Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Fresno County

Court

Fresno County

California

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2021-10-19
Status Open
Type 13 Unlimited Defamation
Docket 453 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Doe, John|Doe, Jane|Doe, Daughter|View Document S Request For Pretrial Discovery Conference For Production Of Documents Set 1 On 12/1/21|View Document S Opposition To Defendants Motion To Strike|View Document 12.4.24 S Opposition To Defendants Motion For Summary Judgment|View Document 12.4.24 S Request For Judicial Notice In Support Of Their Opposition To Defendants Msj|View Document 12.4.24 S Objections To Declaration Of Ricardo Avelar In Support Of Defendants Msj|View Document 12.4.24 S Objections To Declaration Of Paul Parvanian In Support Of Defendants Msj|View Document 12.4.24 S Objections To Declaration Of Eric Saff In Support Of Defendants Msj|View Document 12.4.24 S Compendium Of Exhibits In Opposition To Defendants Motion For Summary Judgment|View Document S Objection To New Facts|View Document 5.20.25 Opposition To S' Motion To Compel Nicea Darling's Deposition
Defendant Spatafore, John Christopher|Community Hospitals Of Central California|View Document S Request For Pretrial Discovery Conference For Pmk And Cor Scheduled For 04/08/22|View Document Plaintiffs Opposition To S Motion To Strike|View Document S Request For Pretrial Discovery Conference Rfa Set One 04/14/23|View Document S Request For Ptdc Specials Set One 04/14/2023|View Document S Request For Ptdc Si General 04/14/23|View Document S Request For Ptdc Si Set One Rfa 04/14/(2023|View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Opposition To S Motion For Summary Judgment|View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Request For Judicial Notice In Support Of Their Opposition To S Msj|View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections To Declaration Of Ricardo Avelar In Support Of S Msj|View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections To Declaration Of Paul Parvanian In Support Of S Msj|View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections To Declaration Of Eric Saff In Support Of S Msj|View Document 12.4.24 Opposition To S Separate Statement O
Photo of Hon. Culver Kapetan, Kristi

Judge

Hon. Culver Kapetan, Kristi

Fresno County (CA)

California

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Jury Trial Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 9:00 AM
  2. Civil Complaint filed View Document Complaint
  3. Summons issued and filed View Document Summons
  4. Notice Filed View Document CV-48 Notice of Case Management Conference and Assignment of Judge for All Purposes Comment Notice of Case Management Conference and Assignment of Judge for All Purpose (emailed)
  5. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service
  6. Summons and Complaint Served
  7. Proof of Service View Document 11-16-21 Proof of Service of Community Hospitals Of Central California
  8. Summons and Complaint Unserved Comment DEFECTIVE Reason : Line #3.a. does not match complaint.
  9. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service
  10. Summons and Complaint Served
  11. Amended Document Filed View Document - First Amended Complaint and Demand for Jury Trial Comment First Amended Complaint; and Jury Demand
  12. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Hearing Comment of Hearing on Demurrer to Plaintiff's Motion to Strike
  13. Demurrer Filed View Document Demurrer Comment of Defendant to Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint
  14. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memorandum of Points & Authorities Comment in Support of Demurrer to First Amended Complaint
  15. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Comment of Paul M. Parvanian in Support of Demurrer to First Amended Complaint
  16. Notice of Motion View Document Notice of Motion Comment and Motion to: Strike
  17. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memorandum of Points & Authorities Comment in Support of Motion to Strike
  18. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Comment of Paul M. Parvanian in Support of Motion to Strike First Amended Complaint
  19. Request Filed View Document Request for Judicial Notice Comment for Judicial Notice ISO Demurrer and Motion to Strike
  20. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Negin, Stephanie Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  21. Case Management Statement Filed View Document CMC stmt Comment HRG on
  22. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Jury Deposit Comment Deposit/Payment for Jury Fees
  23. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement Comment Defendant CHCC Case Management Statement
  24. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers
  25. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for pretrial discovery conference Comment Forwarded to Dept. 501 Plaintiffs dispute set 1 Propounded on
  26. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 3-17-22 Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment by plaintiffs for a dispute arisen regarding a deposition notice production of documents at a deposition or deposition question related to the depo of PMK scheduled for
  27. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition on Request for Pretrial discovery Conference Comment Forwarded to dept. 501 Filed Request Defendant's opposition to dispute re: set one propounded on 12/1/21
  28. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  29. Order Denied View Document Order Denied Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery confence
  30. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( order on request for pretrial discovery conference) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  31. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment for pretrial discovery conference filed Defendants opposition to Plaintiffs request PMK scheduled 04/08/22
  32. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Defendants request for pretrial Discovery conference for PMK and COR scheduled for Comment A dispute has arisen regarding a depo of PMK and COR scheduled for or held on
  33. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  34. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment On reqeust for pretrial discovery conference
  35. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the (Order on request pretrial discovery conference ) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  36. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Plaintiffs request for Pretrial Discovery Conference for Production of Documents set 1 on Comment for Production of documents set 1 propounded on
  37. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard Comment On PTDC Request filed and Opposition filed 3/28/22
  38. Appeared in Person Comment Paul Parvanian
  39. Remote Appearance Via Courtcall Comment Brian Whelan
  40. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  41. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Plaitiff's opposition to RPTDC filed on
