Your case is unique, but you are not alone.
About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.
Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?
How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?
AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.
Full Analytics Report
- Complete case narrative
- Judge details and rulings
- Case disposition and outcome
- All docket entries
- Related cases and filings
Case Information
Parties
Lawyers
Docket Entries
- ORDER
- INITIAL COMPLAINT
- CASE INFORMATION STATEMENT
- NOTICE
- WRIT ISSUED
- WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
- WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
- WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
- WRIT RETURN (GENERIC)
- ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
- WRIT ISSUED
- ANSWER
- MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE
- RESPONSE
- LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM
- ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
- ORDER
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
- ENTRY OF APPEARANCE FILED
- DISCOVERY
- ORDER
- E-MAIL FILED
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
- EXHIBITS
- LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
- ORDER
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM
- DISCOVERY
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY
- RE-NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- MOTION
- E-MAIL FILED
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- E-MAIL FILED
- CONFIRMATION DISMISSAL LETTER
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
- STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 14, 2024 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF GAETANO J. SCUDERI, M.D. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ON NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF GAETANO J. SCUDERI, M.D. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74315543
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 19, 2024 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF PLAINTIFFS LINDA AND JOHN SHIELDS CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ON NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF LINDA AND JOHN SHIELDS ACCEPTED BY: AK TRANSACTION ID: 74358857
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 24, 2024 ALL COUNSEL APPEARED FOR THE HEARING. DEFENDANT EXPERT REPORT IS DUE ON OCTOBER 23, 2024. DEFENDANT DEPOSITION CUT OFF SHALL BE NOVEMBER 1, 2024. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74564582
- EXHIBITS
- EXHIBITS DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 26, 2024 DEFENDANTS MEDTRONIC SOFAMOR DANEK USA, INC. AND SPINALGRAFT TECHNOLOGIES, LLC'S AMENDED CROSS CLAIM (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) REDLINE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74588240
- LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW
- LETTER FOR JUDICIAL REVIEW DATE DOCKETED: SEPTEMBER 27, 2024 LETTER TO THE HONORABLE DANIELLE J. BRENNAN REQUESTING AND EXTENSION TO FILE THE EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE FROM OCTOBER 1, 2024 TO OCTOBER 3, 2024 ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74608443
- ORDER
- ORDER DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 1, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY: JUDGE, FIBERCEL GRANTED (LETTER TO THE HONORABLE DANIELLE J. BRENNAN REQUESTING AND EXTENSION TO FILE THE EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE FROM OCTOBER 1, 2024 TO OCTOBER 3, 2024) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74623059
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 2, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF (I) PLAINTIFFS LINDA L. SHIELDS RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS DCI DONOR SERVICES, INC., AND NEW MEXICO DONOR SERVICES FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES (II) PLAINTIFFS LINDA L. SHIELDS RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS DCI DONOR SERVICES, INC., AND NEW MEXICO DONOR SERVICES FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74640772
- ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM
- ANSWER TO THE CROSSCLAIM DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 3, 2024 DENIAL OF CROSS-CLAIMS BY KENNETHER LINGENFELTER, D.O. AND FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A. CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74652537
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 3, 2024 EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE ON BEHALF OF FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A., AND KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. EXHIBIT A TO EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE EXHIBIT B TO EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURES NOTICE OF SERVICE ON EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURES ACCEPTED BY: AK TRANSACTION ID: 74655285
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 18, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFF LINDA L. SHIELDS RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS AZIYO BIOLOGICS, INC.S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES; (II) PLAINTIFFS LINDA L. SHIELDS RESPONSES AND OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANT AZIYO BIOLOGICS, INC.S FIRST SET OF REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS; AND (III) THIS NOTICE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74786078
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 19, 2024 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. SCHEDULED FOR OCTOBER 25, 2024 BEGINNING AT 1:00 P.M. EST (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74795960
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 19, 2024 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF AKHIL JAY KHANNA, M.D. SCHEDULED FOR OCTOBER 26, 2024 BEGINNING AT 9:00 A.M. EST (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74795960
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 23, 2024 UPDATED EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE ON BEHALF OF FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A., AND KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. NOTICE OF SERVICE ON UPDATED EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE ON BEHALF OF FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A. AND KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74807599
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 24, 2024 EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE OF A. JAY KHANNA, M.D., BY FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A., AND KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. EXHIBIT A TO EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE OF A. JAY KHANNA, M.D. BY FSO AND LINGENFELTER NOTICE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74845359
- DISCOVERY
- DISCOVERY DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 24, 2024 DEFENDANTS MEDTRONIC SOFAMOR DANEK USA, INC. AND SPINALGRAFT TECHNOLOGIES, LLC'S EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) EXHIBITS A - B TO DEFENDANTS MEDTRONIC SOFAMOR DANEK USA, INC. AND SPINALGRAFT TECHNOLOGIES, LLC'S EXPERT WITNESS DISCLOSURE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74847114
- RE-NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- RE-NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF: DATE DOCKETED: OCTOBER 25, 2024 AMENDED NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. SCHEDULED FOR OCTOBER 25, 2024 BEGINNING AT 1:00 P.M. EST (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74860827
- NOTICE OF SERVICE
- NOTICE OF SERVICE DATE DOCKETED: NOVEMBER 2, 2024 NOTICE OF SERVICE OF SUBPOENA DIRECTED TO DOCUSIGN, INC. (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) SUBPOENA DIRECTED TO DOCUSIGN, INC. WITH PROOF OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 74925080
- MOTION
- MOTION DATE DOCKETED: NOVEMBER 3, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE NOTICE OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. TO BE PRESENTED AT THE CONVENIENCE OF THE COURT [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. PLAINTIFF'S OPENING BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. [CONFIDENTIAL FILING] EXHIBITS A-D TO PLAINTIFF'S OPENING BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. [CONFIDENTIAL FILING] CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE TO PLAINTIFF'S OPENING BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCLUDE OPINIONS AND TESTIMONY OF PAYAM NAHID, M.D. ACCEPTED BY: AK TRANSACTION ID: 74927768
- E-MAIL FILED
- E-MAIL FILED DATE DOCKETED: NOVEMBER 21, 2024 ORDER SIGNED BY: JUDGE, FIBERCEL EMAIL FROM ALICIA MAXWELL CONFIRMING THE STATUS CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR 12-05-24 AT 11:00 A.M., VIA COURTSCRIBES. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75053205
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION
- NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 5, 2024 NOTICE OF DEPOSITION OF ALEXANDER R. VACCARO, M.D., FOR USE AT TRIAL SCHEDULED FOR DECEMBER 9, 2024 BEGINNING AT 3:00 P.M. EST. (WITH CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75135476
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OF CERTAIN IRRELEVANT FAMILY HISTORY [CONFIDENTIAL FILING] NOTICE OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OF CERTAIN IRRELEVANT FAMILY HISTORY WILL BE PRESENTED AT THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 2, 2025 [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OF CERTAIN IRRELEVANT FAMILY HISTORY EXHIBITS A-B TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE OF CERTAIN IRRELEVANT FAMILY HISTORY CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75195809
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION WHETHER TUBERCULOSIS CELLS WOULD HAVE BEEN KILLED IF FIBERCEL WAS TERMINALLY STERILIZED WITH (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) NOTICE OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION WHETHER TUBERCULOSIS CELLS WOULD HAVE BEEN KILLED IF FIBERCEL WAS TERMINALLY STERILIZED WILL BE PRESENTED TO THE COURT AT THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 2, 2025. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION WHETHER TUBERCULOSIS CELLS WOULD HAVE BEEN KILLED IF FIBERCEL WAS TERMINALLY STERILIZED EXHIBITS A-B TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION WHETHER TUBERCULOSIS CELLS WOULD HAVE BEEN KILLED IF FIBERCEL WAS TERMINALLY STERILIZED ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75196688
