Your case is unique, but you are not alone.

About 41,000 new cases are filed in U.S. courts every weekday. Behind each one is a person trying to understand what happens next. Here’s what the public record can tell you about this matter — and about the people deciding it.

  • Know your judge

    Every judge has a pattern — what they grant, what they deny, how they handle the kinds of motions your case will see.

  • Know your attorney

    See an attorney’s actual track record — case types, courts, and how they’ve performed in front of this judge before.

  • Know your court

    Every courthouse has its own rhythm — filing-to-resolution times, common dispositions, how often cases like yours settle.

Is this judge more likely to rule for the plaintiff or the defendant in cases of this type?

How has your attorney actually performed in front of this judge?

AICasePredict surfaces patterns from public court records. We don’t predict outcomes and we don’t recommend changing your attorney — that’s a conversation for you and them. We just show you what the record already says.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase
Photo of Fort Bend County

Court

Fort Bend County

Texas

View Court Profile

Case Information

Filed 2022-06-21
Status 434th District Court
Type Other Civil
Docket 635 entries

Parties

Plaintiff Coe, Justin|Comrie, Michael|Dauphin, Russell|Eoff, Toby|Garretson, Kale|Hibbetts, Ryan|Kaspar, Michael|Kenworthy, Clayton|Lewallen, Jacob|Madison, Brian|Permian Valve Repair, Inc. Doing Business As Permian Pump & Valve Doing Business As Permian Pumps & Equipment Doing Business As West Texas Petro Services|Steubing, Bruce Wayne|Wheeler, Michael|Wheeler, Ryan|Young, Bo|Dnow Lp Doing Business As Distribution Now
Defendant Dnow Lp Doing Business As Distribution Now|Coe, Justin|Comrie, Michael|Dauphin, Russell|Eoff, Toby|Garretson, Kale|Hibbetts, Ryan|Kaspar, Michael|Kenworthy, Clayton|Lewallen, Jacob|Madison, Brian|Permian Valve Repair, Inc. Doing Business As Permian Pump & Valve Doing Business As Permian Pumps & Equipment Doing Business As West Texas Petro Services|Steubing, Bruce Wayne|Wheeler, Michael|Wheeler, Ryan|Young, Bo
Photo of Hon. Becerra J Christian

Judge

Hon. Becerra J Christian

Fort Bend County (TX)

Texas

View Judge Profile

Lawyers

Docket Entries

  1. Petition Index # 1 Plaintiff's Verified Original Petition and Application for Temporary Restraining Order, Preliminary Injunction, Permanent Injunction and Damages
  2. Amended Filing Index # 2 Plaintiff's First Amended Verified Original Petition and Application for Temporary Restraining Order, Preliminary Injunction, Permanent Injunction and Damages
  3. Motion (No Fee) Index # 3 Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Discovery
  4. Proposed Order Index # 4 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Discovery
  5. Temporary Restraining Order Index # 5 Temporary Restraining Order
  6. Motion (No Fee) Index # 6 Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Discovery
  7. Request Index # 7 Request for Process
  8. Notice Index # 8 Plaintiff's Notice of Appearance
  9. Notice Index # 9 Plaintiff's Notice of Appearance
  10. Notice Index # 10 Plaintiff's Notice of Appearance
  11. Order Index # 11 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Discovery
  12. Temporary Restraining Order Hearing (2:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian)
  13. Issuance Index # 12 Citation Issued to Toby Eoff
  14. Citation eService Eoff, Toby Unserved
  15. Issuance Index # 13 Citation Issued to Justin Coe
  16. Citation eService Coe, Justin Served 06/27/2022 Returned 06/28/2022
  17. Issuance Index # 14 Citation Issued to Ryan Hibbetts
  18. Citation eService Hibbetts, Ryan Served 06/25/2022 Returned 06/27/2022
  19. Issuance Index # 15 Citation Issued to Michael Wheeler
  20. Officers Return Index # 16 Subpoena Return for Ryan Hibbetts. Not Issued by DC
  21. Citation eService Wheeler, Michael Served 06/27/2022 Returned 06/27/2022
  22. Officers Return Index # 17 Subpoena Return for Justin Coe. Not Issued by DC
  23. Amended Filing Index # 18 Plaintiff's Second Amended Verified Petition and Application for Temporary Restraining Order, Preliminary Injunction, Permanent Injunction and Damages
  24. Motion (No Fee) Index # 19 Plaintiff's Second Motion for Expedited Discovery
  25. Order Index # 20 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Expedited Discovery
  26. No Fee Documents Index # 21 Verification by Declaration
  27. Officers Return Index # 22 Return of Service for Michael Wheeler. Served on 06-23-22
  28. Motion (No Fee) Index # 23 Agreed Motion for Extension of Temporary Restraining Order and Resetting Hearing on Temporary Injunction
  29. Temporary Restraining Order Index # 24 Amended Temporary Restraining Order
  30. Motion (No Fee) Index # 25 Motion to Quash Deposition of Justin Coe
  31. Proposed Order Index # 26 Order (Motion to Quash Deposition of Justin Coe)
  32. Request Index # 27 Request for Process
  33. Request Index # 28 Request for Process
  34. Officers Return Index # 29 Return of Service for Michael Wheeler Served 06/27/22
  35. Officers Return Index # 30 Return of Service for Permian Valve Repair Served 06/27/22 [Subpoena Not Issued by DC]
  36. Officers Return Index # 31 Return of Service for Ryan Hibbetts Served 06/25/22
  37. Motion (No Fee) Index # 32 Motion to Compel Defendants' Depositions Pursuant to TRCP 199.2(b)(2)
  38. Notice Index # 33 Notice of Hearing
  39. Amended Filing Index # 34 First Amended Notice of Hearing
  40. Amended Filing Index # 35 Second Amended Notice of Hearing
  41. Proposed Order Index # 36 Order Granting Motion to Compel
  42. Motion to Transfer/Change of Venue - Civil Index # 37 Defendants' Joint Motion to Transfer Venue and Request for Emergency Hearing
  43. Proposed Order Index # 38 Order (Defendants' Joint Motion to Transfer Venue and Request for Emergency Hearing)
  44. Notice Index # 39 Notice of Hearing on Defendants Motion to Transfer Venue
  45. Motion (No Fee) Index # 40 Motion to Quash Deposition of Ryan Hibbetts
  46. Proposed Order Index # 41 Order (Motion to Quash Deposition of Ryan Hibbetts)
  47. M/Compel Deposition (3:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) 06/21/2022 Reset by Court to 07/05/2022 07/05/2022 Reset by Court to 06/28/2022
  48. Officers Return Index # 42 Citation Return for Justin Coe. Served on 06-27-22
  49. Proposed Order Index # 43 Proposed Order on Motion to Compel
  50. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 44 Defendant's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Defendants' Depositions and Emergency Motion to Dissolve or Modify the Amended Temporary Restraining Order
  51. Motion (No Fee) Index # 45 Defendants' Motion for Expedited Discovery and Motion for Emergency / Expedited Hearing
  52. Proposed Order Index # 46 Order (Defendants' Motion for Expedited Discovery and Motion for Emergency / Expedited Hearing)
  53. Notice Index # 47 Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel
  54. Motion (No Fee) Index # 48 Defendant Toby Eoff's Motion to Transfer Venue and Request for Emergency Hearing
  55. Proposed Order Index # 49 Order Granting Transfer of Venue
  56. Amended Filing Index # 50 Defendants' Amended Joint Motion to Transfer Venue and Request for Emergency Hearing
  57. Motion (No Fee) Index # 51 Objection to Premature Hearing on Motion to Transfer Venue
  58. Proposed Order Index # 52 Order
  59. Proposed Order Index # 53 Order Granting Emergency Motion to Dissolve or Modify the Amended Temporary Restraining Order
  60. Motion (No Fee) Index # 54 Defendant Toby Eoff's Response to Plaintiff Motion to Compel and Defendants Depositions and Motion for Protective Order
  61. Proposed Order Index # 55 Order Granting Protective Order
  62. Notice Index # 56 Notice of Hearing on Defendants' Motion to Transfer Venue
  63. Amended Filing Index # 57 Amended Notice of Hearing
  64. Copy Request N/C of Plaintiff's First Amended Verified Original Petition and Application for Temporary Restraining Order, Preliminary Injunction, Permanent Injunction and Damages filed on 6/21/22-Requested by Gina Slabbaert. E-Served on 07/11/22
  65. Amended Filing Index # 59 Second Amended Notice of Hearing
  66. Issuance Index # 60 Citation Issued to Brian Madison
  67. Citation eServed Madison, Brian Unserved
  68. Issuance Index # 61 Citation Issued to Bruce Wayne Steubing
  69. Citation eServed Steubing, Bruce Wayne Unserved
  70. Issuance Index # 62 Citation Issued to Kale Garretson
  71. Citation eServed Garretson, Kale Unserved
  72. Issuance Index # 63 Citation Issued to Michael Kaspar
  73. Citation eServed Kaspar, Michael Unserved
  74. Issuance Index # 64 Citation Issued to Ryan Wheeler
  75. Citation eServed Wheeler, Ryan Unserved
  76. Notice Index # 65 Notice of Hearing
  77. Motion (No Fee) Index # 66 Defendants' Motion to Modify the Court's Order Granting Expedited Discovery to Allow for an Equitable Division of Deposition Time
  78. Proposed Order Index # 67 Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Modify the Court's Order Granting Expedited Discovery to Allow for an Equitable Division of Deposition Time
  79. Notice Index # 68 Notice of Hearing
  80. Order Index # 69 Order Extending the Temporary Restraining Order
  81. Notice Index # 70 Notice of Hearing
  82. Notice Index # 71 Notice of Hearing
  83. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 72 Defendant's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  84. No Fee Documents Index # 73 Plaintiff's Opposition to Motion to Dissolve
  85. Motion (No Fee) Index # 74 Plaintiff's Objection to Non-Eoff Defendants' Request to Modify the Court's Expedited Discovery Order Extending Deposition Time
  86. M/Hearing (10:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Defendant's Motion to Modify or Dissolve the TRO. Defendant's Motion to Modify the Court s Order Granting Expedited Discovery to Allow for an Equitable Division of Deposition Time
  87. Order Index # 75 Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Modify the Court's Order Granting Expedited Discovery to Allow for an Equitable Division of Deposition Time
  88. Motion (No Fee) Index # 76 Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Responses to Requests for Production and Overrule Toby Eoff's Objections (Again)
  89. Amended Filing Index # 77 Third Amended Notice of Hearing
  90. Motion (No Fee) Index # 78 Defendants' Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff
  91. Proposed Order Index # 79 Order Granting Defendants' Motion to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Documents Responsive Documents Responsive to Defendants' Requests for Production
  92. Notice Index # 80 Notice of Hearing
  93. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 81 Defendant Toby Eoff's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Responses to Requests for Production
  94. Notice Index # 83 Notice of Appearance by John Wesley Wauson and Anabel King with Wauson King as Co-Counsel for Justin Coe, Ryan Hibbetts, Michael Wheeler, Kale Garretson, Bruce Wayne Steubing, Ryan Wheeler, Brian Madison, and Michael Kaspar
  95. M/Compel (11:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) 07/08/2022 Reset by Court to 07/11/2022
  96. Order Appointing Index # 82 Order Appointing Master in Chancery
  97. Motion (No Fee) Index # 84 Defendants Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff
  98. Proposed Order Index # 85 Order Granting Defendants Motion to Compel Plaintiff to Produce Documents Responsive to Defendants' Requests for Production
  99. Notice Index # 86 Notice of Hearing
  100. Amended Filing Index # 88 Amended Notice of Hearing on Defendants' Motion to Transfer Venue
  101. Order Index # 87 Agreed Order Appointing Master in Chancery
  102. Amended Filing Index # 90 Plaintiff's Third Amended Verified Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  103. Motion (No Fee) Index # 91 Plaintiff's Motion for Discovery Sanctions Pursuant to TRCP 215.2(b)
  104. Notice Index # 92 Defendants' Rule 193.7 Notice
  105. Motion (No Fee) Index # 93 Plaintiff's Motion to Shorten Time for Hearing
  106. Proposed Order Index # 94 Order on Plaintiff's Motion to Shorten Time
  107. Amended Filing Index # 95 Plaintiff's Fourth Amended Verified Petition and Application for temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  108. Request Index # 96 Request for Process
  109. Issuance Index # 97 Citation Issued to Russell Dauphin
  110. Citation Eservice Dauphin, Russell Served 07/27/2022 Returned 08/01/2022
  111. Issuance Index # 98 Citation Issued to Clayton Kenworthy
  112. Citation Eservice Kenworthy, Clayton Unserved
  113. Issuance Index # 99 Citation Issued to Permian Valve Repair, Inc.
  114. Citation Eservice Permian Valve Repair, Inc. Served 07/20/2022 Returned 07/22/2022
  115. Judge Docket Entry Line item 82 appointing master in chancery is hereby rescinded.
  116. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 100 Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs Motion for Sanctions
  117. No Fee Documents Index # 101 Defendant Toby Eoff's Deposition Designations for Temporary Injunction Hearing
  118. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 102 DNOW'S Objections to Defendants' Ti Hearing Exhibit List
  119. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 103 Defendants' Objections to DNOW's Second Amended Temporary Injunction Exhibit List
  120. No Fee Documents Index # 104 Defendant Toby Eoff's Brief in Opposition to Plaintiff DNOW L.P. d/b/a Distributionnow's Application for Temporary Injunction
  121. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 105 Defendant Toby Eoff's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  122. Notice Index # 106 Notice of Appearance
  123. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 107 Defendants' Objections to DNOW's Deposition Designations
  124. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 108 Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Ti Hearing Deposition Designations
  125. Notice Index # 109 Notice of Appearance
  126. No Fee Documents Index # 110 DNOW's Brief in Support of its Application for Temporary Injunction
  127. No Fee Documents Index # 111 DNOW's Third Amended Temporary Injunction Exhibits List
  128. Amended Filing Index # 112 Defendants' First Amended TI Hearing Exhibit List
  129. Temporary Injunction Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) 07/05/2022 Reset by Court to 07/19/2022
  130. Order Index # 89 Motion for Entry of Agreed Protective Order (with Signed Order)
  131. No Fee Documents Index # 113 DNOW's Objections to Defendants' TI Hearing Exhibit List
  132. Proposed Order Index # 114 Order Denying Plaintiff DNOW, L.P. d/b/a Distributionnow's Application for Temporary Injunction Against Defendant Toby Eoff
  133. No Fee Documents Index # 115 Defendants' Temporary Injunction Bench Brief Demonstrating Plaintiff Cannot Establish a Conspiracy
  134. No Fee Documents Index # 116 Defendants' Temporary Injunction Bench Brief Regarding a Temporary Injunction Prohibiting Work Without a Non-Compete
  135. No Fee Documents Index # 117 Defendants' Temporary Injunction Bench Brief Regarding Changed Circumstances and Lack of Imminent, Irreparable Harm
  136. Proposed Order Index # 118 Order Denying Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction
  137. Proposed Order Index # 119 Order Granting, in Part, Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction
  138. Order Index # 120 Order Granting Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction
  139. Officers Return Index # 121 Affidavit of Service Return for Clayton Kenworth Served 07-15-22
  140. Proposed Order Index # 122 Order Granting Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction
  141. Amended Filing Index # 123 Plaintiff's First Amended Deposition Designations- TI Hearing
  142. Proposed Order Index # 124 First Amended Order Granting Temporary Injunction
  143. Motion (No Fee) Index # 125 Defendants' Joint Motion for Entry of Forensic Protocol
  144. Proposed Order Index # 126 Order Granting, in Part, Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction
  145. Motion (No Fee) Index # 127 Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion to Temporary Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  146. Officers Return Index # 129 Affidavit of Service Return for Permian Valve Repair, Inc Served on 7/20/22
  147. No Fee Documents Index # 130 Plaintiff's 1st Supplemental Deposition Designations- TI Hearing
  148. Amended Filing Index # 131 Defendants' Third Amended TI Hearing Deposition Designations
  149. Motion (No Fee) Index # 132 Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Temporary Injunction Bench Brief Regarding a Temporary Injunction Prohibiting Work Without a Non-Compete
  150. Order Index # 128 Order on Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion to Temporary Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  151. Motion (No Fee) Index # 133 Plaintiff's Motion to Declare Waiver of TEX.R.EVID. 504 Spousal Privilege by Toby Eoff and to Compel Production or, Responsive Documents or, Alternatively, to Compel Service of A Privilege Log Pursuant to TEX.R.CIV.P. 193.3(b)
  152. No Fee Documents Index # 134 Defendants' Brief in Opposition of Relief Requested in Plaintiff's Proposed First Amended Order Granting Temporary Injunction
  153. No Fee Documents Index # 135 Defendants' Supplement to Evidence Presented at the Temporary Injunction Hearing
  154. Notice Index # 136 Notice of Hearing
  155. Amended Filing Index # 137 First Amended Notice of Hearing
  156. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 138 Defendant Toby Eoff's Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Declare waiver of Tex. R. Evid. 504 Spousal Privilege by Toby Eoff and Compel Production of Responsive Documents or, Alternatively, to Compel Service of Privilege Log Pursuant to Tex. R. Civ. P. 193.3(B)
  157. Proposed Order Index # 139 Order
  158. Officers Return Index # 140 Affidavit of Service for Russell Dauphin. Served on 07-27-22
  159. Proposed Order Index # 141 Order Granting Defendant Toby Eoff's Request for Entry of Forensic Protocol
  160. Motion (No Fee) Index # 142 Defendant Toby Eoff's Request for Entry of Forensic Protocol
  161. Notice Index # 143 Notice of Hearing
  162. Motion (No Fee) Index # 144 Defendants' Motion to Compel Mediation
  163. Motion (No Fee) Index # 145 Motion for Entry of Remediation Protocol Applicable to Non-Eoff Defendants
  164. Notice Index # 146 Notice of Hearing
  165. Motion to Transfer/Change of Venue - Civil Index # 147 Defendants Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy s Motion to Transfer Venue
  166. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 148 Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' [Premature] Motion to Compel Mediation
  167. Motion (No Fee) Index # 149 Motion for Leave to File Response to Motion to Transfer Venue on August 11, 2022
  168. Temporary Injunction Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Plantiff's Request for Amended Temp Inj. 1.5 hours 08/01/2022 Reset by Court to 08/03/2022
  169. Proposed Order Index # 150 Order Granting Individual Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and for Attorneys Fees
  170. Motion (No Fee) Index # 151 Individual Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and for Attorneys Fees
  171. Notice Index # 152 Notice of Hearing on Individual Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
  172. Proposed Order Index # 153 Defendants' Proposed Forensic Protocol
  173. Motion (No Fee) Index # 154 Dnow's Motion for Order Shortening Time to Respond to Discovery
  174. Proposed Order Index # 155 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Order Shortening Discovery Response Time
  175. Notice Index # 156 Plaintiff's Notice of Appearance
  176. Motion (No Fee) Index # 157 Defendants Permian Valve & Repair, Inc. dba Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Request for Attorney's Fees
  177. Proposed Order Index # 158 Order Granting Permian Valve & Repair, Inc. dba Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Request for Attorneys' Fees
  178. Notice Index # 159 Notice of Hearing
  179. Notice Index # 160 Notice of Hearing
  180. Notice Index # 161 Notice of Hearing
  181. Certificate Index # 162 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Michael Kaspar Taken July 7, 2022 ($2,097.15)
  182. Certificate Index # 163 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Brian Madison Taken July 7, 2022 ($2,653.85)
  183. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 164 Defendants' Joint Response to Dnow's Motion for Order Shortening Time to Respond to Discovery
  184. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 165 Defendants Toby Eoff's Response to Dnow's Motion for Order Shortening Time to Respond to Discovery
  185. Proposed Order Index # 166 Order on Plaintiff's Motion to Declare Waiver of Tex.R.Evid.504 Spousal Privilege by Toby Eoff and to Compel Production of Responsive Documents or, Alternatively, to Compel Service of a Privilege Log Pursuant to Tex.R.Civ.P.193.3(b)
  186. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 167 Defendants' Original Answer
  187. No Fee Documents Index # 168 Defendants' Proposed Forensic Protocol
  188. Amended Filing Index # 169 First Amended Notice of Hearing on Individual Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
  189. Amended Filing Index # 170 Second Amended Notice of Hearing on Defendants' Motion to Transfer Venue
  190. Certificate Index # 171 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Michael Wheeler Taken July 11, 2022 ($2610.45)
  191. Certificate Index # 172 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Toby Eoff Taken July 11, 2022 ($2,752.65)
  192. Certificate Index # 173 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Justin Coe July 5, 2022 ($1958.31)
  193. Certificate Index # 174 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Hibbetts July 5, 2022 ($1,835.33)
  194. Certificate Index # 175 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Hibbetts July 5, 2022 ($1,835.33)
  195. Certificate Index # 176 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Hibbetts July 5, 2022 ($1835.33)
  196. Certificate Index # 177 Reporter's Certificate Oral Videotaped Deposition of Halen Phan July 13, 2022 ($1525.89)
  197. Certificate Index # 178 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Bruce Wayne Steubing, Jr. Taken July 13, 2022 ($2,381.95)
  198. Proposed Order Index # 179 Second Amended Order Granting Temporary Injunction
  199. No Fee Documents Index # 180 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Ryan Wheeler July 15, 2022 ($2,333.50)
  200. Certificate Index # 181 Reporter's Certification Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Kale Garretson July, 15, 2022($2,926.53)
  201. Motion (No Fee) Index # 182 Plaintiff's Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  202. Order Index # 183 Order on Plaintiff's Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  203. Certificate Index # 184 Amended Reporter's Certificate Oral Videotaped Deposition of Halen Phan ($1525.89)
  204. Amended Filing Index # 185 Plaintiff's Fifth Amended Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  205. Motion (No Fee) Index # 186 Plaintiff DNOW L.P.'s Special Exceptions to Counterclaims of Defendants Permian Valve Repair, Inc. dba Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy
  206. Notice Index # 188 Notice of Hearing
  207. Certificate Index # 189 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Toby Eoff Taken July 11, 2022 ($2,752.65)
  208. Motion to Transfer/Change of Venue - Civil Index # 190 Defendant Russell Dauphin's Motion to Transfer Venue
  209. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 191 Defendant Russell Dauphin's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  210. Proposed Order Index # 193 Order Granting Defendant Russell Dauphin's Motion to Transfer Venue
  211. Notice Index # 194 Notice of Hearing
  212. Certificate Index # 195 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of Clent Rawlinson, July 12, 2022 ($4251.01)
  213. Certificate Index # 196 Reporter's certification to the Oral and Videotaped Deposition of David E. Brock July 14, 2022 ($2,281.75)
  214. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 198 Defendants' First Amended Answer and Counterclaims
  215. CANCELED M/Transfer Venue (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Other Defendants
  216. M/Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Motion for Partial Sum. Judgement & Attorney's Fees Plaintiff s Special Exceptions 08/17/2022 Reset by Court to 08/25/2022
  217. Amended Filing Index # 197 Order Granting Plaintiff's Special Exceptions to Permian Valve Repair Inc and Clayton Kenworthy's Amended Counterclaims
  218. Amended Filing Index # 199 Defendants' Second Amended Answer and Counterclaims
  219. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 200 Defendants' First Amended Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  220. Notice Index # 201 First Amended Notice of Hearing
  221. Motion (No Fee) Index # 202 Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  222. Notice Index # 203 Plaintiff's Notice of Hearing
  223. Amended Filing Index # 204 Plaintiff's Amended Notice of Hearing
  224. Notice Index # 205 Plaintiff's Second Amended Notice of Hearing
  225. Proposed Order Index # 206 [PROPOSED] Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  226. Amended Filing Index # 207 Second Amended Notice of Hearing
  227. Order Index # 187 Order Granting Plaintiff's Special Exceptions to Permian Valve Repair, Inc. and Clayton Kenworthy's Original Counterclaims
  228. Amended Filing Index # 208 Third Amended Notice of Hearing on Defendants' Motion to Transfer Venue
  229. Amended Filing Index # 209 Second Amended Notice of Hearing on Individual Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment
  230. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 210 Defendant Eoff's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production, and for Sanctions
  231. Proposed Order Index # 211 Order Denying Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production, and for Sanctions
  232. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 212 Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  233. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 213 Defendants Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  234. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 214 Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and Attorney Fees
  235. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 215 Plaintiff's Omnibus Opposition to all Defendants' Motions to Transfer Venue
  236. Amended Filing Index # 217 Plaintiff's Sixth Amended Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  237. Order Index # 219 (Proposed) Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  238. Order Index # 220 (Proposed) Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions as to Defendant Toby Eoff
  239. Order Index # 221 DENIED - Order Denying Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sanctions
  240. Request Index # 218 Request for Process
  241. Order Index # 192 Proposed Docket Control Order
  242. No Fee Documents Index # 222 Defendants' Exception to the Special Master's Ruling on Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4a Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and for Sections
  243. Notice Index # 223 Notice of Hearing
  244. No Fee Documents Index # 224 Defendants Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy Exceptions to Special Master Order
  245. Amended Filing Index # 225 First Amended Notice of Hearing
  246. Notice Index # 226 Notice of Hearing
  247. Notice Index # 227 Notice of Hearing
  248. Proposed Order Index # 228 Order Granting Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents and Privilege Log from Plaintiff and Request for Hearing Under 193.4
  249. Motion (No Fee) Index # 229 Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents and Privilege Log From Plaintiff and Request for Hearing Under 193.4
  250. Amended Filing Index # 230 Amended Notice of Hearing
  251. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 232 Plaintiff DNOW's Response to Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents and Privilege Logs from Plaintiff and Request for Hearing Under 193.4
  252. Proposed Order Index # 233 [Proposed] Order Denying Defendants' Motion to Compel Documents and Privilege Log From Plaintiff and Request for Hearing Under 193.4
  253. CANCELED M/Hearing (10:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Other Defendants Motion for Partial Sum. Judgment Defendants Motion to Transfer Venue 1 hour.
  254. Issuance Index # 231 Citation Issued to Michael Comrie
  255. Citation eService Comrie, Michael Served 09/20/2022 Returned 09/20/2022
  256. Officers Return Index # 234 Affidavit of Service Return for Michael Comrie Served on 9/20/22
  257. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 235 Plaintiff DNOW's Response to NED Defendants' Exceptions to the Special Master's Ruling on Plaintiff's Motion for Rule 193.4(a) Discovery Hearing and for Order Overruling Objections, Ordering Production and For Sanctions, and Response to Defendant Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's Exceptions to Special Master Order
  258. M/Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) NED Defendants' Exception To the Special Master's Ruling on Plaintiff's Motion - 30 minutes
  259. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 236 NED Defendants Reply and Bech Brief on exception to Special Masters Ruling
  260. Proposed Order Index # 237 Order on Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's Exceptions to Special Master Order
  261. Order Index # 243 Order Denying Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents and Privilege Log from Plaintiff and Request for Hearing Under 193.4
  262. Proposed Order Index # 238 Order Denying Defendants' Motions for Partial Summary Judgment
  263. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 240 Individual Defendants' Reply in Support of Motion for Partial Summary Judgment and for Attorneys Fees
  264. Notice Index # 241 Notice of Appearance
  265. M/Hearing (10:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Plaintiff's Motion to Temp. Seal Plaintiff's Motion to Temp. Searl Conf Information 1 hour Defendants Joint Motion to Transfer Venue
  266. Order Index # 216 Proposed Order Denying Defendants' Motions to Transfer Venue
  267. Order Index # 239 Order on Permanent Seal of Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  268. Order Index # 242 Agreed Supplemental Docket Control Order
  269. Amended Filing Index # 244 Plaintiff's Seventh Amended Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  270. Request Index # 245 Request for Process
  271. Issuance Index # 246 Citation Issued to Jacob Lewallen
  272. Citation eServed Lewallen, Jacob Unserved
  273. Motion (No Fee) Index # 247 Dnow's Opposed Motion for Leave to Join Party
  274. Officers Return Index # 248 Affidavit of Service for Jacob Lewallen Served 10/01/22
  275. Notice Index # 249 Notice of Hearing
  276. Notice Index # 250 Notice of Hearing
  277. Proposed Order Index # 251 Order on DNOW's Motion for Leave to Join Party
  278. Notice Index # 252 Amended Notice of Hearing
  279. Amended Filing Index # 253 Plaintiff's Eighth Amended Petition and Amended Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  280. Request Index # 254 Request for Process
  281. Jury Demand Index # 255 Defendants' Demand for Jury Trial
  282. CANCELED M/Hearing (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Other DNOWS Opposed Motion for Leave 30 minutes
  283. Issuance Index # 256 Citation Issued to Bo Young
  284. Citation Eservice Young, Bo Unserved
  285. Motion (No Fee) Index # 257 Permian Valve Repair Inc D/B/A Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  286. Proposed Order Index # 258 Order Granting Permian Valve Repair, Inc. D/B/A Permian Pump & Valve and Clayton Kenworthy's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  287. Notice Index # 259 Notice of Hearing
  288. Motion (No Fee) Index # 260 Defendant Toby Eoff's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  289. Proposed Order Index # 261 Order Granting Defendant Toby Eoff's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  290. Motion (No Fee) Index # 262 Individual Defendant Bo Young's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  291. Notice Index # 263 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Bo Young's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  292. Proposed Order Index # 264 Order Granting Individual Defendant Bo Young's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  293. Motion (No Fee) Index # 265 Individual Defendant Brian Madison's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  294. Notice Index # 266 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Brian Madison's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  295. Proposed Order Index # 267 Order Granting Individual Defendant Brian Madison's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  296. Motion (No Fee) Index # 269 Individual Defendant Michael Comrie's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  297. Notice Index # 270 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Michael Comrie's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  298. Proposed Order Index # 271 Order Granting Individual Defendant Michael Comrie's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  299. Motion (No Fee) Index # 272 Individual Defendant Michael Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  300. Notice Index # 273 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Michael Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  301. Proposed Order Index # 274 Order Granting Individual Defendant Michael Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  302. Motion (No Fee) Index # 275 Individual Defendant Russell Dauphin's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  303. Notice Index # 276 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Russell Dauphin's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  304. Proposed Order Index # 277 Order Granting Individual Defendant Russell Dauphin's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  305. Motion (No Fee) Index # 278 Individual Defendant Justin Coe's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  306. Notice Index # 279 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Justin Coe's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  307. Proposed Order Index # 280 Order Granting Individual Defendant Justin Coe's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  308. Motion (No Fee) Index # 281 Individual Defendant Jake Lewallen's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  309. Notice Index # 282 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Jake Lewallen's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  310. Proposed Order Index # 283 Order Granting Individual Defendant Jacob Lewallen's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  311. Motion (No Fee) Index # 284 Individual Defendant Ryan Hibbetts's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  312. Notice Index # 285 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Ryan Hibbetts's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  313. Proposed Order Index # 286 Order Granting Individual Defendant Ryan Hibbetts's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  314. Motion (No Fee) Index # 287 Individual Defendant Bruce Wayne Steubing's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  315. Notice Index # 288 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Bruce Wayne Steubing's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  316. Proposed Order Index # 289 Order Granting Individual Defendant Bruce Wayne Steubing's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  317. Motion (No Fee) Index # 290 Individual Defendant Ryan Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  318. Notice Index # 291 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Ryan Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  319. Proposed Order Index # 292 Order Granting Individual Defendant Ryan Wheeler's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  320. Motion (No Fee) Index # 293 Individual Defendant Kale Garretson's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  321. Notice Index # 294 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Kale Garretson's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  322. Proposed Order Index # 295 Order Granting Individual Defendant Kale Garretson's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  323. Amended Filing Index # 268 Amended Notice of Hearing
  324. Notice Index # 296 Notice of Hearing on Defendant Toby Eoff's No Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  325. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 297 Defendant Michael Comrie's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  326. Notice Index # 298 Notice of Hearing for Individual Defendant Michael Kaspar's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  327. Proposed Order Index # 299 Order Granting Individual Defendant Michael Kaspar's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  328. Order Index # 300 Notice of Preferential Trial Setting
  329. Notice Index # 301 Notice of Pretrial Conference
  330. Amended Filing Index # 302 Defendants' Third Amended Answer and Affirmative Defenses
  331. Amended Filing Index # 303 Defendant Toby Eoff's First Amended Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses
  332. Order Index # 305 Order for Meeting t Address Adjustments Based on Time Considerations Remaining Before Trial
  333. Order Index # 304 Agreed Amended Docket Control Order
  334. Notice Index # 306 Notice of Appearance
  335. No Fee Documents Index # 307 Reporter's Certification, Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Clayton Kenworthy, as corporate representative of Permian Pump and Valve, August 30, 2022
  336. No Fee Documents Index # 308 Attorney Issued Subpoena for Production of Documents for Sondra Eoff Not Prepared by DC
  337. No Fee Documents Index # 309 Attorney Issued Subpoena for Production of Documents for OP Partner, Inc. Not Prepared by DC
  338. No Fee Documents Index # 310 Attorney Issued Subpoena for Production of Documents for Antlia Financial, LLC Not Prepared by DC
  339. Certificate Index # 311 Reporter's Certification, Oral and Videotaped Deposition of Clayton Kenworthy, August 30, 2022 ($417.85)
  340. Motion (No Fee) Index # 332 Defendant Michael Kasper's No-Evidence Motion for Summary Judgment
  341. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 312 Defendant Jacob Lewallen's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  342. Counter Claim/Cross Action/Intervention/Third Party - Civil Index # 313 Defendant Bo Young's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  343. Amended Filing Index # 314 Defendant Michael Comrie's Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  344. Amended Filing Index # 315 Defendants' Justin Coe, Ryan Hibbetts, Michael Wheeler, Kale Garretson, Brian Madison, Michael Kaspar, Bruce Wayne Steubing, Ryan Wheeler and Russell Dauphin's Second Amended Answer, General Denial, and Affirmative and Other Defenses and Counterclaim
  345. Amended Filing Index # 316 Plaintiff's Ninth Amended Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  346. Order Index # 317 Order Overruling Defendants' Objections and Compelling Production of Documents
  347. Notice Index # 318 Notice of Hearing
  348. Motion (No Fee) Index # 319 Individual Defendants' Motion to Compel Plaintiff's Complete Interrogatory Answers
  349. Motion (No Fee) Index # 320 Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff
  350. Proposed Order Index # 321 Order Granting Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff
  351. Notice Index # 322 Amended Notice of Hearing
  352. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 323 Plaintiff's Omnibus Responses to (1) Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff, and (2) Individual Defendants' Motion to Compel Complete Interrogatory Answers
  353. Proposed Order Index # 324 Order Granting Individual Defendants' Motion to Compel Plaintiff's Complete Interrogatory Answers
  354. Notice Index # 325 Notice of Intention to Take Deposition by Written Questions
  355. Amended Filing Index # 326 Amended Notice of Hearing
  356. Notice Index # 327 Plaintiff's Notice of Partial Non-Suit without Prejudice
  357. No Fee Documents Index # 328 Supplement to Individual Defendants' Motion to Compel Plaintiffs' Complete Interrogatory Answers
  358. Notice Index # 329 Notice of Hearing
  359. Amended Filing Index # 330 Amended Notice of Hearing
  360. Amended Filing Index # 331 Second Supplement to Individual Defendants' Motion to Compel Plaintiffs' Complete Interrogatory Answers
  361. Proposed Order Index # 333 Order Granting Defendants' Joint Motion to Compel Documents from Plaintiff
  362. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 334 Plaintiff's Response to Individual Defendants' Supplemental Briefing
  363. Motion (No Fee) Index # 335 Plaintiff's Motion for Leave
  364. Motion (No Fee) Index # 337 Plaintiff's Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  365. Proposed Order Index # 338 Order on Plaintiff's Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 76A
  366. No Fee Documents Index # 341 Sealed Exhibits to Plaintiff s Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 79A Part 2
  367. No Fee Documents Index # 342 Sealed Exhibits to Plaintiff s Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 79A Part 4
  368. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 343 Plaintiff's Response to All Defendants' No-Evidence Motions for Summary Judgment Part 2
  369. No Fee Documents Index # 344 Sealed Exhibits to Plaintiff s Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 79A Part 5
  370. No Fee Documents Index # 345 Sealed Exhibits to Plaintiff s Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 79A Part 3
  371. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 346 Plaintiff's Response to All Defendants' No-Evidence Motions for Summary Judgment (Part 1)
  372. Notice Index # 339 Notice of Non-Opposition
  373. No Fee Documents Index # 340 Sealed Exhibits to Plaintiff's Motion to Temporarily Seal Confidential Information Under Rule 79A - Part 1
  374. Notice Index # 347 Plaintiff's Notice of Appearance
  375. Digital Device on File Exhibits to Plaintiff's Response to All Defendatns' No-Evidence Motions for Summary Judgment (Filed Under Seal)
  376. Letters Cover Letter
  377. No Fee Documents Index # 348 Plaintiff's Trial Witness List
  378. No Fee Documents Index # 350 Defendants' Joint Trial Exhibit List
  379. No Fee Documents Index # 351 Defendants' Joint Designation of Testimony
  380. No Fee Documents Index # 352 Defendants' Joint Witness List
  381. Motion (No Fee) Index # 353 Individual Defendant's Rule 166 Motion to Dismiss Claims Based on TUTSA Preemption
  382. Motion (No Fee) Index # 354 Individual Defendants' Rule 166 Motion on Their Counterclaim for Declaratory Relief
  383. No Fee Documents Index # 355 DNOW's Trial Exhibit List
  384. No Fee Documents Index # 356 Joint Proposed Jury Questionnaire
  385. Motion (No Fee) Index # 357 Defendants' Joint Motion in Limine
  386. Certificate Index # 349 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of Michael Stone, October 7, 2022 ($2564.70)
  387. No Fee Documents Index # 358 Plaintiff's Draft Jury Charge and Instructions
  388. Motion (No Fee) Index # 359 Permian Pump & Valve's and Clayton Kenworthy's Rule 166 Motion on Defendants TUTSA Preemption
  389. No Fee Documents Index # 360 Defendants' Joint Proposed Jury Charge Submissions
  390. CANCELED M/Summary Judgment (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Passed Defendant T. Eoff No Evidence MSJ Permian Pump & Valve / C. Kenworthy No Evidence MSJ Defendant M. Kaspar No Evidence MSJ Defendant B. Young No Evidence MSJ Defendant B. Madison No Evidence MSJ Defendant M Comrie No Evidence MSJ Defendant M Wheeler No Evidence MSJ Defendant R Dauphin No Evidence MSJ Defendant J Lewallen No Evidence MSJ Defendant R Hibbett No Evidence MSJ Defendant B. Wayne Steubing No Evidence MSJ Defendant R Wheeler No Evidence MSJ Defendant J Garretson No Evidence MSJ Defendant J Coe No Evidence MSJ 10/31/2022 Reset by Court to 11/08/2022
  391. Motion (No Fee) Index # 361 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Ambiguity
  392. Motion (No Fee) Index # 362 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Laches
  393. Motion (No Fee) Index # 363 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Waiver
  394. Motion (No Fee) Index # 364 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Legal Bases for Unclean Hands
  395. Motion (No Fee) Index # 365 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Ratification
  396. Motion (No Fee) Index # 366 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Legal Right or Justification
  397. Motion (No Fee) Index # 367 Plaintiff's Rule 166(g) Motion Regarding Estoppel
  398. Certificate Index # 368 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Russell Dauphin Taken September 13, 2022 ($2846.70)
  399. Motion (No Fee) Index # 369 Plaintiff's Objections and Designations of Deposition and Hearing Testimony
  400. No Fee Documents Index # 370 Plaintiff's Objection to Defendants' Joint Witness List
  401. Amended Filing Index # 371 Defendants First Amended Joint Witness
  402. No Fee Documents Index # 372 Defendants' Joint Objections to Plaintiffs Trial Exhibits
  403. Affidavit Index # 373 Letter to Court with Affidavit of Michael Wheeler
  404. Motion (No Fee) Index # 374 Plaintiff's Motion in Limine
  405. Proposed Order Index # 375 Order in Limine
  406. Notice Index # 376 Plaintiff's Rule 193.7 Notice
  407. Motion (No Fee) Index # 377 Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Joint Trial Exhibits
  408. Notice Index # 378 Defendants Rule 193.7 Notice
  409. Notice Index # 379 Defendants' Rule 193.7 Notice
  410. Pre-Trial Conference Hearing (10:30 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian)
  411. Amended Filing Index # 380 DNOW's First Amended Trial Exhibit List
  412. Amended Filing Index # 381 Plaintiff's First Amended Trial Witness List
  413. Amended Filing Index # 382 Plaintiff's Amended Motion in Limine
  414. Proposed Order Index # 383 Order in Limine
  415. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 384 Plaintiffs Opposition to Individual Defendants Rule 166 Motion on Their Counterclaim for Declaratory Relief and Counter-Motion Under Rule 166 to Strike The Individual Defendants Counterclaim
  416. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 385 Plaintiffs Opposition to Defendants' Rule 166 Motions on Preemption
  417. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 386 Plaintiff's Response to Defendants' Joint Motion in Limine
  418. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 387 Defendants Response to Plaintiffs Motion in Limine
  419. Amended Filing Index # 388 Defendants First Amended Joint Motion in Limine
  420. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 389 Defendants Response to Rule 166(g) Motions on Estoppel, Wavier, and Unclean Hands
  421. Certificate Index # 390 Reporter's Certification Deposition of John Anderson Taken October 24, 2022 ($4,230.26)
  422. No Fee Documents Index # 391 Joint Proposed Jury Questionnaire
  423. Certificate Index # 392 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of David Hood October 11, 2022 ($2969.66)
  424. Amended Filing Index # 393 Defendants' First Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  425. Amended Filing Index # 394 Defendants' Second Amended Joint Witness List
  426. Certificate Index # 395 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of David Cherechinzsky, October 13, 2022 ($2722.91)
  427. Certificate Index # 396 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Brian Madison October 10, 2022 Volume 2 ($2022.05)
  428. Amended Filing Index # 397 Defendants Third Amended Joint Witness List
  429. Order Index # 336 Order Granting Motion for Leave
  430. Amended Filing Index # 398 DNOW's Second Amended Trial Exhibit List
  431. Amended Filing Index # 399 Defendants' Secon Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  432. Certificate Index # 400 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Jacob Lewallen Taken October 25, 2022 ($4,011.11)
  433. Amended Filing Index # 407 Plaintiff's Tenth Amended Petition and Application for Temporary Injunction, Permanent Injunction, and Damages
  434. Jury Trial (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Pref set #1 11/09/2022 Reset by Court to 11/28/2022
  435. Amended Filing Index # 401 DNOW's Third Amended Trial Exhibit List
  436. No Fee Documents Index # 402 First Supplement to Defendants Joint Expert Disclosures
  437. Amended Filing Index # 403 Defendants' Third Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  438. Amended Filing Index # 404 Defendants' Amended Joint Objections to Plaintiffs Trial Exhibits
  439. Proposed Order Index # 405 Revised Order In Limine
  440. No Fee Documents Index # 406 Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Third Amended Joint Exhibit List
  441. Amended Filing Index # 408 Defendants' Fourth Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  442. No Fee Documents Index # 409 Plaintiff's Objections to Defendants' Fourth Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  443. Certificate Index # 410 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Toby Eoff Taken October 18, 2022 ($4547.34)
  444. Certificate Index # 411 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Michael Joseph Comrie Taken October 19, 2022 ($3087.54)
  445. Certificate Index # 412 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of Sheila Enriquez, CPA, JD, CFF, CVA, November 8, 2022 ($3300.86)
  446. Jury Index # 417 Juror Questionnaire 1-25
  447. Jury Index # 418 Juror Questionnaire 26-50 (Packet #46 Not Returned, Juror Did Not Appear)
  448. Jury Index # 445 Juror Questionnaire 51-75
  449. Certificate Index # 413 Notice of Delivery ($643.35)
  450. Jury Index # 414 Jury Excuse
  451. Jury Index # 498 Jury Strike List (Clerk)
  452. Jury Index # 499 Jury Strike List (Plaintiff)
  453. Jury Index # 500 Jury Strike List (Defendant)
  454. Notice Index # 415 Notice of Appearance
  455. Jury Selected Index # 416 Jury Chosen List
  456. Amended Filing Index # 419 Defendants Fifth Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  457. Proposed Order Index # 420 Plaintiff's Supplemental Order In Limine
  458. Notice Index # 421 Notice of Appearance
  459. Order Index # 422 Plaintiff's Supplemental Order in Limine
  460. Certificate Index # 423 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Bo Tyler Young October 31, 2022 ($3,830.26)
  461. Order Index # 424 Order Regarding Defendants' Exhibit 318 and Plaintiff's Exhibits 501, 520, and 600
  462. No Fee Documents Index # 425 Correspondence to Judge
  463. Proposed Order Index # 426 Order
  464. Motion (No Fee) Index # 427 Plaintiff's Motion for Exclusion for Discovery Violations Under 193.6 and 215.2
  465. No Fee Documents Index # 428 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of Clent Rawlinson, November 11, 2022 ($5242.70)
  466. Other Hearing (11:00 AM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian)
  467. Motion (No Fee) Index # 429 Individual Defendants' Motion to Reconsider the Court's December 2 Order and Opposition to Additional Sanctions
  468. No Fee Documents Index # 430 Individual Defendants' Brief in Support of Motion to Reconsider the Court's December 2 Order and Opposition to Request for Additional Sanctions
  469. Motion (No Fee) Index # 431 Trial Brief on Plaintiff's Violation of the Court's Order In Limine
  470. Proposed Order Index # 432 Order Granting Defendants' Trial Brief on Plaintiff's Violation of the Court's Order in Limine
  471. Jury Index # 433 Jury Excuse (11/29/22-12/03/22)
  472. Certificate Index # 434 Reporter's Certification of the Videotaped Deposition of Clent Rawlinson, Volume 2, November 16, 2022 ($1359.50)
  473. Jury Index # 435 Jury Excuse (12/12/22 -12/15/22)
  474. Proposed Order Index # 436 Agreed Order Authorizing Supplemental Jury Compensation
  475. Order Index # 437 Agreed Order Authorizing Supplemental Jury Compensation
  476. Motion (No Fee) Index # 438 Plaintiff's Motion for Interim Opening Statements
  477. Notice Index # 439 Notice of Hearing
  478. Notice Index # 440 Plaintiff DNOW L.P.'s Notice of Appearance of Additional Counsel
  479. Amended Filing Index # 441 Plaintiff's First Amended and Supplemental Motion for Interim Opening Statements
  480. Proposed Order Index # 442 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Interim Opening Statements
  481. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 443 Defendants' Joint Response to Motion for Interim Opening Statements
  482. Proposed Order Index # 444 Proposed Order Denying Plaintiffs Motion for Interim Opening Statements
  483. M/Hearing (1:00 PM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian)
  484. Notice Index # 446 Notice of Firm Name Change
  485. Motion (No Fee) Index # 447 Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment
  486. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 449 Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment
  487. No Fee Documents Index # 450 Supplemental Petition Re: Defendant, Michael Wheeler's Breach of Fiduciary Duties
  488. Jury Index # 451 Jury Excuse (1/17/23-1/20/23)
  489. Certificate Index # 452 Reporter's Certification Saul Solomon December 11, 2022 ($4,343.59)
  490. Order Index # 448 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment
  491. Jury Index # 453 Jury Excuse (01/23/23-01/27/23)
  492. No Fee Documents Index # 454 Correspondence to The Court
  493. Jury Index # 455 Jury Excuse (01/30/23-02/02/23)
  494. Motion (No Fee) Index # 456 Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment
  495. Motion (No Fee) Index # 458 Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Testimony from Defendants' Expert, Geoff Bracken
  496. Motion (No Fee) Index # 459 Individual Defendants Notice of Nonsuit Without Prejudice
  497. Order Index # 457 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment
  498. Other Disposition/Non-Final Index # 460 Proposed Order (Individual Defendants Notice of Nonsuit Without Prejudice)
  499. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 461 Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment Dauphin
  500. Proposed Order Index # 462 Proposed Order (Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Leave for Trial Amendment Dauphin)
  501. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 463 Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Testimony from Defendents' Expert Geoff Bracken
  502. Proposed Order Index # 464 Proposed Order
  503. Jury Index # 465 Jury Excuse (2/06/23-2/09/23)
  504. Amended Filing Index # 466 Defendants' Sixth Amended Joint Trial Exhibit List
  505. Motion (No Fee) Index # 467 Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Speculative and Unsupported Opinions of Defendants' Expert, Saul Solomon
  506. Proposed Order Index # 468 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Speculative and Unsupported Opinions of Defendants' Expert, Saul Solomon
  507. No Fee Documents Index # 469 Plaintiff's Supplemental Petition Re: Defendant, Russell Dauphin's Breach of Fiduciary Duties
  508. Proposed Order Index # 470 Order Granting Plaintiff's Motion to Exclude Testimony From Defendants' Expert, Geoff Bracken
  509. No Fee Documents Index # 471 Plaintiff's Second Amended Trial Witness List
  510. No Fee Documents Index # 472 Defendants' Trial Brief - Jury Submission on Conspiracy
  511. No Fee Documents Index # 473 Defendants Trial Brief on Apportionment of Responsibility
  512. Motion (No Fee) Index # 474 Defendants Motion to Exclude Testimony From Plaintiff Witness Aaron Martin
  513. Proposed Order Index # 475 Proposed Order (Defendants Motion to Exclude Testimony From Plaintiff Witness Aaron Martin)
  514. No Fee Documents Index # 478 Defendants' Joint Response to Plaintiffs Motion to Exclude Opinions of Defendants Expert, Saul Solomon
  515. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 476 Plaintiff's Response to Motion to Exclude Martin
  516. Proposed Order Index # 477 Order Denying Defendants' Motion to Exclude Testimony From Plaintiff's Witness Aaron Martin
  517. Order Index # 479 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 100e [Conspiracy]
  518. Order Index # 480 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 1q [TUTSA: Conspiracy (Liability)]
  519. Order Index # 481 Defendants' Requested Question No. 1p [TUTSA: Conspiracy (Liability)]
  520. Order Index # 482 Defenants' Requested Instruction No. 1u [TUTSA: Bad Faith (Liability)]
  521. Order Index # 483 Defendants' Requested Question No. 10c
  522. Order Index # 484 Defendants' Requested Question No. 1a-2 [TUTSA: Trade Secrets B]
  523. Order Index # 485 Defendants' Requested Instruction NO. 1f [TUTSA: Trade Secrets]
  524. Order Index # 486 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 1e [TUTSA: Trade Secrets]
  525. Order Index # 487 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 1j [TUTSA: Damages - Do Not Compensate Twice]
  526. Order Index # 488 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 1g [TUTSA: Actual Damages A]
  527. Order Index # 489 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 100a [Unjust Enrichment A]
  528. Order Index # 490 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 100b [Unjust Enrichment B]
  529. Order Index # 491 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 100C [Unjust Enrichment - C]
  530. Order Index # 492 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 3b [TTLA: Liability - Intent]
  531. Order Index # 493 Defendants' Requested Instruction No. 10d [TUTSA Conspiracy]
  532. Order Index # 494 Defendants' Requested Question and Instruction No. 20a [TTLA Submission}
  533. Order Index # 495 Defendants' Requested Question No. 20b