  42. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  43. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  44. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  45. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( on Request for pretrial discovery conference ) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  46. Opposition filed View Document Opposition Comment Defendant's CHCC opposition to Request for PTDC filed by Plaintiff on
  47. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request Comment Defendant's CHCC Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference filed
  48. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  49. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( Order on request for pretrial discovery conference ) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  50. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  51. Request Filed View Document Request Comment to take PTDC off calendar
  52. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  53. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar
  54. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  55. Notice Filed View Document Notice Comment Letter Request to Remove Pretrial Discovery Conference from Calendar
  56. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with certificate of mailing
  57. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to request for pretrial discovery conference Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference filed by Defendant on
  58. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  59. Letter Received View Document List filed Comment Request to reschedule the PTDC set for to a different time
  60. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with certificate of mailing
  61. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 8:30 AM Result Heard
  62. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar
  63. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  64. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment order after pretrial discovery conference and chambers minute order
  65. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on order after pretrial discovery conference
  66. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  67. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( on Request for pretrial discovery confernce) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  68. Amended Document Filed View Document 6-14-22 Second Amended Complaint; And Jury Demand Comment **STRICKEN PER SIGNED ORDER - Second Amended Complaint; And Jury Demand
  69. Notice Filed View Document -Notice of Non-Opposition to Demurrer Comment Notice of Non-Opposition to Demurrer
  70. Notice Filed View Document -Notice of Non-Opposition to Motion to Strike Comment Notice of Non-Opposition to Motion to Strike
  71. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  72. Order Received for Signature View Document Stipulation and Order Comment Order signed ~ Fowarded to Dept. 501 ~ Stipulation to Continue July Hearings
  73. Stipulation and Order filed View Document Stipulation and Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment To continue Motion to strike, demurrer, and exparte from July 5, 2022 to July 21, 2022 at 3:30 p.m. in Dept. 501.
  74. Ex parte Filed View Document Ex Parte Application ~ Hearing 7/19/22 Comment Hearing ~ Ex Parte Application for Relief from Late Filing
  75. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document MPA ~ Hearing 7/19/22
  76. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration ~ Hearing 7/19/22 Comment Brian D. Whelan
  77. Request for Judicial Notice View Document RJN ~ Hearing 7/19/22
  78. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Order ~ Hearing 7/19/22 Comment Order signed ~ Pending Ex Parte Hearing ~
  79. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Ex Parte ~ Hearing 7/19/22 Comment Hearing ~ Opposition to Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application
  80. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration ~ Hearing 7/19/22 Comment Paul M. Parvanian
  81. Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Result Heard Comment Relief from late filing of opposition or leave to file 2nd amended complaint ~ Brian Whelan
  82. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  83. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Ex parte application for relief signed and filed
  84. Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Relief from late filing of opposition or to file 2nd amended complaint. Brian Whelan
  85. Notice of Striking/Voiding Filed Documents View Document Notice of Striking/Voiding Filed Documents
  86. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  87. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Negin, Stephanie Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  88. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from Chambers
  89. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  90. Reply filed View Document Reply ~ Hearing 8/16/22 Comment Hearing ~ Reply in support of Demurrer
  91. Reply filed View Document Reply ~ Hearing 8/16/22 Comment Hearing ~ Reply in support of Motion to Strike
  92. Demurrer Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Filed ~ Paul Parvanian
  93. Motion - Strike Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Filed ~ Paul Parvanian
  94. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailing
  95. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  96. Order Received for Signature View Document -Proposed Joint Stipulation For Protective Order Comment Forwarded to: 501 Joint Stipulation For Protective Order
  97. Stipulation and Order filed View Document 8.31.2022 Stipulation and Order for Protective Order Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Protective Order
  98. Amended Document Filed View Document - Second Amended Complaint Comment Second Amended Complaint
  99. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request Comment Forwarded to dept. 501
  100. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition to request for PTDC Comment Community Hospitals of Central California Opposition to Plaintiffs Request for Pretrial
  101. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  102. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  103. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( on request for pretrial discovery conference ) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  104. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Demurring or Moving Party ISO Automatic Extension Comment Declaration of Demurring or Moving Party in Support of Automatic Extension
  105. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  106. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard
  107. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  108. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Negin, Stephanie Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  109. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from Chambers
  110. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 8:30 AM Result Heard
  111. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order on pretrial discovery conference and certificate of mailing.
