Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Case Information
Filed
2023-10-27
Status
OPEN
Type
Professional Malparactice Other Professional
Docket
161 entries
Parties
Plaintiff
Wisman, Carolyn Kay|Wisman, James Oscar
Defendant
Bay County Health System Llc|Davidson, Peter L|Simmons, Shiloh|Rodney, Jean Francois|Hni Hospital Services Of Florida Llc|Bay County Health System Llc, Registered Agent Corporate Service Company
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- EP - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC MOTION TO DISMISS I OF PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR A MORE DEFINITE STATEMENT
- EP - NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF PLAINTIFFS CAROLYN WISMAN AND JAMES WISMAN
- EP DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY M D ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSESTO PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL
- EP - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH RULE 2.516 AND DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESS
- EP - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
- EP - NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY
- EP - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESS FOR DEFENDANTS
- EP - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE - SERVED BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC 01/05/23
- EP - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS REQUEST FOR COPIES
- EP - DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESS FOR RECEIPT OF SERVICE
- EP - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
- EP - DEFENDANT SHILOH SIMMONS ARNO AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFFS
- EP - DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS NOTICE OF PROPOUNDING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMAN
- EP - DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS NOTICE OF PROPOUNDING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN KAY WISMAN
- PAYMENT $10.00 RECEIPT #2024000763
- EP - SUMMONS FOR SERVICE ON CORPORATION- ISSUED-BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM, LLC REGISTERED AGENT:CORPORATE SERVICE COMPANY
- EP - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
- EP - PETER DAVIDSON DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF JAMES WISMAN
- EP - PETER DAVIDSON DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMAN
- EP - PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES
- EP - PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMAN
- EP - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF EMAILS FOR DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DO
- EP - PETER DAVISON DOS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
- EP - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESS
- EP - DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESS
- PAYMENT $400.00 RECEIPT #2023057787
- ORDER REQUIRING GOOD FAITH CONFERRAL AND REVIEW OF PROCEDURES RELATED TO CIVIL DISCOVERY MATTERS
- STANDING CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER
- EP - INITIAL COMPLAINT
- EP - CIVIL COVER SHEET
- PLAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY: HIGBY, CLIFFORD C ASSIGNED
- JUDGE GOODMAN, JAMES J JR: ASSIGNED
- DIVISION E ASSIGNED
- CASE TYPE : PROFESSIONAL MALPARACTICE OTHER PROFESSIONAL
- CIVIL-OTHER FILING FEES ASSESSED $400.00
- P - PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF TAKING VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF BRESLIN HOLDER R
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILIT
- EARING - CIVIL SET FOR 05/07/2025 AT 2:45 PM IN J/ , JDG: GOODMAN, JAMES J J
- P - NOTICE OF HEARIN
- P - DEFENDANTS, JEAN RODNEY, M.D., NOTICE OF SERVICE OF VERIFIED ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS, CAROLYN WISMAN, INTERROGATORIE
- P - DEFENDANTS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLCS DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTIE
- P - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL FOR DEFENANTS AND DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRES
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY, M.D., RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIO
- P - DEFENDANTS, JEAN RODNEY, M.D., NOTICE OF SERVICE OF UNVERIFIED ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS, CAROLYN WISMAN, INTERROGATORIE
- IVIL JURY TRIAL SET FOR 01/20/2026 AT 8:30 AM IN TBA/ , JDG: GOODMAN, JAMES J J
- EARING - CIVIL SET FOR 12/17/2025 AT 9:00 AM IN J/ , JDG: GOODMAN, JAMES J J
- P - ORDER SETTING CAUSE FOR TRIAL AND PRE-TRIAL CONFERENC
- P -PLAINTIFFS AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON M
- P - PLAINTIFFS AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY M
- P - PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF TAKING VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON M
- P - PARTIAL COMPLIANCE WITH REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - PLAINTIFFS NOTICE OF TAKING VIDEO DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY M
- P - DEFENDANTS HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FLORIDA LLC & SHILOH SIMMONS ARNPS RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIO
- P - DEFENDANT SHILOH SIMMONS ARNPS NOTICE OF SERVING UNVERIFIED ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS FIRST INTERROGATORIE
- P - DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS NOTICE OF SERVING UNVERIFIED ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS FIRST INTERROGATORIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF SERVICE OF UNVERIFIED ANSWERS TO PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS REQUEST TO PRODUC
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DO S REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF SERVING VERIFIED RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS FIRST INTERROGATORIE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON, DO'S NOTICE OF SERVING UNVERIFIED RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS'FIRST INTERROGATORIE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON, DO'S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS' FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIO
- P - NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF CAROLYN KAY WISMANS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY, M.DS INTERROGATORIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS REQUEST TO PRODUC
- P - PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS MEDICARE MEDICAID REQUEST TO PRODUC
- P - NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMANS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS INTERROGATORIE
- P - NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMANS ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS CONSORTIUM INTERROGATORIE
- P - NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMANS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS INTERROGATORIE
- P - NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY MDS MEDICARE MEDICAID INTERROGATORIE
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANTJEAN RODNEY M
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANTJEAN RODNEY M