  534. Jury Index # 496 Jury Excuse (2/14/23-2/17/23)
  535. Charge of the Court Index # 502 Charge of the Court
  536. Jury Index # 503 Jury Questions
  537. Jury Index # 497 Jury Excuse (2/20/23-2/22/23)
  538. Jury Index # 501 Case Information Sheet
  539. Notice Index # 504 Notice of Hearing
  540. Copy Request N/C of Order Granting Plaintiff's Application for Temporary Injunction (#120)-Requested by Margo Melendez Karr. E-Served on 03/03/23
  541. Amended Filing Index # 506 First Amended Notice of Hearing
  542. Notice Index # 507 Notice of Appearance of Counsel
  543. Motion (No Fee) Index # 508 Plaintiff's Motion for Entry of Judgment on the Jury s Verdict and for Permanent Injunction
  544. Amended Filing Index # 509 Second Amended Notice of Hearing
  545. No Fee Documents Index # 510 Plaintiff's Application for Court Costs
  546. Answer/Contest/Response/Waiver Index # 511 Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment
  547. No Fee Documents Index # 512 Brief in Support of Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Judgment
  548. Certificate Index # 513 Reporter's Certification Deposition of Aaron G. Martin ($3,060.78)
  549. No Fee Documents Index # 514 Defendant Eoff's Opposition to DNOW's Motion for Permanent Injunction and exhibit 1
  550. Proposed Order Index # 515 Final Judgment and Permanent Injunction
  551. M/Hearing (9:00 AM) (Judicial Officers Becerra, J. Christian, Becerra, J. Christian) Plaintiff's Motion to Enter Judgment 03/08/2023 Reset by Court to 03/09/2023 03/09/2023 Reset by Court to 03/15/2023
  552. Motion (No Fee) Index # 516 Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion to Temporarily Seal Trial Exhibits
  553. No Fee Documents Index # 519 DNOWs Trial Demonstratives 11/30/2022 2/17/2023 Part 1 of 4
  554. No Fee Documents Index # 520 DNOW's Trial Demonstratives 11/30/2022 - 2/17/2023 Part 3 of 4
  555. No Fee Documents Index # 521 DNOWs Trial Demonstratives 11/30/2022 2/17/2023 Part 2 of 4
  556. No Fee Documents Index # 522 Filing of Attorney's Fees Expert Demonstrative
  557. No Fee Documents Index # 523 Filing of Closing Statement Demonstrative
  558. No Fee Documents Index # 524 DNOWs Trial Demonstratives 11/30/2022 2/17/2023 Part 4 of 4
  559. Final Judgment by Jury Verdict Index # 525 Final Judgment
  560. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 526
  561. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 527
  562. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 528
  563. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 529
  564. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 530
  565. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 531
  566. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 532
  567. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 533
  568. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 534
  569. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 535
  570. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 536
  571. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 537
  572. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 538
  573. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 539
  574. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 540
  575. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 541
  576. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 542
  577. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 543
  578. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 544
  579. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 545
  580. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 546
  581. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 547
  582. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 548
  583. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 549
  584. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 550
  585. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 551
  586. Judgment Notice Sent/Rule 306A3 Index # 552
  587. No Fee Documents Index # 553 Filing of NEDs Excluded Exhibits
  588. No Fee Documents Index # 554 Filing of NEDs Excluded Exhibits
  589. Motion (No Fee) Index # 555 Defendant Toby Eoff's Motion for Judgment Notwithstanding the Verdict and Alternative Motion to Modify the Final Judgment
  590. No Fee Documents Index # 556 Defendant Eoff's Trial Slide Demonstratives Part 1 of 3
  591. No Fee Documents Index # 557 Defendant Eoff Trial Slide Demonstratives Part 2 of 3
  592. No Fee Documents Index # 558 Defendant Eoff Trial Slide Demonstratives Part 3 of 3
  593. Motion to Modify Index # 559 Individual Defendants' Motion for Judgment NOV Alternative Motion for Remittitur Individual Defendants' Alternative Motion to Modify Judgment Supplemental Brief in Support
  594. Proposed Order Index # 560 Amended Final Judgment
  595. Notice Index # 561 Notice of Hearing on Defendants' Post-Judgment Motions
  596. Notice Index # 562 Notice of Appearance of Counsel
  597. Motion (No Fee) Index # 563 Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to Defendants' Post-Judgment Motions
  598. M/Hearing (1:30 PM) (Judicial Officer Becerra, J. Christian) Post - Judgment Motions
  599. Cash Bond Letter
  600. Order Index # 564 Order(Plaintiff's Response in Opposition to Defendants' Post-Judgment Motions)
  601. Bond Filed Index # 565 Supersedeas Bond
  602. Motion (No Fee) Index # 566 Unopposed Rule 24 Motion of Defendant Bo Young for Order Setting Amount of Security for Judgment
  603. Notice of Appeal Index # 568 Individual Defendants' Notice of Appeal
  604. Notice of Appeal Index # 569 Defendant Toby Eoff's Notice of Appeal
  605. Notice Index # 570 Notice of Assignment to the Fourteenth Court of Appeals
  606. Letters Confirmation of Notice of Assignment sent to Fourteenth Court of Appeals
  607. Letters Notice of Assignment mailed to Attorneys
  608. Letters Letter from Fourteenth Court of Appeals
  609. No Fee Documents Index # 571 Defendant Toby Eoff's Designation Specifying Material to be Included in Clerk's Record
  610. No Fee Documents Index # 572 Defendant Toby Eoff's Request for Reporter's Record
  611. Order Index # 567 Agreed Order Setting Amount of Security for Judgment
  612. Notice Index # 573 Notice of Conditional Cash Deposit in Lieu of Supersedeas Bond
  613. Clerks Record Complete Copy of Index of Four Volumes of the Clerks Record Complete
  614. Bill of Cost - Other Bill of Costs for Four Volumes of the Clerks Record
  615. Letters Fee Notice for Four Volumes of the Clerks Record Mailed to Appellant Attorney Sanders
  616. Letters Confirmation from the Fourteenth Court of Appeals - Clerks Record Sent
  617. Letters Copy of Receipt and Index of 4 Volumes of the Clerk's Record Mailed to Appellant and Appellee Attorneys
  618. Letters Letter from Fourteenth Court of Appeals (Clerk's Record Received)
  619. Notice Index # 574 Judicial Notice Submission - Defendants' Jury Charge Proposal
  620. Notice Index # 575 Judicial Notice Submission - DNOW Jury Charge Proposal
  621. Request Index # 576 Appellant's Request to Supplement Clerk's Record
  622. Clerks Record Complete Index of Clerk's Record for First Supplemetnal Clerk's Record
  623. Bill of Cost - Other Bill of Costs for First Supplemental Clerk's Record
  624. Letters Fax Confifrmation of Bill of Costs sent to Attorney
  625. Letters Bill of Costs Mailed to Attorney
  626. Letters Confirmation of First Supplemental Clerk's Record sent to Fourteenth Court of Appeals
  627. Letters Receipt and Index of First Supplemental Clerk's Record Mailed
  628. Letters Letter from Fourteenth Court of Appeals
  629. Exhibit Exhibit List for 08-03-2022
  630. Exhibit Exhibit List for 07-19-23 thru 05-11-23
  631. Order Index # 517 Order on Plaintiff's Unopposed Motion to Temporarily Seal Trial Exhibits
  632. Request Index # 577 Request for Second Supplemental Clerk's Record
  633. Clerks Record Complete Index of Second Supplemental Clerk's Record
  634. Bill of Cost - Other Bill of Costs for Second Supplemental Clerk's Record
  635. Letters Fax Confirmation of Bill of Costs sent to Attorney

See the patterns behind this case

The free view above tells you who’s in the room. The detailed reports below show how the room tends to behave — using the same public records lawyers quietly rely on before every hearing.

  • Judge Report

    How this judge has ruled in cases like yours — case mix, motion outcomes, and historical docket. Judges set the floor of what’s possible in your courtroom.

  • Attorney vs Judge Report

    Everything in the Judge Report, plus how your attorney has actually performed in front of this judge. Attorneys move you off the floor — or don’t.

One-time payment, no subscription. Reports describe past public court activity — they don’t predict outcomes and they aren’t legal advice.

Get Free Case Details

Enter your email to receive case information including parties, docket entries, and status updates.

By submitting you agree to our Privacy Policy.

Need this case removed? Enter your email above — the confirmation email includes a case removal link.

Full Analytics Report

  • Complete case narrative
  • Judge details and rulings
  • Case disposition and outcome
  • All docket entries
  • Related cases and filings
$20
One-time purchase

Legal Analytics Has Been Featured In

Featured in Forbes, Bloomberg, The New Yorker, Above The Law, American Bar Association, and more