Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Muskingum Co

Court

Muskingum Co

Ohio

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2023-05-15
Status Closed
Type Ce Foreclosures
Docket 58 entries
Disposition other terminations

Parties

Plaintiff The Huntington National Bank
Defendant Shuster, Deceased, Bonnie|Shuster, Deceased, Richard G|Dittmar, Jennifer|Seyerle, Alice|Evans, Beth|Shuster, Ross|Unknown Spouse Of Jennifer Dittmar|Unknown Spouse Of Alice Seyerle|Unknown Spouse Of Beth Evans|Unknown Spouse Of Ross Shuster|Unknown Occupants|Muskingum County Treasurer
Photo of Hon. COTTRILL KELLY J

Judge

Hon. COTTRILL KELLY J

Muskingum County (OH)

Ohio

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. COURT CERTIFICATE OF RELEASE OF MORTGAGE FILED.
  2. DEPOSIT ON NEW CIVIL CASE FILED. Receipt: 213554 Date: 05/15/2023
  3. INSTRUCTIONS FOR SERVICE FILED.
  4. PRAECIPE FOR SERVICE BY PRIVATE PROCESS SERVER FILED.
  5. NOTICE OF FILING PRELMINIARY JUDICIAL REPORT FILED.
  6. COPIES OF SUMMONS, COMPLAINT, AND THE FOLLOWING SENT BY CERTIFIED MAIL (n-DEF)SUMMON ON COMPLAINT Sent On: 05/15/2023 11:04:49 Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  7. CERTIFIED MAIL ISSUED Issue Date: 05/15/2023 Service: INITIAL SERVICE / CIVIL Method: CERTIFIED MAIL/CIVIL Cost Per: 0.0000 JENNIFER DITTMAR HOME ADDRESS 63 SOUTH 4TH STREET ZANESVILLE, OH 43701 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063729 ALICE SEYERLE HOME ADDRESS 9090 CHANDLERSVILLE ROAD CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063730 BETH EVANS HOME ADDRESS 1307 WHEELING AVENUE ZANESVILLE, OH 43701 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063731 ROSS SHUSTER HOME ADDRESS 9055 CHANDLERSVILLE ROAD CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063732 UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF JENNIFER DITTMAR HOME ADDRESS 63 SOUTH 4TH STREET ZANESVILLE, OH 43701 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063733 UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF ALICE SEYERLE HOME ADDRESS 9090 CHANDLERSVILLE ROAD CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063734 UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF BETH EVANS HOME ADDRESS 1307 WHEELING AVENUE ZANESVILLE, OH 43701 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063735 UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF ROSS SHUSTER HOME ADDRESS 9055 CHANDLERSVILLE ROAD CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063736 UNKNOWN OCCUPANTS HOME ADDRESS 4100 BIG MUSKIE DRIVE CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727 Tracking Number: 941472669904220063737 Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  8. COPY OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT ISSUED THEN HAND DELIVERED TO MUSKINGUM COUNTY TREASURER. RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON MUSKINGUM COUNTY TREASURER BY PERSONALLY SERVING COPY OF SUMMONS AND COMPLAINT TO: DENNIS DOVE, ASST PROS. ATTY. ON: 5/15/2023; SERVED BY: C. BOYD - DEPUTY CLERK Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  9. COPIES OF SUMMONS, COMPLAINT ISSUED TO PROCESS SERVER (PROCEST, LLC) FOR SERVICE OF UNKNOWN OCCUPANTS, BETH EVANS AND UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF BETH EVANS, ALICE SEYERLE AND UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF ALICE SEYERLE, ROSS SHUSTER AND UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF RUSS SHUSTER, JENNIFER DITTMAR AND UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF JENNIFER DITTMAR. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  10. ANSWER OF DEFENDANT, TODD A HIXSON, TREASURER OF MUSKINGUM COUNTY, OHIO & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED BY: ATTY DENNIS DOVE, ASST PROS ATTY
  11. RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL RETURNED AND FILED. ROSS SHUSTER & UNKNOWN SPOUSE.
  12. RECEIPT FOR CERTIFIED MAIL RETURNED AND FILED. JENNIFER DITTMAR & UNKNOWN SPOUSE.
  13. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON ALICE SEYERLE & UNKNOWN SPOUSE (9090 CHANDLERSVILLERD, CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727) MARKED: RETURN TO SENDER, MOVED LEFT NO ADDRESS & UNABLE TO FORWARD; ATTY NOTIFIED.
  14. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON UNKNOWN OCCUPANTS (4100 BIG MUSKIE DRIVE, CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727) MARKED: RETURN TO SENDER, REFUSED & UNABLE TO FORWARD; ATTY NOTIFIED.
  15. ANSWER OF DEFENDANT, JENNIFER & D.J. DITTMAR TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT AND CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: KAIDO, MARK E
  16. NOTICE OF FAILURE OF SERVICE BY CERTIFIED MAIL ON BETH EVANS and UNKNOWN SPOUSE (1307 WHEELING AVE, ZANESVILLE OH 43701) MARKED: RETURN TO SENDER & UNCLAIMED; ATTY NOTIFIED.
  17. SUMMONS RETURNED AND FILED BY PROCESS SERVER, DUSTIN RINE. RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON BETH EVANS BY LEAVING WITH UNKNOWN SPOUSE nka CHRIS EVANS ON 5/22/23; PERSONAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON UNKNOWN SPOUSE OF BETH EVAN nka "CHRIS EVANS" ON 5/22/23 (1307 WHEELING AVENUE, ZANESVILLE, OH, 43701).