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LL
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST TO PRODUCE TO DEFENDANT BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LL
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT SHILOH SIMMONS ARN
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON D
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY M
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LL
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS INTERROGATORIES TO DEFENDANT BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LL
- P -DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DO'S NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMA
- P - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FLORIDA LLCS REQUEST FOR COPIES TO COPIES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY M
- P - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP & HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FLORIDA LLCS REQUEST FOR COPIES TO DEFENDANT JEAN RODNEY M
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANT'S, BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM, LLC, D/B/A ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY, CROSS-NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECU
- P - DEFENDANT'S, BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM, LLC, D/B/A ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY, CROSS-NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECU
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DO S REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PARTIE
- P - NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PART
- P - NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILITY- BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BA
- P - AMENDED DESIGNATION OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EMAIL ADDRESSES OF COUNSE
- P - AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION AUGUST 7 2024 9A
- P - NOTICE OF VIDEO CONFERENCE DEPOSITIO
- P - NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILIT
- P - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP & HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS REQUEST FOR COPIES TO DEFENDAN
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NO-PART
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - AMENDED NOTICE OF TAKING DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF PLAINTIFFS CAROLYN WISMAN AND JAMES WISMA
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS REQUEST FOR COPIES TO DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON D
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES INTERROGATORIE
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS INTERROGATORIE
- P - NOTICE OF SERVING PLAINTIFFS ANSWERS TO DEFENDANT BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEMS INTERROGATORIE
- P - PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMANS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSONS DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT
- P - PLAINTIFF CAROLYN KAY WISMANS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT
- P - PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT
- P - PLAINTIFFS RESPONSES TO DEFENDANT BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAYS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENT
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY MD REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY MD REQUEST FOR PRODUCE TO PLAINTIFFS IN COMPLIANCE WITH MEDICARE MEDICAID SECONDARY PAYOR AC
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY MD REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY MD NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY MD NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFF
- P - DEFENDANTS JEAN ROSNEY M D CONSORTIUM INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMA
- P - PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DO S NOTICE OF PRODUCTION FROM NON-PART
- P - AMENDED DESIGNATION OF PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EMAIL ADDRESS OF COUNSE
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DO S REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF JAMES WISMA
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTIO
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMA
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC MOTION TO DISMISS I OF PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR A MORE DEFINITE STATEMEN
- P - NOTICE OF DEPOSITION DUCES TECUM OF PLAINTIFFS CAROLYN WISMAN AND JAMES WISMA
- P DEFENDANTS JEAN RODNEY M D ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSESTO PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIA
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF COMPLIANCE WITH RULE 2.516 AND DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRES
- P - DEFENDANTS BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC DBA ASCENSION SACRED HEART BAY NOTICE OF APPEARANC
- P - NOTICE OF UNAVAILABILIT
- P - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRESS FOR DEFENDANT
- P - AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE - SERVED BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM LLC
- P - DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON DOS REQUEST FOR COPIE
- P - DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRESS FOR RECEIPT OF SERVIC
- P - NOTICE OF APPEARANC
- P - DEFENDANT SHILOH SIMMONS ARNO AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF
- P - DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS NOTICE OF PROPOUNDING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF JAMES OSCAR WISMA
- P - DEFENDANT HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS NOTICE OF PROPOUNDING FIRST INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN KAY WISMA
- AYMENT $10.00 RECEIPT
- P - SUMMONS FOR SERVICE ON CORPORATION- ISSUED-BAY COUNTY HEALTH SYSTEM, LLC REGISTERED AGENT:CORPORATE SERVICE COMPAN
- P - DEFENDANTS SHILOH SIMMONS ARNP AND HNI HOSPITAL SERVICES OF FL LLCS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF JAMES WISMA
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DOS FIRST REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMA
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIE
- P - PETER DAVIDSON DOS NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES TO PLAINTIFF CAROLYN WISMA
- P - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF EMAILS FOR DEFENDANT PETER DAVIDSON D
- P - PETER DAVISON DOS ANSWER AND AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE
- P - NOTICE OF APPEARANCE AND DESIGNATION OF E-MAIL ADDRES
- P - DESIGNATION OF EMAIL ADDRES
- AYMENT $400.00 RECEIPT
- RDER REQUIRING GOOD FAITH CONFERRAL AND REVIEW OF PROCEDURES RELATED TO CIVIL DISCOVERY MATTER
- TANDING CIVIL CASE MANAGEMENT ORDE
- P - INITIAL COMPLAIN
- P - CIVIL COVER SHEE
- LAINTIFF'S ATTORNEY: HIGBY, CLIFFORD C ASSIGNE
- UDGE GOODMAN, JAMES J JR: ASSIGNE
- IVISION E ASSIGNE
- ASE TYPE : PROFESSIONAL MALPARACTICE OTHER PROFESSIONA
- IVIL-OTHER FILING FEES ASSESSED $400
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In
