Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Case Information

Filed 2023-09-01
Status INACTIVE
Type Tort Other Malpractice
Docket 87 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Estate Of Robert Voytek, Deceased By And Through Charles Voytek, Administrator|Estate Of Carol Voytek, Deceased By And Through Michele Trgo, Executrix
Defendant Progressive Quality Care, Inc.|Progressive Macedonia, Llc Dba Avenue At Macedonia|Progressive Macedonia Real Estate, Inc.|Haitham Azem Md
Photo of Hon. HOLLIE L GALLAGHER

Judge

Hon. HOLLIE L GALLAGHER

Cuyahoga County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CASE FILED: COMPLAINT
  2. COURT COST ASSESSED PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC. BILL AMOUNT 77.9 PAID AMOUNT 62.5 AMOUNT DUE 15.4
  3. COURT COST ASSESSED PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC BILL AMOUNT 77.9 PAID AMOUNT 62.5 AMOUNT DUE 15.4
  4. COURT COST ASSESSED PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC. BILL AMOUNT 77.9 PAID AMOUNT 62.5 AMOUNT DUE 15.4
  5. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702972) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: CHRISTOPHER F MARS [email protected]
  6. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702971) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  7. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702970) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  8. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702969) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  9. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702968) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: JOHN M MOSCARINO [email protected]
  10. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702967) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: TIMOTHY A SPIRKO [email protected]
  11. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702966) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: GEORGE M MOSCARINO [email protected]
  12. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702965) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PAUL W MC CARTNEY [email protected]
  13. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702964) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PAUL W MC CARTNEY [email protected]
  14. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702963) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MICHAEL A HILL [email protected]
  15. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702392) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  16. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702391) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  17. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702390) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MARGO S MEOLA [email protected]
  18. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702389) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: CHRISTOPHER F MARS [email protected]
  19. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702388) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: JOHN M MOSCARINO [email protected]
  20. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702387) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MICHAEL A HILL [email protected]
  21. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702386) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: TIMOTHY A SPIRKO [email protected]
  22. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702385) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PAUL W MC CARTNEY [email protected]
  23. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702384) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PAUL W MC CARTNEY [email protected]
  24. JUDGMENT ENTRY(55702383) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: GEORGE M MOSCARINO [email protected]
  25. PLAINTIFF HAVING FILED A NOTICE OF DISMISSAL, CASE DISMISSED WITH PREJUDICE. COURT COST ASSESSED TO THE DEFENDANT(S). PURSUANT TO CIV.R. 58(B), THE CLERK OF COURTS IS DIRECTED TO SERVE THIS JUDGMENT IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY CIV.R. 5(B). THE CLERK MUST INDICATE ON THE DOCKET THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ALL PARTIES, THE METHOD OF SERVICE, AND THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THIS SERVICE. NOTICE ISSUED
  26. NOTICE FILED BY D4 HAITHAM AZEM ATTORNEY GEORGE M MOSCARINO 0019447 NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL AS COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT
  27. COURT COST ASSESSED ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED BILLED C/O ATTY BILL AMOUNT 289.52 PAID AMOUNT 250 AMOUNT DUE 39.52
  28. COURT COST ASSESSED ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED BILL AMOUNT 289.52 PAID AMOUNT 250 AMOUNT DUE 39.52
