Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Dekalb County

Court

Dekalb County

Georgia

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-12-15
Status Open
Type Tort Wrongful Death
Docket 188 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Randall, Dawn
Defendant Atlanta Heart Specialists, Llc | Alikhani, Zoubin, M.d. | Boston Scientific Corporation
Photo of Hon. Bailey, Charles E

Judge

Hon. Bailey, Charles E

Dekalb County

Georgia

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. 12/15/2023 Complaint Comment Damages
  2. 12/15/2023 Summons Comment Summons - Atlanta Heart Specialists
  3. 12/15/2023 Summons Comment Summons - Dr. Alikhani
  4. 12/15/2023 Summons Comment Summons - Boston Scientific Corporation
  5. 12/20/2023 Affidavit of Service Comment Affidavit of Service (Atlanta Heart Specialists)
  6. 12/21/2023 Affidavit of Service Comment Affidavit of Service (Boston Scientific)
  7. 12/28/2023 Affidavit of Service Comment 12/28/23 - Personal Service
  8. 01/17/2024 Answer Comment Boston Scientific Corporation's Answer to Complaint for Damages
  9. 01/17/2024 Motion Comment Boston Scientific Corporation's Motion to Dismiss
  10. 01/17/2024 Brief Filed Comment Brief in Support of Motion to Dismiss
  11. 01/17/2024 Stipulation Comment Stipulation
  12. 01/22/2024 Answer Comment ANSWER OF ZOUBIN ALIKHANI, M.D. AND ATLANTA HEART SPECIALISTS, L.L.C. TO PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT
  13. 02/01/2024 Entry of Appearance Comment Entry of Appearance - Max Thelen for Plaintiffs
  14. 02/01/2024 Entry of Appearance Comment Entry of Appearance - Drew Ashby for Plaintiffs
  15. 02/14/2024 Response Comment Plaintiff's Brief in Opposition to Boston Scientific Corporation's Motion to Dismiss
  16. 02/14/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  17. 02/21/2024 Request Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corp.'s Request for Oral Hearing
  18. 02/27/2024 Motion Comment Application of Peter Mullenix to Appear Pro Hac Vice
  19. 03/13/2024 Letter Comment Letter from State Bar re: Application for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Peter Mullenix
  20. 03/19/2024 Order Comment Peter Mullenix admitted Pro Hac Vice
  21. 04/11/2024 Entry of Appearance Comment Notice of Entry of Appearance
  22. 04/25/2024 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment Leave of Absence - Max Thelen
  23. 05/05/2024 Notice of Hearing Comment Hearing set for 06/05/2024 at 1:30 PM
  24. 05/07/2024 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment Leave of Absence - LAP
  25. 05/14/2024 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment LOA - RPM
  26. 05/23/2024 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment Notice of Leave of Absence
  27. 05/28/2024 Certificate of Discovery Comment Certificate of Service of Discovery
  28. 06/05/2024 Motions Judicial Officer Bailey, Charles E. Hearing Time 1:30 PM
  29. 06/14/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service for Defendant's First Interrogatories and Requests for Production of Documents to Plaintiff
  30. 06/21/2024 Order Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corp.'s Motion to Dismiss is Denied
  31. 07/08/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  32. 07/08/2024 Summons Comment Summons to BSC
  33. 07/10/2024 Rule 5.2 Comment Rule 5.2 - Certificate of Service
  34. 07/19/2024 Entry of Service Comment 07/12/24-- Notor Service
  35. 07/24/2024 Rule 5.2 Comment RULE 5.2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  36. 07/29/2024 Motion to Compel Comment Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation to Respond to Discovery
  37. 07/29/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  38. 07/31/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Rule 5.2 - Certificate of Service
  39. 08/08/2024 Answer Comment Boston Scientific Corporation's Answer to Complaint for Damages
  40. 08/21/2024 Consent Agreement Comment Consent Motion to Extend Discovery Period
  41. 08/27/2024 Order Comment Consent Motion to Extend Discovery through April 14, 2025 is Granted
  42. 08/28/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Zoubin Alikhani, M.D.
  43. 08/28/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Tom Dlugos
  44. 08/28/2024 Response Comment Boston Scientific Corporation's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel
  45. 08/28/2024 Request Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation's Request for Oral Argument
  46. 08/29/2024 Response Comment Reply in Further Support of Plaintiff's Motion to Compel
  47. 08/29/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  48. 09/10/2024 Certificate of Discovery Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  49. 09/11/2024 Order Comment Plaintiff's Motion to Compel is Granted
