Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Fresno County

Court

Fresno County

California

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-02-21
Status Dismissed
Type 24 Unlimited Product Liability
Docket 464 entries
Disposition settlement

Parties

Plaintiff Tiffin, Rodger|Tiffin, Barbara|View Document 2 24 23 Deposit Of Jury Fees Posted By|View Document 6 7 23 S' Notice Of Posting Complex Fee|View Document 11/18/2024 (proposed) Order Regarding 's Motion In Limine|View Document S Mil No. 7|View Document S Mil 14|View Document S Mil No. 15|View Document S Mil No. 17|View Document S Mil No. 18|View Document S Mil No. 19|View Document S Mil No. 21|View Document S Mil No. 23|View Document S Mil No. 24|View Document 11/26/2024 Notice Of Remote Appearance S Hrg 12/12/24|View Document S Mil No. 22|View Document S Mil No. 20|View Document S Mil No. 10|View Document S Mil No. 11|View Document S Mil No 13|View Document S Mil No 16|View Document Defendants' Opposition To S Mil|View Document S Mil No. 4|View Document S Mil No. 3|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 1|View Document S Revised Motion In Limine No. 3 W/ Exhibits|View Document S Revised Motion In Limine No. 4 W/ Exhibit 1|View Document S Motion In Limine No. 5|View Document S Motion I
Defendant Monsanto Company|Pleasant Valley Hardware Corp.|Coalinga Hardware, Inc.|View Document S Notice To Correct Hearing Dated Re Unopposed Motion|View Document S' Opposition To Plaintiffs Mil|View Document S Mil No. 7|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 1|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 2|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 3|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 4|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 5|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 6|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 15|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 16|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 17|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 8|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 9|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 10|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 11|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 12|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 13|View Document S' Motion In Limine No. 14|View Document 12/2/24 S' Mil No. 19|View Document Stipulation Re Dismissal Of Claims Against Pleasant Valley Hardware|View Document S Mil
Photo of Hon. Skiles Jon M

Judge

Hon. Skiles Jon M

Fresno County (CA)

California

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CRC 3.1385 After Settlement Judicial Officer Skiles, Jon M Hearing Time 3:28 PM Cancel Reason Dismissed
  2. Civil case cover sheet View Document 2-21-23 Civil Case Cover Sheet
  3. Deposit, payment,disbursment View Document 2-24-23 Deposit of Jury fees posted by Plaintiff Comment Deposit of Jury fees posted by Plaintiff
  4. Notice Filed View Document 2-24-23 Notice of Case Management Conference and Assignment of Judge for All Purposes Comment Notice of Case Management Conference and Assignment of Judge for All Purpose (emailed)
  5. Summons issued and filed View Document - Summons
  6. Proof of Service View Document 4-3-23 Proof of Service of Summons and Complaint re: Coalinga Hardware, Inc. (defective)
  7. Proof of Service View Document 4-3-23 Proof of Service of Summons and Complaint re: Monsanto Company (defective)
  8. Proof of Service View Document 4-3-23 Proof of Service of Summons and Complaint re: Pleasant Valley Hardware Corp (defective)
  9. Summons and Complaint Unserved Comment DEFECTIVE Reason : line #2 states Petition was served; however, a petition was not filed on this action.
  10. Summons and Complaint Unserved Comment DEFECTIVE Reason : line #2 states Petition was served; however, a petition was not filed on this action.
  11. Summons and Complaint Unserved Comment DEFECTIVE Reason : line #2 states Petition was served; however, a petition was not filed on this action.
  12. Answer Filed View Document Monsanto's Answer & Demand for Jury Trial Comment & Demand for Jury Trial
  13. Proof of Service View Document 4-6-23 Proof of Service
  14. Proof of Service View Document 4-6-23 Proof of Service
  15. Proof of Service View Document 4-6-23 Proof of Service
  16. Summons and Complaint Served
  17. Summons and Complaint Served
  18. Summons and Complaint Served
  19. Answer Filed View Document 5-17-23 Answer
  20. Civil case cover sheet View Document 5-17-23 Civil Case Cover Sheet Comment ** DESIGNATING CASE AS COMPLEX **
  21. Notice Filed View Document 5-23-23 Notice of Calendar Setting Comment Notice of Calendar Setting - CMC previously set for in dept. 402 is now set for 6/27/23 in dept. 501
  22. Notice Filed View Document 6-7-23 Plaintiffs' Notice of Posting Complex Fee Comment Plaintiffs' Notice of Posting Complex Fee
  23. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  24. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  25. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment notice of calendar setting with certificate of mailing
  26. Order Received for Signature View Document 2023-06-20 Prop Order re Notice of Rem Appear.pdf Comment Proposed Order re Notice of Remote Appearance
  27. Notice of Hearing View Document 2023-06-20 Notice Remote Appearance-signed.pdf Comment Notice of Hearing
  28. Case Management Conference Original Type Case Management Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:28 PM Result Heard
  29. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  30. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment approving court call
  31. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the ( RA020G ) was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on ( ) . Parties served: ( )
  32. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to:[email protected]
  33. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  34. Case Management Statement Filed View Document Case Management Statement
  35. Case Management Statement Filed View Document CMC Statement Comment Hearing date
  36. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance PLTFS Comment Attorney Charles Miller - HRG
  37. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  38. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment approving Zoom for Charles Miller
  39. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  40. Notice of Remote Appearance. Comment Joshua Cools.
  41. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  42. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment approving zoom for Joshua cools
  43. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  44. Case Management Conference Original Type Case Management Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:28 PM Result Heard Comment Zoom Approved: [email protected] [email protected]
  45. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Charles Miller Joshya Cools
  46. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  47. Notice Filed View Document DEFTS Notice of Jury Deposit Comment Notice of Jury Deposit
  48. Association of Attorney filed View Document Association of Counsel Comment hereby associates Shook, Hardy & Bacon LLP and Jamboree Center
  49. Application Filed View Document Application to Appear as Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 05/30/24 Comment Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice
  50. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 05/30/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Application of Kimberly Spangler-Loutney to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  51. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  52. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document - Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Charles W. Miller Type of Appearance Requested: CourtCall
  53. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Comment HRG .
  54. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  55. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document -Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Rodger and Barbara Tiffin Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  56. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Charles Miller (Kimberly Loutey) - Filed (NO DTT)
  57. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order +TR+CM Comment & CM
  58. Association of Attorney filed View Document - Association of Attorney Gregory Dovel Comment Gregory Dovel - Dovel & Luner LLP
  59. Association of Attorney filed View Document - Association of Attorney Alexander Erwig Comment Alexander Erwig - Dovel & Luner LLP
  60. Association of Attorney filed View Document - Association of Attorney Sean Luner Comment Sean Luner - Dovel & Luner LLP
  61. Order Received for Signature View Document Joint Case Management Order Regarding Deadlines; [Proposed] Order Comment FWD to 501 - Joint Case Management Order Regarding Deadlines; [Proposed] Order
  62. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  63. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment continued trial and related dates
  64. Stipulation Filed View Document Stipulation re: (1) Protective and Confidentiality Order Comment Stipulation re: (1) Protective and Confidentiality Order; (2) Order Governing Protocol for Discovery of Electronically Stored Information; and (3) Order Governing Privilege Logs
  65. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Protective and Confidentiality Order Comment Signed and forwarded to clerks office FWD to 501 - [Proposed] Protective and Confidentiality Order
  66. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Order Governing Privilege Logs Comment Signed and forwarded to clerks office Signed and forwarded to clerks office 08/19/24 FWD to 501 - [Proposed] Order Governing Privilege Logs
  67. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Order Governing Protocol For Discovery of Electronically Stored Information Comment Signed and forwarded to clerks office Stip and order signed and forwarded to clerks office 08/19/24 FWD to 501 - [Proposed] Order Governing Protocol For Discovery of Electronically Stored Information
  68. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  69. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Protective and Confidentiality Order
  70. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Order Governing Privilege Logs
  71. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Order Governing Protocol For Discovery of Electronically Stored Information
  72. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pre-Trial Discovery Conference.pdf Comment FWD 501
  73. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Opposition To Request For Pretrial Discovery Conference Comment FWD: D501
  74. Application Filed View Document - Motion for PHV Martinez Comment Motion to Admit Anthony Martinez to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  75. Order Received for Signature View Document - Pro Order Granting PHV Martinez Comment [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Admit Anthony Martinez to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  76. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard
  77. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request of rpretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  78. Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed View Document Request for Pre-trial Discovery Conference Comment Fwd D501
  79. Notice of Motion View Document Pro Hav Vice- Joseph E. Fornadel Comment for Pro Hac Vice- Joseph E. Fornadel, III
  80. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed order Joseph E. Fornadel Comment Pending HRG: [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Admit Joseph E. Fornadel to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  81. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document - Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Alexander Erwig; Gregory Dovel Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  82. Opposition to Request for Pre-Trial Discovery filed Comment FWD 501
  83. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  84. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document - Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: John K. Sherk; Anthony Martinez Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  85. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document - Granted Order Regarding Remote Appearance - John K. Sherk; Anthony Martinez Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment John Sherk Anthony Martinez
  86. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  87. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  88. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Heard
  89. Order filed View Document Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on request for pretrial discovery conference with certificate of mailing
  90. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:00 AM Result Heard
  91. Pre Trial Discovery Conference Original Type Pre Trial Discovery Conference Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 10:00 AM Result Heard
  92. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Alexander Erwig, Greg Dovel, Anthony martinez, John Shirk
  93. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with order after pretrial discovery conference and certificate of mailing
  94. Request Filed View Document Status Report and Request to Vacate Comment FWD: D501- Status Report and Request to Vacate
  95. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Regarding Report and Req to Vacate 10/15/24 hearing Comment ** Order signed** FWD: D501- Proposed Order Regarding Report and Req to Vacate hearing
  96. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment vacating
  97. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Anthony Martinez) - Filed
  98. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Joseph Fornadel)- Filed
  99. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailing
  100. Application Filed View Document Notice of Unopposed App. Pro Hac Vice Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application of Reid Bolton to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice; Memorandum of Points and Authorities
  101. Declaration Filed View Document of Alicia J. Donahue Comment of Alicia J. Donahue In Support of Unopposed Application for Reid Bolton to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  102. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Reid Bolton Comment Declaration of Reid Bolton In Support of Unopposed Application to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  103. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Comment **pending hearing - [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Application of Reid Boton to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  104. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment in support of documents
  105. Motion - Compel Attendance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Greg Dovel
  106. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  107. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order re Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions Comment *Order signed and forwarded to the Clerk's Office on 10-29-24 for further processing* FWD to 501 - Proposed Order re Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions
  108. Motion filed View Document Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions Comment FWD to 501 - Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions
  109. Order filed View Document 10-29-24 Order filed Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment regarding joint motion to continue dates for filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions
  110. Motion filed View Document Joint Motion to Continue Mediation Deadline Comment FWD to 501 - Joint Motion to Continue Mediation Deadline
  111. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Regarding Joint Motion to Continue Mediation Deadline Comment Order signed FWD to 501 - Proposed Order Regarding Joint Motion to Continue Mediation Deadline
  112. Chambers Work - Courtroom JA - Pre Original Type Chambers Work - Courtroom JA - Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  113. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Regarding joint motion to continue mediation deadline
  114. Motion filed View Document Motion to Admit Matthew E. Brown as Counsel Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Motion to Admit Matthew E. Brown to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration in Support There of
  115. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Granting Motion for Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Motion to Admit Matthew E. Brown to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  116. Application Filed View Document Notice of Application for Pro Hac Vice - John Kalas Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Notice of Application and Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of John Michael Kalas; Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet; and Proposed Order
  117. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of John Michael Kalas ISO Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of John Michael Kalas ISO Application to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  118. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Application for John Michael Kalas Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Application for John Michael Kalas to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  119. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Pro Hac Vice - John Kalas Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Application of John Michael Kalas to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  120. Application Filed View Document Motion to Admit Ericka L. Downie to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Motion to Admit Ericka L. Downie to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice; Memorandum of Points and Authorities; Declaration in Support Thereof