  29. UPON NOTIFICATION BY PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL THAT THE CASE HAS SETTLED, THE COURT ORDERS THE PARTIES TO SUBMIT A DISMISSAL ENTRY WITHIN 60 DAYS. THE CASE IS REMOVED FROM THE ACTIVE DOCKET OF JUDGE HOLLIE L. GALLAGHER. COSTS TO BE ASSESSED IN THE FINAL ENTRY. COURT COST ASSESSED AS DIRECTED. NOTICE ISSUED
  30. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF SUSAN ENGEMAN
  31. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF DEBORAH WOODFORD
  32. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF BARBARA LEHMAN
  33. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF WILLIAM MEYERT
  34. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF LORI CONTRERAS
  35. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF SARAH (PROKASY) MCINTYRE
  36. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF GINA MANCINI
  37. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF KEYONNA MAGWOOD
  38. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF KAREN VOYTEK
  39. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF DAVID VOYTEK
  40. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF CHARLES VOYTEK
  41. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF CAROL VOYTEK
  42. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF BARBARA VOYTEK
  43. NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING THE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF MICHELLE TRGO
  44. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2) MICHAEL A HILL 0088130. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF MOLLY B. MORRIS
  45. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFENDANT, PROGESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, LLC 05/02/2024 - MOOT
  46. NOTICE FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC.(D1), PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC(D2) and PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC.(D3) ATTORNEY PAUL W MC CARTNEY 0040207 EXPERT DISCLOSURE OF DEFENDANTS, PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC., PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC DBA AVENUE AT MACEDONIA, AND PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC.
  47. NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS FILED PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2), MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM AFFILIATION AND ADDRESS OF COUNSEL FOR PLAINTIFF
  48. NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2) FILED PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF VIDEO DEPOSITION OF BILL MEYER, BARB LEHMAN, AND KAREN STIER
  49. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2) ATTORNEY MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVING DEFENDANTS WITH PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF VIDEO DEPOSITION OF CORPORATE DEFENDANTS ON FEBRUARY 5, 2024
  50. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2) ATTORNEY MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF DISCLOSURES OF EXPERT WITNESSES
  51. NOTICE FILED BY PLAINTIFF(S) ESTATE OF ROBERT VOYTEK, DECEASED(P1) and ESTATE OF CAROL VOYTEK, DECEASED(P2) ATTORNEY MICHAEL A HILL 0088130 PLAINTIFFS' NOTICE OF SERVING EXPERT REPORTS AND CURRICULUM VITAE TO ALL DEFENDANTS
  52. UPON CONSULTATION WITH COUNSEL FOR ALL PARTIES, THE COURT MODIFIES THE CASE MANAGEMENT SCHEDULE AS FOLLOWS: PLAINTIFFS' EXPERT REPORT DUE 02/02/2024. DEFENDANTS' EXPERT REPORTS DUE 04/18/2024. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS DUE 04/18/2024. ANY RESPONSE DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6. THE PARTIES SHOULD NOT EXPECT ANY EXTENSION OF THE BRIEFING DEADLINES. NOTICE ISSUED
  53. CMC BY PHONE HELD ON 11/21/2023. COUNSEL FOR ALL PARTIES APPEARED. THE COURT SETS THE FOLLOWING CASE MANAGEMENT SCHEDULE: DISCOVERY IS ONGOING. EXPERT REPORT DEADLINES TO BE SET IN A FUTURE COURT ORDER. DISPOSITIVE MOTION TO BE FILED BY 03/01/2024. RESPONSE DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6. FINAL PRETRIAL SET FOR 05/15/2024 AT 02:00 PM. PARTIES WITH FULL SETTLEMENT AUTHORITY MUST BE PRESENT. PLAINTIFF MUST SUBMIT A DEMAND TO DEFENDANT AT LEAST 14 DAYS PRIOR TO THE FINAL PRETRIAL. ALL PARTIES MUST SUBMIT A PRETRIAL STATEMENT THAT INCLUDES THE STATUS OF SETTLEMENT DISCUSSIONS TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST 7 DAYS PRIOR TO THE FINAL PRETRIAL. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 06/10/2024 AT 09:30 AM. ALL PRETRIAL MOTIONS ARE DUE FOURTEEN DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. BRIEFING DEADLINES FOR ALL OTHER MOTIONS ARE GOVERNED BY THE OHIO RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE (SEE RULE 6). ALL PARTIES ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED THAT IT IS THE POLICY OF THIS COURT THAT ALL REASONABLE EFFORTS TO SETTLE DISCOVERY DISPUTES BE MADE BEFORE THE FILING OF ANY MOTION TO COMPEL. PARTIES MUST CONTACT THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY PRIOR TO FILING A MOTION TO COMPEL. PARTIES WILL BE PROVIDED WITH A FULL OPPORTUNITY TO MAKE A RECORD OF ANY PERCEIVED DISCOVERY VIOLATIONS. REQUESTS FOR STATUS CONFERENCES WITH THE COURT OR THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY FOR THE PURPOSE OF RESOLVING DISCOVERY DISPUTES CAN BE MADE AT ANY TIME. PARTIES ARE INSTRUCTED TO SERVE COPIES OF ALL FILINGS ON OPPOSING PARTY VIA EMAIL. IN SETTING THIS SCHEDULE, THE COURT HAS WEIGHED THE INTEREST IN AN EFFICIENT RESOLUTION OF THIS RE-FILED CASE, COUNSEL'S SCHEDULES, AND THE PARTIES DESIRE TO CONDUCT ADDITIONAL DISCOVERY AND CONSIDER NEW EXPERT WITNESSES. NOTICE ISSUED
  54. CMC BY PHONE SET FOR 11/21/2023 AT 09:00 AM. COUNSEL SHOULD CALL 425-436-6325 AND ENTER ACCESS CODE 160911#. NOTICE ISSUED
  55. THE COURT ORDERS THE CLERK OF COURTS TO LIST ATTORNEYS MARGO S. MEOLA (0065555) AND CHRISTOPHER F. MARS (0091604) AS ADDITIONAL COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANTS PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC., PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC DBA AVENUE AT MACEDONIA, AND PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC. CONSISTENT WITH SAID DEFENDANTS' ANSWER. NOTICE ISSUED
  56. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC.(D1), PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC(D2) and PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC.(D3) ATTORNEY PAUL W MC CARTNEY 0040207 ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC., PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC DBA AVENUE AT MACEDONIA, AND PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC.
  57. WAIVER OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS RETURNED SIGNED ON 10/11/2023 RULE 4.7 WAIVER OF THE SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO HAITHAM AZEM, MD
  58. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 51780833 RETURNED 10/6/2023 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT AZEM MD/HAITHAM/ - UNCLAIMED NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  59. ANSWER FILED BY D4 HAITHAM AZEM ATTORNEY GEORGE M MOSCARINO 0019447 DEFENDANT HAITHAM AZEM, M.D.'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
  60. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED D4 HAITHAM AZEM TIMOTHY A SPIRKO 0070589. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL
  61. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED D4 HAITHAM AZEM JOHN M MOSCARINO 0093944. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL
  62. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED D4 HAITHAM AZEM GEORGE M MOSCARINO 0019447. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL
  63. USPS RECEIPT NO. 51780832 DELIVERED BY USPS 09/11/2023 PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC. PROCESSED BY COC 09/20/2023.
  64. USPS RECEIPT NO. 51780830 DELIVERED BY USPS 09/11/2023 PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC. PROCESSED BY COC 09/20/2023.
  65. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 51780831 RETURNED 09/14/2023 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC - NOT DELIVRBL AS ADDR NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  66. WAIVER OF SERVICE OF SUMMONS RETURNED SIGNED ON 09/08/2023 RULE 4.7 WAIVER OF THE SERVICE OF SUMMONS TO PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, ET AL.
  67. SUMS COMPLAINT(51780833) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: HAITHAM AZEM MD 88 CENTER ROAD SUITE 130 BEDFORD, OH 44146
  68. SUMS COMPLAINT(51780832) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA REAL ESTATE, INC. C/O DHP LANDERBROOK, INC. 5910 LANDERBROOK DR. CLEVELAND, OH 44124
  69. SUMS COMPLAINT(51780831) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: PROGRESSIVE MACEDONIA, LLC C/O DHP LANDERBROOK, INC. 5910 LANDERBROOK DR. CLEVELAND, OH 44124
  70. SUMS COMPLAINT(51780830) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: PROGRESSIVE QUALITY CARE, INC. C/O DHP LANDERBROOK, INC. 5910 LANDERBROOK DR. CLEVELAND, OH 44124
  71. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  72. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  73. WRIT FEE
  74. WRIT FEE
  75. WRIT FEE
  76. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  77. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  78. WRIT FEE
  79. JUDGE PETER J CORRIGAN ASSIGNED (RANDOM); RE-FILED CASE, REASSIGNED TO ORIGINAL JUDGE, JUDGE HOLLIE L GALLAGHER
  80. JUDGE PETER J CORRIGAN ASSIGNED (RANDOM)
  81. LEGAL RESEARCH
  82. LEGAL NEWS
  83. LEGAL AID
  84. COURT SPECIAL PROJECTS FUND
  85. COMPUTER FEE
  86. CLERK'S FEE
  87. DEPOSIT AMOUNT PAID EADIE HILL TRIAL LAWYERS

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase