Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Case Information
Parties
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- XXX COST STATEMENT SENT TO: $24.68 IRENE MAKRIDIS (Attorney) on behalf of MELISSA NUTTER (PLAINTIFF)
- SPECIAL PROJECTS JUDGES Receipt: 468877 Date: 08/29/2023
- E-INITIAL CIVIL FEE Receipt: 468877 Date: 08/29/2023
- E-OTHER CIVIL COMPLAINT Attorney: MAKRIDIS, IRENE (16760) Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023
- SUMMONS ISSUED TO DEFENDANT(S). Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023
- Issue Date: 08/30/2023 Service: OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Cost Per: $8.93 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC 1139 W MARKET STREET WARREN, OH 44485 Tracking No: 948900900027627462236 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC C/O CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY S/A 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 103 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 948900900027627462237 DOLLAR TREE STORE INC 500 VOLVO PARKWAY CHEASEPEAKE, VA 23320 Tracking No: 948900900027627462238 DOLLAR TREE STORE INC C/O CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY S/A 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 103 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 948900900027627462239 STULGIS, FRANK C/O FAMILY DOLLAR 1139 WEST MARKET ST WARREN, OH 44485 Tracking No: 948900900027627462240 CITY OF WARREN 391 MAHONING AVE WARREN, OH 44481 Tracking No: 948900900027627462241 CURRINGTON, MICHAEL C/O WARREN CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT 141 SOUTH STREET WARREN, OH 44483 Tracking No: 948900900027627462242 TEMPESTA, FRANK C/O WARREN CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT 141 SOUTH ST SE WARREN, OH 44483 Tracking No: 948900900027627462243 Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023 Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- E-AMENDED COMPLAINT (OTHER TORT) JURY DEMAND ENDORSED HEREON WITH INSTRUCTIONS TO THE CLERK FILED BY: Attorney: MAKRIDIS, IRENE (16760)
- Issue Date: 09/13/2023 Service: SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT (OTHER TORT) Method: CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Cost Per: $8.93 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC 1139 W MARKET STREET WARREN, OH 44485 Tracking No: 948900900027627462442 FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC C/O CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY S/A 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 103 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 948900900027627462443 DOLLAR TREE STORE INC 500 VOLVO PARKWAY CHEASEPEAKE, VA 23320 Tracking No: 948900900027627462444 DOLLAR TREE STORE INC C/O CORPORATION SERVICE COMPANY S/A 3366 RIVERSIDE DRIVE SUITE 103 UPPER ARLINGTON, OH 43221 Tracking No: 948900900027627462445 STULGIS, FRANK C/O FAMILY DOLLAR 1139 WEST MARKET ST WARREN, OH 44485 Tracking No: 948900900027627462446 CITY OF WARREN 391 MAHONING AVE WARREN, OH 44481 Tracking No: 948900900027627462447 CURRINGTON, MICHAEL C/O WARREN CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT 141 SOUTH STREET WARREN, OH 44483 Tracking No: 948900900027627462448 TEMPESTA, FRANK C/O WARREN CITY POLICE DEPARTMENT 141 SOUTH ST SE WARREN, OH 44483 Tracking No: 948900900027627462449 Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462236
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : DOLLAR TREE STORE INC Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462238
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : DOLLAR TREE STORE INC Signed By : WILLIAM PROPUATER Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462239
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : STULGIS, FRANK Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462240
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : CITY OF WARREN Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462241
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : CURRINGTON, MICHAEL Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462242