  112. Notice of Motion View Document Mtn to Strike SAC HRG 2/15/23 Comment Notice of Motion to Strike Portions of Second Amended Complaint
  113. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memo re Mtn to Strike SAC HRG 2/16/23 Comment ISO Motion to Strike Portions of Second Amended Complaint
  114. Declaration Filed View Document Parvanian Dec re Mtn to Strike SAC HRG 2/15/23 Comment Declaration of Paul M. Parvanian ISO Motion to Strike Portions of SAC
  115. Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing re Demurrer HRG 2/15/23 Comment Notice of Hearing on Demurrer to Second Amended Complaint
  116. Demurrer Filed View Document Demurrer to SAC HRG 2/15/23 Comment Demurrer to Second Amended Complaint
  117. Declaration Filed View Document Parvanian Dec re Demurrer HRG 2/15/23 Comment Declaration of Paul M. Parvanian ISO Demurrer to SAC
  118. Request for Judicial Notice View Document RJN re Demurrer and Mtn Strike HRG 2/15/23 Comment ISO Motion to Strike Portions of & Demurrer to SAC
  119. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memo re Demurrer HRG 2/15/23 Comment ISO Demurrer to SAC
  120. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment with certificate of mailing. Due to courtroom availiabilty hearing has been moved to .
  121. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment Corrected the notice sent on . Due to courtroom avaialability, hearing has been moved to 02/23/22 with certificate of mailing
  122. Opposition filed View Document MPA in Opposition to defendants motion to strike Comment Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Strike Portion of Plaintiff's SAC and D's Demurrer to Plaintiff's SAC
  123. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs opposition to Defendants motion to strike Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion to Strike Punitive Damages
  124. Reply filed View Document Reply Comment Defendant CHCC's Reply Memorandum of Points & Authorities ISO Mtn to Strike Portions of SAC
  125. Reply filed View Document Reply Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Demurrer Comment Defendant CHCC's Reply Memorandum of Points & Authorities ISO Demurrer to SAC
  126. Demurrer Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Filed - Paul Parvanian
  127. Motion - Strike Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Filed - Paul Parvanian
  128. Appeared in Person Comment Plaintiff Atty: Brian Whelan Defendant Atty: Ian Wieland
  129. Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter View Document Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Kim Thayer #8725
  130. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment
  131. Taken Under Submission or Advisement
  132. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  133. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with tentative ruling and certificate of mailing
  134. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  135. Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Mangano, Robert Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  136. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment
  137. Answer Filed View Document CHCC's Answer to Second Amended Complaint Comment to Second Amended Complaint
  138. Case Management Statement Filed View Document 6-28-23 Case Management Statement
  139. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Mangano, Robert Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  140. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment Chamber's
  141. Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Comment Notice of Time Change for Case Management Conference/CRC 3.1385
  142. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Defendants Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference RFA SET one Comment John Doe A dispute has arisen re: Form or Special Interog.set one RFA
  143. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Defendants Request for PTDC Specials set one Comment Jane Doe A dispute has arisen regarding form or special Interog set one propounded
  144. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Defendants Request for PTDC SI general Comment Jane doe A dispute has arisen re: form or special interogs set 1 general
  145. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document defendants Request for PTDC SI General Comment John Doe A dispute has arisen regarding form or special interogs set 1 general
  146. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document defendants Request for PTDC SI set one Comment John Doe A dispute has arisen regarding form or speical interogs set one
  147. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Defendants Request for PTDC SI Set One RFA 04/14/(2023 Comment John Doe a dispute regarding form or speicla interogs set one rfa
  148. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference SRogs1 (John)
  149. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference SRogs1 (Jane)
  150. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference FRogs1 (John)
  151. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference FRogs1 (Jane)
  152. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference RFA1 (John)
  153. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference RFA1 (Jane)
  154. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  155. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  156. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice Comment Party: Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  157. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  158. Answer Filed View Document Spatafore's Answer to Second Amended Complaint Comment to Second Amended Complaint
  159. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Party: Community Hospitals of Central California Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  160. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance PLTFS Comment Attorney Brian D. Whelan - HRG
  161. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  162. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  163. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment approving zoom
  164. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  165. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment approving zoom
  166. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  167. Request Filed View Document Request Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Request to Vacate Pretrial Discovery Conferences
  168. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with certificate of mailing
  169. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment X6
  170. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  171. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  172. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Brickey, Daniel Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  173. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment From Chambers
  174. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  175. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  176. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  177. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  178. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 2.14.24 Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference
  179. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 2.14.24 Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference
  180. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 2.14.24 Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference
  181. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 2.14.24 Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference
  182. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  183. Order Granted View Document 2-20-24 Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference
  184. Letter Received View Document Request for Continuance of Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment Letter to Judge Tharpe from Plaintiffs Re: Request for Continuance of Pretrial Discovery Conference
  185. Order Received for Signature View Document Stipulation and Order Comment Joint Stipulation to Continue March 1, 2023, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; Proposed Order
  186. Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing View Document Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing Comment Continue PTDC to
  187. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment of ptdc to 10:30 a.m
  188. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:30 AM Result Heard
  189. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:30 AM Result Heard
  190. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:30 AM Result Heard
  191. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:30 AM Result Heard
  192. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler
  193. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the order on request for pretrial discovery conference was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  194. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:30 AM Result Heard
  195. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order on request for pretrial discovery conference and certificate of mailing
  196. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  197. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  198. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document -Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Attorney for Plaintiffs and Plaintiffs Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  199. Order Received for Signature View Document -(Proposed) Order Regarding Remote Appearance Comment Forwarded to: Dept. 501
  200. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Denied View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Denied Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Brian Whelan
  201. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  202. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard Comment **PERSONAL APPEARANCES ARE REQUIRED***
  203. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment and order on pretrial discovery conference with certificate mailing
  204. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  205. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  206. Order Received for Signature View Document Stipulation to Continue 6/7/24 Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order Comment FWD to 501 - Stipulation to Continue Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order
  207. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  208. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Brickey, Daniel Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  209. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment From Chambers
  210. Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing View Document Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing Comment PTDC continued to
  211. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment Notice of Department Change and Certificate of Mailing
  212. Ex Parte Hearing Original Type Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Result Heard Comment Set Trial Date - Brian Whlen
  213. Ex parte Filed View Document - Ex Parte Application Comment to Specially Set the Trial or In Alt For Hearing on Shortened Time to Set the Trial Date
  214. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document - Memorandum of Points & Authorities Comment ISO Ex Parte Application to Specially Set Trial
  215. Declaration Filed View Document Letter of Documents Returned Without Filing Comment of Brian D Whelan ISO Ex Parte Application
  216. Minute Order Attachment View Document 6-13-24 Minute Order Attachment Comment w/certificate of mailing
  217. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard
  218. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order on pretrial discovery conference and certificate of mailing
  219. Appeared in Person Comment Brian Whelan. BIll Woolman
  220. Order Received for Signature View Document Stip and proposed order to continue PTDC Comment Stipulation to continue PTDC
  221. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  222. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Stipulation to continue ptdc to
  223. General Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Set Trial Dates - Brian Whelan
  224. Notice of Motion View Document Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Motion for Summary Judgment
  225. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document memo re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment in Support of its Motion for Summary Judgment
  226. Statement filed View Document SSUMF re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Redacted - Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  227. Request for Judicial Notice View Document RJN re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  228. Declaration Filed View Document PP Dec re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Redacted - Declaration of Paul Parvanian in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  229. Declaration Filed View Document JC Dec re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Redacted - Declaration of Janet Chisholm in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  230. Declaration Filed View Document RA Dec re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Redacted - Declaration of Ricardo Avelar in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  231. Declaration Filed View Document ES Dec re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Redacted - Declaration of Eric Saff in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment
  232. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Lodging re Motion for Summary Judgment HRG 12/18/24 Comment Defendant's Notice of Lodging of unredacted copy of motion for summary judgment
  233. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  234. Letter Received View Document List filed