  121. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Pro Hac Vice - Ericka L. Downie Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Motion to Admit Ericka L. Downie to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  122. Motion filed View Document - Notice of Motion and Motion in Limine Comment Plaintiffs' Notice of Motion and Motion in Limine For Issue Preclusion of General Causation; Memorandum of Points and Authorities
  123. Order Received for Signature View Document - (Proposed) Order Regarding Plaintiff's Motion in Limine Comment Forwarded to Dept: Order for:
  124. Declaration Filed View Document - Declaration of Susan Posluszny Comment Declaration of Susan Posluszny In Support of Plaintiff's Motion in Limine for Issue Preclusion on General Causation
  125. Application Filed View Document Application for Pro Hac Vice - Lee M. Popkin Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Lee M. Popkin; Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet; and Proposed Order
  126. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Lee M. Popkin ISO Application for Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Lee M. Popkin ISO Unopposed Application to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  127. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Pro Hac Vice for Lee M. Popkin Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Unopposed Application for Lee M. Popkin to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  128. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Pro Hac Vice - Lee M. Popkin Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Application of Lee M. Popkin to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  129. Application Filed View Document - Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice-Claire Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Claire N. Abrahamson; Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet; and [Proposed] Order
  130. Declaration Filed View Document - Declaration of Claire N. Ambrahamson ISO Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice Comment Declaration of Claire N. Abrahamson ISO Unopposed Application to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  131. Declaration Filed View Document - Declaration of Kara M. Flageolet ISO Unopposed Application for Claire N. Abrahamson Comment Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Unopposed Application for Claire N. Abrahamson to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  132. Order Received for Signature View Document - Proposed Order Granting Unopposed Application of Claire N. Abrahamson Comment PENDING HEARING [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Application of Claire N. Abrahamson to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  133. Application Filed View Document Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice - Eugenio Duron-Carielo Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Eugenio A. Duron Carielo; Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet; and Proposed Order
  134. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Eugenio A. Duron-Carielo ISO Pro Hav Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Eugenio A. Duron-Carielo ISO Unopposed Application to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  135. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Pro Hav Vice of Eugenio Duron-Carielo Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Unopposed Application for Eugenio A. Duron-Carielo to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  136. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order Pro Hac Vice Eugenio Duron-Carielo Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Application of Eugenio A. Duron-Carielo to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  137. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Reid Bolton) - Filed
  138. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailing
  139. Application Filed View Document Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of David N. Sneed - Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of David N. Sneed
  140. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of David N. Sneed ISO Application for Pro Hac Vice Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of David N. Sneed ISO Unopposed Application to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  141. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Pro Hac Vice for David N. Sneed Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Unopposed Application of David N. Sneed to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  142. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order for Pro Hac Vice for David N. Sneed - Hrg: 12/18/24 Comment (Pending Hearing) [Proposed] Order Granting Unopposed Application of David N. Sneed to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  143. Notice Filed View Document Defendants Notice to correct hearing dated re unopposed motion Comment Defendants Notice to correct hearing dated re unopposed motion
  144. Notice Filed View Document Notice to correct hearing date Comment Notice to correct hearing date
  145. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 7 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 7
  146. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL 14 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 14
  147. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 15 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 15
  148. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 17 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 17
  149. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 18 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 18
  150. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 19 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 19
  151. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 21 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 21
  152. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 23 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 23
  153. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 24 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 24
  154. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance- Plaintiffs- HRG 12/12/24 Comment Party: Greg Dovel- Plaintiffs- HRG Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  155. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 22 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 22
  156. Notice Filed View Document Exhibits part 2.pdf Comment 2nd Part of Exhibits Related to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 22
  157. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 20 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 20
  158. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 10 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 10
  159. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 11 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 11
  160. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No 13 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No 13
  161. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No 16 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No 16
  162. Opposition filed View Document Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL Comment Defendants' Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL
  163. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of M Larsen Comment Declaration of M. Larsen
  164. Proof of Service View Document Tiffin - Proof of Service.pdf Comment Proof of Service
  165. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  166. Motion in Limine filed View Document Motion in Limine Filed Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 2
  167. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants MIL NO. 7 Comment Defendants MIL NO. 7
  168. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration ISO MIL No. 7 Comment Declaration ISO MIL No. 7
  169. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 4 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 4
  170. Notice Filed View Document Exs 2-3.pdf Comment Exhibits 2 and 3 to Plaintiffs MIL No. 4
  171. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 3 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 3
  172. Motion in Limine filed View Document MIL No. 1 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 1, Exhibits A through C
  173. Notice Filed View Document Ex. D-F MIL No. 1 Comment Exhibits D through F to Plaintiffs MIL No. 1
  174. Notice Filed View Document MIL NO. 1 Exhibit G-I Comment Exhibits G through I to Plaintiffs MIL No. 1
  175. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Appearance of Co-Counsel Susan Posluszny Comment Notice of Appearance of Co-Counsel Susan Posluszny
  176. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 1 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 1 - Other Product
  177. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 1 - Other Products, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration re Defts' MIL No. 1 - Other Product
  178. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 - Other Litigation
  179. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 3 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 3 - NRDC
  180. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 3 - NRDC, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration re Defts' MIL No. 3 - NRDC
  181. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 4 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 4 - SDS
  182. Declaration Filed View Document MIL 4 - SDS, DECL. of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration re Defts' MIL No. 4 - SDS
  183. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 5 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 5 - Seralini