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 08/30/2023 Service : OTHER TORT COMPLAINT (CIVIL) Served : 09/05/2023 Return : 09/13/2023 On : TEMPESTA, FRANK Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462243
- E-NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL WITH SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: COTTER, CHRISTOPHER E (84021)
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/16/2023 Return : 09/22/2023 On : FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC Signed By : WILLIAM PROPUATER Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462443
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/16/2023 Return : 09/22/2023 On : DOLLAR TREE STORE INC Signed By : WILLIAM PROPUATER Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462445
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/15/2023 Return : 09/22/2023 On : CITY OF WARREN Signed By : HEATHER LABBE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462447
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/15/2023 Return : 09/22/2023 On : CURRINGTON, MICHAEL Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462448
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/15/2023 Return : 09/22/2023 On : TEMPESTA, FRANK Signed By : SIGNED NOT LEGIBLE Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462449
- E-MOTION FOR LEAVE TO PLEAD WITH SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: PINZONE, JOHN D (75279)
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 09/27/2023 10:27:07.49
- HEARING SET: Event: FIRST STATUS CONFERENCE Date: 11/30/2023 Time: 9:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2842 Result: NOT NEEDED
- SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Method : CERTIFIED MAIL WITH BAR CODE NEW Issued : 09/13/2023 Service : SUMMONS W/ AMENDED COMPLAINT Served : 09/18/2023 Return : 09/27/2023 On : DOLLAR TREE STORE INC Signed By : CUSTICK Reason : SUCCESSFUL SERVICE Comment : Tracking #: 948900900027627462444
- E-NOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL WITH SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: JOHNSON, APRIL (98781)
- E-MOTION FOR LEAVE TO EXTEND TIME FOR DEFENDANTS FAMILY DOLLAR AND DOLLAR TREE TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT Attorney: JOHNSON, APRIL (98781)
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 09/28/2023 11:14:58.81
- E-ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO DEFENDANTS TO 11/02/2023 Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023
- E-ORDER GRANTING LEAVE TO DEFENDANTS TO 11/02/2023 Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023
- E-NOTICE OF REMOVAL OF ACTION TO THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Attorney: JOHNSON, APRIL (98781)
- E-EXHIBIT FILED Attorney: JOHNSON, APRIL (98781)
- COMPLETE RECORD Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- POSTAGE Receipt: 472171 Date: 11/07/2023
- DEFENDANT COSTS FOR FILING FEE (10/1/13) Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- DEFENDANT COSTS FOR SPECIAL PROJECTS-JUDGES FEE 2012 INCREASE Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- XXX CASE TRANSFER COST STATEMENT SENT TO: DEFT X2 EACH TO PAY $401.51/2= $200.76 JUSTIN E HERDMAN (Attorney) on behalf of FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC, DOLLAR TREE STORE INC (DEFENDANT)
- NON-PAYMENT OF DELINQUENT COURT COSTS Receipt: 474362 Date: 12/21/2023 Receipt: 474363 Date: 12/21/2023
- FIRST NOTICE OF DELINQUENT COURT COSTS SENT DOLLAR TREE STORE INC was sent notice for $200.76. Balance: $200.76 Past Due: $200.76 Printed on 12/13/2023 09:47:49.72.
- FIRST NOTICE OF DELINQUENT COURT COSTS SENT FAMILY DOLLAR STORES OF OHIO LLC was sent notice for $200.75. Balance: $200.75 Past Due: $200.75 Printed on 12/13/2023 09:47:49.75.
- REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO: IRENE MAKRIDIS
- REFUND OF DEPOSIT TO: IRENE MAKRIDIS
- E-NOTICE OF REMAND FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO EASTERN DIVISION COURT FILED.