  235. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  236. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Filed Comment Declaration of Janet Chisholm In Support Of Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment Or, In The Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  237. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Filed Comment Declaration Of Eric Saff In Support Of Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment Or, In The Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  238. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Filed Comment Declaration Of Ricardo Avelar In Support Of Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment Or, In The Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  239. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Filed Comment Declaration Of Paul Parvanian In Support Of Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment Or, In The Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  240. Statement filed View Document Statement filed Comment Separate Statement Of Undisputed Facts In Support Of Defendant's Motion For Summary Judgment Or, In The Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  241. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment by Email & Courier - - Notice of Motion, MPA, Separate Statement x2, RJN, Declaration x8, Notice of Lodging
  242. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment of calendar setting with certificate of mailing
  243. Case Management Conference Judicial Officer Diaz, Maria G Hearing Time 3:00 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar
  244. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  245. Order Received for Signature View Document Joint Stip to Continue November 1, 2024, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order Comment *Order signed and forwarded to the Clerk's Office on 10-31-24 for further processing* Joint Stipulation to Continue November 1, 2024, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order Thereon
  246. Stipulation and Order filed View Document 10-31-24 Stipulation and Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment continue Pretrial Discovery Conference
  247. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:30 AM Result Heard
  248. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  249. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order and certificate of mailing
  250. Appeared in Person Comment Brian Whelan Bill Woolman
  251. Ex Parte Hearing Original Type Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Result Heard Comment Filed Zoom granted for Brian Whelan and Bill woolman Continue SJ - Brian Whelan
  252. Ex parte Filed View Document Ex Parte Application to continue MSJ Comment Notice and Ex Parte Application for an Order to Continue Summary Judgment Motion and Related Dates
  253. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document MPA ISO Ex parte Comment Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support of Plaintiff's Ex Parte Application
  254. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Brian Whelan ISO Exparte Comment Declaration of Brian D. Whelan
  255. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Brian Whelan Bill woolman
  256. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment
  257. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  258. Opposition filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment Comment Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  259. Request Filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Request for Judicial Notice in Support of their Opposition to Defendants MSJ Comment Plaintiffs Request for Judicial Notice in Support of their Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  260. Objection filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Ricardo Avelar in Support of Defendants MSJ Comment Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Ricardo Avelar in Support of Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  261. Objection filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Paul Parvanian in Support of Defendants MSJ Comment Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Paul Parvanian in Support of Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  262. Objection filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Eric Saff in Support of Defendants MSJ Comment Plaintiffs Objections to Declaration of Eric Saff in Support of Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  263. Statement filed View Document 12.4.24 Opposition to Defendants Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts iso Defendant's MSJ Comment Opposition to Defendants Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in support of Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment
  264. List filed View Document 12.4.24 Plaintiffs Compendium of Exhibits in Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment Comment Plaintiffs Compendium of Exhibits in Opposition to Defendants Motion for Summary Judgment
  265. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  266. Order Denied View Document Order Denied Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  267. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:33 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration Comment Stip to Cont PTDC
  268. Order Received for Signature View Document Joint Stip to Continue December 13, 2024, PTDC; [Proposed] Order Thereon Comment Signed - Joint Stipulation to Continue December 13, 2024, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order Thereon
  269. Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing View Document Stipulation for Continuance of a Hearing Comment Continuing ptdc
  270. Reply filed View Document Defendant's Reply ISO MSJ Comment Defendant's Reply ISO MSJ
  271. Objection filed View Document Defendant's Objections to Declaration Comment Defendant's Objections to Declaration
  272. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Janet Chisholm ISO MSJ Comment Declaration of Janet Chisholm ISO MSJ
  273. Statement filed View Document Reply to Opposition Comment Reply to Opposition
  274. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance
  275. Objection filed View Document Plaintiffs Objection to new Facts Comment Plaintiffs Objection to new Facts
  276. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  277. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment James Wilkins
  278. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  279. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Brian Whelan ISO Opposition Comment Supplemental Declaration of Brian Whelan in Support of Plaintiff's Opposition to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment
  280. Summary Judgment Original Type Summary Judgment Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment William Woolman - filed
  281. Appeared in Person Comment Brian Whelan, Bill Woolman, Paul Parvainian
  282. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment James Wilkins
  283. Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter View Document Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Shelly Davis 8947
  284. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  285. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  286. Taken Under Submission or Advisement
  287. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with certificate of mailing
  288. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE View Document 1-2-24 Proposed Stipulation and Order Received Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:33 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  289. Order Received for Signature View Document 1-2-24 Proposed Stipulation and Order Received Comment ***Order signed and entered 1-2-25*** Forwarded to Dept 501 Joint Stipulation to Continue January 3, 2025, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; [Proposed] Order Thereon