  50. 10/01/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  51. 10/07/2024 Response Comment Objection to Request for Production of Documents
  52. 10/08/2024 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment RPM -LOA
  53. 10/17/2024 Motion Comment Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions Against Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation
  54. 10/21/2024 Motion Comment Supplemental Brief in Support of Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions Against Boston Scientific
  55. 10/28/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  56. 10/29/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment FIRST AMENDED NOTICE TO TAKE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF ZOUBIN ALIKHANI, M.D.
  57. 10/29/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment NOTICE TO TAKE VIDEOTAPED DEPOSITION OF LEAH PARK, PA
  58. 10/31/2024 Response Comment Boston Scientific's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions
  59. 10/31/2024 Request Comment Boston Scientific's Request for Oral Argument
  60. 11/01/2024 Response Comment Plaintiff's Reply in Support of Motion for Sanctions Against Boston Scientific Corporation
  61. 11/01/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Boston Scientific Corporation
  62. 11/01/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  63. 11/07/2024 Certificate of Discovery Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery
  64. 11/12/2024 Order Comment See Order on Plaintiff's Motion for Sanctions
  65. 11/19/2024 Notice Comment Notice of Filing of Attorneys Fees Affidavits in Support of Sanctions Order
  66. 11/21/2024 Notice Comment Verified Application for Admission Pro Hac Vice
  67. 11/29/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment First Amended Notice of Videotaped 30(b)(6) Deposition of Boston Scientific Corporation
  68. 12/02/2024 Certificate of Discovery Comment Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's Second Requests for Production to BSC
  69. 12/02/2024 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Tony Bacigalupi
  70. 12/02/2024 Notice Comment Notice of Filing of Plaintiff's Proposed HIPAA Order
  71. 12/03/2024 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  72. 12/10/2024 Notice of Appearance Comment Notice of Appearance of Counsel (Elizabeth Catherine Helm, Sanjay Ghosh, Meghan Pittman)
  73. 12/17/2024 Certificate of Service Comment CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  74. 12/20/2024 Notice Comment Notice of Filing
  75. 12/23/2024 Notice Comment Notice of Filing
  76. 12/23/2024 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service
  77. 01/04/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Second Amended Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition of Boston Scientific Corporation
  78. 01/07/2025 Order Comment HIPAA Compliant Qualified Protective Order
  79. 01/21/2025 Amended Comment Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint for Damages
  80. 01/29/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment Notice of Leave of Absence - Sanjay Ghosh (March 3, 2025 - March 10, 2025)
  81. 01/30/2025 Stipulation Comment Stipulation Extending Time for BSC to File Motion to Dismiss and Answer Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint
  82. 02/02/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment RPM - LOA
  83. 02/03/2025 Amended Comment Second Amended Complaint
  84. 02/03/2025 Certificate of Service Comment Certificate of Service
  85. 02/14/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Third Amended Notice of 30(b)(6) Deposition (Continuation)
  86. 02/14/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment First Amended Notice of Deposition of Tom Dlugos (Continuation)
  87. 02/21/2025 Answer Comment Defendant BSC's Answer to Second Amended Complaint for Damages
  88. 02/21/2025 Motion to Dismiss Comment Defendant BSC's Motion to Partially Dismiss Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint for Damages
  89. 02/21/2025 Brief Filed Comment Brief in Support of Defendant BSC's Motion to Partially Dismiss Plaintiff's Second Amended Complaint for Damages
  90. 02/25/2025 Response Comment Plaintiff's Brief in Opposition to Defendant Boston Scientific's Motion to Dismiss the Second Amended Complaint
  91. 02/26/2025 Certificate of Service Comment Rule 5.2 Certificate of Service
  92. 03/03/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service
  93. 03/05/2025 Substitution of Counsel Comment NOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
  94. 03/10/2025 Notice Comment Notice of Filing
  95. 03/11/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Wyatt Stahl
  96. 03/14/2025 Motion Comment Motion to Amend January 7, 2025 HIPAA Compliant Qualified Protective Order
  97. 03/17/2025 Order Comment Amended HIPAA Compliant Qualified Protective Order
  98. 03/19/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery - BSC's First Discovery Requests to Plaintiff
  99. 03/19/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery - BSC's First Discovery Requests to Plaintiff
  100. 03/20/2025 Notice Comment State Bar of Georgia - Letter Regarding Mary Novacheck's Pro Hac Vice Application
  101. 03/20/2025 Order Comment Application for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Mary Novacheck is Granted
  102. 03/20/2025 Change Of Address Comment Notice of Address Change
  103. 03/28/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Ali Naughton
  104. 03/28/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Thomas Hamilton
  105. 03/28/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Maria Macuare Gorden, M.D.
  106. 03/28/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Rich Dujmovic
  107. 03/31/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Notice to Take Deposition of Plaintiff Dawn Randall
  108. 04/18/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery - Notices of Deposition
  109. 04/24/2025 Rule 5.2 Comment RULE 5.2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  110. 05/05/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Continued Videotaped Deposition of Zoubin Alikhani M.D.
  111. 05/05/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment First Amended Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Maria Gorden M.D.
  112. 05/05/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment First Amended Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Ali Naughton
  113. 05/05/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment First Amended Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Rich Dujmovic
  114. 05/07/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - BSC's Non-Party Requests for Production of Documents
  115. 05/12/2025 Brief Filed Comment Boston Scientific Corp.'s Reply Brief in Support of its Motion to Partially Dismiss Plaintiff's 2nd Amended Complaint
  116. 05/15/2025 Order Comment Boston Scientific's Motion to Partially Dismiss is Denied
  117. 05/16/2025 Motion Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation's Motion for Protective Order
  118. 05/16/2025 Request Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation's Request for Oral Hearing
  119. 05/20/2025 Response Comment Plaintiff's Opposition to BSC's Motion for Protective Order and Cross Motion to Compel
  120. 05/21/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Responses to Boston Scientific Corp's NPRPDs
  121. 05/27/2025 Rule 5.2 Comment RULE 5.2 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
  122. 06/05/2025 Response Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation's Reply to Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion for Protective Order and Cross Motion to Compel
  123. 06/05/2025 Objection Comment Objection to Request for Production of Documents to Non-Party View Point Health
  124. 06/05/2025 Response Comment Plaintiff's Sur-Reply in Opposition to BSC's Motion for Protective Order and Cross Motion to Compel
  125. 06/13/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Rich Dujmovic
  126. 06/13/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Aaron Dunbar
  127. 06/13/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Tom Hamilton
  128. 07/10/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Suzanne Carpenter
  129. 07/14/2025 Order Comment Order on Motion for Protective Order and Cross Motion to Compel
  130. 07/18/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Amended Notice to Take Videotaped Deposition of Zoubin Alikhani, M.D.
  131. 07/22/2025 Rule 5.2 Comment Certificate of Service
  132. 08/06/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Tom Hamilton
  133. 08/06/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Kesler
  134. 08/06/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Tom Hamilton
  135. 08/06/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Kesler
  136. 08/06/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment Leave of Absence - James Foster
  137. 08/07/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Northside Hospital's Response to Boston Scienficit Corp.'s NPRPDs
  138. 08/19/2025 Certificate of Discovery Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Discovery to Boston Scientific Corporation
  139. 08/20/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Notice of Deposition of Anthony Dorsey M.D
  140. 08/20/2025 Motion Comment Consent Motion for Extension of Discovery and for Entry of Scheduling Order