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 01/04/2024 11:42:02.44
- HEARING SET: Event: FIRST STATUS CONFERENCE Date: 02/08/2024 Time: 9:30 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2842 Result: TO BE RESET
- E-MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE WITH SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: MAKRIDIS, IRENE (16760)
- E-CONTINUANCE GRANTED Receipt: 492095 Date: 11/20/2024
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 01/26/2024 15:05:41.52
- HEARING SET: The following event: FIRST STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled for 02/08/2024 at 9:30 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: FIRST STATUS CONFERENCE Date: 02/22/2024 Time: 10:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 **RESET FROM 2/28/24** VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2842 Result: SET STATUS CONFERENCE
- E-NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL WITH SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- NOTICE SENT: to atty j. sanders for fsc set 2/22/24 (appearance filed) SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 01/31/2024 09:56:06.38
- HEARING SET: The following event: FIRST STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled for 02/22/2024 at 10:00 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: STATUS CONFERENCE Date: 03/28/2024 Time: 9:30 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2564 Result: SET STATUS CONFERENCE
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 03/28/2024 09:40:00.12
- HEARING SET: The following event: STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled for 03/28/2024 at 9:30 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: STATUS CONFERENCE Date: 05/09/2024 Time: 11:30 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2564 Result: SET STATUS CONFERENCE
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 05/10/2024 10:37:41.34
- HEARING SET: The following event: STATUS CONFERENCE scheduled for 05/09/2024 at 11:30 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: SCHEDULING CONFERENCE Date: 05/22/2024 Time: 9:30 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 VIA PHONE-PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL TO CONDUCT CONFERENCE CALL-COURT NUMBER-330-675-2842 Result: DATES
- E-MOTION OF DEFENDANT FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 05/22/2024 09:42:39.52
- HEARING SET: The following event: SCHEDULING CONFERENCE scheduled for 05/22/2024 at 9:30 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: FINAL PRE TRIAL Date: 10/17/2024 Time: 10:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 JURY TRIAL-MONDAY 11/18/24 @ 9:00 AM Result: NOT NEEDED
- HEARING SET: Event: JURY TRIAL Date: 11/18/2024 Time: 9:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 Result: NOT NEEDED
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 05/22/2024 12:07:29.19
- HEARING SET: Event: MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS Date: 07/12/2024 Time: 8:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 MEMO ONLY-NO ORAL ARGUMENTS-BRIEFS TO BE FILED-NO APPEARANCE REQUIRED Result: COMPLETED
- E-INTERNAL JUDGMENT ENTRY: SEE JE FOR CASE MANAGEMENT PLAN Receipt: 492095 Date: 11/20/2024
- E-RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: MAKRIDIS, IRENE (16760)
- E-DEFENDANTS CITY OF WARREN, MICHAEL CURRINGTON AND FRANK TEMPESTA'S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- E-NOTICE OF SERVICE OF DEFENDANT'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION PROPOUNDED UPON PLAINTIFF MELISSA NUTTER WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- E-DEFENDANTS CITY OF WARREN, MICHAEL CURRINGTON AND FRANK TEMPESTA'S WITNESS LIST WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- E-DEFENDANTS CITY OF WARREN, MICHAEL CURRINGTON AND FRANK TEMPASTA'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- NOTICE SENT: SPEEDY MAILER (eNOTICES) Sent on: 07/22/2024 11:30:15.38
- HEARING SET: Event: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (MEMO) Date: 08/23/2024 Time: 8:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 MEMO ONLY-NO ORAL ARGUMENTS-BRIEFS TO BE FILED-NO APPEARANCE REQUIRED Result: TO BE RESET
- E-NOTICE OF MANUAL FILING EXHIBIT 2-1 TO DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FIELD BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- (1) FLASH DRIVE LABELED "EXHIBIT'S 2-1 TO WARREN'S MSJ FILED IN A SEALED ENVELOPE AND PLACED INTO FILE (2023 CV 01293) FILED BY: ATTORNEY ZACHARY ANDERSON.
- E-MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: MAKRIDIS, IRENE (16760)
- E-DEFENDANTS CITY OF WARREN, MICHAEL CURRINGTON AND FRANK TEMPESTA'S RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: Attorney: ANDERSON, ZACHARY W (95921)
- E-ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF TO 09/20/2024 TO RESPOND TO DEFENDANT'S MSJ. Receipt: 492095 Date: 11/20/2024
- HEARING SET: The following event: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (MEMO) scheduled for 08/23/2024 at 8:00 am has been rescheduled as follows: Event: MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (MEMO) Date: 09/20/2024 Time: 8:00 am Judge: LOGAN, ANDREW D Location: COURTROOM 1 **mtn for judgment on the pleadings is also pending** MEMO ONLY-NO ORAL ARGUMENTS-BRIEFS TO BE FILED-NO APPEARANCE REQUIRED Result: COMPLETED
- E-INTERNAL JUDGMENT ENTRY: DEFENDANT'S MSJ IS GRANTED. DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS IS DENIED AS MOOT. CAE IS DISMISSED AT PLAINTIFF'S COSTS. SEE JE. Receipt: 492095 Date: 11/20/2024
- MEMO ENTRY: ATTY PINZONE & MAKRIDIS VIA EMAIL - JE 10/11/2024
- POSTAGE Receipt: 492095 Date: 11/20/2024
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In