submission date: 01:42 PM Applies To: BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT)
  79. NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 41(A) OF DEFENDANT ALLSTATE FIRE & CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, ONLY FILED 02:34 PM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688735 Date:
  80. DEFENDANT ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANYS NOTICE OF DISMISSAL OF CROSSCLAIM AGAINST DEFENDANTS ADAM REESE AND MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN FILED eFiling submission date: 02:37 PM Applies To: CRUM, CLARK C (Attorney) on behalf of ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (DEFENDANT) Receipt: 688735 Date: Receipt: 688740 Date: 10/22/2025
  81. AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF ADAM REESE FILED 12:11 PM Applies To: MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT)
  82. MEDIAITON ORDER FILED Receipt: 688735 Date:
  83. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  84. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT TO: CAMPBELL, REBECCA L (Attorney) on behalf of TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY (DEFENDANT); CARBONE, ANTONIA E (Attorney) on behalf of TRAVELERS COMMERCIAL CASUALTY COMPANY (DEFENDANT); MUTGI, SUNDEEP A (Attorney) on behalf of SMOTHERMAN, MICHAEL (DEFENDANT); MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF); CRUM, CLARK C (Attorney) on behalf of ALLSTATE FIRE AND CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY (DEFENDANT); BECK, JONATHON L (Attorney) on behalf of REESE, ADAM (DEFENDANT) Receipt: 688740 Date:
  85. ASSIGNMENT NOTICE FILED
  86. COPIES EMAILED BY COURT Receipt: 688740 Date:
  87. NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 41(A) OF DEFENDANT MICHAEL SMOTHERMAN, ONLY FILED 11:11 AM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF) Receipt: 688735 Date:
  88. EXHIBIT LIST FILED DEFENDANT ADAM REESE'S DISCLOSURE OF EXPERT WITNESSES eFiling submission date: 10:53 AM
  89. PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE EXPERT WITNESS LIST INSTANTER FILED 10:39 AM Applies To: MASSE, DREW R (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  90. ORDER FILED Receipt: 688735 Date:
  91. EMAILED COPIES TO DREW MASSE AND JONATHON BECK Receipt: 688735 Date:
  92. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE FILED 01:16 PM Applies To: BOISSONEAULT, KEVIN J (Attorney) on behalf of MEYER, SR, GARY D (PLAINTIFF)
  93. PROPOSED ORDER PRINTED LOCAL RULE 19.08 Receipt: 688735 Date:
  94. STIPLUATION OF DISMISSAL FILED 01:19 PM Receipt: 688740 Date: 10/22/2025
  95. EMAILED COPIES TO DREW MASSE, KEVIN BOISSONEAULT, ANDREW NASH & JONATHON BECK Receipt: 688740 Date:
  96. COST BILL MAILING FEE Receipt: 688735 Date:
  97. COST BILL FILED
  98. PREPAID COSTS PAID WITH DEPOSIT REFUND GALLON LAW WHEN PAID
  99. COST BILL MAILED REESE, ADAM was sent bill for $703.70 printed on
  100. COSTS PAID WITH DEPOSIT BILLED TO ADAM REESE REFUND GALLON LAW WHEN PAID

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase