Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Portage Co

Court

Portage Co

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-06-20
Status CLOSED
Type Dr Never Married
Docket 59 entries
Disposition other terminations

Parties

Plaintiff Babkoff, Brian D
Defendant Esenwein, Andrea
Photo of Hon. Carnes Thomas J Probate

Judge

Hon. Carnes Thomas J Probate

Portage County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. SEA NOTICE OF RULE 58 ISSUED TO ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE CSEA ATTY (Attorney) on behalf of PO CTY DEPT OF JOB & FAMILY SERVICES (INTERVENOR)
  2. ATERNITY COMPLAINT, MOT TO ESTABLISH A PARENTING TIME SCHED FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG (CSEA) Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  3. USTODY AFFIDAVIT
  4. NSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE
  5. OMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  6. OMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  7. UMMONS ANSWER AND NOTICE OF HEARING FOR APRIL 26, 2010 AT 2:00PM Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  8. ssue Date: 03/30/2010 Service: SUMMONS-COMPLAINT W/RETURN FOR COMPL FOR PATERNITY SET FOR APRIL 26, 2010 AT 2:00PM (J) Method: PERSONAL SERVICE (JUV) Provider: BAILIFF Cost Per: $ ESENWEIN, ANDREA C 5054 SUNNYBROOK ROAD KENT, OH 44240 Tracking No: P000010445
  9. EARING SET: Event: A CIVIL PRETRIAL - NOTICE TO: BRIAN D BABKOFF ROBERT EVAN ROSENBERG Date: 04/26/2010 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  10. UCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : PERSONAL SERVICE (JUV) Issued : 03/30/2010 Service : SUMMONS-COMPLAINT W/RETURN (J) Served : 03/30/2010 Return : 03/31/2010 On : ESENWEIN, ANDREA C Signed By : SERVING ANDREA ESENWEIN Reason : (JUV) SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: P000010445
  11. AGISTRATE'S ORDER. PRETRIAL CONF ON APRIL 26, 2010. ON THAT DATE THE PARTIES ENTERED INTO AN AGREEMENT AND ATTY ROSENBERG, ADVISED THE COURT THAT AN ENTRY WOULD BE SUBMITTED WITHIN 21 DAYS. TO DATE THE ENTRY HAS NOT BEEN SUBMITTED. IF THE ENTRY IS NOT FILED BY JUNE 9, 2010 THIS MATTER SHALL BE SCHED FOR HRG TO IMPOSE SANCTIONS AGAINST COUNSEL FOR PLTF. COPIES TO ATTY ROSENBERG, AND A. ESENWEIN Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010
  12. AGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER. 6/14/2010 PARTIES ENTERED INTO AN AGREED ENTRY, MOTHER SHALL BE THE PRIMARY RESIDENTIAL PARENT FOR SCHOOL PURPOSES. SHARED PARENTING PLAN ATTACHED AS EXHIBIT A. CHILD SUPPORT ADMIN ORDER EST ON OR ABOUT 2/17/2010 ATTACHED HERETO AS EXHIBIT B. WHEN PRIVATE HEALTH INS IS BEING PROVIDED CHILD SUPPORT WILL BE $516.52 PER MONTH. WHEN PRIVATE INS IS NOT BEING PROVIDED CHILD SUPPORT WILL BE $424.07 PLUS PROCESS FEE CASH MEDICAL WILL BE $86.25 PER MONTH PLUS PROCESS FEE. MEDICAL WILL BE PROVIDED EQUALLY BY PARENTS. FATHER SHALL HAVE VISITS WITH CHILD 7 WKS PER YEAR PURSUANT TO HIS WORK SCHED. HOLIDAYS SHALL BE ACCORDING TO COURT STANDARD PARENTING TIME ATTACHED AS EXHIBIT C. COPIES TO ATTY ROSENBERG AND A ESENWEIN, CSEA (5PROV) Receipt: 69681 Date: 06/15/2010 Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  13. OST BILL SENT TO BRIAN BABKOFF 5607 LAKEWOOD RD. RAVENNA, OHIO 44266 IN THE AMT OF $6.41 DUE BY 7/17/2010 COST BILL PLTF VS DEF Sent on: 06/15/2010 09:41:35