  141. 08/25/2025 Order Comment Scheduling Order
  142. 09/02/2025 Amended Comment Third Amended Complaint for Damages
  143. 09/05/2025 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Northside Hospital's Supplemental Response to Boston Scienficit Corp.'s NPRPDs
  144. 09/12/2025 Notice Comment Notice of Withdrawal as Counsel
  145. 09/15/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment RPM LOA
  146. 09/23/2025 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Non-Party Elutia Inc.
  147. 09/25/2025 Order Comment Agreed Protective Order
  148. 10/03/2025 Certificate of Discovery Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's Sixth RPDs to Boston Scientific
  149. 10/03/2025 Certificate of Discovery Comment 5.2 Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's Second RPDs to AHS and Dr. Alikhani
  150. 10/03/2025 Certificate of Discovery Comment Certificate of Service of Plaintiff's First RFAs to Dr. Zoubin Alikhani
  151. 10/15/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Kenneth Kachmar
  152. 10/20/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Kenneth Stein, M.D.
  153. 10/21/2025 Request Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corp.'s Election to Have Fault and Damages Determined in Specific Phases
  154. 10/23/2025 Response Comment Plaintiff's Objection and Notice of Preservation Concerning Boston Scientific's Election for Trifurcation
  155. 11/03/2025 Amended Comment First Amended Notice of Videotaped Deposition of Ken Kachmar
  156. 11/05/2025 Consent Agreement Comment Consent Motion to Amend Scheduling Order
  157. 11/05/2025 Consent Order Comment Proposed Consent Order Amending Scheduling Order
  158. 11/06/2025 Amended Comment First Amended Notice of Deposition of Dr. Ken Stein
  159. 11/07/2025 Motion Comment Defendant Boston Scientific Corporation's Motion for Protective Order
  160. 11/10/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment LOA - RPM 2026
  161. 11/10/2025 Order Comment Amended Scheduling Order
  162. 11/13/2025 Motion Comment DEFENDANTS ATLANTA HEART SPECIALISTS, LLC???S AND ZOUBIN ALIKHANI, M.D.???S MOTION TO JOIN DEFENDANT BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORPORATION???S ELECTION TO HAVE FAULT AND DAMAGES DETERMINED IN SPECIFIC PHASES
  163. 11/13/2025 Rule 5.2 Comment 5.2 Certificate of service
  164. 11/13/2025 Rule 5.2 Comment 5.2 Certificate of service
  165. 11/21/2025 Response Comment Plaintiff's Opposition to Boston Scientific's Motion for Protective Order and Cross Motion to Compel and for Sanctions
  166. 12/01/2025 Motion Comment Verified Application of Alana K. Bassin for Admission Pro Hac Vice
  167. 12/01/2025 Notice of Deposition Comment Second Amended NOVD of Dr. Ken Stein
  168. 12/01/2025 Notice Comment Plaintiff's Expert Witness Designations
  169. 12/08/2025 Notice of Leave of Absence Comment LEAVE OF ABSENCE FOR MAXWELL K. THELEN
  170. 12/12/2025 Certificate of Discovery Comment AHS & Alikani's Supp. Resp. to 2nd RPDs
  171. 12/15/2025 Letter Comment Letter from State Bar re: Application for Admission Pro Hac Vice of Alana Bassin
  172. 12/15/2025 Order Comment Application for Pro Hac Vice Admission of Alana K. Bassin is Granted
  173. 12/22/2025 Brief Filed Comment Boston Scientific Corp.'s Reply in Support of Motion for Protective Order and In Opposition to Plaintiff's Cross Motion to Compel and for Sanctions
  174. 12/22/2025 Request Comment Boston Scientific Corp.'s Request for Hearing on Plaintiff's Motion to Compel and for Sanctions
  175. 01/05/2026 Certificate of Discovery Comment Def. AHS and Alikjhani's Rule 5.2
  176. 01/05/2026 Certificate of Service Comment 5.2 COS - Boston Scientific Corp.'s Expert Witness Disclosures
  177. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Dr. Sandeep Goyal
  178. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Greenberg Traurig
  179. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Dr. Rod Passman
  180. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Reed Smith
  181. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Dr. Donna-Bea Tillman
  182. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Kim Trautman
  183. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Veritext
  184. 01/10/2026 Notice Comment Notice of Subpoena to Dr. Jane Wilcox
  185. 01/12/2026 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Rajat Deo, M.D.
  186. 01/12/2026 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Michael M. Baden, M.D.
  187. 01/12/2026 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Patrick J. Blomberg, M.D.
  188. 01/12/2026 Notice of Deposition Comment Notice of Deposition of Alan Schwartz

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more