  18. SUMMONS RETURNED AND FILED BY PROCESS SERVER, DUSTIN RINE. RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON ROSS SHUSTER & UNKNOWN SPOUSE nka LATISHA SHUSTER BY LEAVING BOTH WITH ALICE SEYERLE, ROSS SHUSTER'S SISTER ON 5/22/23 (9055 CHANDLERSVILLE RD, CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727).
  19. SUMMONS RETURNED AND FILED BY PROCESS SERVER, DUSTIN RINE. PERSONAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON ALICE SEYERLE ON 5/22/23; RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON UNKNOWN SPOUSE BY LEAVING WITH ALICE SEYERLE (9090 CHANDLERSVILLE RD, CHANDLERSVILLE OH 43727).
  20. SUMMONS RETURNED AND FILED BY PROCESS SERVER, DUSTIN RINE. RESIDENTIAL SERVICE WAS MADE ON JENNIFER DITTMAR & UNKNOWN SPOUSE BY LEAVING WITH HARRY TAYLOR ON 5/22/23 (63 SOUTH 4TH STREET, ZANESVILLE, OH 43701).
  21. SUMMONS RETURNED AND FILED BY PROCESS SERVER, DUSTIN RINE. FAILURE OF SERVICE ON UNKNOWN OCCUPANTS (4100 BIG MUSKIE DRIVE, CHANDLERSVILLE, OH 43727) REASON: PROPERTY IS VACANT.
  22. ENTRY ORDERING SERVICE BY PUBLICATION FILED. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  23. AFFIDAVIT FOR SERVICE BY PUBLICATION FILED.
  24. PROPOSED - LEGAL NOTICE FILED.
  25. ANSWER / LETTER FILED. ATTORNEY: PRO SE (BETH AND CHRISTOPHER EVANS)
  26. ANSWER / LETTER FILED. ATTORNEY: PRO SE (ALICE AND CASEY SEYERLE)
  27. ANSWER OF DEFENDANTS, ROSS & LA TISHA SHUSTER AND CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: PRO SE
  28. PROOF OF PUBLICATON FILED W/AFFIDAVIT OF LEGAL NOTICE FILED.
  29. AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATIONS W/ LEGAL NOTICE ATTACHED.
  30. ENTRY FILED. ONE (1) DAY BENCH TRIAL SET FOR MARCH 7, 2024 AT 9:00 A.M. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  31. MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  32. MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT, INSTANTER & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  33. MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED w/ ATTACHMENTS. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  34. NON-MILITARY AFFIDAVIT FILED.
  35. FINAL JUDICIAL REPORT FILED.
  36. MOTION FOR ORDER AUTHORIZING BARRY BAKER AS PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER TO SELL REAL PROPERTY AT PUBLIC AUCTION & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED w/ ATTACHMENTS. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  37. ENTRY GRANTING LEAVE TO FILE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT FILED. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  38. ENTRY FILED. OPPOSITION TO MOTIONI FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT DUE BY FEBRUARY 1, 2024. REPLY BRIEF DUE BY FEBRUARY 16, 2024. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  39. IN REM JUDGMENT ENTRY FORECLOSURE DECREE AND ORDER AUTHORIZING SALE BY PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER FILED. COPIES DISTRIBUTED. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  40. PRAECIPE FOR ORDER OF APPRAISAL AND ORDER OF SALE TO PSO w/ LEGAL DESCRIPTION FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  41. APPRAISAL FEES DEPOSIT Receipt: 220784 Date: 04/02/2024
  42. ORDER OF APPRAISAL BY SHERIFF AND ORDER OF SALE BY PSO ISSUED TO THE SHERIFF OF MUSKINGUM COUNTY. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  43. LAND APPRAISEMENT RETURNED AND FILED. APPRIASED AT $21,000.00 Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  44. CAROL KAIDO Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  45. RUTH ANN LYNN Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  46. SANDY STIERS Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  47. NOTICE OF SALE SCHEDULED FOR AUCTION THROUGH A PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER'S WEBSITE www.auction.com; BIDDING WILL ONLY BE ACCEPTED THROUGH SAID WEBSITE AND WILL BE OPEN A MINIMUM OF 7 DAYS STARTING ON: MAY 29, 2024 ; IF NOT SOLD, A SECOND SALE DATE WILL BEGIN ON: JUNE 5, 2024 and CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  48. MICROFILMING Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  49. MUSK CO RECORDER FEES Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  50. REFUND TO WELTMAN WEINBERG Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  51. COSTBILL ISSUED TO WELTMAN WEINBERG
  52. NOTICE OF FILING PROOF OF SALE PUBLICATION & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  53. NOTICE OF FILING PRIVATE SELLING OFFICER'S REPORT OF SALE & CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE FILED. **PROPERTY SOLD TO HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK ON 5/29/24 FOR $33,330** Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  54. MOTION FOR ORDER CONFIRMING SALE AND ORDERING DEED AND DISTRIBUTION FILED. Attorney: KATZ, MEGAN J
  55. ENTRY CONFIRMING SALE AND ORDERING DEED AND DISTRIBUTION FILED. COPIES DISTRIBUTED. Receipt: 225168 Date: 10/07/2024
  56. DISTRIBUTION ISSUED TO BOOKKEEPER
  57. REFUND CHECK ISSUED FROM DEPOSIT TO MEGAN J KATZ
  58. CHECK ISSUED TO MUSK CO RECORDER

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more