  290. Stipulation and Order filed View Document 1-2-25 Stipulation and Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment to continue 1-3-25 PTDC to 1-24-25
  291. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  292. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order after hearing and certificate of a mailing
  293. Order Received for Signature View Document Order granted ptdc vacated Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Request to Vacate January 24, 2025, Pre-Trial Discovery Conference; and [Proposed] Order Thereon
  294. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment continued from 1-3-25
  295. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre View Document Order granted ptdc vacated Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  296. Stipulation and Order filed View Document Order granted ptdc vacated Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Vacating PTDC
  297. Notice of Motion View Document Notice of Motion - Nicea Darling Hrg: 06/03/25 Comment and Motion to Compel Deposition of Nicea Darling
  298. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memorandum of Points & Authorities ISO Motion - Nicea Darling Hrg: 06/03/25 Comment ISO Motion to Compel Deposition of Nicea Darling
  299. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Brian Whelan ISO Motion - Nicea Darling Hrg: 06/03/25 Comment of Brian Whelan ISO Motion to Compel Deposition of Nicea Darling
  300. Request for Judicial Notice View Document Request for Judicial Notice - Nicea Darling Hrg: 06/03/25 Comment ISO of their Motion to Compel Deposition of Nicea Darling
  301. Substitution of Attorney Filed View Document - Substitution of Attorney Comment Previous Attorney: Ian B. Wieland New Attorney: Tammy B. Webb
  302. Substitution of Attorney Filed View Document - Substitution of Attorney Comment Previous Attorney: Ian B. Wieland New Attorney: Frank P. Kelly
  303. Declaration Filed View Document Supp Dec of BDW re Motion Compel Depo HRG Comment Supplemental Declaration of Brian D. Whelan in Support of Plaintiffs Motion to Compel Deposition of Nicea Darling
  304. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD 501
  305. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document RAG Jason Ward Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Jason Ward
  306. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Defendant Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  307. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Defendant Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  308. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service
  309. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document RAG Laurel Scott Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Laurel Scott
  310. Opposition filed View Document 5.20.25 Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Nicea Darling's Deposition Comment Community Hospitals of Central California's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Nicea Darling's Deposition
  311. Declaration Filed View Document 5.20.25 Frank Kelly's Declaration iso Opposition to Motion to Compel Nicea Darling's Deposition Comment Frank Kelly's Declaration In Support of Community Hospitals of Central California's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion to Compel Nicea Darling's Deposition
  312. Proof of Service View Document 5.20.25 Proof of Service
  313. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed Comment FWD 501
  314. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  315. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  316. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  317. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]/ [email protected]
  318. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  319. Order Denied View Document Order Denied Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  320. Application Filed View Document Application of Jason K. Ward for Pro Hac Vice Admission Hrg: 07/01/25 Comment of Jason K. Ward for Pro Hac Vice Admission to Appear as Counsel
  321. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment by Email - - Declaration, MPA, Notice of Hearing, Application, Proposed Order
  322. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Tammy B. Webb ISO Application Hrg: 07/01/25 Comment of Tammy B. Webb ISO Application of Jason K Ward for Pro Hac Vice Admission to Appear as Counsel
  323. Notice of Hearing View Document Notice of Hearing Hrg: 07/01/25 Comment Re: Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice
  324. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Granting Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 07/01/25 Comment **Order signed and forwarded to the clerks office for further processing on ** (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice
  325. Notice Filed View Document Memorandum ISO Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 07/01/25 Comment Memorandum ISO Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice
  326. Reply filed View Document Reply MPA ISO Motion to Compel Comment Reply MPA ISO Motion to Compel
  327. Declaration Filed View Document Second Supplemental Declaration of Brian Whelan Comment Second Supplemental Declaration of Brian Whelan
  328. Substitution of Attorney Filed View Document Substitution of Attorney
  329. Substitution of Attorney Filed View Document Substitution of Attorney Comment Corrected Substitution of Attorney
  330. Motion - Compel Attendance Original Type Motion - Compel Attendance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Brian Whelan - Filed
  331. Motion - Compel Attendance Original Type Motion - Compel Attendance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Brian Whelan
  332. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  333. Document filed View Document List filed Comment Fwd 501: Document: Letter to Judge Tharpe
  334. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  335. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  336. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment of hearing date change with certificate of mailing
  337. Oral Arguments Original Type Oral Arguments Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 8:30 AM Result Heard
  338. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Jason Ward, Laurel Scott
  339. Appeared in Person Comment Brian Whelan
  340. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  341. Application Filed View Document -Application for Subpoena for Discovery in Out of State Case Comment Commission to Take Deposition Outside CA
  342. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Tammy Webb (Jason Ward) - Filed
  343. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of electronic service
  344. Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Protective Order - Tammie Webb
  345. Declaration Filed View Document DECLARATION OF TAMMY B. WEBB IN RESPONSE TO THE COURTS Comment of Tammy B. Webb in Response to the Court's July 1 2025.