  184. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 5 - Seralini Alone, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration re Defts' MIL No. 5 - Seralini
  185. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 6 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 6 - IBT and Craven
  186. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 6 - IBT and Craven, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration re Defts' MIL No. 6 - IBT and Craven
  187. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 15 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 15 to Exclude Devidence of the Purported Epidemiology Report by the ORD
  188. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 15 Dec and Exhibits Vol 1 of 2.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 15 Vol. 1 of 2
  189. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 15 Dec and Exhibits Vol 2 of 2.pdf Comment Declaration Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 15 Vol. 2 of 2
  190. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 16 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 16 To Exclude Evidence of the Sale or Use of Glyphosate as Boiler Cleaner
  191. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 16 Dec and Exhibits.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 16
  192. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 17 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 17 to Exclude Evidence of the Presence or Absence of Company Representatives
  193. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 17 Dec. and Exhibit.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 17
  194. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 8 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 8 to Exclude Evidence of Genetically Modified Organisms, Related Financial Information, and Bayer's Financial Status; MPA In Support Thereof
  195. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 8 - GMOs, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 8
  196. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 9 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 9 to Exclude Evidence of Prior Enforcement Actions; MPA In Support Thereof
  197. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 9 - Prior Enforcement, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 9
  198. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 10 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 10 to Exclude Evidence of the Tobacco Industry or Tobacco Litigation; MPA In Support Thereof
  199. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 10 - Tobacco Industry, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 10
  200. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 11 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 11 to Exclude Evidence of Bayer's Decision to Discontinue Glyphosate-Based Roundup Sales; MPA In Support Thereof
  201. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 11 - Product Sunset, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 11
  202. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 12 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 12 to Exclude Any Evidence of Glyphosate In Food or Other Unrelated Sources; MPA In Support Thereof
  203. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 12 - Food, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 12
  204. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 13 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine No.13 to Exclude Evidence Regarding Lobbying; MPA In Support Thereof
  205. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 13 - Lobbying, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 13
  206. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 14 Comment Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 14 to Exclude Roundup Product Labels or Advertisements That Plaintiff Did Not Personally See; MPA
  207. Declaration Filed View Document MIL No. 14 - Ads Not Seen, DECL of MLL.pdf Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Support of Defendants' Motion In Limine No. 14
  208. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 1 Comment Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 1, Exhs. A-C
  209. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs REVISED Motion in Limine No. 3 w/ Exhibits Comment Plaintiffs REVISED Motion in Limine No. 3 w/ Exhibits
  210. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs REVISED Motion in Limine No. 4 w/ Exhibit 1 Comment Plaintiffs REVISED Motion in Limine No. 4 w/ Exhibit 1
  211. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 5 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 5
  212. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 8 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 8
  213. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 9 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 9
  214. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 25 with Exhibit A Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 25 with Exhibit A
  215. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 12 Comment Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 12
  216. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 26 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 26
  217. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 27 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 27
  218. Motion in Limine filed View Document - Motion in Limine 18 Comment Deft's No 18 - to Exclude Evidence Regarding Plaintiff's Religion
  219. Declaration Filed View Document - Dec ISO MIL 18 Comment of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendants' MIL No. 18
  220. Motion in Limine filed View Document - Defendants' MIL No. 19 Comment Deft's No 19 - to Exclude Doubt is Their Product and Other Similar Inflammatory Publications
  221. Declaration Filed View Document - Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen Comment of Mathew L. Larsen ISO MIL No 19
  222. Declaration Filed View Document - Omnibus Dec and Exhibits
  223. Proof of Service View Document - Proof of Service - MILs
  224. Notice Filed View Document Notice of Withdrawal Issue Preclusion rtf.pdf Comment Request to Vacate Hearing
  225. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order MIL issue preclusion.docx.pdf Comment ** order signed. FWD to 501 - Request to Vacate Hearing
  226. Proof of Service View Document Tiffin_Amended POS Re Bolton PHV Appl.pdf Comment Proof of Service
  227. Amended Document Filed View Document Amended Declaration of Reid Bolton In Support of Unopposed Application Comment Amended Declaration of Reid Bolton In Support of Unopposed Application to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  228. Mandatory Settlement Conference Hearing Time 10:00 AM Cancel Reason Off Calendar
  229. Application Filed View Document Tiffin - Davis Notice of Unopposed PHV.pdf Comment PHV
  230. Declaration Filed View Document Tiffin - Davis Flageollet Dec and Ex..pdf Comment Kara M. Flageollet
  231. Declaration Filed View Document Tiffin - Davis Declaration of MND PHV.pdf Comment Melissa Nott Davis
  232. Order Received for Signature View Document Tiffin - Davis Proposed Order Granting PHV.pdf Comment ** (pending hearing) [Proposed] Order granting PHV
  233. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  234. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  235. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document rag Greg Doval Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Greg Doval
  236. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to:[email protected]
  237. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the Minute Order & Tentative Ruling was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on December 5, 2024. Parties served: Joshua Cools
  238. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration Comment re: Request to Vacate Hearing
  239. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment vacating hearing
  240. Motion in Limine filed View Document Notice of Motion and Motion to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity Comment Notice of Motion and Motion to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof
  241. Declaration Filed Comment of Matthew L. Larsen ISO Motion to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity
  242. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment by Email - - Notice of Motion, Declaration
  243. Motion in Limine filed View Document Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 6 Comment Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 6
  244. Notice Filed View Document Exhibits 2-3 to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 4 Comment Exhibits 2-3 to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 4
  245. Notice Filed View Document Exhibits D-F to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 1 Comment Exhibits D-F to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 1
  246. Notice Filed View Document Exhibits G-I to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 1 Comment Exhibits G-I to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 1
  247. Notice Filed View Document Exhibits B-E to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 25 Comment Exhibits B-E to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine No. 25
  248. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested
  249. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailing
  250. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment on Application of Reid Bolton to appear PHV
  251. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Party: Att for defendant Type of Appearance Requested: Zoom
  252. Stipulation Filed View Document Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions; Declaration Comment Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions; Declaration
  253. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order to Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Opps. Comment FWD to 501 - Proposed Order to Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Opps.
  254. Stipulation Filed View Document Stipulation re Dismissal of Claims Against Defendant Pleasant Valley Hardware Comment Stipulation re Dismissal of Claims Against Defendant Pleasant Valley Hardware
  255. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  256. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document rag Kara Flageollet Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Kara Flageollet
  257. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Mailed/Emailed to: [email protected]
  258. Motion - In Limine Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Greg Dovel - filed on
  259. Request for Judicial Notice View Document Plaintiffs RJN of the 9th Circuits NRDC Decision; Declaration of Gregory Dovel Comment Plaintiffs RJN of the 9th Circuits NRDC Decision; Declaration of Gregory Dovel
  260. Order Received for Signature View Document [Proposed] Order Granting Plaintiffs' RJN of the Ninth Circuits NRDC Decision Comment [Proposed] Order Granting Plaintiffs' Request for Judicial Notice of the Ninth Circuits NRDC Decision
  261. Opposition filed View Document Stipulation and order requires $60.00 filing fee. Please review and resubmit. Comment Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants motion to exclude testimony
  262. Opposition filed View Document Pltfs' Opp to Defts' Mtn to Exclude Testimony of Jack Goldberg, M.D.; Decl of Greg Dovel Comment to Defendants motion to exclude testimony
  263. Opposition filed View Document Pltfs' Opp to Mtn to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity Comment to defendants' motion to exclude testimony
  264. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE View Document Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions; Declaration View Document Proposed Order to Joint Motion to Continue Dates for Filing of Sargon Motions and Opps. Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  265. Order Received for Signature View Document Tiffin_03_Proposed Order - Heath.pdf Comment Proposed Order Granting Defendants' Motion Re Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath
  266. Proof of Service View Document POS Comment Proof of Service
  267. Motion filed View Document Defendants MIL to Exclude testimony of Dr. Kristan Aronson Comment Defendants MIL to Exclude testimony of Dr. Kristan Aronson
  268. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO MIL Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO MIL
  269. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed order granting MIL To Exclude Testimony Comment Proposed Order Granting MIL re Testimony of Dr. Kristan Aronson
  270. Proof of Service View Document Tiffin - Aronson - Proof of Service.pdf Comment Proof of Service
  271. Motion filed View Document MIL re Testimony of Jack Goldberg M.D. Comment Motion in Limine re Testimony of Jack Goldberg M.D.
  272. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration ISO Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony Comment Declaration ISO Motion in Limine to Exclude Testimony
  273. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed Order granting MIL Re Testimony of Jack Goldberg. M.D. Comment Proposed Order Granting MIL re Testimony of Jack Goldberg, M.D.
  274. Proof of Service View Document Tiffin - Goldberg MTE - Proof of Service.pdf Comment Proof of Service
  275. Order Granted View Document Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment to continue dated for filing of Sargon Motions and Oppositions
  276. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2; Declaration of Greg Dovel Comment to MIL No.2
  277. Opposition filed View Document laintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 4; Declaration of Greg Dovel Comment to MIL NO.4
  278. Opposition filed View Document Exhibits 10-14 to Pltfs' Opp to Defts' Motion in Limine No. 4 and Declaration of Greg Dovel Comment to MIL NO. 4
  279. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants MIL 13 Comment Opp. to MIL 13
  280. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Defendants MIL 18 Comment to defe. MIL NO. 18
  281. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to defendant's motion in limine NO. 9 Comment Opposition to defendant's motion in limine NO. 9
  282. Opposition filed View Document to Defendants MIL NO. 11 Comment to Defendants MIL NO. 11
  283. Opposition filed View Document To Def. MIL 16 Comment To Def. MIL 16
  284. Opposition filed View Document TO MIL No. 13 Comment TO MIL No. 13
  285. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp.
  286. Opposition filed View Document To Plaintiffs MIL 12 Comment To Plaintiffs MIL 12
  287. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. Comment Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen in Support of Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 12
  288. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs MIL No. 11 Comment Plaintiffs MIL No. 11
  289. Declaration Filed View Document Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition Comment Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition
  290. Opposition filed View Document to Plainitiffs MIL no. 9 Comment to Plainitiffs MIL no. 9
  291. Declaration Filed View Document of Mathew Larsen Comment Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen in Support of Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 9
  292. Opposition filed View Document to MIL No. 10 Comment to MIL No. 10
  293. Declaration Filed View Document of Matthew Larsen ISO Opposition Comment Of Matthew L. Larsen in Support of Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 10
  294. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Ptffs MIL No. 14 Comment Opposition to Ptffs MIL No. 14
  295. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen
  296. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Pltffs MIL NO. 15 Comment Opposition to Pltffs MIL NO. 15
  297. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen ISO Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 15 Comment Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen ISO Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 15
  298. Opposition filed View Document Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 16 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 16
  299. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 16 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 16
  300. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Pltffs MIL No. 17 Comment Opposition to Pltffs MIL No. 17
  301. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. to MIL NO. 17 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. to MIL NO. 17
  302. Opposition filed View Document Def. Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 18 Comment Def. Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 18
  303. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. to MIL 18 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 18
  304. Opposition filed Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants MIL No. 10
  305. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs Response to MIL NO. 15 Comment Plaintiffs Response to MIL NO. 15
  306. Motion filed View Document Opposition to MIL No. 1 Comment Opposition to MIL No. 1
  307. Motion filed View Document Exs C and D.pdf Comment Exhibits C and D to Plaintiffs Opp. to Defendants MIL No. 1
  308. Opposition filed View Document Def. Opp to MIL No. 25 Comment Def. Opp to MIL No. 25
  309. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 25 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 25
  310. Opposition filed View Document Opp. to pltffs MIL No. 26 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 26
  311. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew Larsen ISO Opp MIL 26 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion in Limine No. 26
  312. Opposition filed View Document Opp to Pltffs MIL No. 27 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 27
  313. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew Larsen ISO Opp. MIL NO. 27 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 27
  314. Opposition filed Comment Response to MIL NO. 19
  315. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs Response to MIL NO. 17 Comment Plaintiffs Response to MIL NO. 17
  316. Opposition filed View Document Ptffs opposition to MIL No. 8 Comment Ptffs opposition to MIL No. 8
  317. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs Opp. to MIL No. 5 Comment Plaintiffs Opp. to MIL No. 5
  318. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 12; Declaration of Greg Dovel Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 12; Declaration of Greg Dovel
  319. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 7; Declaration of Greg Dovel Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 7; Declaration of Greg Dovel
  320. Opposition filed View Document Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MIL 7 Exhibits C, D, and E Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendants' MIL 7 Exhibits C, D, and E
  321. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 8 Comment Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 8: To Exclude Any Argument, Testimony or Opinion that Roundup Cannot Cause Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma
  322. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen in Support of Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 8 Comment Declaration of Matthew L. Larsen in Support of Opposition to Motion in Limine No. 8
  323. Motion filed View Document Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL NO. 5 Comment Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL NO. 5
  324. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opp. Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 5
  325. Motion filed View Document Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 6 Comment Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 6
  326. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Opposition
  327. Motion filed View Document Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL NO. 7 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL NO. 7
  328. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew Larsen ISO Opp. Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 7
  329. Motion filed View Document Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants MIL No. 3. Comment Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants MIL No. 3
  330. Motion filed View Document Plaintiffs Opposition to MIL NO. 14 Comment Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants MIL No. 14
  331. Motion filed View Document Def. MIL to Exclude testimony Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath
  332. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO MIL Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Motion In Limine to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath
  333. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Def. MIL NO. 6 Comment Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants MIL No. 6
  334. List filed View Document Ex I to Platt. Opp. Comment Exhibit I to Plaintiffs Opp. to Defendants' MIL No. 6
  335. List filed View Document Ex. J-R to Plaintiff Opp. MIL No. 6 Comment Exs. J-R to Plaintiffs Opp. to Defendants' MIL No. 6
  336. Opposition filed View Document Motion in Limine #1 To Exclude argument, testimony or evidence by the EPA HRG: 01/03/2025 Comment Motion in Limine #1 Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 1 to Exclude Any Argument, Testimony or Evidence That the EPA Has Determined That Glyphosate Is Not or Is Not Likely to Be Carcinogenic and to Exclude EPA Documents Related Thereto
  337. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Filed - Mathew Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL #1 Comment Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 1
  338. Opposition filed View Document Motion in Limine -Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs MIL #2 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 2 to Exclude Any Argument or Testimony Regarding Hypothetical EPA Label Decisions
  339. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL #2 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 2
  340. Opposition filed View Document Motion in Limine Filed Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiff's MIL #3 Comment Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 3 to Prevent Monsanto from Arguing That Glyphosate and Roundup Are Synonymous
  341. Declaration Filed Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL No. 3
  342. Opposition filed View Document Motion in Limine Monsanto's Omnibus Opposition to Plaintiff's MIL #'s 4, 19-24 Comment Monsanto's Omnibus Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motions In Limine Nos. 4, 19-24 Regarding Foreign Regulatory Decisions
  343. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew Larsen ISO Monsanto's Omnibus Opposition MIL Nos. 4, 19-24 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto's Omnibus Opposition to Plaintiffs' MIL Nos. 4, 19-24
  344. Declaration Filed View Document Omnibus Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Oppositions to Motions in Limine Comment Omnibus Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Monsanto Company's Oppositions to Plaintiffs' Motions in Limine; Memorandum of Points and Authorities in Support Thereof
  345. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment by Email - - Oppositions and Declaration to Motions in Limine
  346. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue obo Matthew Brown - Filed
  347. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Kara Flageollet (John Kalas) (TD ) - Filed 11/15/24
  348. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Erica Downie) (TD ) - Filed 11/15/24
  349. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Lee Popkin) (TD ) - Filed 11/20/24
  350. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Eugenio Duron-Carielo) (TD ) - Filed 11/20/24
  351. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Alicia Donahue (Claire Abrahamson) (TD ) FILED 11/20/2024
  352. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Heard Comment Alicia Donahue (David N Sneed) (TD ) - Filed 11/21/24
  353. Reply filed View Document Deft's Reply In Further Support of Its Motion to Exclude Testimony of Jack Goldberg, M.D. Comment Defendant's Reply In Further Support of Its Motion to Exclude Testimony of Jack Goldberg, M.D.
  354. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment Kara Flogeollett, John Kalas
  355. On Courts own motion - remote appearance authorized Comment Kara Flogeollett ;John Kalas
  356. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailng
  357. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailng
  358. Declaration Filed View Document TIFFIN - KALAS PHV SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION.pdf Comment Supplemental Declaration of John Michael Kalas In Support of Unopposed Application to Appear as Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  359. Reply filed View Document Reply ISO of Motion to exclude Testimony Comment Reply ISO of Motion to exclude Testimony
  360. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  361. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:28 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Cntd to
  362. Clerk's Certificate of Mailing View Document Clerk's Certificate of Mailing Comment I certify that I am not a party to this cause and a true copy of the Minute Order and Tentative Ruling was placed in a sealed envelope and placed for collection and mailing on the date and at the place shown below following our ordinary business practice. I am readily familiar with this court's practice for collection and processing correspondence for mailing. On the same day that correspondence is placed for collection and mailing, it is deposited in the ordinary course of business with the United States Postal Service with postage fully prepaid. Place of Mailing: Fresno, California on December 19, 2024. Parties served: Joshua Cools
  363. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from chambers with certificate of mailing
  364. Motion filed View Document Notice of Motion & Motion to Preclude use of McKivison Trial Testimony HRG: 01/14/25 Comment Notice of Motion & Motion To Preclude use of McKivison Trial Testimony.
  365. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendant's Motion Preclude Use of McKivison Testimony Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO of Defendant's Motion to Preclude Use of McKivison Trial Testimony
  366. Order Received for Signature View Document Tiffin Proposed Order.pdf Comment Proposed Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Preclude Use of McKivison Trial Testimony
  367. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service
  368. Motion in Limine filed View Document Defnt.s' MIL to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp, HRG: 1/2/25, 9:30AM, Dept. 503 Comment Defendants' Motion In Limine to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp; Memorandum Of Points And Authorities In Support Thereof
  369. Declaration Filed View Document Decl. of Mathew L. Larsen To Exclude Dr. R. DeGrandchamp, HRG: 1/2/25, 9:30AM, Dept. 503 Comment Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen ISO Defendant's Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp
  370. Proposed Document filed View Document Prop OG Def.'s Motion Exclude Testimony Dr. R. DeGrandchamp, HRG: 1/2/25, 9:30AM, Dept. 503 Comment [Proposed] Order Granting Defendant's Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp - Pending Hearing
  371. Proof of Service View Document Proof of Service Comment By Mail for Motion In Limine
  372. Reply filed View Document Reply ISO Motion to Exclude Testimony Hrg: 1/14/25 Comment Reply ISO Motion to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity
  373. Declaration Filed View Document Reply Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen Hrg: 01/14/25 Comment Reply Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Further Support of Motion to Exclude Testimony of Thomas O. McGarity
  374. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath Comment Opposition to Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath
  375. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp Comment Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp; Declaration of Greg Dovel
  376. Opposition filed View Document Exhibit G to Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp Comment Exhibit G to Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp
  377. Opposition filed View Document Exhibits H through R to Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp Comment Exhibits H through R to Opposition to Motion to Exclude Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp
  378. Stipulation Filed View Document Stipulation to Shorten Time Re: Motion to Preclude Use of McKivison Trial Testimony Comment Stipulation to Shorten Time Re: Motion to Preclude Use of McKivison Trial Testimony
  379. Order Received for Signature View Document Order to Shorten Time of Motion granted Comment Forwarded to: 501 Order for: Shorten Time on Motion
  380. Reply filed View Document Defendant's reply ISO motion to exclude Comment Defendant's Reply In Further Support of Its Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Jenifer Heath
  381. Reply filed View Document Reply ISO Motion to Exclude Comment Monsanto's Reply In Support of Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp
  382. Declaration Filed View Document Reply Declaration Comment Reply Declaration of Mathew L. Larsen In Further Support of Monsanto's Motion to Exclude Testimony of Dr. Richard DeGrandchamp
  383. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Heard Comment Order to Shorten Time Motion
  384. Order Granted View Document Order to Shorten Time of Motion granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment shrotening time
  385. Statement filed View Document Joint Proposed Jury Instructions.pdf Comment Joint Proposed Jury Instructions
  386. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Original Type Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Result Uncontested Comment Kara Flageollet (Melissa Davis) (TD ) - filed 12/4/24
  387. Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) View Document Minute Order Attachment (Tentative Rulings Only) Comment with certificate of mailing
  388. Ex parte Filed View Document Ex Parte application Comment application to advance PHV
  389. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed order granting Exparte application Comment Pending Until Hearing 1-2-25 Proposed Order Granting Ex Parte Application
  390. Application Filed View Document Notice of unopposed application unopposed PHV Comment Notice of Unopposed Application and Unopposed Application to Appear Pro Hac Vice of Daniel P. Mach; Memorandum of Points and Authorities
  391. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Daniel Mach Comment Declaration of Daniel P. Mach ISO Unopposed Application to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  392. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet Comment Declaration of Kara M. Flageollet ISO Unopposed Application for Daniel P. Mach to Appear As Counsel Pro Hac Vice
  393. Order Received for Signature View Document Proposed order granting application PHV Comment Pending Until Hearing 1-2-25
  394. Ex Parte Hearing Original Type Ex Parte Hearing Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:29 PM Result Heard Comment Filed OST Pro Hac Vice - Alicia Donahue (Daniel Mach)
  395. Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance Original Type Chambers Work - Notice of Remote Appearance View Document 1-2-25 Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 5:32 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration
  396. Request for Dismissal Received - Pending Review View Document Dismissal of Party
  397. Notice of Remote Appearance. View Document 1-2-25 Notice of Remote Appearance Comment Ex Parte Hearing 1-2-25
  398. Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted View Document 1-2-25 Order Regarding Remote Appearance Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment HRG
  399. Proof of Service View Document 1-2-25 Proof of Service
  400. Notice of Order on Remote Appearance Comment Emailed to: '[email protected]'; '[email protected]'
  401. Opposition filed View Document Opposition To Plaintiffs RJN Of The Ninth Circuits Nrdc Opinion Comment Defendants Opposition To Plaintiffs Request For Judicial Notice Of The Ninth Circuits Nrdc Opinion
  402. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration Of Lee Popkin In Support Of Defendants Opposition To Plaintiffs Request Comment Declaration Of Lee Popkin In Support Of Defendants Opposition To Plaintiffs Request For Judicial Notice Of The Ninth Circuits Nrdc Opinion
  403. Proof of Service View Document POS Comment Proof of Service
  404. Minute Order Attachment View Document 1-2-25 Minute Order Attachment Comment w/certificate of mailing
  405. Order Granted View Document 1-2-25 Order Granted Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Comment Pro Hac Vice
  406. Remote Appearance Via Zoom Comment DATY: Kara Flageollet
  407. Appeared in Person Comment PATY: Daniel Mach
  408. Opposition filed View Document Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Preclude Reeves McKivison Testimony Comment Opposition to Defendants' Motion to Preclude Reeves McKivison Testimony