  14. ETURN OF CN SENT TO BRIAN BABKOFF 5607 LAKE WOOD RD RAVENNA, OHIO 44266 MARKED RETURN TO SENDER NOT DELIVERABLE AS ADDRESSED UNABLE TO FORWARD
  15. ETURN OF COST BILL SENT TO BRIAN BABKOFF, 5607 LAKEWOOD RD, RAVENNA OH 44266 MARKED " RET TO SENDER, NOT DELIV AS ADDRESSED"
  16. EFENDANT'S NOTICE OF INTENT TO RELOCATE FILED BY ATTY ROUBIC
  17. .C.C.J.E.A. AFFIDAVIT
  18. X PARTE MOT. FOR IMMEDIATE CUST. OF THE PARTIES' MINOR CHILD WITH INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICES Attorney: ROSENBERG, ROBERT EVAN (42690) Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  19. X-PARTE EMERGENCY MOTION TO RETURN THE MINOR CHILD TO THE STATE OF OHIO WITH INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE Attorney: ROSENBERG, ROBERT EVAN (42690)
  20. X PARTE MOTION FOR AN EMERGENCY RESTRAINING ORDER WITH INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE Attorney: ROSENBERG, ROBERT EVAN (42690)
  21. OTION FOR GUARDIAN AD LITEM Attorney: ROSENBERG, ROBERT EVAN (42690)
  22. OTION FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT WITH INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE & NOH FOR 12-14-15 AT 3:00 PM Attorney: ROSENBERG, ROBERT EVAN (42690) Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  23. .C.C.J.E.A. AFFIDAVIT
  24. OMPUTERIZED RESEARCH Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  25. OMPUTERIZATION FEE Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  26. EPOSIT - FILING FEE RCVD FROM ATTY ROSENBERG Receipt: 82120 Date: 11/04/2015
  27. UMMONS ISSUED FOR 11-18-15 HEARING AT 10:00 AM AND 12-14-15 PRETRIAL AT 3:00 PM Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  28. ssue Date: 11/04/2015 Service: SUMMONS FOR 11-18-15 HRG AT 10:00 AM & 12-14-15 PRETRIAL AT 3:00 PM(J) Method: PERSONAL SERVICE (JUV) Provider: BAILIFF Cost Per: $ ESENWEIN, ANDREA C 1310 VANTAGE WAY STREETSBORO, OH 44241 Tracking No: P000020250
  29. EARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON EX-PARTE MOTIONS AND MOTION FOR GUARDIAN AD LITEM-NOTICE TO: BRIAN BABKOFF ROBERT ROSENBERG Date: 11/18/2015 Time: 10:00 am Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  30. EARING SET: Event: AN ADULT PRETRIAL -NOTICE TO: BRIAN BABKOFF ROBERT ROSENBERG Date: 12/14/2015 Time: 3:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Result: CONTINUED (J)
  31. UCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : PERSONAL SERVICE (JUV) Issued : 11/04/2015 Service : SUMMONS(J) Served : 11/06/2015 Return : 11/06/2015 On : ESENWEIN, ANDREA C Signed By : TOM ESENWEIN Reason : (JUV) SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: P000020250
  32. EFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLTF'S MOTIONS TO RETURN CHILD TO THE STATE OF OHIO, IMMEDIATE CUST, RESTRAINING ORDER AND MOTION FOR CONTEMPT FILED BY ATTY ROUBIC
  33. AGISTRATE'S ORDER. MATTER CAME ON FOR HRG ON EX PARTE MOTIONS ON 11/18/2015. PLTF APPEARED WITH ATTY ROSENBERG. DEF APPEARED WITH ATTY ROUBIC. PARTIES WILL ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE THE ISSUE THROUGH THE PC DOMESTIC RELATIONS MEDIATION PROGRAM. A HEARING WILL BE HELD IN ABEYANCE. PARTIES WILL BE GRANTED 30 DAYS LEAVE TO FILE ANY ADDITIONAL MOTIONS. THE REQUEST FOR GAL WILL BE RULED ON AT NEXT HEARING. PRETRIAL FOR 12/14/2015 WILL BE RESET IN 45 DAYS ALONG WITH A STATUS CONF. MOTHER AGREES THAT SHE WILL NOT PERMANENTLY RELOCATE OUTSIDE THE STATE OF OH WITH THE MINOR CHILD. COPIES TO ATTY ROUBIC, ATTY ROSENBERG Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  34. EARING SET: The following event: AN ADULT PRETRIAL AND STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled for 12/14/2015 at 3:00 pm has been rescheduled TO 1/4/16 AT 2:00 PM-NOTICE TO: BRIAN BABKOFF ANDREW ESENWEIN MELISSA ROUBIC ROBERT ROSENBERG Event: AN ADULT PRETRIAL Date: 01/04/2016 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Result: CONTINUED (J) Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016
  35. EARING SCHEDULED: Event: MEDIATION SESSION Date: 12/14/2015 Time: 9:00 am Judge: ANTOGNOLI, BENITO CR Location: DR MEDIATION CONFERENCE ROOM
  36. OTICE OF MEDIATION SESSION FILED BY DOMESTIC RELATIONS DIV
  37. OTION FOR CUSTODY FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG Receipt: 82742 Date: 02/29/2016 Receipt: 82843 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt 82843 reversed by 82844 on 03/16/2016. Receipt: 82845 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt: 83015 Date: 04/13/2016
  38. OTION TO ADOPT THE ATTACHED SPP FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG
  39. OTION TO MODIFY VISITATION FILED BY ATTY ROUBIC Receipt: 83015 Date: 04/13/2016
  40. OTION TO MODIFY THE PARTIES CURRENT COMPANIONSHIP TIME SCHED FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG
  41. EARING SET: Event: A HEARING ON DEFENDANT'S MOTION TO MODIFY COMPANIONSHIP TIME AND PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO MODIFY THE PARTIES' CURRENT COMPANIONSHIP TIME SCHEDULE-NOTICE TO: ANDREA ESENWEIN BRIAN BABKOFF MELISSA ROUBIC ROBERT ROSENBERG Date: 01/04/2016 Time: 2:00 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 82843 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt 82843 reversed by 82844 on 03/16/2016. Receipt: 82845 Date: 03/16/2016
  42. EFENDANT'S OBJECTION TO FATHER'S PROPOSED SHARED PARENTING PLAN Attorney: ROUBIC, MELISSA R V (65953)
  43. OTION FOR CONTINUANCE FOR 01-04-16 FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG DUE TO SCHED CONFLICT
  44. AGISTRATE'S ORDER MOTION FOR CONT FILED BY ATTY ROSENBERG FOR HRG ON 01/4/2016 HAS BEEN GRANTED AND RESET FOR 01-29-16 AT 2:45 PM. COPY TO ATTY ROSENBERG, ATTY ROUBIC (3 PROV) Receipt: 82843 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt 82843 reversed by 82844 on 03/16/2016. Receipt: 82845 Date: 03/16/2016
  45. EARING SET: Event: AN ADULT PRETRIAL, STATUS CONFERENCE AND ALL MOTIONS CONTINUED FROM 1-4-16 NOTICE TO: BRIAN BABKOFF ADREA ESENWEIN (BOTH ADDRESS IN FILE) MELISSA ROUBIC ROBERT ROSENBERG Date: 01/29/2016 Time: 2:45 pm Judge: SZYMANSKI, JOSEPH Location: Receipt: 82843 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt 82843 reversed by 82844 on 03/16/2016. Receipt: 82845 Date: 03/16/2016
  46. AGISTRATE'S DEC./ORDER. 01-29-16 AGREED ORDER. PLTF, BRIAN BABKOFF IS REPRES BY ATTY ROSENBERG. DEF, ANDREA ESENWEIN IS REPRES BY ATTY ROUBIC. THE PARTIES HAVE ONE CHILD TO WITT LILLIAN & HAVE COME TO THE FOLLOWING AGREEMENT: DEF SHALL REMAIN THE R/P FOR SCHOOL PURPOSES ONLY & SHALL BE PERMITTED TO RELOCATE WITH THE CHILD TO MICHIGAN. PLTF SHALL HAVE VISIT PURS TO THE COURT'S STANDARD OUT-OF-STATE VISIT SCHED, ATTACHED HERETO. UNTIL DEF RELOCATES WITH THE CHILD, PLTF SHALL HAVE VISIT ON ALTERNATING WKNDS FROM FRI 5 PM TO SUN AT 1 PM. DURING THE WEEKS IN WHICH DEF HAS VISIT FOR THE WKND, PLTF SHALL HAVE VISIT FROM THURS AT 5 PM UNTIL FRI MORNING & HE WILL TAKE THE CHILD TO SCHOOL ON TIME. WHEN THE DEF HAS RELOCATED OUT OF STATE, DEF SHALL BE RESPON FOR PROVIDING THE TRANSPORTATION FOR THE PLTF'S STANDARD OUT-OF-STATE VISIT. DURING THE SUMMERS, THE PARENTS SHALL ALTERNATE PARENTING TIME TWO WEEKS AT A TIME FOR THE ENTIRE SUMMER BREAK. ANY SCHOOL TUITION, FEES OR OTHER SCHOOL EXPENSES OR EXTRACURRICULAR ACTIVITIES SHALL BE DIVIDED EQUALLY BETWEEN THE PARTIES. PLTF, FATHER IS THE CHILD SUPPT OBLIGOR. EFFECT 07-01-16 ON THE 1ST DAY OF THE MONTH WHEN PRIV HEALTH INS IS BEING PROV PLTF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $356.85/MO + 2% PROC CHRG. IF PRIV HEALTH INS IS NOT BEING PROV, PLTF SHALL PAY CHILD SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $319.88/MO + 2% PROC FEE. PLTF SHALL PAY CASH MEDICAL SUPPT IN THE AMT OF $86.25/MO + 2% PROC CHRG. BOTH PARENTS ARE RESPON FOR HEALTH CARE NEEDS OF THE CHILD. PLTF FATHER SHALL BE RESPON FOR 57% OF MED EXP & DEF MOTHER SHALL BE RESPON FOR 43%. COST IN EXCESS OF DEPOIST SHALL BE DIVIDED BETWEEN THE PARTIES. COPY TO ATTY ROUBIC, ATTY ROSENBERG, CSEA ( 3 PROV) Receipt: 82843 Date: 03/16/2016 Receipt 82843 reversed by 82844 on 03/16/2016. Receipt: 82845 Date: 03/16/2016
  47. OST BILL SENT TO BRIAN BABKOFF, 5607 LAKEWOOD RD, RAVENNA OH 44266 IN THE AMT OF $29.92 DUE IN FULL BY 03-29-16 COST BILL PLTF VS DEF Sent on: 02/29/2016 12:37:28
  48. OST BILL SENT TO ANDREA ESEWEIN, 13010 VANTAGE WAY, STREETSBORO OH 44241 IN THE AMT OF $29.91 DUE IN FULL BY 03-29-16 COST BILL PLTF VS DEF Sent on: 02/29/2016 12:38:45
  49. UNC PRO TUNC ENTRY. THE 02-25-16 AGREED ORDER SHALL BE CLARIFIED TO REFLECT THE PLTF-FATHER, BRIAN BABKOFF DOES NOT PROVIDE PRIV MED INS FOR THE CHILD. PRIV HEALH INS COVERAGE IS NOT ACCESSIBLE AT A REAS COSTS TO EITHER PARENT. FATHER SHALL BE RESPON FOR 50% OF THE HEALTH CARE NEEDS OF THE CHILD & DEF-MOTHER, ANDREA ESENWEIN SHALL BE RESPON FOR 50%. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, FATHER SHALL PAY CASH MED SUPPT DURING ANY PERIOD IN WHICH THE CHILD IS NOT COVERED BY PRIV HEALTH INS PURS TO THE ORDER. THE CASH MED SUPPT SHALL BE PAID IN THE AMT AS DETERMINED BY THE CHILD SUPPT COMP WORKSHEET. COPY TO ATTY ROSENBERG, ATTY ROUBIC, CSEA (4 PROV)
  50. ATCH SCAN
  51. OURNAL ENTRY: AN ORDER OF TRANSFER PURSUANT TO R.C. 2301.03(P)
  52. ATCH SCAN: COMPLETE FILE
  53. UDGMENT ENTRY - ACCEPTANCE OF TRANSFER FILED.
  54. UDGMENT ENTRY FILED.
  55. OPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  56. OPY ISSUED TO DOMESTIC COURT.
  57. ERMINATION OF SUPPORT PAYMENTS TO PO CTY WELFARE DEPT FILED (R58).
  58. SEA NOTICE OF RULE 58 ISSUED TO ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE BRIAN D BABKOFF (PLAINTIFF); CSEA RULE 58 (NOTICE) Sent on: 06/29/2023 12:07:58.79 BRIAN D BABKOFF (PLAINTIFF);
  59. SEA NOTICE OF RULE 58 ISSUED TO ATTYS/PARTIES BY REGULAR MAIL OR FACSIMILE ANDREA ESENWEIN (DEFENDANT);

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more