  346. Proof of Service View Document DEFENDANTS PROOF OF SERVICE
  347. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD 501
  348. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment Fwd 501
  349. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested
  350. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document L&M MO w/TR and CES Comment with Certificate of Electronic Service
  351. Order Granted View Document - Order Granting Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Order Granting Application of Jason K. Ward to Appear Pro Hac Vice for Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California
  352. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD 501
  353. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  354. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pre trial discovery conference with CES
  355. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition Comment FWD 501
  356. Letter Received View Document Objection Comment FWD 501
  357. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  358. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  359. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chamber with certificate of eservice
  360. Minute Order Corrected/Amended View Document Minute Order Corrected/Amended Comment Corrected/Amended
  361. Letter Received View Document Letter Comment FWD 501
  362. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of eservice
  363. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference (SRogs5) Comment FWD:D501
  364. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  365. Letter Received View Document Letter received Comment Fwd 501
  366. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with ces
  367. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed Comment Fwd 501
  368. Response filed Comment Fwd 501: Response to Spatafore Letter to Court (Responses)
  369. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document NORA
  370. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Proposed order remote appearance laurel scott Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Laurel A.M. Scott
  371. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Jason Ward Remote.pdf
  372. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Proposed order remote appearance Jason Ward Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Jason Ward
  373. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document Proposed order remote appearance laurel scott Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  374. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document Proposed order remote appearance Jason Ward Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  375. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance filed by Brian D. Whelan Comment Party: Brian D. Whelan Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  376. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document (Proposed) Order for Remote Appearance filed by Brian D. Whelan Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Brian Whelan
  377. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  378. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  379. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  380. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard
  381. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:30 AM Result Heard
  382. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Jason Ward, Laurel Scott, Roger Bonakdar
  383. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment
  384. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Laurel Scott, Jason Ward, Brian Whelan
  385. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order after ptdc and CES
  386. Order Denied View Document Order Denied Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference
  387. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Spec Interr - Brian Whelan (Permission Granted )
  388. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Admissions - Brian Whelan
  389. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  390. Motion filed Comment Notice of Motion & Motion to Compel Further Responses
  391. Statement filed Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California Separate Statement ISO Motion to compel
  392. Declaration Filed Comment Declaration of Tammy B. Webb ISO Motion to Compel.
  393. Proof of Service Comment POS
  394. Memorandum of Points and Authorities Comment MPA In Support of Motion to Compel
  395. Order Received for Signature Comment [Proposed] Order granting MPA ISO Motion to Compel
  396. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document 9.24.25 Opposition to Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD to 501
  397. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  398. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with ces
  399. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document -Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  400. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document RAG Laurel Scott exparte Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Laurel A.M. Scott
  401. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Jason Ward Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  402. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  403. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  404. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document RAG Jason Ward 10/02/ 25 exparte Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Jason Ward
  405. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]; [email protected]
  406. Ex parte Filed View Document Ex parte Application to Continue the Trial and related dates Comment Ex parte Application to Continue the Trial and related dates
  407. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Order Granting Application to continue trial Comment ** Pending Hearing** [Proposed] Order Granting Application to continue trial
  408. Notice Filed View Document nora Comment Notice of Remote Appearance
  409. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Proposed Order Re: Remote appearance Laurel Scott 10/09 Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Laurel Scott
  410. Notice Filed View Document nora Comment Notice of Remote Appearance
  411. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Proposed order jason ward 10/09 Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Jason Ward
