Which Lawyers Win Before Your Judge?

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know Your Judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know The Lawyers

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know Your Court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Alaska Unified

Court

Alaska Unified

Alaska

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-08-09
Status Reopened
Type Eviction Superior Court (3 Pa)|Eviction Superior Court (may Include Rent And Damages)
Docket 85 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Mackie, Marcia|Mackie, John
Defendant Herseim, Harley
Photo of Hon. Cagle John C

Judge

Hon. Cagle John C

Anchorage Borough (AK)

Alaska

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Electronic Delivery of Case Documents (Opt-In) Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff);
  2. Complaint for Eviction Receipt: 2114180 Date: 08/09/2023
  3. Notice to Quit
  4. Summons and Notice to Both Parties of Judicial Assignment
  5. Return of Service - Summons Served On: 8/22/2023 Harley Herseim (Defendant);
  6. Entry of Appearance Harley Herseim (Defendant);
  7. Notice Referring Case to Superior Court
  8. Order (removing case to Superior Court)
  9. Transfer to Superior Court Jurisdiction
  10. Administrative Judicial Reassignment
  11. Additional Filing Fee Due Receipt: 2128153 Date: 10/05/2023
  12. Notice of Change of Contact Information Daisy Borders (Attorney) on behalf of Harley Herseim (Defendant)
  13. Unopposed Motion for 30-Day Extension of Time Attorney: Borders, Daisy (2211091) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #1
  14. Entry of Appearance - Not accepted for filing / Not a party Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063)
  15. Order Granting Unopposed Motion for 30-Day Extension of Time Case Motion #1 Unopposed Motion for 30-Day Extension of Time
  16. Attorney Information - Entry of Appearance on Record Attorney Condie, Craig S representing Plaintiff Mackie, Marcia as of 09/20/2023 Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff);
  17. Unopposed Motion to Join Additional Plaintiff Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia Case Motion #2
  18. Entry of Appearance Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff);
  19. Answer to Complaint for Forcible Entry and Detainer & Counterclaim to Quiet Title (PPK only) Daisy Borders (Attorney) on behalf of Harley Herseim (Defendant)
  20. Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Join Additional Plaintiff Case Motion #2 Unopposed Motion to Join Additional Plaintiff
  21. Attorney Information Attorney Condie, Craig S representing Mackie, John as of 10/17/2023
  22. Demand for Jury Trial Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  23. Plaintiffs' Amended Answer to Counterclaim to Quiet Title Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff); John Mackie (Plaintiff); ; Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  24. Motion for Withdrawal of Attorney with Client Consent Attorney: Borders, Daisy (2211091) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #3
  25. Order Granting Motion for Withdrawal of Attorney with Client Consent Case Motion #3 Motion for Withdrawal of Attorney with Client Consent
  26. Attorney Information Attorney Borders, Daisy dismissed/withdrawn for Defendant Herseim, Harley on 03/18/2024
  27. Motion for Summary Judgment Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia; Mackie, John Case Motion #4
  28. Opposition to Motion (linked to motion) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Case Motion #4: Motion for Summary Judgment
  29. Reply to Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff) Case Motion #4: Motion for Summary Judgment
  30. Plaintiff's Witness List (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  31. Order Granting Motion for Summary Judgment Case Motion #4
  32. Attorney Information Attorney Lancaster, Amanda Michelle representing Defendant Herseim, Harley as of 01/28/2025
  33. Plaintiff's Trial Brief (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  34. Trial Brief (PPK only) Amanda Michelle Lancaster (Attorney) on behalf of Harley Herseim (Defendant)
  35. Motion for Extension of Time (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #5
  36. Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Correct Address in Writ of Assistance Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia; Mackie, John Case Motion #6
  37. Motion to Correct Address in Writ of Assistance Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia; Mackie, John Case Motion #7
  38. Motion for Expedited Consideration of Motion to Correct Address in Writ of Assistance Deemed Moot Case Motion #6
  39. Order Granting Motion to Correct Address in Writ of Assistance Case Motion #7
  40. Motion to Exceed Page Limit (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #8
  41. Motion for Reconsideration (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #9
  42. Motion for Expedited Consideration of: Motion for Stay (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #10
  43. Motion for Stay (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #11
  44. Order Denying MMotion to Exceed Page Limit (PPK only) Case Motion #8