  409. Opposition filed View Document Monsantos Opposition to Nonparty CVNs Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast Trial Comment Monsantos Opposition to Nonparty CVNs Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast Trial
  410. Declaration Filed View Document Declaration re Opposition to Nonparty CVNs Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast Trial Comment Declaration of Lee Popkin in Support of Monsantos Opposition to Non-party CVNs Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast
  411. Proof of Service View Document POS Comment Proof of Service
  412. Notice Filed View Document Defendants Proposed Juror Questionnaire Comment Defendants Proposed Juror Questionnaire
  413. Trial Readiness Original Type Trial Readiness Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Hearing Time 9:30 AM Result Heard
  414. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment re: TRR
  415. Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter View Document Order Appointing Court Approved Reporter Judicial Officer Culver Kapetan, Kristi Comment Dayna Hester
  416. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  417. Jury Trial Original Type Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard Comment at 1:30PM
  418. Jury Trial Original Type Jury Trial Judicial Officer Hamilton, Jr., Jeffrey Y. Hearing Time 1:30 PM Result Heard Comment Time Est 18-20 days
  419. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment with certificate of mailing
  420. Pursuant to CCP 170.1 - Judge Disqualifies Self View Document Pursuant to CCP 170.1 - Judge Disqualifies Self Comment Judge: DTT Date:
  421. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment re: Trial Assignment Comment re: Trial Assignment
  422. Day of Trial Comment Day: 1
  423. Minute Order Attachment Comment Civil Jury Trial Day 1
  424. Appeared in Person
  425. Stipulation/Order to Use Certified Short Hand Reporter Filed Judicial Officer Skiles, Jon M Comment D. Hester
  426. Stipulation/Order to Use Certified Short Hand Reporter Filed View Document 1-6-25 Stipulation/Order to Use Certified Short Hand Reporter Filed Judicial Officer Skiles, Jon M Comment Dayna Hester
  427. Jury Trial Original Type Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard Comment Day 2
  428. Request Filed View Document 1.7.25 Amended Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast Comment Amended Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast
  429. Order Received for Signature View Document 1.7.25 [Proposed] Order on Media Request to Permit Coverage Comment [Proposed] Order on Media Request to Permit Coverage
  430. Response filed View Document 1.7.25 Courtroom View Network's Response to Monsanto Company's Objection to Rule 1.150 Media Request Comment Courtroom View Network's Response to Monsanto Company's Objection to Rule 1.150 Media Request
  431. Day of Trial Comment Day: 2
  432. Appeared in Person
  433. Minute Order Attachment View Document 1.7.25 DAY 2 Minute Order Attachment Comment Civil Jury Trial Day 2
  434. Objection filed View Document 1.7.25 Courtroom View Network's Objection to Tentative Ruling and Request for Hearing Comment Courtroom View Network's Objection to Tentative Ruling and Request for Hearing
  435. Jury Trial Original Type Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard
  436. Day of Trial Comment Day: 3
  437. Appeared in Person
  438. Minute Order Attachment View Document 1.8.25 DAY 3 Minute Order Attachment Comment Civil Jury Trial Day 3
  439. Jury Trial Original Type Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Result Heard Comment Day 4
  440. List filed Comment Joint Witness List
  441. Day of Trial Comment JT Day: 4
  442. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment JT Day 4
  443. Minute Order Corrected/Amended View Document Day 4 - Civil Jury Trial Minute Order Comment First Corrected. Civil Jury Trial Day 4
  444. Notice Filed View Document 1.13.25 Courtroom View Network's Withdrawal of Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast Comment Courtroom View Network's Withdrawal of Media Request to Photograph, Record, or Broadcast
  445. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  446. Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Court Order
  447. General Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Exclude Testimony - Lee Popkin (Date Requested by Party - aware it is after trial)
  448. Notice Filed View Document Joint Notice of Settlement (rtf).pdf Comment Joint Notice of Settlement
  449. Minute Order Attachment View Document 1.14.25 CW Minute Order Comment from Chamber
  450. Chambers Work- Pre Original Type Chambers Work- Pre Hearing Time 6:00 AM Result Heard
  451. Jury Trial Hearing Time 9:00 AM Cancel Reason Court Order Comment Day 5
  452. Minute Order Attachment View Document Minute Order Attachment Comment from Chamber and CM
  453. Exhibit List Filed
  454. Motion - Pro Hac Vice Motion Judicial Officer Tharpe, D Tyler Hearing Time 3:27 PM Cancel Reason Off Calendar Comment Alicia Donahue (Daniel Mach) (Ex Parte for OST Scheduled)
  455. Stipulation Filed View Document Stipulation Between Plaintiffs and Defendant Monsanto to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents Comment Stipulation Between Plaintiffs and Defendant Monsanto to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents From the Record
  456. Proof of Service View Document POS re Stipulation Between Plaintiffs Rodger and Barbara Tiffin and Defendant Monsanto Company Comment Proof of Service of Stipulation Between Plaintiffs Rodger and Barbara Tiffin and Defendant Monsanto Company
  457. Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Original Type Chamber Work - CG Orders - PRE Judicial Officer Gamoian, Lisa M. Hearing Time 5:30 PM Result Chambers Work - Order Submitted for Consideration Comment w/ Stipulation filed
  458. Order Received for Signature View Document Order Re: Stip Between Plaintiffs and Defendant to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents Comment FWD to 403 - [proposed] Order Re: Stipulation Between Plaintiffs and Defendant Monsanto to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents
  459. Order filed View Document Order Re: Stip Between Plaintiffs and Defendant to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents Judicial Officer Skiles, Jon M Comment Stip. to Strike Certain Unredacted Documents from the Record
  460. Notice Filed View Document Notice Filed Comment Notice of Calendar Setting
  461. Opposition filed View Document 022425 Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 10 Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 10
  462. Opposition filed View Document 022425 Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 3 Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 3
  463. Opposition filed View Document 022425 Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 19 Comment Plaintiffs' Opposition to Defendant's Motion in Limine No. 19
  464. Request for Dismissal Received - Pending Review View Document 3-14-25 Request for Dismissal

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more