  412. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document Proposed Order Re: Remote appearance Laurel Scott 10/09 Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  413. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document Proposed order jason ward 10/09 Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  414. Request for Dismissal Received - Pending Review
  415. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]; [email protected]
  416. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]; [email protected]
  417. Notice Filed View Document JW Not of Appear.pdf Comment Notice of Remote Appearance
  418. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document (Proposed) Order remote appearance Jason Ward Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Jason Ward
  419. Notice Filed View Document LS Not of Appear.pdf Comment Notice of Remote Appearance
  420. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document (Proposed) Order regarding remote appearance Laurel Scott Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Laurel Scott
  421. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Ex Parte Hrg: 10/09/25 Comment to Ex Parte Application to Continue Trial Date
  422. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Brian D. Whelan ISO Opposition to Ex Parte Hrg: 10/09/25 Comment of Brian D. Whelan ISO Opposition to Ex Parte
  423. Ex Parte Hearing Original Type Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Result Heard Comment Extenstion to File SJ - Aubrey Kramer- Filed
  424. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document (Proposed) Order remote appearance Jason Ward Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  425. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document (Proposed) Order regarding remote appearance Laurel Scott Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  426. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of eservice
  427. Notice of Motion View Document Motion for Defendant or Summary Judgment Adjudication Comment Notice of Motion and Motion for Defendant or Summary Judgment Adjudication
  428. Application Filed View Document Application to File Renewed Portions of its Second Summary Adjudication Motion Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Application to File Renewed Portions of its Second Summary Adjudication Motion
  429. Request Filed View Document Request for Judicial Notice in Support of It's Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudication Comment Defendant's Request for Judicial Notice in Support of It's Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudication
  430. Statement filed View Document Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in Support Motion for Summary Adjudication Comment Separate Statement of Undisputed Material Facts in Support of Defendant's Motion for Summary Adjudication
  431. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memo P&A's Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudication Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Memorandum of Points & Authorities in Support of Its Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudication
  432. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Lodging of Unredacted Copy of Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's LLC's Notice of Lodging of Unredacted Copy of Renewed Motion for Summary Judgment, or in the Alternative, Summary Adjudication
  433. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar
  434. Motion filed View Document Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Notice of Motion and Motion to Seal Comment Defendant Community Hospitals of Central California's Notice of Motion and Motion to Seal
  435. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Frank P. Kelly III Comment Declaration of Frank P. Kelly III
  436. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Granting Motion to Seal Comment [Proposed] Order granting Motion to seal
  437. Notice Filed View Document 13511DEFENDAN03f7c4a Comment DEFENDANT COMMUNITY HOSPITALS OF CENTRAL CALIFORNIA'S LLC'S NOTICE OF LODGING UNREDACTED DOCUMENTS SUBJECT TO PENDING MOTION TO SEAL PURSUANT TO CALIFORNIA RULES OF COURT 2.550 AND 2.551 (Comment)
  438. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document 13511DEFENDAN042fcdf Comment DEFENDANT COMMUNITY HOSPITALS OF CENTRAL CALIFORNIA'S MEMORANDUM OF POINTS AND AUTHORITIES IN SUPPORT OF ITS RENEWED MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION (Memos)
  439. Statement filed View Document 13511SEPARATE0514062 Comment SEPARATE STATEMENT OF UNDISPUTED MATERIAL FACTS IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION (Statements)
  440. Response filed View Document 13511PLAINTIF06a16b7 Comment PLAINTIFF JOHN DOE'S SUPPLEMENTAL RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT COMMUNITY HOSPITALS OF CENTRAL CALIFORNIA'S FORM INTERROGATORIES-GENERAL, SET NO. ONE (Responses)
  441. Declaration Filed View Document 10-10-25 Declaration of F. Kelly ISO Defendant's Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudicatio-HRG Comment Declaration of Frank Kelly In Support Of Defendant's Renewed Motion for Summary Adjudication
  442. Memorandum of Points and Authorities View Document Memorandum of Points and Authorities Comment Defendant Community Hospitals Of Central California's Memorandum of Points And Authorities In Support Of Its Renewed Motion For Summary Adjudication
  443. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  444. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Req for Prod - Laurel Scott
  445. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Req for Prod - Laurel Scott
  446. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Req for Prod - Laurel Scott
  447. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Spec Interr - Laurel Scott
  448. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Spec Interr - Laurel Scott
  449. Motion - Compel Further Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Spec Interr - Laurel Scott- Filed
  450. General Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Seal - Laurel Scott (TD ) Frank Kelly- Filed 10/10/2026
  451. Summary Judgment Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Comment Tammy Webb
  452. Mandatory Settlement Conference Hearing Time 10:00 AM
  453. Trial Readiness Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 9:30 AM

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more