Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Cuyahoga County

Court

Cuyahoga County

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2022-08-17
Status INACTIVE
Type Tort Dental Malpractice
Docket 118 entries

Parties

Plaintiff John R. Whitmer
Defendant Cleveland Clinic Mercy Hospital C/o Ct Corporation System, Statutory Agent|Cleveland Clinic Foundation C/o Ct Corporation System, Statutory Agent|Katherine Cheffins Dds|Andrew Wojtkowski Dmd|George Williams, Jr. Dds|Kurt C. Garren Md|Kurt C. Garren, M.d. Inc. C/o Kurt C. Garren, Statutory Agent|John Does 1 Through 20 Unknown Persons And Entities Which Are Responsible For Plaintiff's Injuries|Mercy Medical Center|Sisters Of Charity Health System
Photo of Hon. Ashley Kilbane

Judge

Hon. Ashley Kilbane

Cuyahoga County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. CASE FILED: COMPLAINT
  2. COURT COST ASSESSED JOHN R. WHITMER BILL AMOUNT 433.05 PAID AMOUNT 250 AMOUNT DUE 183.05
  3. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020649) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: SANDRA M DIFRANCO [email protected]
  4. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020648) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PATRICK S CORRIGAN [email protected]
  5. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020647) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: PATRICK S CORRIGAN [email protected]
  6. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020646) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: RYAN JOSHUA KUN [email protected]
  7. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020645) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: RYAN JOSHUA KUN [email protected]
  8. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020644) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MATTHEW P BARINGER [email protected]
  9. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020643) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: MATTHEW P BARINGER [email protected]
  10. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020642) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: JOSEPH J TRISCARO [email protected]
  11. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020641) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: STEPHEN P GRIFFIN [email protected]
  12. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020640) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: THOMAS W WRIGHT [email protected]
  13. JUDGMENT ENTRY(52020639) SENT BY EMAIL. TO: THOMAS W WRIGHT [email protected]
  14. PLAINTIFF HAVING FILED A NOTICE OF DISMISSAL, CASE DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE. COURT COST ASSESSED TO THE PLAINTIFF(S). PURSUANT TO CIV.R. 58(B), THE CLERK OF COURTS IS DIRECTED TO SERVE THIS JUDGMENT IN A MANNER PRESCRIBED BY CIV.R. 5(B). THE CLERK MUST INDICATE ON THE DOCKET THE NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF ALL PARTIES, THE METHOD OF SERVICE, AND THE COSTS ASSOCIATED WITH THIS SERVICE. NOTICE ISSUED
  15. NOTICE FILED BY P1 JOHN R. WHITMER ATTORNEY JOSEPH J TRISCARO 0081209 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE
  16. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE SCHEDULED FOR 10/10/2023 AT 02:00 PM IS CANCELLED.
  17. SUBPOENA SERVICE RETURN FILED, NON-PARTY 9999999 SUBPOENA RETURN ON DAVID ASH, DMD
  18. NOTICE FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) KURT C. GARREN(D6) and KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC.(D7) ATTORNEY STEPHEN P GRIFFIN 0039655 NOTICE OF SERVICE
  19. JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND CASE MANAGEMENT DATES, FILED 05/15/2023, IS GRANTED. THE DEADLINES IN THE 11/14/2022 CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER ARE EXTENDED AS FOLLOWS: DISCOVERY SHALL BE COMPLETED BY: 09/01/2023. IF A DISCOVERY DISPUTE ARISES, THE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TELEPHONICALLY OR IN-PERSON. IF AFTER A GOOD-FAITH ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE THE ISSUES A DISPUTE REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHOULD CONTACT THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY BY EMAIL WITH A SUGGESTED DATE AND TIME FOR A ZOOM CONFERENCE WITH THE COURT, AND INCLUDE A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE ISSUES TO BE DISCUSSED. THEREAFTER, THE COURT MAY ORDER BRIEFING. PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT REPORT DUE: 10/02/2023. DEFENDANTS' EXPERT REPORT DUE: 12/08/2023. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS TO BE FILED BY: 10/09/2023. DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS SHALL INCLUDE BRIEFING AS TO THE THEORY OF LIABILITY, MATERIAL FACTS, AND OTHER MATERIAL INFORMATION, SUCH AS CONTROLLING LAW OR THE EXISTENCE AND APPLICATION OF A CHOICE OF LAW PROVISION. RESPONSES DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6(C). ALL DEPOSITION PAGES THAT ARE CITED SHALL BE ATTACHED TO THE MOTIONS AND BRIEFS. ALL PAGES SHALL BE SECURELY FASTENED (A BINDER CLIP IS NOT ACCEPTABLE). UPON FILING, HARD COPIES OF ALL DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS, BRIEFS, AND EXHIBITS SHALL BE DELIVERED TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY ON THE 11TH FLOOR. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE SET FOR 01/11/2024 AT 11:00 AM. SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE, EACH PARTY SHALL PROVIDE THE COURT WITH A BRIEF STATEMENT OUTLINING THE CLAIMS TO BE DISCUSSED, THE FACTUAL SUPPORT OF ANY DISPUTES, AND ANY OFFERS OR SETTLEMENT DISCUSSION HAD TO DATE. THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENTS NEED NOT BE FILED, BUT INSTEAD SENT TO THE STAFF ATTORNEY. FINAL PRETRIAL SET FOR 02/27/2024 AT 01:00 PM. THE PARTIES SHALL EACH FILE A FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THE FINAL PRETRIAL AND SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: - A BRIEF STATEMENT OF FACTS AND LEGAL ISSUES; - STIPULATIONS; - LIST OF WITNESSES WITH BRIEF SUMMARY OF EXPECTED TESTIMONY; - LIST OF EXHIBITS EXPECTED TO BE USED A TRIAL; - ANY ANTICIPATED UNIQUE LEGAL ISSUES; - AN ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL; - ANY CONTEMPLATED PRETRIAL MOTIONS; AND - SPECIAL EQUIPMENT OR POTENTIAL LOGISTICAL REQUESTS. THE PARTIES SHALL EXCHANGE TRIAL EXHIBITS NO LATER THAN SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SHALL UPDATE THE PREVIOUSLY-PROVIDED SETTLEMENT STATEMENT. TRIAL BY JURY SET FOR 04/08/2024 AT 09:00 AM. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO SUP.R. 41 AND LOC.R. 17 REGARDING CONTINUANCE OF TRIAL. TRIAL BRIEFS DUE ONE DAY BEFORE TRIAL. DAUBERT OR EXPERT-RELATED MOTIONS IN LIMINE: ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPORTED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED BY THE EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE SET BY THE COURT. IF NO EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE WAS SET, THEN ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED AT LEAST FORTY-FIVE (45) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE PARTY CHALLENGING THE PROPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL FILE A COMPLETE COPY OF THE EXPERT'S REPORT(S) AND COMPLETE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS, IF THE EXPERT WAS DEPOSED. MOTIONS IN LIMINE SHALL BE FILED TWENTY-ONE (21) DAYS BEFORE THE START OF TRIAL. RESPONSES DUE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 6(C). NO REPLIES ARE PERMITTED. AFTER THE DEADLINE FOR RESPONSES, COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TO RESOLVE THE MOTIONS IN LIMINE, AND, AT LEAST (3) DAYS PRIOR TO TRIAL, THE PARTIES SHALL FILE A JOINT NOTICE INFORMING THE COURT WHICH MOTIONS IN LIMINE ARE UNOPPOSED OR RESOLVED, AND WHICH REMAIN OPPOSED. DEPOSITIONS, AUDIOVISUAL OR TRANSCRIPTS, TO BE PROFFERED AT TRIAL. ANY PARTY WISHING TO PROFFER DEPOSITION TESTIMONY AT TRIAL IN LIEU OF THE DEPONENT'S ATTENDANCE SHALL EXCHANGE SUCH DEPOSITION TESTIMONY BY COUNSEL AT LEAST THIRTY (30) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES SHALL MEET TELEPHONICALLY OR IN PERSON TO DISCUSS ANY OBJECTIONS TO THE PROFFERED TESTIMONY. IF ANY DISPUTES RELATING TO THE TESTIMONY REMAIN AFTER THE GOOD FAITH CONFERENCE, THE PARTIES SHALL SEND HARD COPIES OF THEIR RESPECTIVE DESIGNATIONS WITH OBJECTIONS EITHER ANNOTATED IN THE MARGINS OR OUTLINED IN A SEPARATE DOCUMENT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST FOURTEEN (14) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES MAY INCLUDE A BRIEF STATEMENT FOR CONTEXT FOR THE OBJECTIONS IF NECESSARY. JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND JURY INTERROGATORIES ARE DUE SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES IN ORDER TO SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. THE PARTIES SHALL SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST ONE (1) DAY BEFORE TRIAL. IF ANY DISAGREEMENT REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHALL HIGHLIGHT DISAGREEMENTS TO THE COURT. THE PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES SHALL BE SUBMITTED IN MICROSOFT WORD FORMAT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY. FURTHER, THE PARTIES ARE ENCOURAGED TO SUBMIT A JOINT STATEMENT OF THE CASE TO BE READ TO THE JURY. ALL PARTIES AND COUNSEL OF RECORD TO BE PRESENT AT BOTH THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND THE FINAL PRETRIAL OR APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS WILL BE IMPOSED, INCLUDING DISMISSAL PURSUANT TO CIV. RULE 41(B)(1) OR DEFAULT JUDGMENT (AS APPLICABLE). THE COURT HOLDS SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES AND FINAL PRETRIALS BY ZOOM, UNLESS THE ORDERED OTHERWISE OR THE PARTIES REQUEST IN-PERSON SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND/OR FINAL PRETRIAL AT LEAST TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE EXPECTED TO BE FAMILIAR WITH THE OHIO RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, THE LOCAL RULES, THIS COURT'S STANDING CIVIL ORDER, WHICH CAN BE FOUND ON THE COURT'S WEBSITE, AND ANY OTHER ORDERS OF THIS COURT. NOTICE ISSUED
  20. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND CASE MANAGEMENT DATES 05/30/2023 - GRANTED
  21. NOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL FILED NOTICE OF SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL
  22. PURSUANT TO THE STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO MOVE OR PLEAD, FILED 03/22/2023, DEFENDANT GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. D.D.S. MAY MOVE OR PLEAD TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST SET OF INTERROGATORIES AND REQUESTS FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS BY OR ON 04/21/2023. NOTICE ISSUED
  23. STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO PLEAD FILED STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO MOVE OR PLEAD
  24. NOTICE FILED BY P1 JOHN R. WHITMER ATTORNEY JOSEPH J TRISCARO 0081209 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
  25. CMC BY PHONE HELD ON 11/09/2022. THE PARTIES APPEARED THROUGH COUNSEL OF RECORD. STATUS OF CASE DISCUSSED AND THE FOLLOWING DEADLINES SET: ALL DISCOVERY TO BE COMPLETED BY 05/31/2023. IF A DISCOVERY DISPUTE ARISES, THE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TELEPHONICALLY OR IN-PERSON. IF AFTER A GOOD-FAITH ATTEMPT TO RESOLVE THE ISSUES A DISPUTE REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHOULD CONTACT THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY BY EMAIL WITH A SUGGESTED DATE AND TIME FOR A ZOOM CONFERENCE WITH THE COURT, AND INCLUDE A BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE ISSUES TO BE DISCUSSED. THEREAFTER, THE COURT MAY ORDER BRIEFING. PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 06/30/2023. DEFENDANT'S EXPERT REPORT DUE 08/31/2023. DISPOSITIVE MOTION TO BE FILED BY 07/03/2023. RESPONSES DUE PER CIVIL RULE 6(C). ALL DEPOSITION PAGES THAT ARE CITED SHALL BE ATTACHED TO THE MOTIONS AND BRIEFS. ALL PAGES SHALL BE SECURELY FASTENED (A BINDER CLIP IS NOT ACCEPTABLE). UPON FILING, HARD COPIES OF ALL DISPOSITIVE MOTIONS, BRIEFS, AND EXHIBITS SHALL BE DELIVERED TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY ON THE 11TH FLOOR. SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE SET FOR 10/10/2023 AT 02:00 PM. SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE, EACH PARTY SHALL PROVIDE THE COURT WITH A BRIEF STATEMENT OUTLINING THE CLAIMS TO BE DISCUSSED, THE FACTUAL SUPPORT OF ANY DISPUTES, AND ANY OFFERS OR SETTLEMENT DISCUSSION HAD TO DATE. THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE STATEMENTS NEED NOT BE FILED, BUT INSTEAD SENT TO THE STAFF ATTORNEY. FINAL PRETRIAL SET FOR 11/06/2023 AT 01:00 PM. THE PARTIES SHALL EACH FILE A FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SEVEN DAYS BEFORE THE FINAL PRETRIAL AND SHALL INCLUDE THE FOLLOWING: - A BRIEF STATEMENT OF FACTS AND LEGAL ISSUES; - STIPULATIONS; - LIST OF WITNESSES WITH BRIEF SUMMARY OF EXPECTED TESTIMONY; - LIST OF EXHIBITS EXPECTED TO BE USED A TRIAL; - ANY ANTICIPATED UNIQUE LEGAL ISSUES; - AN ESTIMATED LENGTH OF TRIAL; - ANY CONTEMPLATED PRETRIAL MOTIONS; AND - SPECIAL EQUIPMENT OR POTENTIAL LOGISTICAL REQUESTS. THE PARTIES SHALL EXCHANGE TRIAL EXHIBITS NO LATER THAN SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE FINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SHALL UPDATE THE PREVIOUSLY-PROVIDED SETTLEMENT STATEMENT. JURY TRIAL SET FOR 12/06/2023 AT 09:00 AM. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE DIRECTED TO SUP.R. 41 AND LOC.R. 17 REGARDING CONTINUANCE OF TRIAL. TRIAL BRIEFS DUE ONE DAY BEFORE TRIAL. DAUBERT OR EXPERT-RELATED MOTIONS IN LIMINE: ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPORTED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED BY THE EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE SET BY THE COURT. IF NO EXPERT MOTION DEADLINE WAS SET, THEN ANY MOTION CHALLENGING PURPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL BE FILED AT LEAST FORTY-FIVE (45) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. THE PARTY CHALLENGING THE PROPOSED EXPERT TESTIMONY SHALL FILE A COMPLETE COPY OF THE EXPERT'S REPORT(S) AND COMPLETE DEPOSITION TRANSCRIPTS, IF THE EXPERT WAS DEPOSED. MOTIONS IN LIMINE SHALL BE FILED TWENTY-ONE (21) DAYS BEFORE THE START OF TRIAL. RESPONSES DUE PURSUANT TO CIV. R. 6(C). NO REPLIES ARE PERMITTED. AFTER THE DEADLINE FOR RESPONSES, COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER TO RESOLVE THE MOTIONS IN LIMINE, AND, AT LEAST (3) DAYS PRIOR TO TRIAL, THE PARTIES SHALL FILE A JOINT NOTICE INFORMING THE COURT WHICH MOTIONS IN LIMINE ARE UNOPPOSED OR RESOLVED, AND WHICH REMAIN OPPOSED. DEPOSITIONS, AUDIOVISUAL OR TRANSCRIPTS, TO BE PROFFERED AT TRIAL. ANY PARTY WISHING TO PROFFER DEPOSITION TESTIMONY AT TRIAL IN LIEU OF THE DEPONENT'S ATTENDANCE SHALL EXCHANGE SUCH DEPOSITION TESTIMONY BY COUNSEL AT LEAST THIRTY (30) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES SHALL MEET TELEPHONICALLY OR IN PERSON TO DISCUSS ANY OBJECTIONS TO THE PROFFERED TESTIMONY. IF ANY DISPUTES RELATING TO THE TESTIMONY REMAIN AFTER THE GOOD FAITH CONFERENCE, THE PARTIES SHALL SEND HARD COPIES OF THEIR RESPECTIVE DESIGNATIONS WITH OBJECTIONS EITHER ANNOTATED IN THE MARGINS OR OUTLINED IN A SEPARATE DOCUMENT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST FOURTEEN (14) DAYS IN ADVANCE OF TRIAL. THE PARTIES MAY INCLUDE A BRIEF STATEMENT FOR CONTEXT FOR THE OBJECTIONS IF NECESSARY. JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND JURY INTERROGATORIES ARE DUE SEVEN (7) DAYS BEFORE TRIAL. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES SHALL CONFER REGARDING JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES IN ORDER TO SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES. THE PARTIES SHALL SUBMIT A JOINT PROPOSED SET OF JURY INSTRUCTIONS TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY AT LEAST ONE (1) DAY BEFORE TRIAL. IF ANY DISAGREEMENT REMAINS, THE PARTIES SHALL HIGHLIGHT DISAGREEMENTS TO THE COURT. THE PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND INTERROGATORIES SHALL BE SUBMITTED IN MICROSOFT WORD FORMAT TO THE COURT'S STAFF ATTORNEY. FURTHER, THE PARTIES ARE ENCOURAGED TO SUBMIT A JOINT STATEMENT OF THE CASE TO BE READ TO THE JURY. ALL PARTIES AND COUNSEL OF RECORD TO BE PRESENT AT BOTH THE SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND THE FINAL PRETRIAL OR APPROPRIATE SANCTIONS WILL BE IMPOSED, INCLUDING DISMISSAL PURSUANT TO CIV. RULE 41(B)(1) OR DEFAULT JUDGMENT (AS APPLICABLE). THE COURT HOLDS SETTLEMENT CONFERENCES AND FINAL PRETRIALS BY ZOOM, UNLESS THE ORDERED OTHERWISE OR THE PARTIES REQUEST IN-PERSON SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE AND/OR FINAL PRETRIAL AT LEAST TWO WEEKS IN ADVANCE. COUNSEL AND PRO SE PARTIES ARE EXPECTED TO BE FAMILIAR WITH THE OHIO RULES OF CIVIL PROCEDURE, THE LOCAL RULES, THIS COURT'S STANDING CIVIL ORDER, WHICH CAN BE FOUND ON THE COURT'S WEBSITE, AND ANY OTHER ORDERS OF THIS COURT. NOTICE ISSUED
  26. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48943703 DELIVERED BY USPS 11/01/2022 SISTERS OF CHARITY HEALTH SYSTEM PROCESSED BY COC 11/09/2022.
  27. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48943618 DELIVERED BY USPS 11/03/2022 MERCY MEDICAL CENTER PROCESSED BY COC 11/09/2022.
  28. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) KATHERINE CHEFFINS(D3), ANDREW WOJTKOWSKI(D4), MERCY MEDICAL CENTER(D9) and SISTERS OF CHARITY HEALTH SYSTEM(D10) ATTORNEY THOMAS W WRIGHT 0017529 ANSWER ON BEHALF OF DEFENDANTS MERCY MEDICAL CENTER, THE SISTERS OF CHARITY HEALTH SYSTEM, ANDREW WOJTKOWSKI, DMD, AND KATHERINE MYRON, DDS (FKA CHEFFINS) TO PLAINTIFF'S AMENDED COMPLAINT
  29. ANSWER FILED BY D5 GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. ATTORNEY PATRICK S CORRIGAN 0046785 DEFENDANT GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR DDS'S ANSWER TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT
  30. SUMS AMENDED COMPLNT(48943703) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: SISTERS OF CHARITY HEALTH SYSTEM 2475 EAST 22ND STREET CLEVELAND, OH 44115-0000
  31. SUMS AMENDED COMPLNT(48943618) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: MERCY MEDICAL CENTER 1320 MERCY DRIVE NW CANTON, OH 44708-0000
  32. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  33. WRIT FEE
  34. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  35. WRIT FEE
  36. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED DEFENDANT(S) KATHERINE CHEFFINS(D3) and ANDREW WOJTKOWSKI(D4) THOMAS W WRIGHT 0017529. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE OF COUNSEL
  37. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC.(D7) and JOHN DOES 1 THROUGH 20(D8) ATTORNEY STEPHEN P GRIFFIN 0039655 ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS KURT C. GARREN M.D. AND KURT C. GARREN M.D. INC TO PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT.
  38. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  39. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  40. 3RD PARTY COMPLAINT AGAINST P1 JOHN R. WHITMER ....JOSEPH J TRISCARO 0081209 WITH POVERTY AFFIDAVIT PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT FOR DENTAL NEGLIGENCE (WITH JURY DEMAND)
  41. PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT, FILED 10/06/2022, IS GRANTED. PLAINTIFF SHALL FILE HIS FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT WITHIN SEVEN (7) DAYS OF ENTRY OF THIS ORDER. NOTICE ISSUED
  42. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR JOHN DOES 1 THROUGH 20 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  43. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR WOJTKOWSKI/ANDREW / 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  44. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR CHEFFINS/KATHERINE/ 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  45. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR TRISCARO/JOSEPH/J 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  46. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR CORRIGAN/PATRICK/S 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  47. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR GRIFFIN/STEPHEN/P 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  48. SCHEDULE ATTORNEY NOTICE. NOTICE GENERATED FOR DIFRANCO/SANDRA/M 10/16/2022 17:01:54
  49. CMC BY PHONE SET FOR 11/09/2022 AT 02:30 PM. PURSUANT TO LOCAL RULE 21, PART I, THE COURT WILL CONDUCT A CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE. DISCOVERY SCHEDULE, AMOUNT IN CONTROVERSY, EXCHANGE OF EXPERT REPORTS, DATE FOR FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE, REFERRAL TO ARBITRATION, ETC., SHALL BE RESOLVED AND INCLUDED IN A BINDING DECREE AND ORDER FORMALIZED. ALL COUNSEL ATTENDING SHALL HAVE FULL AUTHORITY TO ENTER INTO A BINDING CASE MANAGEMENT ORDER . PLAINTIFF'S COUNSEL SHALL INITIATE THE CONFERENCE CALL WITH ALL OTHER PARTIES AND CONTACT THE COURT AT THE APPOINTED TIME AT 216-443-8618. PARTIES SHALL BE PREPARED TO DISCUSS DISCOVERY PROGRESS AND SCHEDULING MATTERS, ETC. COUNSEL AND UNREPRESENTED PARTIES SHALL FOLLOW THE DISCOVERY PROCEDURES OUTLINED IN CIVIL RULE 26(F) IN PREPARATION FOR THE CASE MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE.
  50. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED D5 GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. PATRICK S CORRIGAN 0046785. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  51. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED D5 GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. PATRICK S CORRIGAN 0046785. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  52. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48708377 DELIVERED BY USPS 10/03/2022 CHEFFINS DDS/KATHERINE/ PROCESSED BY COC 10/12/2022.
  53. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48708340 DELIVERED BY USPS 10/03/2022 WOJTKOWSKI DMD/ANDREW / PROCESSED BY COC 10/12/2022.
  54. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48708249 DELIVERED BY USPS 10/03/2022 WILLIAMS, JR. DDS/GEORGE/ PROCESSED BY COC 10/12/2022.
  55. MOTION FILED FOR P1 JOHN R. WHITMER JOSEPH J TRISCARO 0081209 PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND COMPLAINT 10/24/2022 - GRANTED
  56. SUMS COMPLAINT(48708377) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: KATHERINE CHEFFINS DDS 77 RIDGE SIDE DRIVE POWELL, OH 43065-0000
  57. SUMS COMPLAINT(48708340) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: ANDREW WOJTKOWSKI DMD 8238 EDMUND COURT CIR NW MASSILLON, OH 44646-0000
  58. SUMS COMPLAINT(48708249) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. DDS 4774 MUNSON ST NW #303 CANTON, OH 44718-0000
  59. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  60. WRIT FEE
  61. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  62. WRIT FEE
  63. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  64. WRIT FEE
  65. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  66. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  67. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  68. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48578106 DELIVERED BY USPS 09/19/2022 KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC. PROCESSED BY COC 09/28/2022.
  69. PURSUANT TO THE STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO PLEAD AND JOURNAL ENTRY, FILED 09/21/2022, DEFENDANTS CLEVELAND CLINIC MERCY HOSPITAL AND THE CLEVELAND CLINIC FOUNDATION MAY MOVE OR PLEAD TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT BY OR ON 10/12/2022. NOTICE ISSUED
  70. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 48362911 RETURNED 09/23/2022 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT WOJTKOWSKI DMD/ANDREW / - RETURN TO SENDER NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  71. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 48362910 RETURNED 09/23/2022 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT CHEFFINS DDS/KATHERINE/ - RETURN TO SENDER NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  72. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 48362912 RETURNED 09/23/2022 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT WILLIAMS, JR. DDS/GEORGE/ - RETURN TO SENDER NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  73. STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO PLEAD FILED STIPULATION FOR LEAVE TO PLEAD AND JOURNAL ENTRY
  74. NOTICE FILED BY P1 JOHN R. WHITMER ATTORNEY JOSEPH J TRISCARO 0081209 PLAINTIFF'S NOTICE OF FILING AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT
  75. SUMS COMPLAINT(48578106) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC. 515 UNION AVENUE SUITE 157 DOVER, OH 44622-0000
  76. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  77. WRIT FEE
  78. PRAECIPE FILED PRAECIPE
  79. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 48362914 RETURNED 9/9/2022 FAILURE OF SERVICE ON DEFENDANT KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC. - UNCLAIMED NOTICE MAILED TO PLAINTIFF(S) ATTORNEY
  80. ANSWER FILED BY DEFENDANT(S) KURT C. GARREN(D6) and KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC.(D7) ATTORNEY STEPHEN P GRIFFIN 0039655 ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS KURT C. GARREN, M.D. AND KURT C. GARREN M.D. INC.
  81. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE, FILED DEFENDANT(S) KURT C. GARREN(D6) and KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC.(D7) STEPHEN P GRIFFIN 0039655. NOTICE OF APPEARANCE
  82. CERTIFIED MAIL RECEIPT NO. 48362913 RETURNED BY U.S. MAIL DEPARTMENT 08/25/2022 GARREN MD/KURT/C. MAIL RECEIVED AT ADDRESS 08/31/2022 TENDERED TO AGENT FOR FINAL DELIVERY
  83. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48362912 DELIVERED BY USPS 08/25/2022 WILLIAMS, JR. DDS/GEORGE/ PROCESSED BY COC 08/31/2022.
  84. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48362911 DELIVERED BY USPS 08/24/2022 WOJTKOWSKI DMD/ANDREW / PROCESSED BY COC 08/31/2022.
  85. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48362910 DELIVERED BY USPS 08/24/2022 CHEFFINS DDS/KATHERINE/ PROCESSED BY COC 08/31/2022.
  86. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48362909 DELIVERED BY USPS 08/25/2022 CLEVELAND CLINIC FOUNDATION PROCESSED BY COC 08/31/2022.
  87. USPS RECEIPT NO. 48362908 DELIVERED BY USPS 08/24/2022 CLEVELAND CLINIC MERCY HOSPITAL PROCESSED BY COC 08/31/2022.
  88. PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO FILE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT, FILED 08/17/2022, IS GRANTED. PLAINTIFF SHALL FILE ALL NECESSARY AFFIDAVIT(S) OF MERIT BY OR ON NOVEMBER 15, 2022. NOTICE ISSUED
  89. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362914) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: KURT C. GARREN, M.D. INC. 2057 WOODHAVEN DRIVE DOVER, OH 44622
  90. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362913) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: KURT C. GARREN MD 515 UNION AVENUE SUITE 157 DOVER, OH 44622
  91. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362912) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: GEORGE WILLIAMS, JR. DDS 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219
  92. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362911) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: ANDREW WOJTKOWSKI DMD 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219
  93. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362910) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: KATHERINE CHEFFINS DDS 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219
  94. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362909) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: CLEVELAND CLINIC FOUNDATION 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219
  95. SUMS COMPLAINT(48362908) SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL. TO: CLEVELAND CLINIC MERCY HOSPITAL 4400 EASTON COMMONS WAY SUITE 125 COLUMBUS, OH 43219
  96. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  97. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  98. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  99. WRIT FEE
  100. WRIT FEE
  101. WRIT FEE
  102. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  103. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  104. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  105. SUMMONS E-FILE COPY COST
  106. WRIT FEE
  107. WRIT FEE
  108. WRIT FEE
  109. WRIT FEE
  110. MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF TIME PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR ENLARGEMENT OF TIME TO FILE AFFIDAVIT OF MERIT 08/26/2022 - GRANTED
  111. JUDGE ASHLEY KILBANE ASSIGNED (RANDOM)
  112. LEGAL RESEARCH
  113. LEGAL NEWS
  114. LEGAL AID
  115. COURT SPECIAL PROJECTS FUND
  116. COMPUTER FEE
  117. CLERK'S FEE
  118. DEPOSIT AMOUNT PAID JOSEPH J TRISCARO

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more