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT EVIDENCE PERSONAL TO DEFENDANT KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. WITH (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) NOTICE OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT EVIDENCE PERSONAL TO DEFENDANT KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. WILL BE PRESENTED TO THE COURT DURING THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 2, 2025. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT EVIDENCE PERSONAL TO DEFENDANT KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. EXHIBITS A-B TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE IRRELEVANT EVIDENCE PERSONAL TO DEFENDANT KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75197192
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE THAT SURGEONS OTHER THAN DEFENDANT MIX LIVE CELL ALLOGRAFT WITH PATIENTS BONE MARROW ASPIRATE WITH (CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE) NOTICE OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE THAT SURGEONS OTHER THAN DEFENDANT MIX LIVE CELL ALLOGRAFT WITH PATIENTS BONE MARROW ASPIRATE WILL BE PRESENTED TO THE COURT AT THE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR JANUARY 2, 2025. [PROPOSED] ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE THAT SURGEONS OTHER THAN DEFENDANT MIX LIVE CELL ALLOGRAFT WITH PATIENTS BONE MARROW ASPIRATE EXHIBITS A-F TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE EVIDENCE THAT SURGEONS OTHER THAN DEFENDANT MIX LIVE CELL ALLOGRAFT WITH PATIENTS BONE MARROW ASPIRATE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75200873
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 DEFENDANTS KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. AND FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A.S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE AND LIMIT SPECIFIC TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERT WITNESS DR. ALEXANDER VACCARO NOTICE OF MOTION PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. AND FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A.S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE AND LIMIT SPECIFIC TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERT WITNESS DR. ALEXANDER VACCARO CERTIFICATE OF COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75205268
- MOTION IN LIMINE
- MOTION IN LIMINE DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 13, 2024 DEFENDANTS KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. AND FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A.S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE AND LIMIT SPECIFIC TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERT WITNESS DR. GAETANO SCUDERI NOTICE OF MOTION DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF DR. GAETANO SCUDERI SEPTEMBER 19, 2024 DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF LINDA SHIELDS FEBRUARY 22, 2024 DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPT OF LINDA SHIELDS SEPTEMBER 25, 2024 PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANTS KENNETH LINGENFELTER, D.O. AND FIRST STATE ORTHOPAEDICS, P.A.S MOTION IN LIMINE TO PRECLUDE AND LIMIT SPECIFIC TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERT WITNESS DR. GAETANO SCUDERI CERTIFICAE OF COMPLIANCE CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75205403
- E-MAIL FILED
- E-MAIL FILED DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 19, 2024 EMAIL FROM YVONNE SAVILLE ADVISING THAT THE CASE HAS SETTLED. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75251898
- CONFIRMATION DISMISSAL LETTER
- CONFIRMATION OF DISMISSAL LETTER DATE DOCKETED: DECEMBER 19, 2024 THIS LETTER IS A CONFIRMATION THAT THE COURT HAS BEEN NOTIFIED BY THE PLAINTIFF OR PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL IN THE ABOVE REFERENCED CASE THAT THE PARTIES HAVE SETTLED THIS MATTER AS TO ALL CLAIMS AND ALL PARTIES. IN ORDER FOR THE COURT TO CLOSE ITS FILE, A STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL MUST BE FILED. IF A STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL, OR A LETTER STATING THE STATUS OF THIS MATTER, IS NOT FILED WITH THE COURT WITHIN SIXTY (60) DAYS OF THE DATE OF THIS LETTER, THE COURT WILL DISMISS THIS ACTION WITH PREJUDICE. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75251920
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM
- JUDICIAL ACTION FORM DATE DOCKETED: JANUARY 10, 2025 JUDICIAL ACTION FORM FROM HEARING HELD ON DECEMBER 5, 2024. ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75401177
- STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL
- CLOSED: STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL DATE DOCKETED: MARCH 6, 2025 STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75768272
- ORDER
- ORDER DATE DOCKETED: MARCH 11, 2025 ORDER SIGNED BY: JUDGE, FIBERCEL SO ORDERED (STIPULATION OF DISMISSAL) ACCEPTED BY: SD TRANSACTION ID: 75802569
Get Free Case Details
Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.
By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.
Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In