  45. Order Granting Motion for Expedited Consideration of: Motion for Stay (PPK only) Case Motion #10
  46. Order Inviting Response to Motion for Expedited Consideration and Underlying Motion. Response Due: 2/13 4:15 PM, Reply due 2/14 8 AM Case Motion #10: Motion for Expedited Consideration of: Motion for Stay (PPK only), Case Motion #11: Motion for Stay (PPK only)
  47. Non-Opposition to Expedited Consideration and Opposition to Motion for Stay (2 Pleadings 1 Filing)(PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff) Case Motion #10: Motion for Expedited Consideration of: Motion for Stay (PPK only)
  48. Opposition to Motion for Stay (2 Pleadings 1 Filing)(PPK only) Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff); John Mackie (Plaintiff); Case Motion #11: Motion for Stay (PPK only)
  49. Order Granting Motion for Stay (PPK only) Case Motion #11
  50. Motion for Extension of Time Deemed Moot Case Motion #5
  51. Reply to Opposition to Motion for Stay (PPK only) Amanda Michelle Lancaster (Attorney) on behalf of Harley Herseim (Defendant) Case Motion #11: Motion for Stay (PPK only)
  52. Notice of Filing Response Pursuant to Court's February 14, 2025, Order on Motion for Stay (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  53. Order Denying Motion for Reconsideration (PPK only) Case Motion #9
  54. Plaintiffs' Trial Brief (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  55. Trial Brief (PPK only) Amanda Michelle Lancaster (Attorney) on behalf of Harley Herseim (Defendant)
  56. Plaintiff's Witness List (PPK only) Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie, John Mackie (Plaintiff)
  57. Request to Appear by Telephone (PPK only) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #12
  58. Order Granting Request to Appear by Telephone Case Motion #12 Request to Appear by Telephone (PPK only)
  59. Request to Appear by Telephone Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Harley Herseim (Defendant); Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #13
  60. Notice of Filing Unsigned Financial Declaration Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Harley Herseim (Defendant);
  61. Order Granting Motion on Record Herseim, Harley Case Motion #13 Request to Appear by Telephone
  62. Civil Deficiency Memo mailed re: You did not serve the other side with the Request to Appear by Telephone. You must give the other side in the case copies of every document you file in court. This is called service. Do one of the following: If you are using TrueFiling, and the other side is also using TrueFiling or provided an email address to the court, you can complete service in TrueFiling; or Fill out the certificate of service section at the end of the form; or File a separate certificate of service form that includes: the documents served, who you served, when you did service, and how you provided copies to the other side in the case. You can use Certificate of Service (form TF-700), available at ak-courts.info/tf700. Civil Rules 5(f) and 5.1(c)(3). Administrative Bulletin 92 Civil Deficiency Memo (6/25) Sent on: 07/23/2025 12:08:47.00 Harley Herseim (Defendant);
  63. CD/Tape Duplication Receipt: 2311128 Date: 08/19/2025 Receipt 2311128 reversed by 2311178 on 08/19/2025. should have been cash, not cc Receipt: 2311181 Date: 08/19/2025
  64. Log Notes: Non-Jury Trial
  65. Log Notes: Trial Call
  66. Witness List Non-Jury Trial
  67. Hearing Findings Taken Under Advisement Judge Cagle, John Christian (1102009) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia; Mackie, John; Herseim, Harley Case Motion #14
  68. Log Notes: Non-Jury Trial
  69. Exhibit List (Form TF-200 or TF-201) For Plaintiff (Non-Jury Trial)
  70. Exhibit List (Form TF-200 or TF-201) For Defendant (Non-Jury Trial)
  71. Court Order: Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law (Damages)
  72. Motion to Withdraw with Client Consent Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #15
  73. Consent for Withdrawal of Attorney (link to motion) Case Motion #15: Motion to Withdraw with Client Consent
  74. PROOF OF SERVICE
  75. Proposed Judgment for Attorney's Fees (Creates Motion Record) Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Filing Party: Mackie, Marcia; Mackie, John Case Motion #16
  76. Notice of Filing Judgment for Attorney's Fees (linked to motion) Case Motion #16: Proposed Judgment for Attorney's Fees (Creates Motion Record)
  77. PROOF OF SERVICE
  78. Motion for Extension of Time Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Filing Party: Herseim, Harley Case Motion #17
  79. PROOF OF SERVICE
  80. Opposition to Entry of Judgment (linked to motion) Attorney: Lancaster, Amanda Michelle (NA20399) Case Motion #16: Proposed Judgment for Attorney's Fees (Creates Motion Record)
  81. PROOF OF SERVICE
  82. Reply to Opposition to Entry of Judgment (linked to motion) Attorney: Condie, Craig S (0507063) Case Motion #16: Proposed Judgment for Attorney's Fees (Creates Motion Record)
  83. PROOF OF SERVICE
  84. Order Granting Motion for Extension of Time Herseim, Harley Case Motion #17 Motion for Extension of Time
  85. (Non-Jury Trial RE:Damages 09/24/25) Exhibits to Storage RM#134 / PLT x1 Manilla Envelope Craig S Condie (Attorney) on behalf of Marcia Mackie (Plaintiff) 3PA-23-02085CIEX3PA-112

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more