Brett Smith

Significant win for general contractors at the Texas Supreme Court. Represented a general contractor in a case decided by the Texas Supreme Court on May 7, 2021. The court issued an opinion in favor of our client in a case of great concern to general contractors having a presence in the State of Texas - JLB Builders, LLC v. Hernandez. The court reversed an 8-5 en banc opinion from the full Dallas Court of Appeals that may have significantly broadened general contractor liability for injuries to subcontractor employees. The Texas Supreme Court ruled that our client did not retain contractual control or exercise actual control over the subcontractors work. As a result, the court ruled that our client owed no duty to the subcontractors employee. General contractor win affirmed by the Dallas Court of Appeals. Defended an upstream contractor which was sued as a result of a subcontractor employee falling off of a roof of a multi-story apartment building while performing roofing work resulting in his death. The trial judge entered a judgment in our clients favor. Plaintiffs appealed the summary judgment to the Dallas Court of Appeals unsuccessfully resulting in affirmation of the trial judges order in our favor based upon our clients lack of control over the subcontractors work performed at the time of the incident. The Dallas Court of Appeals opinion in this case has been cited by other appeals courts over 65 times. Gonzalez v. VATR Const. LLC, 418 S. W.3d 777 (Tex. App.-Dallas 2013, no pet.) Wrongful death healthcare liability claim defense verdict for skilled nursing care facility. Represented a skilled nursing care facility in a healthcare liability lawsuit that was filed by the family of a resident for wrongful death. A defense verdict was returned in our clients favor resulting in a take nothing judgment. Another defense verdict in a wrongful death healthcare liability claim for skilled nursing care facility. Defended a skilled nursing care facility in a healthcare liability lawsuit that was filed by the family of a resident for wrongful death. The case was tried before a jury in East Texas. After evidence was presented by both sides, including expert witness testimony, the jury returned a verdict in favor of our client resulting in a take nothing judgment. Defense win in a $5,000,000 lost profits claim. Defended a welding company sued by a concrete manufacturing company alleging that our client started a fire at their cement plant which they claimed resulted in a $5,000,000 business interruption profit loss. After a jury trial, a defense verdict was returned in favor of our client. Successful motion for summary judgment regarding a traumatically brain injured minor which was upheld on appeal. Served as lead counsel for an owner/manager of an apartment complex in defense of a claim made by a tenant relating to an incident involving a young child falling out of an upper floor window resulting in a traumatic brain injury. We filed a motion for summary judgment on behalf of our clients on the basis of no duty because of lack of control. The trial judge in Denton County agreed with us and granted the motion. Plaintiffs appealed to the Fort Worth Court of Appeals which issued an opinion consistent with the trial judges decision. Plaintiffs requested that the Texas Supreme Court consider the court of appeals decision, but that request was denied leaving the summary judgment in place in favor of our clients as a take nothing judgment. Successful commercial case involving breach of fiduciary duty claims, lost profits and disgorgement of lost profits. Served as co-counsel in a commercial case wherein our client claimed that a former employee breached his fiduciary duty while still employed with our client due to his soliciting the departure of other employees, carrying away confidential information, acting for his future interests at the expense of his employer by using the employers funds or employees for personal gain or by a course of conduct designed to hurt the employer, usurping a business opportunity that belonged to that employer and working for interests of a competitor of that employer. With respect to damages, our client requested lost profits as a result of the breach of fiduciary duty and disgorgement of profits in the past for the profits gained by the subsequent employer as a result of the breach of fiduciary duty. After all evidence was presented at trial and before closing arguments, the case settled at mediation.